Everything is good at McAllister's I suggest everything on the menu but my go to is the New Yorker.

Needed some fuel after going to the movies across the street and placed an online order for pickup. They have a pickup window, but not typical drive thru and order window. It's pickup only. We got the McAlisters Club and French onion samich. The club was good, I would give it a 4 for taste and quantity. The French onion was lacking so gets a 2.5... all in all we expected better. So to even the score, giving the review an overall 3. I will say the service was good as our order was quick, and we were happy how extremely well everything was packaged for the to-go order. Nothing was getting spilled and that's really good to consider for to-go orders. So to answer the magic question if we'd return, yes if in the mood for a loaded club sandwich vs typical drive thru alternatives. read more

McAlister's Deli - McAlister's Club (side and top view) - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

See all

Food was very good. The dine in wait time was longer than usual. Otherwise even though there is no table service the staff is very helpful and keeps your drinks topped off. read more

McAlister's Deli - Tea story - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

McAllisters in gibsonton. You need more people on a Tuesday. Wife and i went last night around 7. 2 people on the side. Looked like food drivers. One employee in the back making food. One employee in front running around making drinks, filling napkin holders and making roll ups. We watched for about 5 minutes. Turned around and left. No acknowledgement we were even there. Might be a one off since it's always been well staffed. read more

I love the aesthetic in here. The vibrant colors and lighting. I would love to come back w a book and snuggle into the couch. They get a little swamped at time so be patient. I love the scan at your seat table service. Food is deli style so soups, sandwiches & spuds (loaded potatoes) - I just learned this :) ample parking and family friendly. read more

See all

THIS is a very underrated deli! The staff here is exceptionally professional & friendly. Having only been to McAlister's in Missouri, I was pleasantly surprised to find the quality food & service I've always loved. My personal fave is their GIGANTIC chicken bacon ranch SPUD w/sweet tea! The Memphian sandwich is loaded with great fresh meats...Thank you, Re'Nariya, we will be back! GREAT SERVICE! read more

This has become Our go to place for Sandwiches and Salads. And of Course, that Infamous Sweet Tea. This Place Makes me close my eyes in Delight when I eat. Food is Always Fresh. The Cashier/ Server are So Pleasant. I get the Choose 2 meal and it never Fails. McAllister Club is Awesome. And I get the Pecanberry Salad as my side. Perfection. My Partner got the Italian. Always so full of Flavor. With a side of the Potatoe Salad. It's a little sweet if you like that. But if you don't care for the sweet , add some s and p. It helps. Thanks to the Staff at McAllister for a Lovely Lunch. Much Love from a Returning Customer. read more

See all

Valentine's Day lunch! Couldn't pick a better place to go. The food is always fresh and this potato is off the chain. Pulled pork, mac n cheese, bacon and bbq sauce - come on! The staff are really helpful and cheerful. Love this place. read more

McAlister's Deli - Smokehouse Giant Spud - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

Wanted a quick bite before heading to the movies and decided to stop by McAlister's. First, the service was excellent. From entering, to ordering, to food service, to cleanup, great service. The food was basic but fresh and delicious. Portions size was good. I had a 1/2 grilled chicken salad and 1/2 bacon potato. I loved the potato and would order that again. I had a strawberry lemonade and that was delicious. Overall good experience and recommend you try it out. read more

McAlister's Deli - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

See all

Hadn't been here in awhile and was pleasantly surprised at new menu options! Always like the Pick 2 where I had a spud and 4cheese melt sandwich this time. Good portions, reasonable prices. Will be back! read more

McAlister's Deli - Pick 2 - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

I gave them a 1 because I couldn't give a negative 10 as a rating. Ordered $100 of food but had to send someone else to pick it up. EVEN face timing me and showing them I ordered, they would not give the person I sent the food and no refund.......!!!!!!! Will NEVER order from them again, spread the word that they are NOT customer friendly!!!!! read more

Visited this location recently after having fond memories of this chain which I visited in my college years in the midwest. This location was easily accessible off of I75 at Gibsonton exit. I ordered the you pick two which allowed me to get a half a sandwich and a half of a loaded baked potato. Both were delicious and I would absolutely recommend either of them but for me the tea is what I remember most about McAlasters. Their ingredients are always fresh and I am a fan of the chain and it was good to have a reminder at this location of why I fell in love with them in the first place. The service was great and the restaurant was clean. I highly recommended them if you love this type of food. read more

McAlister's Deli - My You pick two of Bake potato and chicken sandwich - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

See all

I stopped in here for lunch on a Saturday. I went to the counter to place my order and was greeted by friendly staff. I got the Choose 2 with the Spicy Turkey Melt and the Grilled Chicken Salad with Ranch dressing. I love their unsweetened ice tea. I was pleasantly surprised at the large portions and couldn't finish all of the salad. I did get the pickle on the side and I loved how garlicky it was. This casual chain is a pleasant experience since they bring you your food and then a little later check to see if you need anything else. I enjoyed my meal and look forward to coming back again soon. read more

McAlister's Deli - Choose 2: Spicy Turkey Melt and Grilled Chicken Salad - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

I genuinely don't know how this location has so many sweet and kind people working. Every time I have gone I am left with a smile and felt so taken care of by the staff! Food is also so yummy and the tea is DUH amazing! read more

Great sandwiches and soup/sides. I have come here a few times as well as an Orlando location and it never disappoints. Good selection with the freshest bread. You also must try the cheesecake & carrot cake. To top if off, the service is friendly and on point! My new favorite lunch place. read more

I was under the weather and decided that I was gonna get McAllister's to feed the flu. I ordered a peach tea without the ice and I was told it was OK that I got it without the ice and then she commenced to fill the cup of 3/4 of the way this tea is way too expensive to slight me on it And when I asked for a refill, she reluctantly refill the team. I requested extra butter and sour cream for the baked potato I didn't get it. This is all part of the experience and making the food taste the way I would like it to taste for me to eat it and when you're denied it after spending $20 on one meal for a Lunch I won't be coming back read more

McAlister's Deli - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

This was my first time as McAlister's Deli and it wont be the last though I will give it some time before I return and I'll tell you why. To start, the ambiance inside is much nicer than I expected going into a sandwich shop, seriously the place is neat. The food wasn't long of a wait and although the potato was dry I had no complaints on the flavor of the meal. I wanted to give 5 stars so badly but the service provided at the register was hard to look past and unfortunately it was just my luck on this side of the line where I was that Jasheeda was working, between the monotone voice and rushing you to the next part of the order before you can finish saying what you're saying, you can tell she didn't want to be there. Meanwhile the other hostess on the opposite end at the other register you could hear and see her bubbly attitude and she was really treating her customers with kindness. I saw the people behind me get treated the same way and then the people after them got ignored as she looked to them walk up then went off to the back uncalled for but thankfully the other hostess acknowledged them and called them to the other side. Jasheeda would be better fit dishwashing in the back where she doesn't have to be face to face with clients and she can be monotone and have an attitude with the dishes instead. I feel that the quality of customer service is just as important as the quality of the food.. read more

See all

I was thinking the sandwiches were a bit overpriced, but we had some delivered the other night, and they were worth it! So much meat in the small sandwich! I was very pleased! My only missing star is from the bottom bread being so soggy, from being wrapped up on the ride over. Next time I'll ask for the bread on the side. No complaints when we've been inside the restaurant as well. Love to see some coupons or something like that in the future! read more

One of the best Italian sandwiches I've had, fresh ingredients, served hot, and the bread was absolute perfection. Flavorful, satisfying, and made with care. Service was fast , inside everyone was friendly, restaurant well lit. Definitely recommend! read more

McAlister's Deli - The Italian 12" - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

See all

My 1st visit to McAlisters deli and everything was delicious. I have seen multiple locations but never once tried McAlister's but my sister was in the mood for soup and salad and Panera bread was busy so we decided to make the drive and it was totally worth it. I got the Reuben and chili that was super delicious and filling the reuben is packed with meat so was the chili. My sister got a French dip and broccoli cheddar soup and they were both good. The ajuu I tried was flavorful. Even the kids love their food the kids cheese pizza was good and every kids meal comes with a cookie which I thought was nice. The establishment itself was clean, and the service was really on point. They helped me carry my drinks to the table and even helped us clean up in the end. Definitely a five star experience. read more

See all

Atmosphere - nice. The restaurant is bright and clean. Service - Very Good. The staff is friendly and the service prompt. In addition, the Manager stopped by our table frequently to ask if we need anything Food - Very Good. I had the roast beef club sandwich with a side of potato salad. The sandwich is large. The roast beef was very tender and the bread fresh. The potato salad was delicious. Overall Value - Given the quality, quantity and price, this is a very good value. read more

McAlister's Deli - a view of the counter area - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

See all

I came back, and still immensely like this place. My goal is to try everything on the menu except the pastrami which I don't like lol. This time I had the spicy turkey sandwich and it was great. The bread was fresh and the ingredients all worked well together. An employee, I am guessing the manager, checked on us twice to make sure we liked our food and to offer refills on the iced tea. Great touch! read more

McAlister's Deli - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

Still our favorite sandwich shop , clean, friendly with excellent food - fast sevice and fairly priced read more

McAlister's Deli - The New Yorker - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

See all

I'll start off by saying, this review is based entirely on my delivery order experiences - I haven't dined-in at this restaurant yet, so I cannot speak for the service and environment at the physical location, but my coworkers and I order the baked potatoes for lunch and they are so delicious, and HUGE - I had to leave a review and rave about them. We've tried almost every single one - and they're all great, but my favorites are the chipotle chicken and bacon spud and the spud max. We will continue ordering the baked potatoes from here - they're so worth it! read more

McAlister's Deli - Chipotle chicken and bacon spud - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

Great food served fast in a clean restaurant what more could you ask for in a "fast" food place. I especially like the 1/2 & 1/2 menu selection. read more

McAlister's deli is known for a more upscale and healthy type sandwich, the service was friendly and good, the food was good, the portions were average size, the price seemed a bit high, but overall very good. read more

See all

I had a pulled pork spud. I could not believe the size of the potato! A tad disappointed with the topping ratio to potato, but it was very tasty and I've made a meal and two snacks from this humongous potato! read more

I've eaten here three times. I would say my first experience was rather lackluster. However all of my subsequent visits have been on point. Food prepared well, staff really friendly and the restaurant clean. I appreciate the effort made by management to improve on their service to guests. This is why I have become a more frequent shopper. read more

See all

1st time. ordered cuban sandwich. bread was soft and pork was dry and tasteless. my friend ordered the Rueben. she said it was good. will try again but never a Cuban from this restaurant. read more

Absolute terrible experience I ordered online and my estimated pick up time was estimated 12:55 pm when I arrived I instead had to wait an additional 20 mins because I was told and I quote "dine in orders are priority " it's a cold sandwich it doesn't take long to prepare . Staff was respectful but was just terrible online experience won't be ordering again . read more

First things first, this is no deli. If you are a New Yorker like In am you know what I mean. More a fast food/casual dining/cafeteria. Wife got a corned beef on rye with brown mustard and swiss cheese. This was essentially a bread sandwich. Maybe two three slices of meat. Not good. I got the asian salad. This was pretty good. Fresh greens, nice crunch and tasty dressing. Don't think we'll be coming here again, $23 is a bit much for what we got. read more

McAlister's Deli - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

I was excited that a Deli would be close by. I'm not excited any more. If you're expecting this Deli to be like Katz or Carnegie, you're in for a huge disappointment. I ordered a corned beef sandwich with swiss cheese and hot mustard on rye bread. This was the thinnest deli sandwich I've ever gotten. The bread overtook the sandwich. The corned beef is not like freshly cooked corned beef but is a sliced lunch meat. I had to open it to see if there was any cheese on it. Mustard was ok, lol. I also pulled off all the crust of the bread so that I could actually taste the little meat that was in this sandwich. Service was nothing special, just typical workers. Being a pretty new place it looked clean and nice. Price, too much for too little. This is a one and done for me. Back on my search for an authentic deli corned beef sandwich. read more

McAlister's Deli - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

We go to the Gibsonton location when on that side of Brandon. Never disappointed. The counter help are the most pleasant of other places I have been. Food is very good. I didn't care for one of my sides and the server insisted on replacing it with something else. Never had that happen before. Will definitely go back. The service is right on. read more

When I was a Police Officer, me and my coworkers would eat here at least once a week. Especially when we were trying to eat healthy. But once I retired and moved to Florida, there weren't any near me until they opened this one in Gibsonton Florida, I'm only a few miles away and since my wife is a healthy eater and has never dined here before, this was a safe bet. My wife had the healthy garden sandwich with a cucumber salad on marble rye and I also had the healthy garden with bacon on a ciabatta bread with chips. We had a sweet tea and lemonade mix to wash our food down. Our meal was great, it had a fresh taste and the presentation of our meal was very nice. The customer service is as good and they are friendly.m read more

See all

Food definitely did not taste that great. My son would not even go near the mac & cheese and he eats every kind. It had a weird aftertaste to us. read more

Hubby and I visited McAlister's for the first time. As we walked in we were promptly greeted by the ladies behind the counter. We ordered sandwiches and salad. I had the veggie sandwich and my hubby ordered the Grilled chicken club and Southwest Chicken Avocado Salad. Mmm the sandwich was full of flavor and the bread nice and fresh. We really was looking forward to trying one of their soups however, the soup warmer was down. Definitely will be back. read more

See all

Best sandwich shop around. Their McAllister club on wheat is great. Get the potato salad as a side when you do a pick 2. The sweet tea taste as if it was made in Mississippi. Thanks me later read more

Awesome food and service. We stopped in for lunch I had the New Yorker absolutely delicious. My wife had a turkey sandwich she liked it but she tried mine and decided to take half of it. So we each had half of each other's sandwich. Both was excellent but I definitely enjoyed the New Yorker better. Can't wait to come back and try a couple other sandwiches. But that corned beef and pastrami New Yorker definitely I'm going to have that again. read more

McAlister's Deli - Salad Near Me - Gibsonton, Florida

Family and I always enjoy McAlisters, there is not one near us in Fishhawk. Whenever we are near one we try and stop, this location is closest to us, and hasn't disappointed yet. Broccoli cheese soup is always reliable, kids love the options they pick from, and have not had a bad sandwich. read more

The food is always fresh and delicious. The grilled chicken sandwich is great. Also nice to see a steamed broccoli side that's super healthy. The staff is always friendly and super helpful. read more