Great counter service Great Fresh selection including locally sourced seafood and shellfish. We got 5 pounds and cod loins last week from Mastic Seafood, very good! Delicious! fresh, cleaned and boneless. The place is spotless! Highly recommended! read more

Mastic Seafood - Cod - Seafood Markets Near Me - Mastic, New York

See all

My favorite seafoods fresh along with a great selection, service and prices! Stop in for a quick full filling dinner!! Thank you Mastic Seafood! read more

One of the best seafood markets on Long Island with incredible prices. You want a 7lbs lobster, most of the time they carry the big boys. The service has always been friendly and helpful. They'll steam the lobster for you on site if you ask. read more

Actually the only place to pick up FRESH seafood! Always clean & busy, with a great assortment of fish, lobsters, shelled critters at a fair price. Never disappointed! read more

Great selection and service! We have used for large parties at Christmas and other holidays. read more

Love this place! Authentic fresh seafood market with excellent choices and staff. As soon as you hit the door you know you've found an old school market with the products you want. The customer area is clean and the display cases are well stocked but go early for the crabs! This place is the hub for all the local restaurants and markets so skip the middle man and the added charges and just go to the source. read more

Having been a fish monger for 5 years, I'm a pretty good judge of fresh seafood . I know what to look for. Bright eyes on whole fish, moist flesh on fillets. I can always count on a good find here! Never been disappointed, they know their stuff. When have you seen 10 or more people behind a fish counter? They are THAT busy. Can't say enough about the quality. Trust me you can't go wrong. read more

Very good service!! Soon as you walk in the store you are greeted with "how are you doing today? May I help you today?" They have quality seafood, fresh, nice and professionally prepared and packed. The display is 10/10 and you can order as you want...custom cuts or custom orders. Keep it up guys!! Your customer service is exemplary!!! read more

Wonderful attentive staff Fresh Fresh Fish Preorders always ready Wonderful variety Superb pricing read more

Best fish market around!!! The staff is so kind and patient and the fish is always fresh !

I drive from Ronkonkoma to by seafood at Mastic Seafood. Everything's fresh the line moves fast and they have everything all year round " that's what I noticed". All the help are professional and fast. read more

We went to Mastic Seafood today for the first time. We were planning to have a dinner for a special occasion. My sister really likes seafood so my mom wanted to take her to Red Lobster. But we convinced her that the amount of food you pay for there is really not worth it and might not be fresh for takeout. So we convinced her to try to purchase some fresh seafood here to cook at home! They did not disappoint! We arrived around 4:30pm and it was popular! There were many people also in line! The prices are based on market price, so they might fluctuate from time to time. But we purchased two 1.25lbs. lobsters for $18.99. Along with 2lbs. mussels ($5), 12 clams ($5), and 1lbs. steamers ($5.99). Everything totalled together was $34.72! It was such a great deal double the amount of food you would get at a restraunt! Everything tasted super fresh and good! We will definitely be returning customers! To cook everything we added olive oil, garlic, onion, seasoning, some water, white wine potatoes and corn in a big pot. It was very good and fed our family of 4 very satisfied. read more

See all

Excellent experience!! Seafood is fresh right off the boats and beautifully displayed. Prices are great and the staff are friendly and helpful. I was visiting family out on Long Island as I'm from Florida. I highly recommend this market and will definitely visit again when in town. read more

Mastic Seafood is a special place. You will be hard pressed to find a better selection of fresh fish and prompt service anywhere on the planet, much less the east end of long island. Living in the Hamptons, one gets used to being price gouged. Mastic Seafood is a no frills exception to east end shopping read more

I used to go here all the time growing up on Long Island and over time this place has gotten worse. The service is fast but the people unless they know you on a first-name basis they do not treat you that well. I came in recently during my visit to my parents and my wife was craving some blue crabs so this was my go-to spot to get them. It was a weekend so it was busy and they still haven't figured to get a number system, so I was there waiting with a few other people and there was a gentleman that came after me who must have known the counter person because he started chatting with him and then that person ended up helping him and I was thinking to myself wth I was here before him but whatever someone was out a few minutes after to help me and so I ordered 2 dozen blue crabs and she had to go to the back to get a brand new basket of them and I could see her picking and searching for small ones and not just grabbing what was on top. I was getting annoyed but she was rushing and wasn't listening to me so I was telling myself I hope they're aren't any dead ones when I get home and what do you know there were 3 out of 24 dead. Next time I am gonna have to open the bag up and count when I'm there... jk I'm not coming back. read more

What was once a decent place has now been overtaken by so many better options. The fish is rarely fresh (you shouldn't smell fish); and the amount of health code violations are staggering. Avoid -- the best you might get is food poisoning. read more

Have shopped here many times over the years and have never ever experience a problem -- Always reasonably priced and totally Fresh ! Christmas is coming so I'll shopping here for the Night of the 7 Fishes ! read more

Great selection of fresh fish. Fast service. Fast turnover ensures good options. So why the 2* rating?? Easy: Our fish regularly has bones in it. Unacceptable. Nothing but excuses from the managers: "Guys are working fast;" "we're really busy," etc. Bunk! Prices are not cheap. Do the work, boys. When I get into my kitchen, your prep work should have been completed. Other markets in the area do a more thorough job. Not a big deal if I have to ask a few more questions at another nearby place to find out how fresh something is. You work for me, not the other way 'round. read more

Mastic seafood has a very wide selection of seafood. My family purchases huge volumes of seafood here each summer. The fish turns over quickly and they have a huge customer base. I saw Luke Voit buying lobster here a few weeks ago. read more

Thank you Mastic Seafood for making my 4th of July BBQ a huge success! The baked clams are best restaurant quality and the Monk fish was tender and almost sweet! I'm hooked on Monk fish!! Thank you! Clams and Oysters always fresh and sweet, we tried other fish stores and you are the best west of the Ponquoge bridge! read more

The seafood is always fresh and the price is pretty good. It's my go to place for seafood.

Just a great place to go for fresh excellent fish of different kind. Have used it got about 20 years, never been disappointed.

Located in one of the more unlikely spots for a seafood distributor, this neighborhood fishmonger mainstay is always jammed year-round. Consequently, the customers smell as bad as or worse than the fish, that's all part of Mastic Seafood's charm. Expect to wait and to pay..and for parking to be tough. Friendly but tough local guys run the joint, efficiently performing all the tasks that go along with a well-stocked fish business. I most recently got a soft shell crab cleaned and a pound of bay scallops. $12.05 and a debit punch-pin machine later, I strolled in with a tasty bounty... Not sure why the listing awkwardly has it as two words. read more

Stay away! Over priced frozen fish. Bought flounder that was so mushy you couldn't even eat it! Looks like I'll be searching for a new fish market! read more

I wish I had a local fish market like this by me. They have just about anything you want and at very decent prices. Fish is fresh and good looking. I learned if your extra nice, they'll usually hook you up a bit too. (IE. med clams for the price of sm, or a few extras) read more

Couldn't be happier to have such a great fish market so close to home. Everything I've ever gotten there has been fantastic - scallops, prawns, clams...and the CRAB SALAD! Delish! Great place and very friendly staff! read more

Great place to buy fresh seafood. I went in with my aunt this weekend to buy what we needed for a lobster boil for 10 people on 4th of July. The prices are great and the staff is helpful and friendly. We got 10 1.25 pound lobsters, a bunch of littlenecks, and a ton of shrimp. It was $120, which isn't cheap, but my aunt said it would've been more if she had gone to CorJ in Hampton Bays. Everything was delicious. I wish we weren't doing a lobster boil because their red snapper looked so good. The crowd of customers varies - sometimes you'll see someone come in and drop over $500 on a big feast, and you'll have people come in who don't want to spend more than $5 but want a fresh piece of fish for dinner that night. If you live close enough, stop in. Bring your cooler, they'll gladly give you some ice to keep your purchase fresh while you drive home. read more

Best seafood store on the island ! I gave it 4 stars simply because sometimes they charge for the head and bones of the fish

NASTY baked clams.....couldn't even eat them.....The shrimp was okay. I just guess you can't buy prepared food at seafood places. I should know better....but still....they should not be that nasty...dry.....fishy......too fishy... read more

If you are looking for an old time fish market that offers the freshest seafood on Long Island at great prices Mastic Seafood is the place to go! I have been shopping there for the last 20 years and have never been disappointed. The owners are great business men that take pride in what they do. read more

Mastic Seafood is everything a seafood purveyor should be. This isn't a restaurant. Nor does it cater solely to the timid seafood buyer alone. I mean, if you want founder fillets or a few lbs of salmon, you can get it. But that's just the beginning. Though the store is narrow and rather small, the selection is anything but. The cases are lined with rows of fresh, colorful fish of every variety. And the HEADS ARE ON. Why is this important? Because if I want fish without a head only, I'll shop at the grocery store. Dang, I'll buy my seafood in a can. This isn't that kind of experience. This is the genuine article. A couple of weeks ago I bought a dozen sea urchins. We frequent buy whole freshly caught fish, tails and heads, for broiling. We visit Mastic Seafood almost every week. It's a part of our lives. (Once you've selected your fish, head over to Frank & Sons bakery for fresh bread and cookies. The experience will remind you of the way food used to get bought and why that experience mattered.) read more