Miss Ada is a special place. Pre-COVID, mid-COVID -- whatever angle you want to take, Miss Ada looks like a queen. This spot had been on my list for quite some time before I finally visited. I live on the UWS and rarely venture to Brooklyn, which is the primary reason I didn't come here sooner. Though had I lived in the neighborhood without knowledge of the NYC restaurant scene, I probably wouldn't have given Miss Ada a second glance. It's unassuming and fairly bare bones. But the product and hospitality coming out this place is as excellent as you'll find in the whole city. If you like Mediterranean fare, coming here is a no-brainer. You'll find elevated Israeli classics that are true to their roots with an added layer of creativity. It has adapted beautifully to the new COVID reality and remains a powerhouse in the scene.
Came to Miss Ada last Saturday night. We had an 8pm reservation, but weren't able to be seated until around 8:40. On some nights I'd be highly bothered, but the staff here made it all worth it. After we were waiting for about 10-15 minutes, the host brought us complimentary frozen drinks (a marg for the bf and a frosé for moi) as a gesture of appreciation for our patience. Another 15 or so minutes went by and as we were finishing up our first round, the host scurried back and informed us that our table would be ready very soon but that he'd happily bring us a second round, on them, if we'd like. We declined but thanked him graciously. Truthfully, since COVID began, I haven't been able to just stand around socially and chat with a drink in hand, so the experience was refreshing (we were on the sidewalk, Miss Ada is still fully outdoors for COVID).
Once we were finally led to our table, the host assured us that he would comp some small plates for us, which he did. They really do value customer satisfaction here and the place overall is just so warm and welcoming. Part of why I wanted to come to Miss Ada was the famed backyard garden, which is as quaint and romantic as advertised. The tables are maybe a tiny bit too close together but not nearly as bad as what I've seen elsewhere. The setup is thoughtful and makes for a great dining experience.
While the frozen drinks were definitely the highlight cocktail-wise (though we also tried the lavender old-fashioned, which was yummy), the wine menu was also powerful in its own right. An emphasis on natural, biodynamic wines with a diverse selection of by-the-glass options. I've generally been hesitant to get into orange wines since my first few tastes in the past weren't to my liking, but I felt adventurous here and ordered a glass once our food started arriving. I was rewarded for my curiosity -- the wine was funky and earthy but not overpoweringly bold, just what I was in the mood for. Just take their advice here!
Now onto the main event. Truly magical food. The menu here is huge (even by pre-COVID standards), so it's really quite a challenge to deliberate. Sharing is recommended, encouraged, essentially mandatory, and should you not want to share maybe just take your business elsewhere? Sorry, I don't mean that. You'd just be silly not to want to try to cover every last crevice of this menu. The dips and kebabs are the royalty but it's all fair game. They're known for their za'atar-crusted salmon and their brick chicken entrees as well, but my recommendation is skip the mains, go the the littles. I'd say we covered good ground. Eats, below:
Whipped Ricotta w/ Brown Butter, Honey, Sage: A++
This is truly mind-blowing. I could forgo all dessert for the rest of my life and just eat this. Seriously heavenly, decadent perfection. Sweet, rich, creamy, all the good stuff.
Lamb Shawarma Hummus w Amba, Parsley: A++
It's clear why they're known for their dips here. Another unbelievable dish, served with pita but honestly you could easily just eat this straight. Rich, super flavorful and had me missing Israel.
Falafel w/ Feta, Olives, Green Tahini: A++
Okay, so speaking of Israel, the best falafel I've ever had was undoubtably there. But if you want my vote for the best *fancy* falafel, Miss Ada wins in a landslide. The perfect amount of crisp on the outside and the green tahini was just next-level tasty.
Salmon Belly kebab w/ Labne, Charmoula: A
Wasn't quick enough to get a picture before we dug in but this was fantastic. Melt-in-your mouth good. One of the smaller skewers on the menu so ordering this could enable you to try more dishes.
Short Rib w/ Red Cabbage, Israeli Mole: A+
Another perfectly seasoned, well-executed and varied dish. These kebabs are next-level and ideal for sharing. Great on their own, better in the mole. read more