McAlister&#x27;s Deli

While in Greenfield, Indiana you've got to check out The Depot!…read more FROM GRAIN ELEVATOR TO FAMILY RESTAURANT: this place has history, character, and heart. The building towers above the surrounding area, and we could see it from blocks away as we drove toward it. It has those old school Midwestern, small town vibes that you just don't see much anymore. The restaurant is large and clearly a popular local spot, so I'd recommend making reservations ahead of time. After a short wait, we were seated in their lively main dining room. They have an extensive cocktail menu, appetizers, and plenty of mains truly a menu where there's something for everyone. Think classic, down home American cooking in a casual, no frills setting. Our table sampled a little bit of everything, but if you order one appetizer, get the fried pickles! I'm a sucker for that cornmeal style batter and the sriracha ranch was the perfect touch. For my main, I ordered the loaded wedge salad and when I say this thing was HUGE, I mean it! It was practically an entire head of lettuce, so definitely expect leftovers. The wedge was cold, crisp, refreshing, and delicious. The staff were incredibly nice and attentive, the kind of place where they call you darling and greet you with a smile. It's not fancy and there are no frills, but that's exactly what makes it special. Good food, genuinely friendly people, and that classic down-home neighborhood feel.

It was our first time here and we enjoyed the restaurant's vibe and the service was great. The…read moredrinks were good and the price was only $10 a martini with tons of selection! The food was so-so. I ordered a grilled chicken BLT wrap and the chicken was... weird. Very stretchy, wet and like the weirdest texture so I couldn't finish it. Chips were good, and we liked the 'tater kegs' app.

Front area

Tater Kegs

See all

Patio

Indy Gyros

4.8(67 reviews)

0.7 mi

Our new go-to place for fast-Greek food. There are dine-in, take out, and drive-thru options…read more It's a casual dining experience with good food, at reasonable prices. Portions are ample. And Kumar is always on hand to guide you, if you need it! Gyros are delicious; seasoned chicken is yum; rice is cooked perfectly; and the spanakopita is top notch. Also, the tzatziki is my number one favorite anywhere!

Really good food and attentive service. We had a lamb gyro and a falafel gyro. Both were…read moredelicious! Vibe is fast food, but the food is so much better than that!

Greek menu

RED VELVET

See all

Jersey Mike's Subs

4.1(12 reviews)

0.7 mi

Jersey Mike's is one on my fast food favorites when I'm in a hurry. Today, I was picking up subs…read morefor lunch. This was my first visit to this location in Greenfield. The staff was extraordinarily friendly and helpful. They didn't skimp on the fixings. I ordered two Italian subs fixed "Mike's" way with lettuce, tomato, oil, vinegar and spices. The subs were huge and packed with plenty of meat. The thin sliced ham was really good. The dining area has a Jersey Boardwalk theme. For a moment, I felt like I was at the beach and not land locked in Central Indiana. This Jersey Mike's offers great service and subs. I'll be back for sure.

Jersey Mike's is a good option when you just want something light versus heavy…read more I've had their turkey and their ham sandwich and they're both great. There are a few tables to sit and eat at, but I always get mine carry out. The place is nothing fancy just a place to relax and grab a sandwich. Get your sandwich Mike's way, and you won't be disappointed!

See all

The Mug

4.0(288 reviews)

1.2 mi

The sign says What's the Rub, but the receipt says it's still The Mug…read more We stopped by here on a random Tuesday night in September. I've always wanted to try this place since I first saw it awhile back. Seems like they only recently have inside seating (which is very limited). We decided to go outside with our drinks ... and then the bees were incredibly invasive and bothered us the entire time. The staff brought out our food to our table. Which was nice (except for the bees). The brisket smash was superb! Definitely delicious, and satisfied my hungry appetite. Combined with a side of fried okra (!) and coleslaw, you've got yourself a yummy meal. The ribs were not as great and my SO probably won't be getting that again. Am definitely looking forward to coming back here ... especially when I'm in the mood for a smashed brisket! I'm just sorry I forgot to take photos. Maybe next time!

Bbq is amazing the have very good side dishes The…read moretenderloin is really good come with fries

"Game on" on the patio!

The Pork Tenderloin

See all

Firehouse Subs

3.4(38 reviews)

0.5 mi

I ordered a sandwich and salad. The sandwich was so sloppily thrown together, i could barely tell…read morefor sure if it was what I ordered. Not to mention that the food was cold and bread was soggy. Luckily it tasted good.

Asked for tomato's, got tomato's. asked for grilled cheese…read moregot Mac and cheese. when they replaced the grilled cheese the curly hair male slid it off the counter onto the floor and both gentlemen laughed behind the counter . I don't get why they thought that was funny

See all

Tyner Pond Farm

5.0(22 reviews)

0.5 mi

•$$$

This is a regenerative farm. I appreciate the extra effort they put into making their food safe and…read morethe best tasting possible. I like to order online and have them drop off at my doorstep. I do wish they still carried raw milk. If you've not checked them out, go to tynerpondfarm.com and place an order if you live local. Order $63 plus gets free delivery to your front door. You cannot beat that! Put in your ZIP Code to see if they deliver to your area. I live on the west side of Indianapolis and I am in their delivery zone. They are very friendly and very helpful and very knowledgeable. You can get a lot of information off of their website. Give them a try!

Love Tyner Pond Farm. Their approach to sustainability is impressive. Eggs, sausage, beef--all of…read moretheir products are superb, & free delivery--fantastic.

Beefy!

See all

Happy pastured pigs

Jimmy John's

2.5(30 reviews)

0.1 mi

Chef Joseph here. Wife and I got thier 16 in Total Tuna sub today. I can see why they added the…read morecucumber, tomatoes, onions, and, lettuce to mask the bad taste of the TUNA. The tuna was not fresh, not sure when it was made. First time I have eatten here and my last.

I order from here multiple times a week. My order is always correct (minus not cutting my sandwich…read morein half like i always ask) and they are very quick with delivery.

#1 THE PEPE

See all

Jimmy John's Greenfield, Indiana 46140

The Confection Connection

4.6(18 reviews)

0.7 mi

We stopped by on our way home to Dayton, OH and I'm so glad we did!…read more We tried the cookies and cream cookie and a snickerdoodle cupcake. Both were absolutely delicious and reasonably priced. Would love to try more in the future! The store has a good seating area that offered multiple boards games, which is a neat idea. Staff was also friendly.

I've been wanting to try this place for awhile and noticed they are on DoorDash. The club sandwich…read moreis stacked and has a good amount of ham and turkey. It is served on toasted bread and warm. The soup, well I was little disappointed. The base was broken, it wasn't smooth and creamy. The taste was bland and didn't taste the cheddar cheese.

Chocolate lcing

Thick layer of chocolate fudge with the cherries.

See all

Massive thick layers of chocolate icing

Dave's Express Care

3.4(31 reviews)

1.7 mi

All fresh. No frozen . Good people own it. No frozen…read morehamburger. Everything I've ever had had been very good

Really good poerk tenderloin in the cafe in the back of the car wash facility. Very large and…read morefresh with a great breading to loin ratio. Recommend to get your BPT fix on here.

Headed in to the wash

Dave's burger burnt

See all

Menu express grill

Lincoln Square Pancake House

4.4(153 reviews)

1.1 mi

Lincoln Square Pancake House is perfect for breakfast, brunch, or lunch. They have a large menu of…read moreitems to choose from. I really enjoyed the customer service here. The staff are super friendly and upbeat. And they welcomed us as we entered the restaurant. I ordered the Turkey, Ham, and Bacon Club sandwich, which came with two sides. I chose fries and a bowl of fruit. The fruits were a good mix and were sweet. I was surprised at how big the sandwich was and only finished half. I'm glad they separated out the mayonnaise and left it up to me on how much or how little I want to add. It was delicious. The ambiance is very comfy and welcoming. They have music playing lightly in the background. There are plenty of seats and I can imagine this place being packed during the weekend. Overall, Lincoln Square Pancake House is a great spot to have a delicious meal. The portions are generous, the prices are affordable, and the vibe is laid back and chill. Our server was kind and friendly too. Highly recommend!

Came here on a Sunday at 10am and it was busy! But a good busy where you can see why the people…read morebring their families to come and enjoy a nice breakfast or lunch meal. Located on Main St, it gives a very hometown comfort food feel. Service was incredibly fast for the volume of people that were there. Our server was like a friend-chatty, attentive and helpful. Everyone got something they liked. I loved my healthy waffle. It had the best Greek yogurt on it that I've ever tasted. Husband got an omelet and one son got the Cinnamon Toast Crunch French toast. Perfect portions for all of it.

See all

Fresh Fruit Bowl

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Mandy T.

0

1

0

2 years ago

I wish I could give it more stars but the last two out of the three times that I've gone here with my mom and my wife and kids in the evening around 6:37 the manager that is there seems to be too focused on the younger females that are there trying to be a counselor for them because all they want to do is cry about the littlest things that have nothing to do with work and then she leaves some poor girl on the floor for an hour or more while she's in the back office I'm guessing talking to the younger girl but also why we've been there and she's up at the counter talking to the young girls that are there she's talking about how she can teach them how to give b******* and showing them pictures of her man's dick and all this other stuff that is inappropriate for a manager let alone a customer to be hearing and when I tried to complain the manager that's they're doing it her name is Angie just wants to run off and not deal with any problems the food was good but it was the experience with the staff that is out on the floor taking your orders and bringing your food and that one manager that has ruined it there's another manager there it's an African-American his name I believe is Jesse he at least tries and the other lady that works there I can't remember her name I think it starts with an A as well she seems to be okay but the Angie manager is probably the worst person to pick is a manager has completely crapped on this establishment that could be better with the right management read more

Tammy W.

Elite 23

13

41

31

3 years ago

I know it seems like it's the place in town, it very well could be Not my opinion. I went in 1st time ever. A friend and I

McAlister's Deli - sandwiches - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Greenfield, Indiana Restaurants near McAlister's Deli

BEST of Greenfield, Indiana Things to Do near McAlister's Deli

BEST of Greenfield, Indiana Desserts near McAlister's Deli

BEST of Greenfield, Indiana Coffee near McAlister's Deli

BEST of Greenfield, Indiana Parking near McAlister's Deli

BEST of Greenfield, Indiana Breakfast near McAlister's Deli

BEST of Greenfield, Indiana Pizza near McAlister's Deli

BEST of Greenfield, Indiana Lunch near McAlister's Deli

BEST of Greenfield, Indiana Shopping near McAlister's Deli

BEST of Greenfield, Indiana Smoke Shop near McAlister's Deli

Best of Greenfield

Things to do in Greenfield

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed McAlister's Deli also viewed

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

4.1

(21 reviews)

Classic Olive garden atmosphere with an exceptional staff…read more The Greenfield Indiana location is one of the best. Laura runs the bar, and there's a full staff ready to deliver. There are many menu items that I love, but tonight was the Classic lasagna for me, coupled with the signature salad and bread sticks.

This is a review that has also been a long time coming. I meant to do it back when I lived in…read moreGreenfield, but man did I understimate this place. I went to an Olive Garden back when living in Miami, FL and I was not happy at all with the service. It was noisy, crowded, chaotic, etc. I went to celebrate a friend's 21st birthday years ago in Miami and never ever returned back into one of these places ever because it just was a bad memory for me. I had been a server for a few years by that point but I have to say that this one in Greenfield was the exact opposite, like legit night and day. It was crowded the night my parents and I went, like shockingly so. The parking lot was full which made finding a parking spot a little harder. There was a wait to get in but it reminded me of the waiting area for Macaroni Grill in Doral, FL. There was classic Italian music playing so I couldn't complain about that. The vibe was pretty chill too. I was pleasantly surprised. I imagined it being so loud and busy and unenoyable but this was the exact opposite. The aesthetic was refind, elegant, demure. We waited maybe like 30 minutes or so at most and then we were sat in a booth somewhat away from the larger tables. There is this touchscreen device you can play games on or order food on or summon your server for. Our server's name was Autumn. She was amazing, cordial, kind, attentive, and very knowledgeable. She had recommendations for me and everything and I am picky. I believe I went with the Chicken Marsala which was so delicious. Honestly, I was blown away by the service and quality of the food. The ambiance was nice like the lighting and the menu was just extensive enough that there were a wide variety of options. There were also plenty of drink options which i did not partske in, but we did have wine. I really appreciated the endless breadsticks and soup. So yummy. This would be a percect place for family gatherings and such or even a first date. I mean I would not have minded being taken there and it was also quite affordable. The manager was also kind enough to speak with us as well. We learned he was a native Floridian from Perrine, FL which was neat. Overall, it was a very enjoyable experience that I severely underestimated. If I was in Greenfield again, I would definitely go back. The manager was kind and diligent as was Autumn. I honestly did not expect it to be that kind. Food was warm, good quality, nice portion sizes, amd delicious. I was so happy to leave woth leftovers:)

Perkins Restaurant & Bakery

3.2

(94 reviews)

I love this Perkins location. It has such a chill, Sunday morning vibe every day of the week! We…read moreenjoy going here to grab breakfast or a quick lunch from time to time. This past Sunday, we stopped in to do just that. We were seated in the furthest corner of the restaurant (a new area for us) and Julie was our server. She was great. We would definitely request to be seated in her section again. I had the Build Your Own Sampler with chicken tenders, onion rings and mozzarella sticks. My husband ordered the French Toast Platter. Everything was good. We also ordered dessert to go. They are also a bakery, so you can't go wrong with any of their baked goods. I had the New York Cheesecake and hubby ordered the Chocolate French Silk Pie.

The best things about this Perkins location are the service, atmosphere, and--of course--the pies…read more The portion sizes are solid and definitely filling. While nothing we ordered really stood out as amazing, everything was good and satisfying. The restaurant itself was clean and inviting, and I appreciated that the seating allowed for comfortable conversation without feeling crowded by neighboring tables. The staff truly made the experience--they were friendly, attentive, and welcoming throughout our visit. We decided to take slices of pie to go, and honestly, they were the highlight. Absolutely delicious and worth the trip alone. I would definitely return and would especially recommend Perkins for a relaxed dessert date.

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.3

(11 reviews)

This new location recently opened in my area, and they advertised with coupons. For this location…read moreonly, I used my coupon for half off of a giant sub. I decided on takeout of a giant sub of #55 big chicken sandwich included provolone instead of American cheese, banana peppers instead of jalapenos, and on (whole) wheat. I believe it was the first time I ate their wheat bread. They have Udi's gluten-free bread with an additional cost. The staff was patient and willing to explore with me the ingredients of the meats.

They used to be great when they first opened. Last couple of times there was very little meat on…read morethe sandwich and the lettuce was old and brown. I used to go once a week but I won't be going back any more.

Wild Eggs

3.8

(81 reviews)

I was greeted when I walked in. The restaurant was clean. I loved the decor. Liz was my waitress…read moreand she was great. I believe that this was my first visit. The food came out as it was done vs coming out together. The sweet tea was definitely sweet. I wasnt able to finish my food. My bill was around $20. Make sure to check them out if you're in the area.

Creative atmosphere, which is fun, especially for kids. Very loud and limited space. Food is good…read moreand they offer gluten free choices which I was excited about. Unfortunately, there is NO BUTTER for toast or cooking. All entries are cooked in oil or a butter/margarin mix! I was hoping to get a side of vegetables or the spinach, but that is cooked in the flat iron where they use canola oil. So I could only Eat poached eggs with dry toast for $8.99. It should have been $6.00, but the waitress charged for an egg entree instead of the sides only. For me a return visit for dry toast and eggs is not worth it. If you don't mind canola oil or margarine, that have lots of interesting options.

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store

3.0

(79 reviews)

First off, this is the first time I've ever wrote a good review for Cracker Barrel. Honestly, every…read moretime (around 7times) I have been to a Cracker Barrel, something goes wrong. We are out of that, served wrong meal, etc. This time when traveling, husband asked if we could try their campfire chicken. He knows I was reluctant but the campfire chicken was amazing! No joke! Place was clean and the waitress, Kelseigh, was awesome! Great restaurant!!!

Absolutely the worst service!!!! Wasn't even that busy but sat at a table for 15 minutes as the…read morestaff continued to walk by us and never even acknowledged us. Others around us sat after us and had already been helped, 3 staff cleaning one table? No drinks probably should be your first clue we have not been assisted. Finally came over and when I mentioned how long we had been waiting, there wasn't even an apology, but yet an eye roll in a look of agitation!. Asked to speak to the manager and he did nothing, we left and we won't be back. Do better Cracker Barrel!

West Coast Sourdough Indiana Noblesville

3.3

(19 reviews)

Delicious, delicious, delicious! I honestly can't say it enough! This is probably my fourth time…read morecoming here within the last month, and that alone should tell you how much I love it. **My go-to is the Garlic Pesto Turkey with pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and their house mayo, and it is SO good every single time! Not only is the food amazing, but the restaurant is always clean, and the staff is super nice, helpful, and welcoming. You can tell they care about their customers and making sure you have a great experience. If you haven't tried West Coast Sourdough Deli yet, you definitely need to! I'll absolutely be back again... probably sooner than I should be!

The Clam "Chowder" wasn't chowder or soup, at all...it was a GLOOPY, GLOPPY, GOOPY heap of…read moresomething that came out of the bottom of the soup tureen. (I even heard the food attendant exclaim as much.) So instead of serving me a fresh cup, they sent out the bottom of the barrel glop. No clams, no potatoes, no flavor, just a blob of whatever. The turkey "cranberry" sandwich might has well been billed "one 1/2 Turkey on 1/3 huge stale sourdough bread, with 1/6 everything else, including a whisper-thin layer of cranberry. It was the biggest rip-off with zero balance for a good sandwich. I was so digested by the whole experience, I just threw everything away and went around the corner to Panera Bread and got a 4.5 star meal ~ should've done that in the first place and saved me $19.

The Depot

3.8

(248 reviews)

While in Greenfield, Indiana you've got to check out The Depot!…read more FROM GRAIN ELEVATOR TO FAMILY RESTAURANT: this place has history, character, and heart. The building towers above the surrounding area, and we could see it from blocks away as we drove toward it. It has those old school Midwestern, small town vibes that you just don't see much anymore. The restaurant is large and clearly a popular local spot, so I'd recommend making reservations ahead of time. After a short wait, we were seated in their lively main dining room. They have an extensive cocktail menu, appetizers, and plenty of mains truly a menu where there's something for everyone. Think classic, down home American cooking in a casual, no frills setting. Our table sampled a little bit of everything, but if you order one appetizer, get the fried pickles! I'm a sucker for that cornmeal style batter and the sriracha ranch was the perfect touch. For my main, I ordered the loaded wedge salad and when I say this thing was HUGE, I mean it! It was practically an entire head of lettuce, so definitely expect leftovers. The wedge was cold, crisp, refreshing, and delicious. The staff were incredibly nice and attentive, the kind of place where they call you darling and greet you with a smile. It's not fancy and there are no frills, but that's exactly what makes it special. Good food, genuinely friendly people, and that classic down-home neighborhood feel.

It was our first time here and we enjoyed the restaurant's vibe and the service was great. The…read moredrinks were good and the price was only $10 a martini with tons of selection! The food was so-so. I ordered a grilled chicken BLT wrap and the chicken was... weird. Very stretchy, wet and like the weirdest texture so I couldn't finish it. Chips were good, and we liked the 'tater kegs' app.

Rise & Shine

3.5

(120 reviews)

Love this place. I usually get a cup of fruit along with breakfast staple items but instead of…read morebeing served a simple cup with maybe 3-4 varieties of fruit in it, I'm presented with a fruit tray, almost a charcuterie, of six different fruits which was unexpected. Now this tray was a bit more expensive than a cup of fruit from some other places, but that's OK because the fruit was ripe and flavorful and well worth it. It's good to change-up the expected every now and then. I will definitely re-order it again. I;m looking forward to another visit real soon. I haven't tried the Bananas Foster Waffle yet but it looks completely over the top and crazy with a scoop of vanilla ice cream that appeared to me to be the size of a softball as I was hypnotized by it and trapped in its vortex of apparent deliciousness, Sadly it was ordered and delivered to another table. My only nit-pic would be that the chef work on the scrambled eggs a bit more and not too cook them longer, but cook them slower so they come out fluffier, moist, and without any browning on the underside. A chopped up omelet is not scrambled eggs. The eggs were still good but there was room for improvement here. I realize the chef is trying to get food out as quickly as possible, and its easy to let scrambled eggs go too long on the heat, so maybe I'll mention it to the wait staff that the eggs do not need to be hurried. The wait staff was prompt and attentive, and the various style of PJ's were a nice touch. The front of house is kind of big so noise can be an issue but it wasn't terrible on my most recent visit with the dining room about 3/4 full. If the restaurant got enough complaints about the noise levels, it would be pretty easy to fix with some strategically placed sound abatement materials to cut down the noise level even further in the dining room.

My wife and I had quite possibly the worst experience we have had in a long time here. We came in…read moreat 1pm on a Sunday, and the place was somewhat busy. It was hottt in the restaurant, almost causing me to sweat. We were at in the middle of the room surrounded by other tables- the place was loud which compounded the heat we were feeling. I ordered the biscuits and gravy combo. The biscuits were hard, the gravy cold, and tasted as if they had been sitting out all day. Lacked much flavor at all. The hashbrowns were undercooked, and had a chemical taste to them. The bacon was chewy and greasy. Service was another part that compounded on the terrible experience. Our sever was more interested in standing at the checkout counter chatting with her friends. Refills were non existent. My wife had gotten pancakes with her meal. Our food came out, and her pancakes were missing, but we were reassured they were coming. We see pancakes coming, but they go to a table that arrived ~15 minutes after us. More pancakes coming, but they went to an another table that came after us. We finish our meal, and no pancakes in sight. Our waitress brings our bil. "Hey my wife had pancakes with her meal and they never came." "Oh I can go see where they are." "We are finished with our meal. We don't really want them." "Oh I can box them up for you." "No thanks. We would rather them just be taken off the bill." "Okay, let me go do that for you." She returns, says they can't be taken off because they are part of a combo. We understand that, but we never received them, nor do we want them as the meal is finished. The only thing I can do is box them up for you. We decline. No other ways to try to reprimand the situation. We pay. She goes up to the counter, starts talking to her friends, and they all look over and start laughing at us. As we are walking out, we are visibly upset. One of the friends goes "have a good day." We don't say anything. "Please come back to see us." We don't say anything. "Hope you come back." This is childish behavior. Ultimately, food was terrible, service was awful, and ambiance was poor. Waffle House would have afforded us better service, more appetizing food, and would have cost half the price.

The Old Spaghetti Factory

3.0

(194 reviews)

I always go there after getting my braces, the food is always good, the place is always clean, the…read moreservers are nice especially Angela. I would definitely recommend this to a friend we'll be back

This is an odd but enjoyable place. Service is excellent…read more Food is tasty with some unusual presentations. Vegetable side dishes are special. This is a place I keep on returning to.

Arni's

3.7

(416 reviews)