I've been a fan of Nicola for years. I miss them at the beach, but this location is large and comfortable, with plenty of indoor and outdoor seating and ample parking. I've always enjoyed a salad and either pizza or a Nicoboli when I come here. Today, I tried the "heart healthy" fare, including a tossed salad, a mini pizza (fat free dough and no cheese) and Nicoboli (fat free dough, no cheese with veggies snd sweet peppers. Honestly, I didn't know what to expect. But I can say that the no-fat versions of the pizza and Nicoboli were both tasty and satisfying. The dough for both items was cooked perfectly, with a nice crunch and the pizza had a good amount of veggies and sauce. The Nicoboli was larger than I thought, with veggies and sweet peppers. (I might ask for a tiny amount of cheese in the Boli next time. It was good, but a little cheese inside would help hold the ingredients together. Once we cut the Boli in half and bit it, the veggies started pouring out.) I'm pleased there are a number of items on the menu for dietary concerns, including fats and cheese, which are accommodated here. I thought my time at pizza places might be over, or, at least, awkward (pulling cheese off from a slice, eating half a slice), but this is great news. The salad (shared between two people) was ample as a side salad and was fresh. The service was good. read more

I've been enjoying Nicola's my entire life. It's such a unique spot for pizza and pasta. The family style atmosphere is perfect whether you'd like to enjoy one of their game nights or a meal with all the kids! I love the pizza which is always extremely cheesy or their baked ziti's read more

Nicola Pizza - Mac n' Cheese -- like Kraft but BETTER! Only $5! - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

See all

I've only eaten here a few times, but I think it's pretty decent food! I have gotten takeout with some family and we all seemed to agree that the cheese is very thick and rubbery. I haven't gotten their regular pizzas yet, but the Pepperoni Pizza Bites are very good! One of my family members also LOVES their Fried Zucchini Bites! However I think the ranch would be better if it wasn't Hidden Valley ranch and it was restaurant made. I would give it five stars, but, make the ranch restaurant made, make the cheese less rubbery, and it'd be great and worth a 5 star review! I recommend going here if you and your family love pizza and want to eat out! read more

Awesome food! First time here! Maddie was great! All the TVs had great sports on as well as we stay longer because of a wicked storm. Thanks!!! read more

Finally got to order lunch and dine in here. It is a very nice atmosphere and lots of seating. Came here around noon and got seated right away and some stopped by our table for our drink order within minutes. We ordered a Nicoboli, pizza and fries and everything was hot and delicious and served very quickly. The fries and the crust taste freshly made and we loved every bite. The service was excellent with frequent check-ins and refills on drinks. I am looking forward to trying out some pasta dishes and salads next. I would highly recommend. read more

See all

Delicious food. Outstanding and polite service. Casual dining. Great quality and affordable. I ordered a Nicolboli to-go. I was told by my friend thay lives there, it's their version of a pizza hot-pocket. We also had the Chicken Parm sandwich, a medium pepperoni and onion pizza, boardwalk fries with cheese sauce on the side, as well as a house salad. Ended up taking a lot to go since I don't plan on cooking the next 2 days. I really enjoyed dining here and highly recommend this gem of a restaurant! read more

See all

Finally got to visit the take out area of the new (to me) location! There is a large parking lot and the walk up to the take out area was easy. The setup is very nice to accommodate lines and there are tables available to sit outside after picking up a take out order. I just got 2 slices. One pepperoni slice and one with fresh tomatoes. Thanks to the cashier for suggesting that one! Next visit we will sit inside to enjoy the vibe! read more

We ordered DoorDash Delivery and the food was pretty good. We ordered the large shareable adult pizza and it was loaded with peppers, onions, sausage, pepperoni. It was very heavy and yummy. Our order came unexpectedly with a bucket of fries and the kids loved it! read more

Nicola Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

Favorite part of this place is the salad! Place was packed but we were in and out for a party of 5 within 90 minutes. Food came out super quick and service was decent. Good for a consistent meal! read more

See all

Don't waste your time at this location! Service was horrible! My husband went to pick up our order and the waitress/hostess gave him attitude. The guy that handed off the order told him that he needed to go to another area to get sauces instead of just getting them for him. Food is sub-par. I've had better pizza from a gas station. Don't know what's up with this location, but this isn't Nicola's. Super busy during off season for no reason, in my opinion. read more

The first thing is something that is kind of rare theses days, the customer service is absolutely the best that me and my family has ever experienced. This place truly wants the customer to have a great experience and if you go, you will definitely get it. As for the food we always order the same, bucket of fries and pepperoni pizza. Always very good and always fresh. If you receive food and they think it's not up to their standards they will let you know and correct it immediately and will always make it right. My family has never left the restaurant without being completely satisfied and in fact we always bring food back home. read more

Wow, the new location is stunning - so large and roomy. Jenni has been before but this was my first time. Service was great, the environment comfortable, and Nicholas still walked around saying hello and asking how everything is. I used the bathroom before eating and was amazed at how neat and clean it was. I mentioned this to Nicholas and he said, "if it isn't, we might as well shut the whole place down." Anyway, we had salads, Nic-o-Boli, large cheese pizza, and a small fry. The fries were gigantic and tasted terrific with vinegar and no ketchup. The salad was large enough for us to split and our server thoughtfully brought us an extra plate. The bolis were okay after we got extra sauce but it's the pizza that's the star here: plain cheese for us and the crust is light, crispy, and delicious, the sauce slightly sweet, and the cheese thick, creamy, and delicious. Yum! read more

See all

Good Service and excellent food ; itis very affordable for families. Plan on returning soon with my family.

Never disappoints. Best of everything. Consistent! which is very important to me. The staff is always pleasant and helpful. Plenty of parking. Doesn't get any better. read more

We went to watch the Eagles game of course we had a pitcher of Sam Adams Octoberfest, it was very cold. We had the Special $14 dollar hot wings and zucchini bites both which were excellent. The pizza was good but not my favorite pie in the area. It didn't suck eitherOur waitress and service people were friendly and efficient. The ambience is a very cool sports bar, if you don't mind noise this is your place. Definetly will go back, great place to watch football read more

We came to watch the football game, drink some beers and get some food. Sat at bar. At 8:15 the game wasn't on any of the bar TVs so I asked the bartender (blond, middle aged woman) if she could get the game on for us. She said "I have no control over the TVs sorry". We asked a manager next and they got it turned on. Next we ordered a calzone. It took 45 minutes for it to come out and it was COLD. Sent it back, they made a new one for us and it came out in less than 10 minutes, but it was cold too! Sent that one back too and cancelled the food order. I asked for the manager and she apologized and said she'd take the calzone off our bill. Thanks a lot, we didn't eat the darn thing of course you're taking it off the bill! Got attitude from the blind server test of the night. Never coming back here. read more

Had such a great experience at Nicola Pizza in Lewes! Our waiter, Mason, was fantastic--super attentive, friendly, and on top of everything without ever being intrusive. He really made the whole experience even better. And of course, the Nic-O-Bolis were as amazing as ever--seriously, they never disappoint! Highly recommend if you're in the area! read more

The goated pizza spot of Rehoboth, no debate! Get yourself a nicopoli and you'll be in heaven. read more

Excellent service and friendly staff Menu has great selections and happy hour specials. read more

We came back here about two weeks ago and had another fantastic experience! The environment was on point, the Nic-a-bolis were really good and we had a great time. Rosa did a very good job at taking care of us. And their gluten free pizza was really good too! read more

See all

My childhood and young adult memory of this place was always the most incredible Nic-a-boli to eat. I arrived at the new location a few weeks before Labor Day so there were more locals on a Friday than out of towners. The new locations is away from the beach and I truly feel that the dynamic has changed from a one block from the ocean beach restaurant versus to a town Pizza/ Italian restaurant . Service was good and the staff are very friendly. They Ask how you how is everything. I knew there is a wait for the Nic-a-bolis. I asked for extra sauce on the side the Nic-a-boli is great just as I remember, and the cheese was melting out which I love. I just I'm having a hard time the move as I no longer feel the beach vibe . they have TVs with the horse races on. I will definitely go back to bring home a box they cost $ 126 for 11 Nic-a-bolis. read more

See all

The Pizza is one of the better options in the area. I think I ever prefer it over Grotto actually. I like the large bar area in the restaurant itself. It's a good place to watch a game and get some food. I also like the pickup spot in the back which makes calling ahead and taking out easy. read more

I had both pizza and cheesesteaks this week. Both were great. Their cocktails are not watered down and they are reasonably priced. The place is mobbed in summer because it is really great. The service is exceptional. All work like a well oiled machine. We ate outside Both times and it was comfortable and friendly. Inside is really pretty and set up well. And parking is really good for Lewes. I will be back ! read more

See all

Everytime we order takeout- our order is WRONG. Even after triple checking. Including our order tonight. And we always order 1 Pepperoni Boli. How hard can it be?.... read more

Fun family place to go when near Rehoboth. The Everything Nicoboli was awesome! If you like pizza, then this is the place to come in this area. The service was great and the food came out relatively quick. Give it a try! read more

Nicola Pizza - Split the Nicoboli with my Mom! - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

See all

The chicken parm was delicious but everything else about my experience was bad. First off I really wanted a calzone but the guy working there said they dont sell them. But in fact they do another work told me after I ordered that they were called something else and a semi version of a calzone. Very disappointed at the first experience here how a worker didnt tell me about it until I interacted with a different worker. Secondly it took over 30mins to make my order when they claimed 20min. Also the second worker slipped up too. I asked for no anchovies which he got. But I specifically asked for no peppers and olives and he said that the everything doesnt come with it. I believed him even though I read the menu. Came out that the menu was correct. Just a terrible experience and service. Not to mention the pizza wasnt good either. Overpriced, terrible service, mid pizza. Would not recommend read more

See all

Always hits. I grew up in the area, moved a few hours away, but whenever I come back around I make it a point to go to Nicolas once (or twice) each time. Devil pizza, salad (with cheese, onions, and raspberry vinaigrette!) are my go-to! read more

Food was very poor, low grade greasy meet, cheap cheese ingredients, service was lacking. This is a mid price pizza restaurant that apparently can only survive because it is on a very busy highway. Total disappointment on every level. Abandoned most of the food, couldn't wait to leave and eat somewhere else. Grottos Pizza across the street much better choice. read more

Oh what you used to be. But now you ain't. Stopped in today on the way back to Maryland. Wife order the nicaboli. I ordered the meatball sub. Her nic a whatever shell was a hard as a dead horseshoe crab. My meatball sub was- the roll was as hard as a dug out wooden canoe filled with meatballs? the size of quail eggs topped with a sheet of cheese that would work as a tarp. In case you don't get it, it sucked. Big time. I had to give it one star otherwise it wouldn't allow me to post. it should be ZERO STARS. read more

Food is delicious, drinks are great! Service is excellent, most have been here for years! We come every Wednesday and never disappoints us!

We got to-go food. The pizza is good, but we weren't impressed by our other food -- the spicy Stromboli was soggy, as were the fried pickles. When they say you can add bacon to the cheese fries, they mean it. The to-go windows are separate from the restaurant and they have a well honed system. My food was ready very quickly. read more

This place is just what you want after a long day of beach/softball. The pizza is really good. Their version of a calzone is really good, the "nic-o-boli". It's right next to a few hotels, which makes it way convenient too. The waitstaff was super friendly. Their takeout was quick too. They were faster than the automated estimate the site gives you. read more

Wow, as someone who never really frequented Nicola's while they were on Rehoboth Ave, we've been twice to their *newer* location on Coastal Hwy - and we're now definitely Nicola's people! The service is great, the food is piping hot, and we've been while the dining room is packed with a wait, and while it's a slower lunch time. Each time we're met with a smile! The kids love the outside fire pit & throwing coins into the fountains. Such a fun time at Nicola Pizza! read more

Service was spot on , pizza was delicious and had house salad for two or more . Very enjoyable atmosphere inside and outside

Very nice outside bar to hangout at. I had an orange crush which was perfectly made. The spicy bbq wings were delicious. Very messy but worth it. Definitely a cool spot to hangout and chill after the beach. Located right next to our hotel and was a great spot to catch a meal. Service was okay but very nice. Will go again! read more

Nicola Pizza - Orange crush, Untraditional PITA, and Twisted Tea - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

Friends invited us here. They are locals, and remember when this place was located down the road and they hung out here as teenagers. They really talked this place up. Loving their nickbolis (basically a folded pizza or Stromboli )and pizza. The parking lot was packed, but the restaurant wasn't, and we were seated right away. The waiter took the orders . I ordered everything nickaboli without anchovies. It does have a lot of pizza ingredients. Unfortunately, I wasn't impressed. Pizza King or Hungry Howies are much better. The dough was bland, and the sauce was bland. They did have a lot of cheese in them, but overall, it was fair. I truly think our friends like it because of the nostalgia of reminiscing their teenage days. If I go back, I won't order the same item, but they do have a good size menu, so finding something else won't be a problem. read more

Nicola Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

See all

I give five stars when I can't wait to go there again! I've only had plain cheese pizza and french fries here and they are both so good!!!! Pizza is basic, not even NY/NJ style, but man is it good!!! Fries are beach style and what a great taste!!! And several dollars' cheaper than Grotto. I always say I want to try something else, but I always end up going with the pizza--one of these days. Coke products!! read more

My family and I enjoyed some takeout! I preferred the beef Stromboli and my partner liked the supreme. I always love their salads with the delicious mozz cheese and chicken tenders. This was my first time at the location and the inside is very big and clean. When I ordered the takeout online it said 25-30 minutes but it actually took only 6 minutes! The bottoms of our nicobolis were a bit soggy because of this but still delicious! We got anchovies on the side and they gave us so many which was great as well read more

See all

Always love their service and food when we dine in. But, the take out just isn't worth it. Their loyalty program barely ever works and the portions are ridiculously smaller. We ordered an Italian wedding soup for pick up and it didn't even fill 1/2 the container. Out of curiosity what I just spent money on, we measured it out and it didn't even fill a 1C measuring cup. That's ridiculous. According to their counter people "that's a full serving". read more

Nicola Pizza - Wedding soup to go. Not even half a container. - Pizza Near Me - Lewes, Delaware

See all

Okay, so the pizza wasn't bad but kinda bland. The crust cooked and not doughy. The place is big and geared for the beach crowd. It was close to where I was staying for the night. read more

See all