Fuhgeddaboudit!…read more That's all I gotta say. This place had me talking like I was born in Brooklyn after one bite. I got the special: $30 for a 16-inch cheese pizza (added pepperoni because plain pizza wasn't invited to this party), 10 buffalo wings comes a side of ranch but you can choose a flavor, garlic bread. While we waited, people kept coming in and out grabbing to-go orders. That's always a good sign the food is going to be amazing and everyone knows something I don't. Then the food arrived. I looked at that pizza and said Fuhgeddaboudit. Took one bite Fuhgeddaboudit. The cheese was perfect, the pepperoni had great flavor, and the sauce wasn't trying to take over the whole pizza like it owned the place. Everything was balanced. Then I tried a wing Fuhgeddaboudit. Some of the best oven-baked wings I've had from a pizza shop. My only advice: if you're getting them to go, ask for extra sauce because those wings soak it up faster than a New Yorker can say "Fuhgeddaboudit" Now the garlic bread well that's the only thing that would be sleeping with the fishes. But I'll give it a pass because I've never really been a garlic bread guy anyway. So if you ever see a Brooklyn Pizzera shop and you're hungry, stop in. I promise after that first bite you'll be looking around saying "Fuhgeddaboudit!"

Absolutely great!!! It's been a huge improvement compared to years and years ago…read more Customer service: 10/10. Som place give passive aggressive attitude and not notice it, but the staff here is patient. The gentleman with glasses has been great with the multiple visits I've made. Food: 9.5/10 selection is really high for a NY style pizza and offer beef pepperoni substitutions. Price: 10/10 in today's economy, getting. Huge cheese pizza for $18 is great!!!!! Diner: 9.5/10 add an arcade machine maybe lol, very clean, not loud, fountain machine is placed near and easily accessible. Overall love it!!!

Ordered their Family#1 meal, 2 large gourmet pizzas, cheese bread and 2L soda. I only received the…read morepizzas. Called restaurant was told missing items would be delivered in 25-30 minutes. Hour later, items still missing, restaurant is called. I've been given explanation from new POS, to we don't have that deal, to our receipts only show 2 gourmet pizzas, and finally to call Uber Eats. Contacted uber eats and was told there's nothing they can do about it.

In a failed management decision this business has tried to go "online" and disabled their phone…read morenumber. You are forced to use their yelp "order" link which is a terrible experience and doesn't allow you to submit anything. Just answer the phone so we can place our order.

SO good: great food, great value, great service. Very generous portions for the price…read more I'm mostly vegetarian & they had a lot of vegetarian options. A bonus is complimentary buttery garlic knots. Janice/Janis, our server, was awesome. They can accommodate large groups. There was a coach/bus in the parking lot & the passengers were filing out as we walked in.

The food was ok, I had salmon and pasta. It wasn't amazing but it wasn't bad. The decor was not…read moregreat. There was a trash bag hanging from the ceiling and dry wall damage. The tv was playing Fox News propaganda so I had to sit through anti trans, anti immigrant bs while I tried to eat. Weird choice to put on the tv for an Italian place. Won't be going back.

I heard about this location a few years ago and everyone raved about it so I decided to check it…read moreout since I was in the area. The restaurant is located in a shopping strip so the parking was free. When we walked in the restaurant was empty. I ordered a large Classic Combo pizza, individual pepperoni pizza, wings (Buffalo and Garlic Parmesan) and a 2-liter soda. My grandson loved his pepperoni pizza. However, the Classic Combo pizza was very dry. The wings were good but the dressings they give you do not complement the wings well. The tea and Diet Coke was out of service. Also, one of the two restroom stalls was also out of service. The service from the cashier was okay. The ambiance was dull. They had TVs on the wall but none of them were on and I don't recall hearing any music. Overall, it didn't measure up to the Godfather's Pizza that I loved as a kid.

Amazing sauces, and crusts. Reminds me of how Pizza Hut use to be for those 80s babies or before…read more That's the taste. I go, All-meat always or meat lovers, minus that bacon. Bacon bits isn't my thing, has to be real bacon on a pizza for me. Just that texture. Other than that, they do well here. Never had a bad pizza. Don't sleep on Godfather's.

First time here and we loved it All of the staff was super…read morefriendly We will be back

Pizza and Service was Great! New Haven Style and The Neapolitan was done right. Crispy and Tasty!!…read moreIt definitely will be a go to spot for me.

I placed a phone order as I always do. Order was supposed to be ready in 10 minutes. I got there,…read moretold them my name and they said they were still making my order. After waiting another 15 minutes, I asked if they were making my order because it had been 30minutes after order was placed. They asked my name again and then they said they couldn't find my order? They said i called the wrong Marcos which was not true because I have their number saved since we eat there at least 1-2 a month. I asked for their phone number and then showed them that I had called that number 35minutes prior. Then I said forget it at this point, I'm not going to wait another 15minutes. They could've cared less.. my thing is they told me they were still working on my order and still had me wait another 15minutes.. if I wouldn't have got up to ask, I would've been there for who knows how long.

Great pizza and a very friendly staff. The restaurant is clean and I've never regretted visiting…read more The service is fast and affordable!!

5 star alert! Authentic Chicago pizza Here!…read more I was really disappointed when the old location closed down. I would drive all the way from champion forest just to get his amazing pies. Absolutely amazing pizza! Glad to find they reopened! Food: the pizza is absolutely amazing! The cheese is imported from Wisconsin. The sauce is made homemade from four tomatoes. Everything is organic and home made. You know the pizza is quality is great when you eat the pizza and don't get sick. They use quality great ingredients. Charles is the owner and he really goes out of his way to make his clients feel at home. He has excellent customer service skills. You can also tell he is very passionate about his business and the food he serves up. This is one of my Chicago pizza I've ever had.

I don't give many one stars, but this place earns it. I am sitting here writing this review. It's…read moreso bad I don't even want to get a refill on my tea. I had to take my pizza back to the counter to ask where the Italian sausage was. It's under the cheese, almost lunch meat thin sausage, and about one slice of black olive per slice of pizza. I guess the sauce was ok, but the lack of seasoning and cheese just made it a crappy pizza. 22 dollars for two drinks and a large two topping pizza. I wish I checked yelp first. Definitely go to cici's instead.

Recently ordered delivery from this spot and it was just okay for me. Pizza prices are a little on…read morethe pricier side. Was excited that they have mozzarella sticks so got an order of those and they were pretty good. The pizza itself didn't really stand out for me it was a little bit on the saucier side and the dough was pretty thick, maybe next time I will try their thin crust pizza.

Another chain pizza spot that does not stand out except for its gourmet pizza prices. I expect a…read morelot of pepperoni from a place called pepperonis including bold (cup and crisp) pepperoni as a topping. If you have a coupon or their daily special, check them out. I think this restaurant will be successful once the kinks are worked out and I applaud them for selling out on their highly anticipated debut (delayed opening date). It's a cute clean shop (no inside seating) but friendly staff and manager. They have amazing fizzy lemonade in a cute bottle branded for them, like a keepsake. The pizza has inconsistencies. The hand tossed New Yorker all pepperoni was good, although mine had the wrong sauce (marinara vs pizza sauce) and a lot of extra crust, no flavor options. This version of their crust is hand stretched and fresh. So I went with this one. No solution was offered for the mistake, just an excuse. In good faith, i ordered again a few days later, this time thin crust, which I did not enjoy due to the sauce/crust ratio. So far, Pepperoni's does not have the depth or the old world pepperonis to replace my go-to pizza chain--Marcos.