I have been here twice. Once to eat in and another time for takeout. We came on a weekend to eat, with no reservations. Business was already brisk. Were seated quickly and in a reasonable time served. The food was great. I had a seasonal special of Risotto and Squash. My partner had a pasta dish. They were delicious. Another time we ordered pizza. The order was made online and in a few minutes I received a call, informing me that the desert I ordered (Tiramisu) was out. Asking if I had any other requests. The lemon cake I chose was also especially nice. (Note: It was a Tuesday at about 6:45 I came to pick up the takeout order and I was surprised at how the place was already full of folks and lively with conversation, and people eating.) Something that I can't help noticing, both as an eat-in customer, and returning to pick up my pizza, is how intelligent and communicative the servers all seem to be. Another thing is the general good mood of people inside, and casually interacting with others coming and going from this establishment. It is a venue in a small town, and perhaps something about that seems to express some of the nicer aspects of small town living. read more

I've been a semi-regular customer for several years. This time will be my absolute last. I had a serious complaint about my order, called and asked to speak to the manager, was told they would call me back. They never called back. Now I notice they are looking for employees in almost every category. What used to be a great place to get food and drinks has gone so downhill it's disappointing. To not call a customer back is inexcusable. Due to the nature of my complaint I will never order food from this establishment again - it was that bad. read more

Mill River Tavern did not disappoint! Their bubbly flights of mimosas were absolutely amazing -- so many fun flavors and super refreshing! Perfect for a brunch date or a girls' day out. Highly recommend! read more

See all

We've been here a couple times and it's a nice tavern. We only ordered pizzas both times. They were tasty and fresh. The pizza could be a bit more crisp, but we enjoyed them. The drinks are good and prices are fair. We will definitely be back. read more

Mill River Tavern - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hatfield, Massachusetts

See all

It's a local spot for sure with the occasional F-bomb from the bar. Kids; cover your ears. No matter, vegetable pizza was absolutely delicious. Fresh veggies, tangy marinara, and superb crust; all of it expertly wood-fired. Service was prompt and courteous. As for the vibe, layout was a bit tight, much of the real estate given over to the bar. Mostly high tops with a couple of booths. The outside terrace looks very attractive for summer suppers. read more

Food was delicious - the risotto special was so good! It was a corn risotto with grilled chicken - the flavor was outstanding and the portion was huge! We also ordered a small cheese pizza - very good and the chicken nugies- which were fresh and tasty. We had the meatball appetizer- which was so good - it was also a good sized portion - 5 meatballs. Our server - Alena- was phenomenal- so attentive and helpful. read more

Service was slow, soup cold ,burger ordered well was medium rare! chicken wings tasted frozen and reheated .

Good pizza. Amazing Risotto. Mushroom heaven. Delicious My friend had a pizza. It was great too. Risotto stole the show.

I stopped by the Mill River Tavern in Hatfield for pizza takeout very recently. The place offers dine-in and takeout including a variety of traditional and specialty thin crust pizzas (NY style & Old World style) in 10" and 14" sizes, calzones, salads, sandwiches, and desserts. The bar offers several beers (on tap, bottles & cans), wine, and cocktails. The pizzas are baked on an open flame here. The place is very cozy with high top seating, table seating, and seating at the bar. I quickly looked at a menu when I got here and the server suggested the Smokin' Sausage Pizza, which I decided to order a 14" pie ($20). The pizza was hot, boxed and ready in about 15 minutes. While I was waiting, the server brought out some ice water to where I was sitting, which was appreciated since it was hot and humid outside. I enjoyed my pizza outside with my big fountain drink. The Smokin' Sausage pizza was loaded with several toppings including fresh basil, tomatoes, red onions, roasted red peppers, cream sauce, sliced Italian sausage, and mozzarella cheese on a thin chewy fire baked crust. This pizza was very tasty and after enjoying 3 slices, I was all set with 5 more slices left for the next day. read more

In the middle of our meal, we were required to move tables and help move all of our plates , food silverware and drinks. Business must be so good that they don't need mine. I'll be happy to accommodate them in the future by never going back. read more

We were so excited to try this place. New to us and we heard it was good. It was busy when we arrived and more people came in after us. Some had to wait for a table. It took too long for the server to come over to take our drink order but we chose to be patient. It took way too long to actually get our drinks (2) and discussed leaving but decided to be patient. Once we did get our drinks we had to wait even longer to order food. The server finally came over. We started ordring with our appetizer and she left and said "let me put that in". When we finally got our app we had no utensils or napkins so we had to go ask for them. We finished our app and still had not placed our food order. She finally came back to take our order but the food never came. She never came back to offer another drink. We were growing very impatient when we saw people that came in after us, finished, paid and leaving with their leftovers. We had to go ask where our food was. The server had to go to a downstairs kitchen to check. While waiting to find out the status another table that had arrived only 5-10 minutes prior, received their app. That is when we decided it was time to leave. The server came back to tell us one of our meals was ready but the other was not. Too late. We were done. We had been there over an hour. All tables I mentioned had the same server. She should have known who came in first. The bar was almost full when we arrived, more people arrived after us and was empty when we finally gave up. read more

Our pizzas were not cooked enough, the cheese was cheep and it over powered the sauce and toppings. The table was not cleaned!! and food was delivered in a random order. We came here when they first opened, the care and attention that went into the food was cleaner and more on point than tonight. Now that it has become more popular, you can tell that the food is rushed and undercooked. I think this place has taking quite a beating. It's not evolving into as wonderful a restaurant as I had hoped, sadly. I do not want to come here again however if I end up here, I hope that it's better than the experience I had tonight. this place has very strong bones and I'm fearful that it's not heading in the right direction. that being said if you want good atmosphere and a good beer, please come here this place is worth your time and it's worth the experience. however if you're coming here with your family and you're looking for a good dining experience like we were. please go elsewhere. read more

Garlic knots and sausage pizza....heavenly. Garlic knots melted in your mouth. Loved the crispy thin-crust pizza.

Super yummy appetizers and the pizza was amazing! Can't wait to come back again to try some other stuff! Server was attentive and food came out hot and delicious! read more

After a 10 hour ride we needed a beer (cold), a pizza (hot and good) and service (warm and friendly). Mill River Tavern hit a triple!! Everything was just right and the pizza was really delicious. We had the meat lovers pizza with a cold beverage that made the day perfect. Highly recommended. And we'll be sure to come back on the return leg of our trip. read more

First time at this cozy corner in Hatfield- a little hidden gem of a restaurant with a great bar and friendly staff, cute decor inside and a great outdoor patio, and AMAZING, creative pizzas! Highly recommend the Old world style pizza. Delicious, fresh toppings. Everything seems to be cooked with lots of love and care. Will return! read more

Great food, great staff. Everything on the menu is so good. The pizza is absolutely amazing and the drinks and always so unique and tasty! 10/10 recommend! read more

We ordered take out. Food was not hot and fresh. Mozzarella sticks were congealed and under cooked. The accompanying marinara sauce was absolutely terrible. The Overwhelming amount of oregano made it inedible. The crispy chicken Caesar wraps, had soggy wilted lettuce, and the potato chips were soggy and soft as well. We ordered online-we arrived on time to pick up our order-(we are staying one minute away) my guess is they had the order ready we'll ahead of our scheduled pick-up time, which resulted in poor quality meal. read more

Great service by Tad! Fantastic food! Highly recommend the ride to Hatfield! Great ambiance!

Best breakfast sandwich in western mass with the homemade biscuit! Highly recommend, fast friendly service!

A quick meet up with friend brought us here and was delighted we came.Great service (see Catie) great pizza and great selection at bar.All that adds up to 5 well deserved stars! read more