Very charming, old-school atmosphere with great service and a friendly staff. Sports all over the place including on the televisions and on the walls. Amazing memoribilia. Must see! The food is awesome. Burgers are the best anywhere. Toasted pretzel bun, unique fries. Steak was really good, too. Not expensive. Big recommend. read more

Mattingly's Tavern - Best Burger in Orange County - Bars Near Me - Florida, New York

Tavern is the perfect description. First time here. We went for the wing special on Wednesday. We ordered wings and didn't give our usual request. Naked, hot and extra crispy. And they were perfect. The Matingly dry rub was great and the flavor of the hot wings was exceptional in flavor and very low heat. We look for Rolling Rock or Papts but the on tap Modelo was fine. James, the bartender and host was a great guy. Made us newbies feel right at home. It is a truly home town tavern. read more

Tonight was our first time dining at Mattingly's Tavern and it didn't disappoint. It was wing night and we specifically went for the wings. They were delicious and you certainly could beat the price. The bartender was tending bar and taking orders, he was certainly working hard and he was friendly and nobody was neglected. The food did take a while to come out, but we could totally look past that with the food being delicious. We will definitely be returning. read more

Mattingly's Tavern - Chicken Wings - Bars Near Me - Florida, New York

See all

It's a unique bar with tables atmosphere. Food was really good fries are homemade and top notch, chicken sandwich was awesome and same with wings. If busy it may be slightly slow for food but it's worth the wait for what type of food. read more

Our beer was warm and the drinks are over priced. Also, my food was not edible. One positive is they have an outdoor fire pit to sit near which is nice, which helps when there is a band because it can get very loud. read more

I stop in to Mattingly's Tavern every time I am in Florida, NY and it is always an all-around great experience. The food is always delicious, the service is prompt, and the staff is always very welcoming. I highly recommend Mattingly's Tavern if you're looking for a good bite or a cold drink! read more

I absolutely love Mattingly's. It is such a fun atmosphere with live bands, lotto, games and a jukebox. The owners Tom and Erin are the most friendly people along with all their staff. This bar is right in the heart of town. If you're looking for a late night bite or just a nice cold beer or cocktail, this is your place. I visit Mattingly's every time I visit New York from California and it's the greatest place. read more

Mattingly's Tavern - Bars Near Me - Florida, New York

Nothing special here, basic bar food,looks appears lik it's just a locals hang out where u have your old timers betting horses, etc. Which is ok. We stopped in on memorial day,got a few apps to share and the guys drank a beer or 2. Again, nothing special. read more

Tried Mattingly's for the first time this week and loved every part of it! I'm not sure if they always have this special but I got the lunch special; it included 1 appetizer, 2 entrees and two cocktails that came in mason jars for $30. I paid a little extra to get their sampler appetizer to try out a bunch of different items so I know for the next time what to get. The Mac n'Cheese bites and the fried pickles were amazing! I highly suggest trying either of those if that's something you like. For entrees we got two chicken tenders. Seemed fresh and wasn't heavily breaded. The best part of the meal though was the side of "chips" that came with the chicken tenders. Half way between fries and chips, these were delicious. So crispy, so addictive! Honestly the whole meal was just tasty!! For the drinks we got two tequila sunrises and they were good. Very well balanced and by being in the mason jars it was easy to mix real quick to make sure it hadn't separated on the drive back to my house. I also picked up some Jell-O shots and omg, any party I will be having at my house will be having these at it. Honestly can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Delivery; Onion Rings burned, rare hamburgers well done; Thighs, one good, one too dry to eat, order delayed twice. Has been better before, but no excuse that these items should have made it out of the kitchen since they were packaged (handled) for takeout. read more

Mattingly's Tavern - Onion Rings - may they rest in peace - Bars Near Me - Florida, New York

Patrick!!!! All I have to say in this review is Patrick! Best bartender. Best wings. Weird bar. Great place!! read more

We really like this place. Sometimes we're confused as to what's going on, like is it sports or live music...? But the service is always stellar and friendly, and the wings are excellent! If you like very spicy, get those adobo caliente- the name makes you think they'll be mexican tasting, but really they're just a great amount of heat! Also strongly suggest the potatoes, much better than regular fries! read more

Mattingly's Tavern - those potatoes! thin and perfectly fried! - Bars Near Me - Florida, New York

Absolutely terrible service. Started out by myself ordered a drink and an appetizer. My wife joined me a few minutes later. Waited for a half hour, waiter never came back. Just moved out here and am trying to support businesses, so far this one disappointed. read more

I've never been inside this place because I only moved here about 3 months ago but the food is pretty good but expensive and small portions. Also they're losing a star for not putting the honey mustard on the sandwich and hiding the fact that the honey mustard isn't homemade. They should try making a homemade honey mustard. This isn't McDonald's or Burger King. Other than those two things, it's not disgusting but it's not the best thing I've tasted. I've tasted a lot worse food. read more

Mattingly's Tavern - Grilled Chicken Sandwich w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats - Bars Near Me - Florida, New York

We tried brunch yesterday. The bacon, egg and cheese on a pretzel roll was the best breakfast sandwich I've ever eaten. Bottomless mimosa was a great idea! Thank you. read more

The food and atmosphere is exactly what I love in a local tavern. Great food, cozy, friendly, fair prices and clean. Burgers and wings are outstanding! They even have vegetarian choices! I love their beyond burger, and it's on a pretzel bun, yummm! Cocktails rock and a great selection of beer in the bottle and on tap. I highly recommend Mattingly's Tavern. read more

Mattingly's Tavern - Awesome garlic Parmesan wings! - Bars Near Me - Florida, New York

See all

We ordered takeout at Mattingly's and all I have to say is the food was excellent. Service was great! I live in NJ, but when we go for our visit this is a "must visit" spot! read more

Went here with my girlfriend and her two friends to celebrate her 21st with some drinks. Being 20 I was the DD and ordered some water. As a person who does not consume alcohol on the daily or even know what half the things they said when they ordered I'm rating this Tavern on its service and responses based off the party. They all loved the drinks they were served. Mike the bartender was super attentive to us and made sure our night was special. He did the due diligence to check our IDs to withhold a proper standard and they started ordering away. He made some of his own drinks that he thought my girlfriend would like and she was super happy with the results. The girls where enjoying themselves to some tasty drinks and some recommended tunes the bartender asked us. He really made our night much more fun with his recommendations for drinks and accommodating anything we wanted. We arrived at 10pm ish and the kitchen was unfortunately already closed. My only highlight to making my time there better was to order some food to keep myself busy but that wasn't the case. Although I don't expect much from a bar for high quality food I was really looking forward to reviewing it. If I do happen to ever go back to this place I'm sure going to try out the kitchen. Overall I would recommend this place to anyone in the Warwick area. I hope my bar expertise will get better to offer more concise reviews but this will have to do for now. Hope this review helps! read more

Mattingly's Tavern - Otterpop (Mike Special) - Bars Near Me - Florida, New York

Yummy delivery, quick and easy. Burgers were delicious and who would have guessed that flat fries could be that good? Smiles all around!

Great hamburgers!! I had the onion Swiss burger and it was so good. I enjoyed the flattened potatoes too.

I get it. It's a bar. It's bar food. I don't expect Michelin rated levels of quality from an establishment like this. But let's get real here. This food, at best, is awful. The burgers are laughable, thin, tasteless, grade F beef patties that were thawed from god knows when they were thrown in their freezer and sentenced to death. The fries and really, every appetizer, are opened from a bag sourced from Costco and obliterated in the deep fryer, and just inedible. Even the stupid arcade games are inoperable (don't accept cash in the slot) making it a triple bogey for the course. BIG PASS. Do not come here if you have any respect for your stomach or what a good dive bar burger can be. 0 out of 5. Not only that, I've given this place two opportunities before I posted this. The owner hopefully reads this and makes some serious changes before the space is for lease again. Or not. read more

I feel like he can't wait for me to go , yet that's his job !! It's a young person attitude not cool just engaging with friends I was made to feel uncomfortable so I left. I always leave a good tip if I feel it's earned and other bartenders there were good to me but not this one 11/30/22 wed night , I grew up there , so disappointed I really liked. That place , younger people have no respect read more

Myself, my husband and a friend walked into Mattingly's during Phase 3 of Covid. The 3 of of us were camping nearby for the 4 of July and figured we would stop in for a drink and some dinner.  They told us we were not allowed to sit at the bar because there was 3 of us. They informed us that we could only sit 2 people at the bar.  This confused us because the regulations state if we come together and are staying together, we can sit together as long we are no more than a group of 10 and are spaced 6 feet apart from other guests which we would have been. In addition, we were confused because the Manager was sitting at the bar having a drink and he was prohibiting us from having a drink.  Based on his lack of knowledge of Covid and overall unprofessional and unwelcoming demeanor, we left and went to the establishment across the street where they greeted us warmly. They also informed us that the manager of Mattingly's had called them to warn them that we were "Covid spies" sent to be sure businesses were following guidelines. "Covid spies"? Really? We were simply patrons, following all rules, trying to celebrate our nation's birthday yet, we were discriminated against because they assumed we were spies. What does Mattingly's have to hide that they would deny us so quickly thinking we were spies? Makes me wonder... read more

I really don't like to do this... however, we can think of Nothing good to say about this place. Very limited menu, no help, the poor bartender is "the waitstaff", the cook doesn't know what " Med rare" means, therefore the burger was dry and the "no label" Ketchup didn't help, " No Chardonnay" was the final straw. Don 't bother! read more

Came in today to grab a drink and lunch while in Florida and got despicable treatment from the owner Tom Mattingly. I sit at the bar and the friendly waitress (she must feel like a battered wife working under Tom) asks me politely what I want. As she is pouring the Stella I just ordered, the owner stands up from the only table that is occupied to ID me. After giving him my ID, he quickly says he cannot serve me because of my out of state Pennsylvania ID. I don't know exactly why that restaurant was completely empty during the height of the lunch rush, but having an owner that is so uninviting and makes his customers out to be liars might be a reason! If you want a good environment for lunch, just walk two doors down to Barrel 28. Much friendlier staff and they know how to read an out-of-state ID if your visiting. read more

Terrible service. Manager asked for ID's after we were served beers and took our beers away, claiming that out of state ID's were unacceptable. He asked me for my astrological sign to check if my ID was real and told me I was wrong even though I read my daily horoscope. Do not go here! read more

I was traveling on the east coast visiting friends and we had heard from a local that the best wings in town were at mattinglys. So, our group gathered and went and found a table by the bar. The place was awesome. Not only was the food amazing (we ended up having several courses) but the friendly atmosphere and fun staff made the experience top notch. Perfect place for watching sports. Perfect place to hang with buddies. Nice spot for family time. I highly recommend it... I'm coming back soon. Rob R read more

We stopped by around 8pm on Father's Day after a hot day of playing golf. We were promptly greeted by Johnny and sat outside due to NY Covid phase. Beer selection was good. We had fried pickles as an appetizer and both of us had steak burgers with fries (like shaved potato skins) which were both excellent. Service was very good and nice banter with our server. Prices are very reasonable. Give them a try. Highly recommended read more

went there last night to check it out, laid back place to have a burger and a couple beers. John, the bartender seems to personify the "laid back" vibe of the place. I had a cheese burger, tasty with a crisp hunk of lettuce and tomato, the fries were good, too. I knocked off a star because I prefer red onion on my burger, there was a nice slice of onion there but it was a Vidalia.....not too devastating. all in all, it's a friendly place to have a burger and brew. read more

Awesome sports bar with all the NFL games on. Great atmosphere with great bartenders!!!

Great local place! Bartenders are great as is the food! They have PBR on tap! Atmosphere and lots of TV's! Watch a game and grab a beer and some food! read more

I went in with too high of expectations. This is just a local bar with some quick bites. We went in and stood for 5 minutes at the bar before being noticed and told we could seat ourselves and order at the bar. We planned on getting wings for dinner there but with the inconsistent service and lack of knowledge on gluten free drinks at the bar, we ended up elsewhere. Great drinks but I would not plan to go for food or service. read more

Wings have gone really down hill. Barely any flats, all are just this broken bone non-drum stick if chicken that is not really eatable.

I want to say good things, I really do. Friends of mine had a poor experience when the restaurant first opened and I always like to give them time to work the kinks out. Now that things are opening up, we decided to try the food and dine in. We ordered the wings which are supposed to be awesome according to some reviews and I thought they were very mediocre. Meals we ordered: impossible burger was a small, hard, salty puck with nothing on it. Chicken tenders were so over cooked that some couldn't be eaten, flat fries were interesting but many were so over fried that oil oozed out of them and the fried chicken was average. We also ordered some Margaritas and they looked pretty but were so incredibly sour like someone doubled the sour mix concentrate and we couldn't finish them. I hope this review helps others with their decisions and hopefully is a wake up call for the restaurant that things are coming alive again and people want to come out to dine and be with others. The restaurant needs lots of refiguring. read more

Great bar atmosphere, bartender was fun and entertaining. Wings were really good, not a fan of the garlic wings as it was in a white cream sauce but everything else was good. read more

Top notch sports bar....stadium style food and wings are off the charts...numerous local IPA's and a full bar....all Sunday NFL games and enough TV's for any sport you would loke to view. read more

Best salmon burger ever tasted and the curly fries were wonderful. Yvonne Cheyney, Southern California.

Mattingly's is all you could want in a neighborhood bar and grill. Tom and Erin have created a spot you want to hang out with your friends for hours, watch a game, get some great pub eats, in a friendly atmosphere with a full compliment of beer and spirits. Love this place!! read more

Average at best. Yelp wants more words of description for the review, but there's really noting else to offer here. Mediocre.

Great place to hang with friends and watch a game. Pub food is on point and servers and bartenders are super nice. Clean and great service. read more