I love Mary's Pizza! We had it all the time when we were little and it tastes just the same. I can only complain about prices but that's every restaurant nowadays. At least with Mary's I know what I'm paying for and know I like it! They have gluten free pizza crust and a gluten free pasta option too. I'm all about the pepperoni pizza with those little pepperonis that curl up and get super crispy.. I love them so much. I always ask for fresh basil too. I might like Mary's Salad even more than the pizza... lettuce, shredded cheese, shredded carrots, kidney beans, green beans, garbanzo beans, hard boiled egg, salami, and beets. Soooo good. We like to get blue cheese AND italian dressing (my dad swears he invented this dressing combo haha). If you order delivery or pick up, make sure to ask for extra dressing, otherwise you'll just get one tiny little container. We usually order takeout, so I'm not totally familiar with the service or in-person dining experience, but the place still looks and smells the same, and the staff I've talked to have always been kind and accommodating. read more

If you're looking for great food and service at a decent price, don't pass this place up. Food is delicious and fresh. Service was attentive - adequately checking in and making sure our glasses were full. As an added plus, this place is clean and tidy with thought put into the decor. You actually feel good eating here. Super easy to get to and convenient parking. read more

We got a pizza the other night, Ashton made it & was amazingly awesome!! It was late & we mistakenly ordered from the other location, he did not hesitate to make us our pizza....his kindness & customer service vibe was stellar!! read more

I'm basing this review on their meatballs and lunch offerings, as I have not had much of Mary's pizza at this location. Environment: to eat outside here is a fabulous, warm place. The wait staff are very warm and down to earth. The spaghetti and meatballs lunch with salad is truly awesome if you are craving that old school spaghetti feeling. They also have specials and cool desserts. Will eat here anytime. I love Mary's Pizza Shack. read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Spaghetti and meatballs for lunch on a Wednesday. - Pizza Near Me - Sonoma, California

See all

Stopped in and ordered a large Mary's combo to go. It was ready in 20 minutes and was delicious! Also love their salads and appetizers. Hostess was friendly and competent. read more

Sorry just three stars for a delivery pie that just wasn't tasty. Pie arrived without requested plates, forks, salt, cheese, peppers. Crust was a bit soggy although toppings were generous although not evenly spread. Just an average pie, could have been better. read more

Terrible take out dinner tonight. Our salad was very soggy, perhaps with excess water. My Wife would not eat it. After I was surprised that they no longer have rigatoni, I ordered spaghetti with meat ball. It was just OK, but we did not care to eat all the dish. I'm sad to say that we will not ever go back..... read more

The very best pizza I've had in a very, very long time! My husband was just as thrilled as I was, and our son loves pizza, but he was extremely satisfied with our pizza from Mary's pizza shack. Our waitress was very sweet and let us in on the history of Mary's Pizza shack, Giving us information about the pictures on the walls and who's doing what where! There's many Mary's pizza shacks to go to, but we had the privilege of visiting the original. If you happen to be in the area or in the mood for an exceptionally good pizza take the drive to Mary's Pizza shack in Sonoma. You will not be disappointed! Or one of their many locations. This chain is family owned, and operated! read more

First off, Marys Pizza Shack is SO MUCH MORE THAN PIZZA! We sat outside for lunch on the shaded patio and spent some time going over the extensive menu. We came hungry and everything sounded good so it was a tough decision. Our server was excellent and patient with us. We decided to split the Ancient Greens Salad and the Chicken Parmesan entree. The salad would have been hearty enough for the two of us, it was full of delicious ingredients and a blend of fresh lettuces all in a light citrus vinegarette. But...once the entree came to the table it was like we had grown a second stomach. We devoured the pasta that was cooked al dente and had a light white sauce and the breaded and lightly fried chicken breast that was covered in a fresh tomato sauce. The quality was fabulous and what a value for the price. read more

See all

This is a local favorite, baby showers, birthdays, meetings, holiday parties. My meal was delicious and relaxing mellow under the shade tree. They were slammed, but my sandwich was worth the wait. REALLY WORTH IT! read more

See all

The cheeseburger I ordered had zero flavor. The service was atrocious! The young lady gnawed and chewed in her gun the whole time. It took more than 5 minutes for us to greet us and there were only 3 tables (including us). She finally took our order and only came back to deliver the food and give us the bill. No check in to see how everything, or we were doing. We had to go up to her to get extra napkins, as she was too busy on her cell phone. The soup and salad comes with bread and butter but we also had to request that. 5the minestrone soup my aunt got was superb as was the Marys house salad. Cant beat the salad there. The place was clean as it should be because as stated before, only 3 tables were being used. Train your staff on customer service. read more

OK, not great, just OK. Medium pizza, 3 drinks, and breadsticks $63. Their food is always great, but the service fell a bit short. Server was MIA, so the hostess wiped down the table as we were being seated. After waiting 5-7 min, still no server, so the hostess came back over and took our drink orders. 5 stars to the hostess for recognizing the situation. read more

I ''heart' Mary's- their pizzas (I remember a spicy salami with arugula), soups (wonderful minestrone) and pastas (i like that they have two different pestos- One creamy and one redolent of garlic)..Their meatballs are terrific, and their wine selection is decent and totally affordable. My parents used to know Mary, and I remember when tripe with Spanish sauce was available off menu! read more

We love all the food here and come with the kids often. Pizzas are delish and salads and pastas are homemade. We have never had an issue with the food or service. It's our go to family dinner spot!! read more

Pizza great!!! Loved the crust. My first time there visiting and it was good. Patio is great, sat under a 100 year old Magnolia tree. I will be back every time in Sonoma. 62 years in business tells ya they are doing something right. Give it a try read more

See all

The food, service and ambience has always been great, at both the restaurant near the Square and in Boyses. Comforting, consistently good food, and reasonable wine. read more

I want to love Mary's, I know it's an institution. Their pizza is good, but pricey for what you get. Service runs hot and cold - definitely between locations, but sometimes at the same site on the same visit. I stopped in recently - because I wanted lunch, and parking was a pain everywhere else, and yes, I realize that's a low bar for choosing a restaurant, but hey - that's how the day goes sometimes. I was greeted by one server who told me to choose a table and they'd be right with me, and then I waited for awhile...until a different server showed up. Other than dropping my food (and needing to be reminded that part of it was missing), nobody checked to see if I wanted another beverage, or otherwise stopped by the table, until it was time to drop the check. Lunch - which was a small, oily caesar salad, a soft drink, and a modestly-sized, decently prepared eggplant parm that was unaccompanied by any pasta (noted as such on the menu), but included bread which I had to remind the server to bring half way through the meal (and which he said, while included, I needed to 'ask him for' - I beg your pardon? It's on the menu as included with the meal. What are these hoops, and why are you asking me to jump through them?). Lunch was $25 + tax and tip. I will say that the outside deck seating, while a bit chilly this time, is charming with its paper lanterns. On balance, given the price vs value of the food & the lack of consistency in service, Mary's is going to continue to not be my top choice for a meal (or continue to be the place I meet someone else for lunch when they insist on that as a choice). read more

So we got there and I had a hankering for Spaghetti and meatballs. No bread was served. My partners salad came a house salad and I got Cesar salad. The iceberg lettuces looked wilted. The spaghetti was too much with store bought sauce. Not authentic fresh tasting. Sorry I grew up in NYC and have ALOT of first generation Italians as friends. That sauce didn't taste like it took 6 hours to make in the back. The meat lacked seasonings. Mary's legacy is lost. This is the second time I give Mary's a chance and this place gets a C --sorry! Last time I come. The food tastes like it's from a can for a school lunch room. Even the Arnold Palmer was weak!! I gave it 3 stars because at least the waitress was attentive. read more

Everything needs to be improved. Just paid $60 for a pizza and salad. Pizza toppings wrong, not edible. Wedge salad was a joke Salad dressing tastes like water and garlic, obviously runny Every order is wrong, even when dining in. read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Bad pizza. Does it look like half cheese???? - Pizza Near Me - Sonoma, California

I am yet to see someone working here frowning, everyone always seems to be in a good mood, really helps adding the feeling that I'm welcome here and not an inconvenience. I myself wish I was this happy while I work. I like pizza a lot and being someone who likes to travel a lot I can say the this place has some of the best there is only probably is that I belly keeps begging for more even after I eat. anything on the menu makes me want more. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHahahahah it's that good trust me. Aside from the friendly staff I love eating inside it's always cozy especially when get the big table in the corner all to myself. Speaking about tables what's up with that little one? This town has a heart and it's definitely located in Mary's pizza shack the food here is loved and it shows read more

We've only picked up from here and the food has been good every time. We've never actually been inside, so we don't know what the ambiance is like or the service inside. But, it's always been prompt and friendly when they bring it out to us in the car. read more

I've been in The Valley since 1981 and pretty sure well over 200 pizzas have come from one of the two Mary's in Sonoma. Over the last month or two I've ordered a Toto's and Mary's specials. Each time I was deeply disappointed and Missing Mary being there to maintain her reputation. I just ordered a Toto's again and I'm very sorry to say there is no longer a decent non-yuppy pie here. No flavor, not enough if any sauce and I kept having the impression I had water in my mouth with every bite. I'm now forced to drive to Vallejo for Napoli's on Tennessee. Sorry Mary, you're deeply missed! read more

Ewwwwww! Ordered pizza here since our usual place was closed on Labor Day. Pizza was sorta edible but the worst was when we looked at the salad! Looked like the egg had mold on it! Never again read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Pizza Near Me - Sonoma, California

See all

Great service, meh pizza. If the pizza matched the smiles, it'd be a five-star shack. But hey, at least the breadsticks are on point!

Great food little bit pricey but no complaints. Food was delicious. I would recommend this establishment of course I really like their pizza a lot. read more

I wrote this pizza place off for most of the 2 years I've lived nearby, judging from the lackluster reviews. But I gave it a try last week, and I was delightfully surprised at how shockingly good the pizza was. I would venture to say that it's the best pizza in town and probably stands above any of the pizza places I have frequented in S.F. north Beach. The dough they use is thin yet chewy and crunchy on the edges , and the tomato sauce and ingredients are fresh. It was so addictively good that I must have inhaled 4 large pieces in a 10 minute eating frenzy. read more

Killer Pizza, pasta ....basically everything they make. They know how to make killer food. Friendly servers are the norm! Good beverage choices! Only thing keeping me from going more often....$70 bill (tip included) for one medium pizza, a soup and small salad combo & 2 Ice Teas. Es todo....no mas!! I know prices are going up for everything....but $70 without even some brewskies!!! WOW!!! read more

I enjoy eating at Mary's Hwy 12. It has been a while since I haven't been inside. Our waiter was really nice and friendly and very attentive. You can't go wrong coming to eat here everything is delicious. read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Pizza Near Me - Sonoma, California

See all

Mary's house salad delious with pesto cheese twists! Service is always great! I enjoy Mary's pizza on the square the most ! Wonderful people coming in and going out and walking by! I enjoy most of all the patio with fireplace ! read more

I will always love Mary's pizza shack. I remember when I was a kid going to the original one there on 12. Mary Fazio always took care of us wayward kids. She had the biggest heart anyone could ever have. Her food was always cooked with love and she made sure those of us that didn't have any money didn't go hungry. Such a loving family God bless them. The food is amazing by the way. read more

The restaurant is easy to find, and lots of parking in the private lot. Beautiful patio seating under a big magnolia tree. Pizza, pasta, breadsticks, everything you want in a pizza joint! Our waitress was slow and cranky. She made some crack to us about "gobbling our pizza" (a medium for two people) which was weird. The pizza is just okay, but very expensive. Medium pizza, breadsticks, one ice tea and one water was almost $50.00. And it was not good pizza. A small smattering of pepperonis on our pepperoni pizza. The ambiance is diner/cafeteria. We won't return to this restaurant. read more

Mary's Pizza Shack - Pizza Near Me - Sonoma, California

See all

I was really disappointed that on Valentine's Day. I picked up a large pizza to bring to a lady friends house with her daughter and half was supposed to be sausage which turned out to be no sausage larger than my pinky fingernail. I was so disappointed as was my lady friend, and especially her daughter who cried because she's the one who wanted sausage. read more

Ordered a slice of pizza with anchovies There were to many anchovies on the pizza you could not even see the sauce and they were extremely salty The pizza was not edible Highly disappointing read more

Finally I dropped in for a bite to eat on a weekend evening. I have driven by tons of times and always wanted to eat here. I am a regular at the Dixon location and enjoy a Mary's pizza and Mary's salad. First of all, don't drive like a speed demon into the parking lot. Watch out for folks walking off the porch. It is a straight shot from the porch steps into the parking lot. Anyway, the place was packed. It is smaller and less spacious than the Dixon location. The tables are much closer together. Since the place was packed; it was loud. LOUD. Like I can't hear the person sitting next to me loud. Oh the Mary's salad...that darn salad is fabulous. As I was eating it, momentarily all the noises were drowned out. I was in the zone with my salad. Order it with the Sonoma dressing...yum. But for those vegetarians out there, be forewarned that the salad comes with a slice of salami served on top. Yes, meat will touch your salad. Just letting you know. Plus you get complimentary bread with butter pats. It is served warm, oven baked. So it has a crisp crunch to it. Our waitress was super nice. But she was a bit forgetful. She forgot to give us plates, napkins, and our bread. We had to remind her each time. Also we got someone else's bill. We pointed it out and she fixed it pretty quickly. But again she was super friendly. She knew all the regulars and chatted them up as well as is. I have a feeling, or it is me wishfully thinking she was not usually this forgetful. Well at least she was attentive to our drink refills. read more

See all

Get frozen, will save you money and ,great better pizza. Now I know why I haven't ordered from this crappy place in years. Still crappy pizza You order thin crust and crispy and end up with doughy rubbery, lack of taste pizza. Waste of money. read more

Mary's on Highway 12 - Went to pick up pizza, and was totally ignored. Cashier/manager spent time talking to customer who was standing there drinking wine while she placed order. Was not even greeted. I finally pulled up a chair while they continued talking. I then asked the pizza maker if my pizza was ready and he said yes. That's when I was finally acknowledged. My time is more important and I'm never going back. Pizza is way too expensive and the crust on mine was burnt as well as it was thin. read more

The most expensive mediocre pizza I've ever had. These prices are outrageous and I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone.

We have had many issues with this location over the years, that cringe feeling usually hits when my wife says " let's get Mary's" This time was incredible, Max answered the phone fir our order, listened with intent and asked questions about how we like it. When I picked it up, I went through the order, to verify we get what we pay for. Surprisingly everything was perfect. Max definitely needs praise for finally fulfilling what we were used to 30 years ago. Yup, we've been surviving on Mary's since high school read more

Great pizza and their choice of salads are amazing. Love their garlic bread, portions are huge.

Lackluster pizza Their " thin " pizza was a chewy thick mess. Topping seemed decent quality and the staff was friendly, but i would skip this location if you are looking for a good pizza read more