This is a great little café in the middle of town. I went on a recent Saturday morning and it's…read morefull of character and is a great breakfast that's an even better deal. I had the breakfast shoe, which is two biscuits covered in hash browns, sausage gravy and two eggs on top. Each item was cooked perfectly-biscuits weren't overcooked, hash browns were browned appropriately and the eggs were cooked as ordered. The gravy was the highlight-some of the best gravy I've had in a long time. Friendly service and it's not far off of I-70 between St Louis and Indianapolis, so if you want to pull of for a great comfort food experience for breakfast or lunch, this is your place.

Stopped here on our across country road trip. The homemade biscuits with their breakfast sandwiches…read morewere beyond incredible. Flaky, buttery and delicious. Most importantly their pie was pure homemade goodness. Do yourself a favor and have everyone at the table get a different slice and better yet, bring an entire pie home with you!!! Highly recommend and wish it was in my neighborhood to frequent daily. Worth the 3 mile drive off the highway! Plenty of parking for larger vehicles such as a uhaul.

Great place whether you're looking for a buffet or want to order from the regular menu. The staff…read moreis friendly, and the atmosphere feels very family-oriented and welcoming. I really like the cute barn-style building, which fits perfectly with the rural location. It's also conveniently located close to Casey, making it an easy stop when checking out some of the area's big attractions like the pitchfork and mailbox. The food is a nice option whether you're stopping in for a full meal or just exploring the area. Plenty of charm and a relaxed atmosphere make this a fun local spot. Definitely worth checking out if you're in the area!

Tried their famous 1-lb. pork chop and catfish dinner to go. So delicious with generous portions…read more.. we managed to have 2 meals out of our order! Pleasant and friendly staff. Charming restaurant and cozy front lobby. The giant pitchfork is perched right outside the front door! They also have a beautiful garden with a small pond where you could enjoy the lovely flowers and the surrounding farm. Will definitely come back on our next visit to Casey!

Great breakfast & Customer Service! Glad we found this place!…read moreIt seemed like a place locals frequented.

We stopped in on our 10hr drive back to Chicago. It was a great break from all the driving. We were…read morelooking for a place that had a little bit of everything to satisfy 2 adults and 4 kids. Everything we ordered was great and the service was excellent.

The word on HDR is that they serve some of the best pies available, as in these are destination…read morepies. Hazel Dell is a tiny hamlet south of Greenup and Casey, and north of Newton. It is open every day except Sunday and open for lunch and supper. The restaurant is in a tiny building just south of the four way stop. There is nothing else here, so I might recommend calling ahead.

Fantastic! Call ahead and either find out when the pies are available or reserve a pie…read more I stopped in for lunch and had her special plus pie! Delicious. I also took home 2 cinnamon rolls.

Went there Tuesday.09-15-2026. 7-7:30 .Seemed like they had room. Party of 6 was being waited on…read morefor a table. It was just husband and I. Don't know if they thought we were part of that six. But there was no reason why they couldn't ask if we were with them or not. After 10 minutes we left. We were trying to find a new place to eat. Since we travel your area a lot. But seems we will be looking elsewhere.

Leaving the parking lot now as we left our very first visit to Gabby Goat! Brittney was our…read morewaitress and she was amazing! We decided last minute this morning at the hotel to grab Sunday Brunch at Gabby Goat before heading back home and we don't regret it. Well, he might as he's driving and I will for sure be taking a nap like the passenger princess I am. We've always passed through Effingham on our travels but have never visited until now. We will definitely be back. The breakfast was delicious, the restaurant is gorgeous, and the attentiveness of Brittany was top notch! She took great care of us and we may have laughed a little too hard at a couple of things. Thank you Brittany and the Gabby Goat team!

Family friendly atmosphere, good service and wonderful food! I ordered a grilled cheese sandwich…read moreand it came out perfect! vanilla ice cream topped our lunch off. It was delicious as well!

Great food and excellent service. We had breakfast here today. Eggs, pancakes, and bacon were…read morecooked perfectly.

Are you kidding me?! It is so refreshing to find out that old fashioned diners like this still…read moreexist, instead of just sterile chains with no homey flavor. Flo (IYKYK), also known as Shannon, was the sweetest waitress who made us feel like old friends. When the cook screwed up my BLT by putting mayo on it instead of on the side we heard her yell to him that I "was born here and hasn't been back in 50 years, so don't JACK it up!". I may have gotten choked up... On Shannon's recommendation we got the BLT and a pancake the size of the entire plate. both were perfect! I don't think I have ever had a better pancake! And the bonus is that the whole meal was $11. If I ever drive through again, I am stopping at Crossroads Cafe!

Feature a series of melts sandwiches with no idea how to cook them…read more Country fried steak tasted like it came frozen and was thawed out. Wait staff were excellent. I used to really enjoy this restaurant when I visited Marshall. So disappointed.

Well they sure aren't kidding about the "on the tracks" part. If there were a window on the north…read morewall, you could reach out and smack a train as it roars by. And indeed one roared by as we were eating, and the whole place shook. That may not be the ambiance you're after for a nice quiet breakfast, but you're given fair warning by the name of the place if not its physical location. So the food was a mixed bag. My fried mushrooms looked promising at first by their hand-breaded appearance, but they arrived overcooked. My egg and sausage biscuit sandwich on the other hand was outstanding, and my wife's lone pancake -- she was correctly advised one would would suffice -- was the size of a hubcap and damn near could have fed both of us. There's no gilding the lily here, it's just straightforward heartland diner fare served with the ambiance, service, and smile to match, for about 11 bucks each all in -- drink, tax, tip, everything.

This was your typical hometown restaurant. Cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, quick service. Very…read morenice. The food was good but nothing out of this world. They have a daily soup of sausage potato cabbage and that was much better than it sounded! The Italian beef had a good texture but there was something I couldn't put my finger on a taste in it I didn't love. Didn't prevent me from eating it though! The salad was your typical salad. Nothing out of the ordinary but good. Overall a good lunch!

Excellent service and w we quality meal. 8 of us had a staff outing day from our church…read more All grilled burgers, grilled tenderloin sandwich was perfect & home grown banana peppers were awesome. Lots of variety of toppings for sandwiches. CASH only - no cards or checks accepted. Outside dining was picnic tables clean atmosphere and fun experience. Family friendly.

Worth the drive to eat these delicious burgers. Cash only. Burgers are grilled while you wait…read more Seating outside on the picnic tables. The burgers are bigger than he bun. Condiments are sitting on the table and you help yourself. It was simple, tasty and fun.