We wanted tuna for dinner. Called our former stinky standby. Cor-J, and tuna is $29.95 a pound! Shocking. It was $9.99 a pound on sale at King Kullen last week. So called Atlantic Seafood. $21.99 a pound. Sigh, but better than Cor-J. We drove over there, and it's a combo seafood market/restaurant, like whatever Indian Cove is called now. (It was Indian Cove almost my entire life, and now it's on its third or maybe fourth name change, and I absolutely cannot be bothered to keep track.) The fish looked fresh and wonderful, and a friendly, very helpful man weighed several different pieces so we could choose. One of us, not me, eats very small portions. We got two pieces, and when seared, they were delicious!! We had walked in through the restaurant, and exited through a giant fake shark jaw into a picnic area. The market part was small and fun, with lots of fake crabs. I got a menu to peruse later, because I want to come back! read more

See all

Food was amazing! Everyone was really nice and I felt like home. My wife never had ate all her food but she ate everything. I don't do season so I went with a burger and it was great. We loved the decor because when on vacation these are kind of places we like to visit. The kids loved seeing the giant shark head. It's not big but there is more than enough parking . You can also buy fresh fish to take home. Amazing place to stop by if you are visiting from out of town. read more

See all

This a was worthy stop on our way out to Montauk the Friday before Columbus Day weekend. This casual sit down spot has indoor and outdoor seating (with heaters), friendly service and good a selection of seafood favorites. I had no complaints about my meal I got a cup of a special menu item; shrimp and corn chowder which had the right amount of sweetness from the corn to cut the rich soup and accompany the shrimp. My fried flounder sandwich was perfectly fried and had a bit of a nostalgic vibe to me - for some reason I don't see a lot of flounder on menus nowadays. The fries were great as well. I tried the clam chowder and it was pretty inedible - it tasted like gloopy flour and water mixed together. The fish tacos came as a pair and were generous and tasty. I would stop in again if I find myself this far out on the island. read more

See all

I came here simply to try the fried fish sandwich , because someone locally told me it was the best. I didn't know it was also a market with a nice selection of fresh seafood. The sandwich was quite good and two decent pieces of fish . What stood out was how fresh it tasted. The tartar sauce was also very good and homemade. The fries were also great and perfectly salted. I will definitely come back to try other options although who knows , maybe I will get that delicious sandwich again since it was so good ! read more

See all

Always a simple pleasure . Family fun ! Little kids to grandma and grandpa! Simplicity at its best read more

Steamers and mussels and cod, oh my! I've written about this place before, so I must be a fan. It's where I go when I'm jonesing a bucket of steamers (in season, of course), though their fish and chips and shrimp tacos have often kept me satiated over the years. This is the kind of place where simple, and delicious seafood reigns. A comfortable dining room, space to dine alfresco (also in season) and huge sharks mouth to walk through as you enter the place! Did I mention that they're also a fresh seafood market? Lots of goodness from the briny deep to choose from and many a time I've come home with something fresh to cook for dinner. Tons of parking out back in the gravel lot (what, you'd frequent a seafood shack that didn't have one?). Always friendly and warm service (they politely ask for tips in cash) and great, simple, well-prepared food. Heck, they even have some BBQ for you lubbers out there. All cards accepted, a great selection of wines & beers and outstanding local shellfish. One of favorites on the island. read more

Atlantic Seafood - Shellfish on ice. - Seafood Near Me - Center Moriches, New York

It's got a local vibe, with outdoor seating. Service is decent & food is good. A little pricey, but if you want to sit near the huge jaws ya gotta pay! Clean & helpful staff if you want to pick up some fresh fish from the market there to prepare at home. read more

Atlantic Seafood - Jaws! - Seafood Near Me - Center Moriches, New York

Absolutely greatest food and Friendly accommodating Service Long time local Favorite!! Never been disappointed.. read more

Food was excellent for lunch. Shrimp corn chowder is awesome. My hubby had the cod with spinach, feta and tomatoes. Delicious. The only sticking point for me is the carpeting. Very stained and just gross. Everythig else is lovely read more

very cute tiny spot with amazing service and cocktails were great!! the only disappointment was the new england chowder. bowl is tiny and not much bigger than a cup, doesn't stay warm in plastic bowl. and no flavor really or clam meat in it had to add salt was lackluster. oysters were fresh and great. will be back but yeah chowder needs lots of help read more

After all of the reviews, I had to try this place out. Recently went for dinner. Appetizers we ordered were fried calamari, Mussels in white wine & garlic & a bowl of chilli. Calamari was good, a but overcooked. Chilli was delish! Mussels were good as well! For dinner I ordered the broiled shrimp with french fries. Shrimp was way over-cooked. Husband got a broiled seafood dish. He said it had no flavor except the paprika water it was sitting in on the dish. Waitress was super friendly & attentive. Quick service & everyone was nice! Cute little old style seafood joint with nautical decor & a fireplace to keep you warm! read more

See all

I really liked this place. I went for lunch on a Saturday. I had a Soft Shell Crab Sandwich ( special) and Raw Oysters. The wife had clam chowder and lobster salad sandwich. I had a few beers and driver had one rum punch. Service was excellent. The place has a funky old seafood look. I'd be a regular if I lived in the area. read more

The ambiance and kitchy shark at the door is adorable - love the fish shack vibe. Went in for lunch in early April - not a long wait. Ordered a fry sampler platter with a side of rice and everything was really delicious. Id definitely go back for more! Obviously being seafood the meal was probably around 30-40 for not a super a lot of food but it did warm the belly and was very tasty. read more

The fried clams and coconut shrimp were good, the brisket was decent. That said it really seems like there is a complete lack of effort put into the food which is surprising considering how much competition there is within driving distance. I think most of the food (at least what we had) comes from a can or a freezer, is microwaved or deep fried and that's it. I would most definitely avoid the nachos, the mac & cheese and basically anything else that they add their "cheese" to. It was like reheated, thick, white gravy with absolutely zero flavor. Not cheddar or American or Gruyere, just a thick white paste, whatever it was, it was not actual cheese. The nachos were absolutely the most disappointing thing I ever tried. Stop and shop bagged nachos with this goop ladled onto it and microwaved with a few pieces of tomato plopped down onto it. The Mac and cheese was just pasta with this same goop on it. Zero seasoning or flavor at all. The BBQ sauce on the brisket tasted like Kraft out of the bottle. It was not terrible food but definitely not good. It's pretty clear there is a total lack of effort put into anything. My wife's broccoli was either boiled or microwaved with, again, zero seasoning at all. I guess they figure that there is salt and pepper on the table and you can ask for tobasco sauce so there's your flavor. read more

Atlantic Seafood serves a generous portion of cod and toppings in their cod fish tacos. The quality of their fried flounder sandwich has been consistent over the years. You can order a baked potato instead of fries. Staff is always friendly and accommodating. Ordered broiled flounder as takeout, and the fish appeared to be thrown into the container. The atmosphere is very casual and food is served on disposable dinnerware. read more

See all

it smelt TERRIBLE they got my drink wrong i asked for a iced tea and lemonade mix and they gave me a strawberry lemonade... the worker made the restaurant smell terrible and was insanely rude and told me she would skrew my man and it was a TINY restaurant i was bombarded by dirty smelling things (not fish) and was itching her armpit and smelt her hand after ..? and i would not recommend this place there was too many fishy style decorations i was pretty frightened.. never in my lifetime would I recommend.. read more

We were in the mood for seafood and decided to try this place, as we've never been here. If you're not looking for it, you can easily drive right by. Indoor/Outdoor seating options, we chose to Dine indoor. Extremely no-frills, carefree, relaxed restaurant, down to plastic cups and paper plates, which was perfect for us. Small, but sufficient bar area. For appetizers, we ordered the baked clams and crab cake. Both had the perfect coating and crunch, while the inside of each was tender. Both were delicious. Nice sized clam bits in the clams and a good amount of crab in the cakes. For dinner, my husband ordered the fried seafood platter, which included shrimp, scallops, clam strips, and flounder. He chose french fries for his side. Everything had a nice coating and was perfectly fried. He enjoyed it very much. I ordered the clam bake, which had mussels, clams, steamers, and a whole lobster, along with a full corn on the cob. Everything seemed to be steamed in a butter broth, which made it all very flavorful. It was excellent. Service was decent, and the shell buckets were quickly emptied and replaced. We look forward to returning to try other menu options. If you enjoy seafood and a laid-back atmosphere, we highly recommend it. ONE CAVEAT: They charge 3.99% for charge cards. When the receipt arrives, there are no lines to add a tip. When we asked the server, she said the system is outdated, and does not allow for lines to be printed, she has to charge the card a 2nd time for a tip - so an additional 3.99%??? read more

See all

This seafood restaurant and fish store combined has the nickname Haws from the huge fish shaped entrance. Menu has a variety of seafood, pasta, and bar options. read more

I love this spot and have been coming here as long as I can remember. It's probably the best fried flounder sandwich anywhere -- just the basics, done perfectly. I usually get that but occasionally I splurge on a lobster dinner, or even the clambake feast. It's all good. I like the ambiance very much as well, not because it's fancy but because it's not. The focus here is on making good food. I must warn you: the punch is delicious but also pretty strong! In all, I do recommend as a good restaurant and a good fish market. read more

The service was great and place was extremely casual , in other words, not fancy at all. The seafood was very fresh and I'd recommend the special because you'll get a reasonable priced meal The shrimp pizza was good but a little too much cheese. Who would think too much cheese isn't great but they over did it Otherwise, enjoy. I did read more

First time in... we're active seniors and stopped by for a light New Year's Day lunch... the casual, relaxed decor is great.. the staff (Sarah) terrific... seated us and we noticed that everything was neat clean and friendly! GREAT! Two bowls of chowder... hot with oyster crackers Yummy! 1/2 order of Steamers and the Calamari appetizer... WOW! Steamers we're nice size and perfectly prepared, Calamari was hand-cut, a substantial portion and some of the best I've had on the island...! A special thank you to Sarah for her smile, kind service and professionalism... Ambiance: this is a casual eatery, not Pretentious... (white tablecloths-cloth napkins and fancy tableware... Nope)... perfect! VALUE: okay gang... fresh high quality sea food is expensive on the island... if you are looking for cheap seafood this isn't your place... if you are looking for great quality seafood nicely prepared and served in a friendly casual setting THIS PLACE IS IT! ... Go there... say hello to Sarah... sit down and enjoy! read more

It's been quite a few years since we visited this restaurant. But it's restaurant week and it's local so we went for lunch. Staff was very friendly. I started with the New England clam chowder. I know it had pieces of clam in it but there was no clam flavor. It was more of a cream soup with some potatoes in it. My husband had the fried calamari. It was a bit chewy, not terrible just not great. I had the smoked brisket sandwich, it was topped with American cheese and crispy onion straws on a soft bun. A bit too much bbq sauce for me but it was okay. Served with some of the best French fries ever. My husband had fish tacos, fried cod homemade hose slaw. He enjoyed them, but again not great. Server was lovely! read more

My family and I stopped here after pumpkin and apple picking. We sat on the deck because it was warm out. The staff was very sweet, and the food was great! I had a burger with fries, and my family had hot lobster rolls-- which they all loved. We shared an appetizer of calamari which was great too. Its a small place but i highly recommend eating here for a quick bite for lunch. Great food and great service. Thank u! read more

Atlantic Seafood - Burger with lemonade - Seafood Near Me - Center Moriches, New York

WOW!! In Center Moriches for my Covid vaccine. We did a Yelp search and found a great spot for lunch but Waze took us here (?) Lucky for us. We sat outside where there were 2 picnic tables with heat lamps The waitstaff wore masks. Plenty of people sat inside. We were the only ones outside The food is great here We had a trio sampler of soups. New England clam chowder, Manhattan clam chower and lobster bisque. All were very good. Pretzel bread came on the side The clam strips were better than we've ever had in Montauk. Perfectly cooked, filled with clam and the batter was perfection. Home made fries and cole slaw came on the side (entree size). Dipping sauces were cocktail sauce and tarter sauce. The shrimp tacos was a winner. We loved the food so much we'll come back in 3 weeks (1hour drive from home) when we get our 2nd Covid vaccine. That good!! read more

See all

I had the Brisket wet with Broccoli and my friend had the Shrimp Tacos. The food was delicious and the waitress (Lina) was outstanding! read more

See all

if you're thinking about getting the seafood linguine, you should go get it ASAP!!! this is the BEST seafood linguine BY FAR that i've ever had. I started with the mushrooms first and oh my god... the mushroom tasted AMAZING and my bf think so too and HE DOESNT LIKE MUSHROOMS!!!!! The SAUCE is so good, perfect and creamy too its INSANE. The scallops and lobsters are HEAVENLY. Although, the shrimp is kinda overcooked but THAT BESIDES THE POINT. YOU GUYS SHOULD STILL GET IT YOU WILL NEVER REGRET IT. YOU LITERALLY GET WHAT YOU PAID FOR. I am so HAPPILY full right now. I cant believe it. plus.... we only have to wait for 15 mins!!!!!! read more

DECOR: a bit divey, casual. Small indoor area as well as a small outdoor spot with picnic tables. FOOD: ordered mussels and coconut shrimp for appetizers. Both were good. For dinner ordered Blackened Chicken Wrap w/ chipotle mayo, cheeseburgers, and the Beef Brisket Sandwich. Everything tasted good, especially the fries. Very crispy and salty. Only negative comment is the beef brisket sandwich was constructed very poorly, the brisket was half off the bun so my husband had to try and rebuild it b4 eating. SERVICE: this is where my review landed at only 3 stars. The service kind of stunk. Waitress was very nice, but it took about 45 min for just our appetizers to come out. We were so hungry and to top it off we had a toddler with us that was not only hungry also, but very fidgety. It made for a frustrating dinner sadly. read more

See all

FYI: The address on the restaurant website is different: 125 Main Street, Center Moriches. This place is really cute! I don't understand all the negative reviews. Mostly the main gripe was the price. So you want fresh seafood, but want to pay the lower prices? Personally, the food was good and the prices are reasonable. Their drink menu looks very yummy-$7-9 for a cocktail like pina colada or mimosa. The space is laid out with a lot of space between tables. Everyone is wearing a mask. Food came hot and fresh and well seasoned. My favorite is the shrimp and lobster pizza. It was a crispy cracker like dough. The seafood topping was pleasant, not too over powering. We also bought food from the seafood market. It's convenient to come here for lunch and buy food for dinner too! They have a nice selection of crabs in the refrigerator and fresh fish and prepared food in another case. I would totally come back here and recommend it to anyone in the area. read more

Atlantic Seafood - Lobster and shrimp pizza. - Seafood Near Me - Center Moriches, New York

So fresh that the place does not smell like fish lol I love their wild caught salmon. read more

This place has fresh seafood; the cod, sea scallops and raw clams were fantastic. Server was friendly. Scallops were large, sweet, and some of the best I've had. We ordered Calamari and crab cake for appetizers. Calamari was good, crab cake was disappointing. It was large but had way too much breading. It would be much better at a smaller size with very little bread, just enough to bind so that the taste of crab stood out. The brown butter cod with capers was really melted butter and not brown butter. The cod was fantastic and could have been outstanding if it had the nutty flavor of brown butter. I would go back and try other fresh seafood (mussels looked good). I would not get a crab cake but everything else was good! read more

Good food but too expensive for paper plates and cups . Overall though good place if you have a little extra coin laying around.. read more

Atlantic Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Center Moriches, New York

Great place, great food! Ordered a burger was very good! Good seafood! Good drinks! Best local spot around!

Fresh seafood place! You can't go wrong! Not the fanciest place but the food is good!

CRAB BUCKET = $115 !!! Just an FYI. Someone in our party ordered the crab bucket. Everyone else's dinners were under $30; the bucket was $115. I feel that either 1) this whopper of a price should be made known by the server, or 2) it should be posted/updated as the MP changes. Usually when out to dinner, nobody wants to start asking what each of the MP (market prices) are because they don't want to seem like they are pinching pennies when out to dinner with friends. This is not a high-end restaurant and NOBODY is expecting that surprise on their bill. Price transparency from the restaurant would be an appreciated addition. read more

Wonderful fresh seafood with excellent menu varieties! Good service in a fun atmosphere!

Loved this little seafood spot. Worth the trip. Huge menu. Don't worry if you're with people who don't eat seafood. They have something for everyone. I started with a margarita. It was very good. For appetizers we had the Little Neck clams and my husband had the soup of the day - shrimp and corn chowder. He loved it. I tried it and it was excellent. The clams were very fresh. My husband had the Blackened Shrimp Wrap. Spicy, flavorful but not too hot. Me and our friend tried the soft shell crab sandwich. I'd been craving some soft shell crab and this sandwich hit the spot. Crispy and cooked just right. Ever the tarter sauce was better than most I've had. Loved the fries too. Our friend couldn't get over how good the food was. Want to go back soon! read more

See all

There are few times in life where you'll come across sweet potato fries that are so perfectly crisp and delicious that you slow down while eating them. Atlantic seafood has those perfect fries! And I ate every. single. one of them. The maple syrup dipping sauces sweet and goes nicely. I love the outdoor seating area with the massive shark jaw that you walk through to go inside the restaurant. Also great for Insta pics. The interior is decorated with catchy slogan's and nautical doodads. Taxidermy fish and fishing nets add to the sea theme. My friend was raving about the burger here, so she had a cheeseburger and regular fries. I decided to go with the flounder fish sandwich and sweet potato fries. Very happy I did. The regular fries were ho-hum. Thin without much crunch. The burger was very good. I wasn't a fan of the fried flounder, but seeing as how the fryer temp was spot on, had it been another type of fish, this would've been an excellent sandwich. The seasoning was tasty, bun was soft, the lettuce and tomato were fresh. The tartar sauce was delicious. We had a kombucha and an IPA that paired nicely. My IPA was only five bucks on special. The kombucha was $7.99, but was great to try once. The service is attentive and friendly. It was later in the evening and the restaurant wasn't full, so it was quite comfortable for dinner . I had heard it gets pretty busy. We were able to catch up and chat and had a lovely experience. I would definitely go back, especially in the warmer months when you can sit outside, And to revisit those sweet potato fries. read more

See all

We knew from our Yelp Directions that this little Gem was there but if you blinked driving down Montauk Hwy at night you would def miss it. The sign by the road had bulbs out and it was only by slowing down on this lonely stretch of hwy that we found it...the open sharks mouth beckoning all that dare enter. Talk about funky...this little "shack" is a real find...it contains not only a small restaurant but also a fish market. Bon and I entered and were greeted by a mostly female staff of young energetic gals who all had a smile and were there for your every need. We settled down and had an ice cold beer and a skinny margherita....both wonderful! We perused the menu and chose a couple of appys: a dozen Cherrystones which were perfectly shucked and tasted briny like they were swimming a couple of hours ago,,,,also tried the Steamers...sweet and perfectly prepared...so far a joy ! We shared a main of Seafood Fra Diavalo; mussels, clams, shrimp on a bed of speghetti in a wonderful spicy sauce and enjoyed every bite. The freshness of their food and the perfect prep makes this a def 4 star establishment....if you have the will to find Atlantic, you will have a great seafood feast! In the summer it must be packed so now is the time to go. read more

See all

So very disappointed, Shrimp were doused in Cajun seasoning but that didn't make them flavorful, Mac and cheese was a total disaster (nothing more to say about it). Sad to say, the wings were the best part to come from a SEAFOOD place and they were mediocre at best. read more

See all

Let me start by saying my meal was delicious. I really never had a bad meal here. The problem I have is the fact is that they are extremely expensive and you get served with plastic plates and cups. My bill was $81.00 for 2 seafood dishes. No drinks, just water. $35.99 each plate with a $2.58 processing fee because I used my credit card. I guess if I ever want to get robbed I'll be back. I wanted a meal, not to buy the place. Such a shame! read more