Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mattituck Shellfish

    5.0 (4 reviews)

    Mattituck Shellfish Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mattituck Shellfish

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Greg C.
    0
    62
    159

    2 years ago

    No frills , From sea to plate in less than 6 hours. This is THE place to get fresh shellfish.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Very fresh clams. Harvest the same day. You can buy at wholesale prices. They are open from 4:00pm - 8:00pm

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Seafood Markets 1,235 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Justin's Chop Shop - Chicken Pot Pie. They can be found in the freezer section or in the  prepared food section.

    Justin's Chop Shop

    4.7(55 reviews)
    4.2 mi
    $$

    Justin's Chop Shop Read this review!…read moreI bought a 2 inch Rib Eye Steak on the bone. Justin the owner served me, I remember because it was my first experience. I normally shop at the Fish Market next door and the cheese shop next door. The steak came out to 80 dollars and I also got a free Greek Chips he was selling as well. I remember I was upset because that evening I had a work emergency and ended up freezing that expensive steak. I recently found it I'm my deep freezer two months later and thawed it, seasoned it with sea salt and fresh pepper and grilled it. I am a private chef I should know a great cut of meat. This steak was absolutely delicious and I cooked it to perfection. It was so delicious that the dog was growling as he normally gets the bone. It's Daddy's Bone! Tip I like to add fresh lemon and a dash of soy sauce. Justin's Chop Shop Awesome Maximilian Southampton NY

    What a nice store! Stopped in for a freshly made smashburger after hearing about them and we ended…read moreup getting the "signature burger" and "Justin's burger". Was very surprised when they came out so small literally like sliders. At $12 a piece, even though they came with some fries, I thought the price was high. I do understand we're paying a premium for a burger from a quality butcher but probably wouldn't order again. Although very tasty! Loved the chopped pickles. They have a nice selection of gluten free pasta products from Italy which I hadn't seen before. Got a few of those and some pickles, chips and sauces too. Nicely organized produce section, friendly staff and overall a very nice business to frequent!

    Photos
    Justin's Chop Shop - Ahi Tuna

    Ahi Tuna

    Justin's Chop Shop
    Justin's Chop Shop

    See all

    Out of the Blue Seafood - Delivery was great

    Out of the Blue Seafood

    3.9(308 reviews)
    4.7 mi
    $$

    In a very casual ambience, the service is excellent and the staff is super nice. The menu is large,…read morewith lots of seafood choices, so it is hard to decide. Tonight I had the Shrimp/Scallop Diavlo and it was terrific! Really delicious and not too hot/spicy - just right. The shrimp and scallops were just perfect. And the hot garlic bread might be the best I have ever had, much better than at the other 11946 restaurants here, that's for sure. The local brownie was the right price and very good. I would definitely recommend this place and return here. It is a not a gourmet restaurant, but still excellent for its type of eatery. Check it out if you love fresh seafood!

    Way too understaffed for end of June on Montauk Hwy. In Hampton Bays - especially at the beginning…read moreof the heading into the long stretch of Shinnecock area. This is a top location and workers were stressing and edgy. Two more people needed at least. In food - Build it they will come! Crowd wise at least. Asked about the Manhattan - no taste offered Just a scoop lifted and comment about it being Manhattan clam chowder . Oh ok so then just give me the small - cant do a quart untested - lol Over comes the New England - eeek Ok so then when told - insisted I told him New England and the classic flinging out of the cup after saving the chowder - Thanked Was grateful for the soup - tipped and thought wow - they need to ramp up the front counter - who were also getting clams - one woman gave a waiting tables away to a new person on the line - heard that stressing out my soup guy - When in the Hamptons chill out and thank them - it's a lot to go from 2 to 100 in a few weeks. Dockers is the only place that nails it every time - but you're going to pay for it. All around ok place for all types of seafood - Manhattan chowder is Meh - watery potatoey - But a few fresh clams - so ok. Their claim to fame is their clams and steamers - fresh and delicious. Nice outdoor picnic tables on the deck before the door. Wait service and cool drinks or beer. Insider a few tables for dining in. Very reliably good. Go to chill out and enjoy real locally made soups and fresh seafood.

    Photos
    Out of the Blue Seafood - Menu

    Menu

    Out of the Blue Seafood - Snow Crab Clusters

    Snow Crab Clusters

    Out of the Blue Seafood - Outdoor patio

    See all

    Outdoor patio

    Westhampton Beach Indoor Winter Market

    Westhampton Beach Indoor Winter Market

    3.9(8 reviews)
    4.4 mi
    $$

    Weshampton Farmer's Market is a small but good Farmer's Market that makes you look forward to…read moregoing. The east end is a treasure trove of produce and seafood, and you can find a bit of many things in one place here on Saturdays, 9 -1. April through September Rain or Shine is their motto... Lots of cage free organic eggs, poultry, locally caught seafood, a few bakeries like Blue Duck and Sweet Andies cookies, fruit pies, various spices, sauces, honey makers, etc. Even in from "up island" are plants and flowers, further still in from Brooklyn, one vender brings in homemade ravioli ... all kinds from spinach, mushroom, to lobster, and amazing oversized chewy twisted seeded Italian bread, marinara sauce etc. Local grown, in season produce, like strawberries, asparagus etc. Back locally polka dot bakery will give you a fix of variousl flavored pound cake. The star of the show are the ladies at the front that bring in fresh seafood and have super fresh large sea scallops.. Yum!! broil those for something good next to your organic salad... I've been to various markets in Hicksville, Northport Village, and they can be kind of hit or miss and quirky to say the least. So when heading east, its only few minutes south of Montauk Hwy, a block off Main Street in the village. Easy to find.

    Fun thing to do on your weekend! Giving three stars because I don't like that they don't require…read morevendors to display their certifications for organic produce, or the names of their farms etc. there's not way to tell if a vendor is being honest about what they are selling being organic which is very strange to me, especially since on their website under vendor rules they are supposed to enforce that they all have signs stating such. They also had barley any fruit which I was bummed about. I'm from CT and prefer the farmers markets here TBH.

    Photos
    Westhampton Beach Indoor Winter Market - Unfortunately not a single stand even remotely approaches this bounty

    Unfortunately not a single stand even remotely approaches this bounty

    Westhampton Beach Indoor Winter Market - Summer Dahlias at the Westhampton Beach Farmers Market.  Exclusively from Pierpont Blossom Farm

    Summer Dahlias at the Westhampton Beach Farmers Market. Exclusively from Pierpont Blossom Farm

    Westhampton Beach Indoor Winter Market - Classic jam 1 performing at Westhampton beach Farmer's market on June 1, 2019.

    See all

    Classic jam 1 performing at Westhampton beach Farmer's market on June 1, 2019.

    Cowfish - Crispy Brussels sprouts

    Cowfish

    4.1(1.1k reviews)
    4.7 mi
    $$$

    Look, I'm just going to get to the point. This place over looks the harbor, is festive and what…read moresome might call loud, and has excellent food. The menu isn't huge which always is a good sign. Make reservations if you can, it was packed at 9pm. The whole staff was incredibly friendly and helpful. I like to have a good time with staff if they're up to it. These folks all had a fun time with us. A must do if you're in the Hamptons.

    Came here for a business meeting ... It was not my choice. I was worried it would be a little too…read more'corporste' when I saw they do lots of private events, etc. but it actually turned out great. The menu isn't the best ... I did struggle finding something that excited me. It was your typical upscale but unimaginative menu. However, I am pleased to say that the food was delicious and the portions were very good. The wait staff was outstanding. Very often, during a business meeting at other restaurants, I have had waitors interrupt the train of thought ... or mid-sebtence swoop in and ask if everything is alright or if more drinks are needed. Here, our waitress did a great job of appearing during very good times and not being overbearing, yet at the same time being helpful and attentive. The atmosphere is okay. Inside is kind of typical of an upscale corporate event-style venue. The upper outside deck is fantastic with views of the water and comfortable seating. I would come back if I was in the area. Though there are better food options elsewhere in the Hamptons, for a sit down restaurant that you can do business in, it hits all the right notes. Prices are high, as expected, in the Hamptons.

    Photos
    Cowfish
    Cowfish - Mezza (? I think) plate app!!

    Mezza (? I think) plate app!!

    Cowfish

    See all

    Mattituck Shellfish - seafoodmarkets - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...