The staff is super nice and I want to love this place! I can see myself maybe visiting again / wanting to come to Omaha just to come here again, granted it's pricey and my experience today was eh so maybe not?
So I'll start with the bad first; they don't carry the Snickers Pie anymore for some reason, so I tried to get something similar.
The Peanut Butter Cup cheese cake sucked, it was bland. I wish I could've found a picture here first. I thought it would have caramel drizzled on the top, i guess it was in it? I didn't taste caramel at all.
If you do order it you're going to want to give it time to melt a bit because it comes pretty hard, as most cheesecakes do fresh out the freezer.
Its also more of a grainy kind of cheesecake- sort of like those protein balls you can get at the store- Like a protein bar- instead of the smooth daiya stuff you can get at the grocery store- which honestly, if you wanted this you could just pick up a chocolate daiya cheesecake, let it sit out a bit and cover with peanut butter and graham cracker sprinklings on top. When it was completely melted i could taste the chocolate and caramel more but the protein bar center remained. I feel like calling this cheesecake is a stretch.
I only ate a bite and was kinda done with it but I didn't want to be a bother and try to get a refund since i purchased and had a bite. Plus the staff was nice and some visibly alternative and I didn't want to give them a hard time. It sucked to waste $10 on a grainy cheesecake slice though.
So the next was the ice cream. I'm convinced what i was given wasnt the peanut butter, as my friend got the peanut butter shake- which was AWESOME! Super tasty, recommend. But this had some kind of orange fruity tasting parts in it? I didn't realize it was probably not it until my last couple bites and once against didn't want to be a bother.
I wish i got my caramel sauce on the side, or asked about the orange pieces when I came back to get the caramel on because they forgot to put it on my ice cream
(luckily i bucked up and bothered them about that- because it was extra and was forgotten as opposed to something I've already eaten)
All that aside, besides wasting $10 on a bland gritty cheesecake slice and getting the wrong ice cream scoop the mint chip scoop was nice, (pretty small for $2.60~) it had nice dark chocolate slices of different sizes. It's a more crunchy thing, with bigger than usually chips so if you're looking for mint with hints of chocolate that's not the one for you.
The Dutch chocolate scoop was nice, i don't know how Dutch chocolate is suppose to taste but paired with the caramel (which was great! I don't know what it was made of- i think it was coconut? It was more of a sauce and had little black specks. Tasty)
The peanut butter shake was really tasty! It was my favorite and sadly wasn't mine. I would recommend that above all else here.
I definitely encourage people to try this place out, and want to give it 5 stars as an all vegan restaurant with nice alternative staff and a clean look (if that wasn't the case this probably would've been 2 stars?), but I spent $20~ in the end to enjoy a very small scoop of mint chip and chocolate ice cream with caramel.
If my friend hadn't let me have some sips of their peanut butter shake I would've been way sadder and felt pretty ripped off. I definitely feel like all vegan spaces and spaces that employ alternative people are important. I hope they can get their service together a bit more (i came at like 11:30AM, it wasn't like people were tired) and hopefully bring back the snickers pie / maybe change their cheesecake so it's smoother? read more