I have been going to Mihm's Charcoal Grill for decades.I remember standing outside after bar time waiting for a seat. If I remember correctly, and correct me if I'm wrong, it had 6 stools and 3 booths. When they moved across the street, I followed. When they changed owners, I followed. When they closed, I wasn't happy. When they reopened, I was overjoyed. So tonight was not my first time at Mihm's. And after all these years, I hope it won't be the last time. Tonight, like so many nights, I had the steak sandwich with cheese, onion, and butter. Some places say they have a butter burger... You haven't had a butter burger until the butter runs down your chin. My only disappointment is that the "We Don't Serve Coke Products" is down. Just the story is worth keeping the sign-up! If you have been there before, stop back and enjoy the burgers (Chili is pretty good). If you haven't been there before, stop by and give Mihm's a try. read more

See all

First timer for trying this butter burger joint. The atmosphere was nice and whatever music they were streaming was great. It can be a little loud there when it's busy, but that's all part of the vibe. Service was great, they tag team the tables so multiple servers checked on us. Definitely going to go back and have a beer with my burger next time! Oh and definitely get a double patty, I got a single and my friends double with bacon looked fire read more

Mihm's Charcoal Grill - Burgers Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin

While in Wisconsin, I felt like a brat and some cheese curds. This quaint little diner had both and both were tasty! Service was outstanding! Amber was super helpful and friendly! read more

Mihm's Charcoal Grill - Brat with everything (butter, onions and pickles) - Burgers Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin

See all

Service was impeccable from the time we walked in until we left. We hadn't been there before and burgers are my husband's favorite food, so he's always looking for a good burger place. Let me just say that the place smells amazing because of the charcoal grill. There are no more than 10 tables and a bar to sit at but they were all almost taken even though it was 4 in the afternoon. My husband ordered the 1/4 lb cheeseburger and a brat piggy back with fries. I ordered a chocolate shake with 1/3 lb cheeseburger with onion rings. We both said yes to butter, onions, and pickles even though we really didn't know what that meant until we received our food. The size of the burgers are up there in portion sizes, at least the bread. My husband felt like his patty was a little too thin. He also said that the burger needed some seasoning. The charcoal flavor came through but the meat itself needed more seasoning. The fries are a lightly battered fry but probably not fresh made. They were a little thicker so they had a good meaty bite. The onion rings were beer battered, I believe...or at least like a tempura batter. The shake was thick and chocolatey. There was nothing wrong with the food but it didn't quite measure up to what we read and heard about it. Very good but not great. It was a little weird to have butter as a condiment even though I'm pretty sure that I have Paula Deen DNA in my blood. read more

See all

Stopped in on a busy Saturday. Sat at the counter which was a little tight, but I'm a hefty guy (lol). Within 1 minute we had our drink order in, another minute our food order. Wife ordered a double with mayo, lettuce, and pickle, and I had a single cheese with onion tomato and ketchup. Both had well done fries. 12 minutes later, we had burgers to the bar. Char-grilled with real lump charcoal in the cooking area. Wife said she should have had mine, and I wish I had gotten hers. lol. Be prepared for not getting blood work done for the next few days, cause you can see the butter lump they put on each bun. Overall, delicious in every way. I would be back daily if I could. read more

Absolutely loved it! Everything was great! The staff was awesome and we can't wait to come back (and add it to our take out list)!

Ate the chili and barfed!!!!! old and nasty! The chicken soup was all broth, 1 tiny piece of chicken.. if you were out just say so don't do that you lost 2 customer, new owners must be scraping by cause we never had problems previously. Sad..... read more

This is the best place to get a buttery burger it's the best place in the Fox valley we go there at least once a week

OMG--- so first time since the exchange of ownership. I took my boyfriend who it was his first!!!! What a fantastic dinner. It was Friday so it was busy, I think 8 tables and then the single seats. You guys were the BOMB buzzing around as busy as it was and checking on everyone and excusing the wait! Can't rant enough! Great Job Guys! Keep up the butter and the onions and the great personalities!!!! read more

Go to Mihm's, buy a burger and a malt, thank me later. Awesome greasy mushroom Swiss burger. Good onion rings. Great malt. They serve fast and it is a great little joint. read more

Mihm's Charcoal Grill - Mushroom Swiss burger and onion rings - Burgers Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin

See all

Mihms has always been a good place to eat. I had a cheeseburger and a order of cheese curds. The cheeseburger was good but the cheese curds were over cooked and a little dark. It seemed like they had been cooked twice, I don't think they were, but maybe oil needed to be changed. The service was good, they were friendly and quick. It is somewhat like going to a back in time diner, worth the stop. read more

Love this place, glad its a bit of drive from my home. Too good, I'd end up on 600lb life if it was next door. Burgers are fantastic, tots are great and so are the onion rings. Don't wear your favorite shirt, things can get a little messy. read more

Well my opinion is this Buns dry not the buns past owners used Steak sandwich no charcoal flavor period French fries not Kringle cut read more

Ordered take out, sirloin brgr n fries. A few things: 1) done to perfection 2) under $10, great value! 3) friendliest folks 4) local owners Thanks again for an excellent meal read more

As usual, great food, and service at a reasonable price. The charbroiled burgers are fantastic. They even come on a Manderfield's bun. My wife had an egg salad sandwich that she loved. And it all goes great with some fried mushrooms. read more

Love this place! Food was out of this world delicious and staff are the nicest people. Must recommend to anyone looking for an outstanding meal. read more

My only previous visit was a few years ago now and I know they're closing next month, so my review isn't going to impact their business as much as it would have if I had remembered to post it when I actually stopped. That said, I'm leaving a review anyway because they deserve it. I'm sad it took me so long to find out about Mihm's when I was actually living in the Fox Valley because I feel like so many years were wasted not enjoying their delicious food. Needless to say, the burger is one of the best I've ever had. The cheese curds were great and the caramel apple pie for dessert is also among one of the best pies I've ever had. I plan on stopping at least once more before they're gone and I highly recommend everyone else do the same and take advantage of this treasure. read more

What an amazing little place for old school burgers and shakes.!!! All the people are very friendly.

MIHM'S IS OPEN AGAIN! New owner! Same food. Butter burgers, YAY!!! Come by and support the new owner, super nice. read more

Mihm's Charcoal Grill - Butter steak burger and mushrooms. - Burgers Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin

1st time here. Excellent burgers. Decent price. Excellent service! Excellent rings. Crystal Clean restaurant along with very clean washrooms mens/womens. Great parking. Very nice owner Amber was so nice and chatted with us to make sure all was good. Loved the charcoal grill! We'll be back next trip from Suamico! Thanks for cooking our lunch today!!! read more

Mihm's Charcoal Grill - Hamburger piggyback with a brat and rings on the side! - Burgers Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin

I got a serloin burger, it was good, liked the addition of butter, the bun was a bit dry, and the meat was overcooked to my liking ( I like burgers medium rare, it was well-done) the customer service was great tho! read more

Mihm's is a very special place for my si and myself. The Mihm's hamburger is awesome. in my opinion the best hamburger in the Fox Valley.

We've gone there many times in the past and loved it! But now for my husband and I to get 2 burgers, 1 order of fries and 2 malts (which are very good) it was almost $40. Way too expensive to go back. Sorry read more

I had to try Mihn's after learning from a friend that he thinks "Mihn's has THE BEST cheeseburger in Wisconsin." I took his statement as a my culinary investigative mission! The menu is simple. Burgers, brats, fried cheese curds, shakes and malts, etc. KISS totally works for this iconic family-run restaurant. I ordered a butterscotch malt, a hamburger and an order of salt and pepper tots to share. My husband ordered double butterflied brats. Sitting inside the restaurant to eat I must have heard the following inquiry dozens of times, "onions, pickles, butter?" It is faithfully asked of each and every sandwich ordered. I must say that the "onions, pickles and butter" combo really escalated my hamburger to super delicious. The fresh hard roll was THE perfect bun and the beef was flavorful and nicely seared. Stellar. Burger. My butterscotch malt was equally fantastic! All of our food was great. Just remember to bring cash, as no credit or debit cards are accepted. read more

See all

When my wife found Mihm's Charcoal Grill online, I was expecting a tavern, but when we arrived, it was a cozy diner. The Ground Sirloin Burger was greasy and great, just like it should be! I cannot remember when I've had a burger this great, it's worth going out of you way for this one. The Cheese Curds are top notch as well because there aren't many places that have batter fried curds as good as these! I had a Root Beer Float to top it off, nice part is that the ice cream was not soft serve. The bathrooms were clean and plenty of soap and hot water to clean your greasy hands. There were all kinds of age groups from elderly to a young couple with children. The music was pleasant and the establishment was clean and attractive. The staff was wonderful! The burly man working at the grill greeted us when we entered and let us grab a booth to look at the menu. We look forward to stop by again! Thank you! read more

Food has not changed since I was a teenager. The burgers are heart stoppers with the charcoal and butter flavor. Add one of the many sides and Mim's is worth the visit and wait to get in. Seating is very limited. read more

This is a neat little burger joint that cooks over an open charcoal pit. The fries are coated in corn starch which gives them crisper texture. They are delicious. The buns are warmed above the burgers as they cook, gives them a smokey flavor. Try this place if you are tired of the cookie cutter burger joints. read more

See all

The food is FABULOUS. All the staff enjoy being at work even on Saturday. They cook with love and you can taste it. It is well worth the drive no matter where you are coming from. We drive just over an hour just for lunch there and it was one of the best drives we have taken in a while. We will definitely make the drive again. Thank you for great food and great staff. Keep doing what you do, you all sure made our day. Matt and Emily Beaver Dam read more

I have had this place bookmarked for a while and I finally got over, established 1958 is on the sign which was unexpected because I didn't know it was that old. The place was packed at noon on Saturday with old and young people having burgers and frys. The place is old school looking with a U shaped lunch counter and booths along the walls. They only take cash but if you don't have cash they have an ATM by the front door. I ordered the cheeseburger with how ever they make it, I'm not changing anything so I can taste how the original is. The bun was soft with a hard top crust and not an all soft bun. This butter burger was a true greasy spoon cheeseburger that has pickles, diced onions, ketchup and brown mustard. The cheeseburger was pretty tasty with that grill flavor and I can see why they were packed, get a double because the patty is thin. Is this the best cheeseburger no but the whole experience makes it a must stop for any burger fan. read more

See all

Open again--despite it saying closed on Yelp (as of 5/2/23) When having a friendly debate about the best burgers in the Valley, Mihm's definitely deserves a place in that conversation. Mihm's is a small, no frills joint that serves up great charcoal grilled burgers. read more

First time came here today with my mom and Eric, had a good lunch, we three had hamburger and drinks.!! I recommend this place if you are in the area. They were friendly, food and drinks was great!! read more

Disappointed last week....not saying the steak sandwich meal isn't good...but not GREAT as it's been for 40 years that I've been enjoying the food. I had a fabulous meal...chocolate malt, fries, steak sandwich...with friends in May....tasted very close to what I have come to expect with butter dripping down my arms....yum! November 12...so excited to have lunch with friends. Once served, I commented that the fries were changed....was told by our server that they were having problems getting consistency and switched providers. I will say it's the first time I've not finished my fries. We also noticed a different bun...not that the new bun was bad....just not as good. Biting into the sandwich there was little running of butter...I started getting a dry sandwich feel. What we discovered was when we bit into the center of the sandwich, we also bit into a block of some type of margarine that was still semi hard...and of course not butter. Don't know if the "butter" was frozen when added to our sandwiches, but it sure didn't melt. The chocolate malt was the only thing that didn't change and it was fabulous like always. The rest....well...not so much. read more

Always good....maybe not so healthy, but always good. Great service and reasonable prices.

The best butter burger with onions. Very popular among locals. Always a treat. You won't be disappointed.

So... I've been going to Mihms for years. I grew up right down the road on 1st street and in the summer times I always couldn't wait to go over and pick up a juicy butter burger after school. Now looking back and having them open after being closed down shortly it's nice to see an old tradition come back now with the family. Everyone there is always in a great mode and can make an average day the best day:) read more

We were in WI visiting and were introduced to Mihms. Service was great, they were super nice and fast. It's diner style food but their burgers were delicious! If I lived close, this would definitely become a staple in my life. Great portions, great prices - just a tip - CASH ONLY. read more

Greatest grilled burger around in my opinion...onion rings are nice and crispy the way I like them Fast, friendly service from the owner read more

First time, trying out the famous burgers and they were delicious!!! We thoroughly enjoyed this small treasure in the heart of Menasha.

Excellent old-school diner. They cook your burger in a charcoal grill in the wall! Your doctor will only let you eat there once a year because it has too much baked in deliciousness read more

So bummed they're closing. Had to stop by with my grandpa to have a burger and shake. Delicious and greasy as always. read more

Mihm's Charcoal Grill - Hamburger and cheesecurds - Burgers Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin

See all