Cancel

Open app

Search

Middleton Diner

4.2 (41 reviews)
ModerateNew American
Closed 11:00 am - 7:00 pm

Middleton Diner Photos

MIDDLETON DINER ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Moderate noise
Good for groups
Good for kids

You might also consider

More like Middleton Diner

Recommended Reviews - Middleton Diner

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

the front of the restaurant
Jody K.

This is very much a little small-town diner. There are 2 rooms with tables, not much decoration. There didn't appear to be any menus, but there was a white board that showed the soup of the day, 2 sandwiches (a hamburger & hot beef) and a list of pies. The choices appeared to be that or the buffet, which consisted of a small but good salad bar and another hot food bar with fried chicken, ham, green beans, mashed potatoes, gravy and some soup. Nothing fancy and not a wide variety, but it all tasted homemade and fresh. And, at $10.99, it was priced well. As I was leaving, I noticed that they had cinnamon rolls, and I got one to go. Again, it was fresh, likely homemade and delicious. And, the staff was very friendly.

Excellent salad bar

See all

11 years ago

Great food, love the chicken and bread pudding. The price is high but worth every penny!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Middleton Diner

Review Highlights - Middleton Diner

Best broasted Chicken, Pork Chops and Friday fish in Mid Michigan.

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

Verify this business for free

People searched for New American 109 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Fireside Grille - Bacon Cheeseburger

Fireside Grille

4.3(24 reviews)
23.2 mi
$$

What a great place to dine in Shepherd, Michigan! Fireside Grill will suit your needs and add…read morecomfort to your meals

A pretty good overall experience, perhaps a few things could be improved for next time…read more I was pleased with the quality of our appetizer, as well as the creativity. We went with a fried goat chase appetizer, which I've never had before, and never even seen on another menu before. The cook clearly enjoys using balsamic glaze as this was used on both the appetizer and later on my entrée as well. Balsamic glaze is certainly delicious, but I'm not sure if it goes well on quite as many things as the cook seems to think it does. My entrée was a dish of mushroom ravioli prepared in a purée made with green peas. I noted that the chef used a variety of spices in preparing the purée, to very good effect. My wife ordered the New York strip, and what was brought out looked very good. We both had cocktails, and in both cases the cocktails or well-made. I ordered a Mojito type drink made with tequila. My wife ordered a strawberry Mamosa. I noted the care that was taken in preparing both drinks which tells me there's a professional bartender on staff. About the only thing that needs to be improved is the service. We waited just a bit too long for certain aspects of the meal in a restaurant that was nearly empty. The server was certainly polite and well mannered, but I think he was the only one working that evening. Perhaps on weekends they're better staffed?

Photos
Fireside Grille - Chicken Wrap

Chicken Wrap

Fireside Grille - The Hurricane!

The Hurricane!

Fireside Grille - Wing Dings

See all

Wing Dings

The Forager - Shrimp Tacos

The Forager

4.5(125 reviews)
41.0 mi
$$

What a great place! My wife heard about the Forager from a coworker and we've been meaning to try…read moreit for quite some time. We made a reservation for a Saturday evening. It t was perfect since we didn't have to wait at all for our table but the place was busy; lots of people were excited to be there. We ordered our drinks and the beet and goat salad to split as an appetizer. It was delicious and huge with loads of goat cheese and tasty pickled beets and zesty arugula. For our meal, I ordered the Pork Schnitzel with squash and zucchini and my wife got the whitefish that was one of the specials. The schnitzel had an incredible mushroom sauce and was cooked perfectly with the right balance of crispy and tender. We had a great time and plan to make the drive there regularly! It's great for a date night or a group or family meal!

Beautiful restaurant inside and out; our server was Perry and he was exactly what you want in a…read moreserver. He was attentive, made good recommendations and was very energetic. I appreciated him selling us on things. Our food came out pretty fast and the drinks were very good! I got the pulled pork sandwich, came with a side of coleslaw and I would definitely recommend it. Our bruschetta was great and the calamari was pretty good as well. Amish chicken with the mashed potatoes were phenomenal. To finish it all off, the mango cheesecake was very good. I would highly recommend that. Great spot in a small town.

Photos
The Forager - Lavendar Cocktail

Lavendar Cocktail

The Forager - Fish and chips

Fish and chips

The Forager - Apple crisp

See all

Apple crisp

Middleton Diner - newamerican - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...