4 star average? Are you nuts?
I had to pick up my mom from the airport and had to hang around Phoenix for a bit before her flight. I was craving some ice cream so I decided to stop by here. It had good Yelp reviews and was near where I was at. Um.....kind of wish I had gone somewhere else!
I walked up to the converted house and there were about 5 people in front of me. This place is TINY! You can only fit about 3 people comfortably in the place. There is only one guy working in the joint so it took a little bit to serve the other people. While waiting, I noticed that some of the ice cream looked a little melted and not normal. The lady in front of me tried to order a scoop of pistachio and the guy let her know that it wasn't available. He took a spoon and showed her how he couldn't scoop it out. Turns out that the heater (not sure if it was the heater in the place, or the heater in the ice cream cooler) was permanently on and they couldn't turn it off? WTF is that? Truly lived up to the "Melt" name. Anyways......placed my order for one scoop of Nutter Butter, one scoop Little Debbie, and one scoop Cookie Wasted. Paid the man my $6.25, he scooped my ice cream (to his credit, he did hook me up with pretty large scoops) into a Chinese takeout container, added a fortune cookie on top and I was on my way. Here is how it was, flavor by flavor..............
Nutter Butter- Tasted like the peanut butter cookies. The ice cream was really, really soft though (due to the heater issue) and a bit icy. Not sure if it could have been better more hard or what, but I was not that impressed. It tasted and reminded me of the ice cream I can make at home in my Cuisinart mixer. Decent but not great.
Little Debbie- Um...couldn't differentiate the taste of this and the Nutter Butter really. Peanuty ish like those little wafer bars, but same texture and taste. The mix ins were skimp, too.
Cookie Wasted- Vanilla base with oreos and chips ahoy cookies. Once again, soft, icy and the mix ins were skimp. This flavor was the best of the bunch, but even then, it was just average.
First impressions are very important. I was not impressed at all with the quality of ice cream. I can make stuff at home that is better than this. The shop is too small, the ice cream too expensive, and the ambiance is a little too "hipster" for my liking. I don't think I will ever return. Ice cream is like pizza..it's never really "bad", but this is definitely 2 star worthy and there are plenty other good ice cream shops located in Phoenix. Meh! read more