My sweet h bbq chicken sandwich was good and I had a backed potato and the bacon cheddar sour cream. they need to add more ingredients to their specialty baked potatoes. I had the bacon and cheddar, and it was very dry with only a few pieces of bacon and cheddar on it. I had to ask for more sour cream and butter, and I can't believe the manager had bought it out to me. She could have looked at it and said oh wow I'm gonna take this back but she didn't. I didn't want to complain to them. I just asked for more ingredients but they need to do better and I've experiencing all our baked potatoes and I think it's just this location in Kokomo. read more

Normally a fan of McAlisters, but today it was as slow as molasses. Arrived a few min before 11, there was one lady working the cash register and two guys hiding behind the tea stand, so they didn't have to be seen. Shortly after 11, roughly 4 employees showed up and seemed like things started to move a little quicker. It took over 20 min to get my order, that I placed on the app. I wish I hadn't, as I would have left after waiting so long. Food is typically good, really enjoy their salads and tea. As I went up to counter, there was a sign asking for patience, due to short staffed. Maybe have it in the door, so people are aware before waiting in the line so long. Oh well.. read more

Contracted food poisoning. Would not recommend getting the baked potato. They also forgot my cookie and my daughter's chips.

They make a really good South Easter salad. Always super fresh and I like that they also do 1/2 salad 1/2 sandwiches option Will definitely come back again read more

I typically go to McAlister's all the time when I'm in town and it's great. Today was a major exception. The cashier was extremely short and unfriendly. I asked for no pickle spear and low and behold my plate came with a pickle spear in the middle of my food. The worst part undoubtedly has to be the macaroni floating in my Au Jus. I did not have macaroni. Edit - Directly following my initial review, a waitress dropped a tray next to our table that covered us in what appears to be cottage cheese. No one came over to apologize or ask if we needed a rag or napkins. read more

McAlister's Deli - Macaroni floating in Au Jus - Delis Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

Ordered 2 Memphian on wraps. Received them on bread. Girl does not listen. She was an airhead!. Then I got my receipt with no code to get points. Ask someone and he said sorry but did not even offer to look into it. Yelp replied and gave me a bogus email address to Alissa Oliver at southernrockrestaurants and of course it did not go thru! Just pass my email along to her! read more

Eat in Soup served in a cardboard cup and half sandwich priced at $16 is way overboard!! Service was ok! Liked the music.

Well, trying to support business during this pandemic has been an eye opener. You would think that you would always receive good service considering, but no. Lunch Tuesday was disappointing. My soup was watery and the guacamole was bad on my salad. read more

Good food. Only thing they keep forgetting is my pickles for delivery. Love their food. Great service.

Well this was an excellent stop. I had the Orange cranberry club, and He had a smokey pepper jack turkey. Both were excellent. The sweet tea was a good addition to the meal. We tasted the variety of pickles available and they have a nice sharp flavor to accompany your sandwich. We finished up our meal with cookies. I had the peanut and He had the Macadamia nut, both very tasty. The restaurant is clean, the servers were happy and helpful. Friendly service is always a plus. I also appreciate that the restrooms were very clean. Over all this was a plus plus stop along our way. read more

McAlister's Deli - Big menu. Sandwiches and stuff. - Delis Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

See all

I don't think it's appropriate to hire someone so rude to work a customer service position. The other problem is the lack of clean tables for customers to sit at. Now we have waited absurdly long for our food while it's sitting at the window getting cold. Hate to say this at a place i enjoy so much. read more

Was disappointed as they have changed a few things. They did away with Green Tea , now I know that's a personal preference but means a lot to me. The plastic glasses are so thin they are hard to pickup. Did away with a few of my favorite sandwich's so for me not the allure it once had and probably won't be on top of choices to eat! read more

Food was ice cold! Both my food and my husband's food. Not lukewarm...ice cold. Gross! We were regulars...new year new place to eat. Bye McAlisters. read more

i have grew up eating here but not anymore. i made an review on google but i think it should be on here too. the service i got at the beginning was great, but when i told them my sandwich (french dip, almost $40 for 2 sandwiches) was messed up and not really cooked all the way they told us the meat ships to them that way which is concerning because don't you still have to cook it!? well i caved in with only one sandwich being refunded back as an independent student on one income, should have known not to eat good one night haha! well on the way out a worker black hair kinda tan skinned said "BYE!" as i walked out. that was what sat me over was the shitty remark. awful service, food made awful and i guess not cooked? still can't wrap my head around it. and how they hire on such rude people! read more

Here is an update to my review of McAlister's Deli in Kokomo. The WiFi connection is still terrible. And the Manager is worse. I have class in the evening so between work and school I get something to eat. I was in the restaurant at least once a week for 4 weeks sometimes twice a week. From around 4:30 until 5:30. Every time I was in the restaurant I got to listen to the manager deliver his berating reprimands to the staff. On my final visit the music was not working, so his lovey behavior could be enjoyed by all the guests throughout the restaurant. I want to be able to eat and then do some work. But I just couldn't stand listening to they yelling. I have since stopped visiting this location and I now go to Panera's across the street where the atmosphere is so much better. Update: 3 months ago the owner messaged me about my review. Stated she would be contacting me privately. I agreed to talk with her and have not heard one word since. Not so good with the follow through. I was in the restaurant business for 20 years and it's how you solve your problems that really sets your restaurant apart. read more

I had the chopped Italian salad which oddly enough was not chopped. It was a fairly good portion size but not very good. My friend had the "The McCalister" signature club sandwich, and it was disappointing at best. If you're gonna have a sandwich, and call it your signature sandwich and name it after your franchise it better be special. This club sandwich was lacking in the "layers" the description talks about. Very thin and not alot of meat, and it's not cheap. Another friend had a chicken salad croissant and macncheese and was not thrilled either. It was more like a lettuce and tomato sandwich, very little chicken salad. I would not go back there are soo many better options for sandwiches and salads. read more

See all

Just ordinary. Not what I consider a true deli. Deli sandwiches should have meat stacked high and plentiful. These are sparsely filled. I could make these sandwiches at home. read more

Maybe it's just me, but a cup of McAlister's chicken dumplings paired with a sweet iced tea is like a hug. We often ordered for pick-up this winter. read more

The food is fresh and mighty tasty! the dine-in service was excellent! Rose was so on top of checking on us and refilling our drinks. She was friendly and it was her service that made our first time experience there great! This will definitely be a regular spot for us. read more

Mike goes above and beyond to make sure you are taken care of and have everything you need while at his restaurant.love the food

Or first time at McAlisters. We really had no idea what to expect. I was pleasantly surprised by the menu variety; however, I was disappointed in myself for not doing some yelp research first. We didn't know what to order! Settled on a "choose two." We both had half a grilled chicken sandwich and a Caesar salad. The sandwich was quite tasty with a good amount of chicken, fresh spring mix, and a good honey mustard sauce. Unfortunately, the sandwich was all but ruined by the dry, stale, flavorless "croissant" on which it came. Think of Cheddars' delicious, flaky, mouth-watering croissants -- and then think of their opposite... that's what we received at McAlisters! The Caesar salad was better--a little larger portion than expected. Positives: efficient ordering process, LARGE glasses of water, nice variety of pickles and peppers Negatives: dry, stale, flavorless croissants Takeaways: We will be back because of the reasonable prices and menu variety. I will ask for my next sandwich on wheat bread rather than a croissant. The place reminds me of a more reasonably-priced Panera. read more

Understanding that during these times, things can go wrong or take longer. However, when you order through the app and pay for additional items you should get them without poor service or bad attitude. It's interesting that you can go to one location and NOT have to pay extra because they give you the correct amount. But to pay extra and then be treated poorly, is just unacceptable. They're poorly staffed and don't care if you're a paying customer. I don't recommend THIS location whether there's a pandemic or not. Poor service, subpar food and disregard for paying customers. read more

What you'd expect from a chain. Good but nothing crazy. Nice service. Clean. Can't complain about free pickles, either. read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

See all

Just left McAllisters....what a great meal we had for $20.00. My husband's Chicken Dumpling soup was mush. My Club sandwich...first one came out on wheat bread. I had specifically asked for white bread with no honey mustard. Server brought it out... said they would make another. We were eating on the patio...she hurried away, and obviously, did not hear me say no honey mustard. New sandwich came out on white bread...with honey mustard. I give up! Upon leaving, I stood at the counter waiting for a refill. The order taker looked right at me....then told the people in line to order to come up. Customers deserve better than this for the money spent. Pretty sad! read more

I just wanted to give a shout out to Clay! He has done an amazing job during this crazy time! Always friendly and helpful! I've been going to this store for over 10 years -watched many managers and employees come and go! I hope Clay stays! read more

This is the best go to for lunch in the city, however if you don't want your sandwich toasted, tell them! They toast everything! We always get the sweet tea but sometimes it's not made correctly and tastes just like unsweetened. I wish they'd bring back the Pot Roast spud. read more

Great sandwiches and very kind staff. They made food for my brother and I right before closing as we were in the middle of an 8 hour road trip. I really appreciated the hospitality! read more

This is one of my favorites in Kokomo. I'm very impressed. Their food is very good and much better for you than the usual fast food that available in this town. And of course the ice tea is great. read more

Two carryout orders, two disappointments. If I pay for something, I expect to find it in the bag once I'm home! Besides being shorted on 2 orders there should be at least be someone in the kitchen that can make a baked potato and not wrap a sandwich so tight that it looks like a sick burrito when you open it. read more

I'm still outside waiting....... for half hour past the pickup time. What the hell its going on with this place

Sunday around 11am and extremely busy, with people saving tables, while others stood in line to order. Linesmoved quickly as did delivered food. My grilled cheese and chicken noodle soup were hot and tasty. No food pictures this time. . read more

Love there food.Good service They also have good salads.My favorite is the Savannah salad. I also like there pick 2 menu. read more

It'd not really a deli. It's Panerra Bread knock-off. The place was busy...even so, the people working seemed a little unorganized. The manager's need to get more people to clean up. There seemed to be no one cleaning up the tables. I stood by a dirty table waiting for it to be cleaned for almost 5 minutes. I see staffing problems and a need for stronger management. The sandwiches were OK. I ordered a vegitarian sandwich. I was surprised that it didn't have beans sprouts on it (I should have read the menu better). I was also surprised that the sandwiche was so small. The portions for all the other sandwiches seemed large except for mine. The chicken tortilla soup was good. It had nice texture and a little heat at the end. So, the soup saved the day. I wonder if the soup is outta a jar or home made? read more

Update. Nope. Still 1 star. Ordered online, arrived early so we expected to wait. Called inside to tell them we were here. 30 min later (20 min past our time) I called inside again. The first person that answered never let anyone know we were there so our food had been sitting on the counter getting cold. When it finally came out to us, 3/4 of our order was wrong. read more

2 years ago I would come here regularly and always be pleased with my experience. Something has changed recently. The pickle bar is no longer available. Sat down, waiting thirty minutes for our meal. Only to find they didn't bring my husbands which was a Caesar salad. Wait for my husbands meal to come out then we begin to eat but before we do he spots a hair in my salad. He asked for extra dressing on the side, it came on a soggy salad they brought out later which looks as though it had been back there the whole time. The chicken salad I ordered had seriously less than half the chicken that regularly comes on it. Which that can be looked at as nit picky but when we order our food a chicken salad on croissant/side salad and a chicken Caesar salad and the total is $25 for what is basically fast food you should be pleased with the plate. The hair being in the food was the last straw and we took out plates to the counter for our money returned. Manager understood and gave us our money back. Even though they were understanding we won't be back in fear of another similar experience. read more

I'm from Ohio and whenever I'm near Indy, I head out to a McAlister. Love all the potato options and the sweet tea! read more

McAlister's Deli - Spud 'ole and their great sweet teas! - Delis Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

I had a delightful experience. Service staff was warm and friendly. Food came quick and was very tasty. I had the soup and sandwich, both were good. Even the water tasted nice and clean with no chlorine or hard mineral flavors. Restaurant and restrooms were virtually spotless. Decor was whimsical and fun, with lighthearted and upbeat music playing. There was plenty of seating, with a good mix of booths and tables, which the staff was proficient at keeping cleaned off as patrons depart. On my way out I spoke with the manager and complimented the food, staff, and overall experience. She was thrilled to hear my kind (and honest) words, and asked if it was my first time at a McAlister's (it was). She then said that no newcomer can leave without trying their chocolate chip cookies, and gave everyone in my party a large tasty cookie, on the house. I'm impressed, and hope to return. read more

We love coming here. They have a variety of good food and give adjust your order the way you want it. read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

this place is absolutely insane. all of the workers are rude. their kids cookies are always burnt and taste like burnt oven, causing my kids to blow our toilet up. ive found multiple hairs in my food. ive found a caterpillar in my salad. workers are always high and have seen multiple workers outside smoking. this girl named shelby gave me a disgusting ass look and over charged me on my sweet tea. my order is always wrong and cold. on top of that, ive asked multiple times for gluten free bread because i am terribly terribly terribly allergic and have yet to see a slice of gluten free bread. this other worker named steve, he's tall and skinny, has vaped so many times on the patio right in front of my children. the same worker was in his red durango smacking a girl as i was leaving the parking lot, and when my kids and i were eating, i saw him slip 20's in his pocket. most of these workers look miserable and look like they have been crying all day, i feel bad for the good ones. yall should be ashamed. cannot believe the management would allow this. will never be back, after multiple attempts of trying to give this store a chance. absolutely disgraceful and disgusting. if there was a choice for a 1/10 of a star i would not even give that. read more

Today while I was in to eat at the I saw my favorite girl! I was pleasantly surprised to find out that Pam Dart was in fact running your Kokomo McAlister's. I was so happy to see her. I have watched her since her Texas Roadhouse days. Hiring Pam was the smartest thing McAlister's has ever done. I don't know a soul that has ever met Pam and not loved her. When she left Roadhouse that place was never the same. You got a good one with Pam, McAlister's. Don't let her go. Cheryl Sutherland read more