Our family moved to Vallejo in 2021 and this is conveniently down the street from our home. You walk in are greeted, they patiently wait for you to order and help you if you need anything to modify. Pizza takes about 15-20 minutes. We're never in a hurry, but we always get the salad bar buffet style. Also they put away the salad at 7:30pm so get there way before so you can get your salad fix. Free refills at the fountain, a lot of space for parties, love that it's next to our CVS pharmacy so we can get our meds and other last minute home groceries like soda from CVS or some big spray so it's in a nice area for my families needs. Pizzas are always amazing, no issue for more ranch. Everyone we come it's always on point. read more

I ordered two pizzas from here yesterday and the medium combo made me and my kids sick. The sausage had a funny smell and taste. Immediately after eating we felt nausea plus are stomach has been bubbling and we all have diarrhea. Also I called the store and manger has yet to contact me. And I have ordered from them many times before. Never again! If I could give a zero I would read more

So the Niners last win of the year netted me an awesome coupon for some pizza! We looked to see what the options were and I stumbled across Indian fusion pizzas which I had no idea they had! We got a large Chicken Curry pizza that was amazing! Great curry flavors, all the vegetables were crisp and played so well in the pizzas success. Jalapeños were a nice touch to bump the heat up a bit and the chicken was flavorful and not dried out. We also got the garlic sticks with cheese since the discount was there on the pizza. They were solid, nothing wrong there with a good amount of cheese on them. I will absolutely be ordering from them again and will make sure to try a few of the other Indian pizzas! read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Chicken Curry Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Benicia, California

See all

Ordered a mountain size pep and suasage. got home and opened box to find a Frankenstein pizza. Looks as if slices were taken out and they had to squeeze remaining pieces together or instead of making a mountain size they took other pizzas they had on hand and threw them together. very disappointing because I have never had this issue at any other Mt. mikes. Will never buy from this store location again! You have been warmed read more

So many pluses here. Lunch buffet and happy hour m-f. Staff friendly and there are tvs to watch sports. $12 specialty pizza $5 for 5 wings $5 draft beers $10 calzones Very spacious spot with plenty of parking. I didn't use the bathroom. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Benicia, California

I had a great time sitting eating salad with my daughter while they made our two large pizzas to take home for the rest of the family. There was a 20% coupon at the restaurant and they let me use it...NICE. The restaurant was clean, including the restroom and the cashiers and other teammates were very warm and friendly. read more

See all

Love the pizza and friendly customer service. Location is right off the highway on my way back home, very convenient that next door there is a CVS where I get my essentials and dinner! read more

The pizza is always great! The employees are always smiling and are very kind. The best part is during football season they give a 49% off discount through the app when the Niners win! read more

Who ever was making pizzas Tuesday night 11/25/25 suuuuccckkkks. Probably the worst mountain Mike's pizza I've ever had and I usually love mountain mikes. Such a waste of money. All dough and barely any cheese or toppings. Please retrain whoever was cooking. I probably won't go to this location anymore. read more

Ordered MM for Halloween. They aren't doing any sort of QA. I ordered online the service was fine got the pizza on time and all but the slices are SMALL - see photo in comparison to my hand I didn't purchase a kid pizza and I can't believe they're charging full price for these small slices like this. I don't mind paying for pizza but it needs to be the normal slices this was really a shame and disappointing. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Extra small slices - Pizza Near Me - Benicia, California

See all

The za was pretty standard za. Fire af honestly ngl. But why cut it small like this??? Edit in response to Brittany. Why are you calling me a farm? I'm taking a star off for that read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Benicia, California

See all

By FAR THE WORST EVER Pizza from any Mountain Mike's I've ever been to.Counted out 9 I repeat 9 pieces of pepperoni on a large McKinley $34 pizza. Barely any sauce on it , and if a $34 pizza which is all bread, no sauce and some cheese sits well with you be my guest! All young kids with no older management regulating the quality and customer satisfaction of how a pizza should be like, I highly recommend skipping this rip off location of a pizza chain! Good riddens forever! Crap! read more

I moved to Benicia a year ago, I've ordered from this mountain mikes about 3 times since I've moved here and it's been a bad experience every time. It's sad because I love mountain mikes pizza from other city's I've lived in/worked in so I'm always hoping maybe it has improved and I'll try it again. My daughter won't eat this and after paying $15 for a small cheese pizza I'm so mad. I ordered on DoorDash because after placing a delivery order on the website after 8pm they called me and told me they have to void it because there driver went home so i understand that but DoorDash doesn't do full refunds so I'm just put money for the horrible dinner. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Benicia, California

Absolutely terrible. I frequent a number of local pizzerias and decided to give this a try even though it's a chain and will never do it again. We got the Valentine's Day large pizza (should have known this was a bad idea) but it came cold, smaller that a regular medium, and tasted like cardboard. The breadsticks were also cold and flavorless. Don't ever order from here. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Large heart shaped pizza - Pizza Near Me - Benicia, California

See all

Sometimes your week sucks and you think oh maybe the weekend will be better! And it's only a little better. So you throw out your goals to eat healthy and just want something you can trust. We trust Mountain Mikes. We got to happily enjoy a half half specialty snowy alps and sizzling bacon! The garlic white sauce has never been beat by anyone else. And for the girl who hates red sauce and the husband who eats mostly anything; all is well. We stared at the golden egg machine and still didn't win. But it's cool cause the pizza had a cheese pull. Shout out to the girl at the counter who brought us ranch. You're a real one! We live like 5 minutes away now so we'll be back. Thanks mountain mikes for being a reliable treat. read more

See all

I went to get a pizza for me and my wife on Monday night around 845 and they would not take my order I thought you were OPEN till 9 guess not. Went to round table that night read more

Service was great. Food was hot and fresh. We have ordered online as well, their online ordering is easy and reliable. Also if they have a question about what you ordered online they actually call to verify what you want instead of guessing or bringing something they interpreted wrong read more

If I could I would give 0 stars ,Completely disappointed with this location I order a pizza for delivery waited 1 hour until I noticed the pizza still hasn't been delivered so I called and asked were the pizza was come to find out they delivered to the incorrect address so I asked for a refund since they were already closed and no longer making delivery's. The employee said she could not get me a refund and when I tried to speak to manger she told me there was no manger on site so she took my information and handed it over to a "GM" received a phone shorty after from him and he told me that my address on the system was the address they delivered the pizza at which was NOT my address I tried to talk to him and he did not let me speak What so ever he said that the Police ARE HIS FRIENDS and that he need to report me since they get these types of phone calls very often were people call and say they never received there food and ask for there money back and lie. Not only did he make me feel like I was lying but the fact that your attitude was very aggressive is SUPER unprofessional. I would never order from this location ever. This was my first time ordering since I moved to this area and I'm completely dissatisfied. Round table will always be number 1 for me. read more

I ordered from this store on DoorDash yesterday and what was delivered was absolutely vile. I ordered the Apple of my Pie which is something I've tried before from a different location and liked. What we received is a repulsive, grotesquely raw, entirely inedible, underbaked abomination from the pits of hell itself. It's also missing several ingredients. It's supposed to have cheese and cinnamon topping that bakes to a golden brown over the apples. For me, everything was so unbaked that the poor apples slid right off of their pedestals revealing the sticky raw dough that violated my eyes and turned my stomach in horror. DoorDash dummy robot only reimbursed me for half of what I paid for this disgraceful trash-Goblin they call Apple of my Pie at this particular location. read more

See all

I ordered pizzas for lunch on a Sunday afternoon using the website. I've done it many times at another location in the next city over, so I thought the process would be just as seamless. Sadly, that wasn't the case here. This location doesn't have indoor dining at this time. So when you walk in, it looks very dead. There appeared to be only two workers in the back - one of them running back and forth, covering both front and back. After I placed my order, I thought 30 minutes would be ample time to have my order ready. But when I arrived, they hadn't even started my order. I had to wait 20+ additional minutes for my food. The food quality was not as good as the other location I frequent, it may have been undercooked because the crust was cardboard-like. I know Mountain Mike's Pizza is good pizza, but I think this location is sadly lacking. read more

I used to be a huge fan of Mountain Mike's when I lived in the Bay Area. Quite a few years ago, though, they went through a slump in quality (in my opinion) and that caused me to stop eating their pizza. Fast forward to a few days ago, my wife and I decided to treat my parents to pizza and when asked where they'd like it from, my mom suggested Mike's. I wasn't too excited about that but over the years she's eaten at places I wanted to go that she didn't, so fair is fair. I ordered and left to pick up it up a little bit later. On arrival, I found the restaurant to be clean and the employee inside from friendly and welcoming. Once I got back, I tried a slice and I'm happy to report that the quality has improved significantly. Good pizza and good customer service. read more

They make my pizza correctly when i come in and order. I ordered through the app today and the pizza was wrong. The pepperoni pizza (which i added Spicy Sausage and mushrooms to) had NO pepperoni's on it. I love to eat here bc i love the pepperonis. At the store i also showed my app for my free reward side which they couldn't honor either because they do not know how. I did call and she asked if i wanted 15% off or a new pizza which i was not going to go back to pick up. And quite honestly, i do not like to have my food remade. Even if i was still in store. I do not know if they are upset and may mess with my food. I asked for a refund on my purchase and she said without seeing it, she can't refund me which i offered a photo but she did not allow. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Benicia, California

Ordered a sausage and cheese pizza. Where the hell is the sausage if there is scarcity going on that I'm aware of. What a total waste of money time effort pitiful three pieces of sausage or a slice of a large pizza. Sad sad sad never again. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pitiful sausage and cheese pizza from Mountain mad expensive only reason the slice is missing is they had hungry kids - Pizza Near Me - Benicia, California

The cashier was nice and friendly. My pizza and wings were ready in a reasonable time. The inside was clean.

I received an email from Mountain Mike's advertising a coupon for kids 12 and under for 499 lunch buffet. My kids are on summer break so I thought wow what a great idea pizza and salad sounds good. We arrived at around 12:30. There was no one in sight and no food in sight except for the salad bar that was so low on food and limited, we had to wait 15 minutes for the pizza to come out. The lady charge me to add on the salad bar, but did not charge the next two people after me. I thought that was a little unfair. Please step up your lunch buffet. read more

This was by far the worst experience I've ever had ordering pizza from here. My pepperoni pizza was burnt and seem to have been sitting under a heat lamp for about an hour. The slices were all messed up and it just wasn't fresh. I get it it's new years but that not an excuse for poor food service especially after paying $70.00! read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Benicia, California

Aye blood where is the pepperoni I'm paying for pepperoni not cheese with a lil bit of pepperoni read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Benicia, California

These guys redeemed themselves.... Disregard my previous post..... last night we Had a great pizza delivered right to the field at joe Henderson movie night. Pizza was large, hot and delicious. Also love how part of the proceeds of the pizza goes to the school. Thank you mountain mike for contributing to the local schools. read more

Ordered half pepperoni half luau chicken. The chicken on the pizza smelled weird and after a few bites I knew it was bad. I had food poisoning from the bad pizza! I looked closely at the chicken on the pizza and there were green spots on it. Disgusting! Really poor quality. Going elsewhere next time. read more

I don't normally write bad reviews of restaurants but oh my god did this one deserve it. The whole pizza itself was so dry that it was a pain in the ass to even try and chew it. There's hardly any sausage on it even when I asked for extra, and the cheese just did not taste right. I would honestly rather go to round table for a chain pizza place but I would still stick with either pizza pirate or Pacific pizza Edit: The store manager reached out to offer their sincerest apology. I will be giving them another try in the near future read more

I placed an order via Uber Eats and called in to the location immediately for them to add extra sauce to my pizza as there was no option to do within the Uber Eats app. The young woman on the phone said it would be fine and that they could do that. About 2 minutes later I get a missed call from a totally different number and try calling the number back to no avail. The number was disconnected. Then I call the actual phone number to the location just to follow up and the young woman then reneged what she initially told me and "the cook already started your pizza so we couldn't add extra sauce." Generally, I'm easy to please but I'm just turned off by the young woman not upholding her word. Then I asked as a customer service gesture if she was able to at least give me some complementary marinara sauce on the side to which she refused at first. Then, she put me on hold and said that she could only provide one but I'd have to pay for extra, which is nice, however, extra sauce on the pizza itself is what I asked for and asking me to pay added insult to injury. My enthusiasm for choosing this location has dwindled. I'm rather disappointed as one of the reasons I order pizza from Mountain Mikes is extra sauce on the pizza. As this was my first ever experience with this location, it will be my very last. I will not be supporting this location anymore. All I wanted to do was support a local business and eat my favorite pizza with extra sauce on this fine Wednesday evening after a long day of work. I should have stuck with Mountain Mike's on Sonoma Blvd. in Vallejo as they always add extra sauce without inconvenience or hassle. Be safe y'all. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - No sauce - Pizza Near Me - Benicia, California

Literally was on hold for 10 minutes to order take out, which is fine. But as soon as the lady picked up she pretended not to hear me and hung up on me. So I called back and said "please don't put me on hold you just hung up on me" then she just said "Oh ok" then hung up again. Horrible Service. I'm going to round table or pizza pirate! SMH read more

Didnt know you have to pay for extra toppings just to receive toppings. Sausage and peppers. Very little Sausage, plenty of peppers! $31 disappointment. Pizza was also dry needed more sauce. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Sausage and peppers. Mostly peppers - Pizza Near Me - Benicia, California

See all

If you are looking for pizza locally I would say this place is it. It's tough to be a business/restaurant in this day and age.... But with that being said I generally have sub par experiences. Food generally isn't ready on time even with online ordering. I'd also like to preface that I don't expect my order out on the dot, but within a reasonable 10-15 minutes after the ETA is given is always nice. Additionally staff seem to give average experiences. It's a more leisurely paced and take your time vibes.... Very single task oriented, as in staff are not well trained to multitask and be efficient. On what seems a quiet day with only 2 customers in a 15 minute time span the front workers were confused.... The worker was apparently waiting for a side of honey garlic for the wings... though no special requests were made but rather he thought it was wings with a side of sauce? If you are going to be put on the front end you should at least know your menu. Definitely think some re-training would go a long way to make these employees successful. But anyways back to the pizza review: it was flavorful but cold. read more

Pizza quality has gone down. I wish I would've taken a picture of how it was sliced. Completely terrible. I wouldn't visit this location again. read more

My family are repeat customers because we love the pizza and breadsticks. It's a tasty, convenient meal that gives us enough leftovers for the next day. The staff is always friendly in my experience. The one reason I had to take away one star is, we usually get our food delivered, and almost never receive the Parmesan and peppers we ask for. This time we didn't even receive the ranch which we paid extra for. I called the restaurant about this before, but now that it's still happening, I thought I'd come here in hopes it will improve. At the end of the day, it's a small inconvenience, I still really like this location and would recommend it. read more

Not sure why the low reviews but my wife ordered the everest pizza, a basic combination pizza, but it was ready in 20 minutes and it was great when I brought it home. When I picked it up I was greeted and was out the door, it looked like it's Togo only as well. I prefer mountain mikes over little Caesars or round table that's just me. read more

Two stars, not one, but only because historically they've been pretty reliable. Yesterday night, ordered a 32 dollar pizza via EAT24. Received the confirmation that the order was placed. Waited 20 mins, and since i was working, my wife headed over to pick it up. She got to the the store and was informed that they never received an order for me. Went back and forth and back and forth, and then back and forth so more! Bear in mind that i already for this pizza, i received confirmations that this store was getting it ready and it was on time. The manager on site really made us feel like we had to prove to them that we were not lying, which is horrible to do when you work in the "hospitality industry". I paid my money, the 3rd party service confirmed that this store had my order and was working on it. So, after wayyyy too long, I resorted to have to forward them my personal emails (key-word here: "personal email") they my (1) confirmed my order , AND (2) my email (from my pesronal account) confirming that I paid for it. My wife hard headed about stuff like this. I'd prefer not to waste my time and i'll find another pizza place. We are in no way short on place to eat pizza.. Anyhow, she waited for them to make it. They said that because they "never got the order" that we'd have to wait the regular amount of time for the pizza to cook. At this point, it was almost an hour of valuable time wasted. But,this is where it gets kinda funny.... The manager on site explained they they have "NEVER HAD TO CONFIRM AN ORDER FOR EAT24". Common sense called BS, because a business structure for an SAAS service provider, such as EAT24, would be completely out of business tomorrow if they never confirmed with a partner restaurant brand/chain that they were actually getting the orders..... just think about that....that statement makes no sense. As a side note, I work in software, I write SLA contracts as part of my day to day workflow. An SLA is a "service level agreement" that explains how the process or software works, and how a software company will resolve issues or problems should one arise. A professional would laugh themselves silly if they saw an SLA that says, 'we never asked the client (restaurants) to confirm the order'. Anyhow, she's waiting, and five minutes or so after they offered to make the pizza IT WAS READY! They have magical ferry dust that creates pizzas faster than some people can urinate in a toilet! I was impressed. The best part, right when she called to say they had it ready, i received an email from EAT24 saying the restaurant had just advised that the order was fulfilled. LOL. bear in mind, they "never got this order", from the managers mouth, so the other logical explanation was that the ferry that gave them the ferry dust which makes pizzas in 5 mins VS 25 mins that it normally takes on a busy weekend, and also told EAT24 that my food was about to go out the door! So, to bring this all to an end, and to offer some proper feedback, Mountain Mike's should look this review as some form of a NPS score or Net Promoter Score (some more software and restaurant verbiage). If they do, they will realize that by looking at the terrible reviews on social media. ALL THE REVIEWS on Yelp, these reviews also serve as a KPI (key-performance indicator) that they are not doing something right. Oh yes, and, i sent over an email to EAT24 because they asked for feedback. They replied that this location confirmed the order not ONE time, but TWO times which they verified on their action logs. Once via tablet set exclusively for EAT24, but again via a general email address at the restaurant. So, someone is full of it.....and based on my professional experience in tech, the person what was full of it was not emailing me back in tens minutes to advise they issued me a full refund and would have someone reach out to the restaurant to ask they are telling people that they "do not confirm any orders". When you own a restaurant, you sell two things that mean more than anything else - 1) food, and 2) service. Food was fine, but service sucked big time. Thanks for reading my rant! Forgive any typos, have an appointment i need to be at, so i am not proofreading. read more

Came here with the kids for the all you can eat. Great price and selection. Helpful friendly staff. Kayla and Maxx treated us like royalty even though it was extremely busy! read more

The service is always good. The employees are very helpful and the pizza is always hot and delicious. This Mountain Mikes is a very convenient stop when I am picking up dinner for my family in a flash. read more