We weren't really wanting Italian, but there's not many 4* options in the Nationwide area to choose from. Martini turned into the best "forced hand" reservation we ever made and we will be going back! From the very attentive waitress, to our dessert & coffee, every single thing was superb. We settled on the filet special covered in melty cheese with just a few noodles & broccoli to make the perfect amount, but we did split their house salad, and I thought my husband may lick the plate clean of the dressing haha We had the calamari & a side of mushrooms with our steak, they were also amazing. We finally shared a delicious cremebrûlée for dessert. It is much larger than any other restaurant serves, so we could barely finish it! The only downside of our night is a matter of taste; my husband's specialty Old Fashioned turned out to be a lot sweeter than he is used to, but I quite enjoyed it! read more

We've been eating here since it opened in the 90s and it's one of the few restaurants that has kept up with food trends. I had the Sicilian sour which is a fun take on a whiskey sour. I wish they had kept the old focaccia recipe. It was so much better. The shrimp arrabiata is big enough for 2 and penne à la vodka is also generous! We had the branzino and it was delicious. The crispy potatoes and fennel balance it perfectly. Get the pistachio dessert for a gluten free piece of heaven. Service was good but the restaurant is too loud in the main room. read more

See all

Best Italian restaurant so far in this area. Everything was delicious tonight and service was amazing. Pasta galore and more. Perfect place for an Italian modern setting read more

See all

This place is must when in town for work. Our waiter, Dan, was absolutely fantastic. He made great suggestions, was attentive, and matched our enthusiastic energy really well. We had drinks and a wide variety of dishes including appetizers.The pasta was fabulous as always, my one coworker had some of the best carpaccio I've tasted in my life, one had the lamb which I tasted and it was well seasoned and tender. The mix of fun folks, great service, and excellent food made for a really fun evening. read more

Dinner with my old boss. It's been years since I've eaten at Martini's, not because of any bad experience, but because the food at Marcella's is so much better and affordable. We decided on Martini to shake it up a bit. First off, this is a beautiful restaurant with a great vibe. Add the excellent attention and service, and you have the foundations to a great dining experience. We skipped the appetizers and went for a salad and entree. I got the Lamb pappardelle and a Caesar salad. Both were delicious. While both were good, we kept comparing the dining experience to Marcella's. We always leave there feeling like we have a much better happy hour experience with a great value. We both looked at each other and said, next time we are going back to Marcella's. Having said that, we both really enjoyed the dining experience at Martini's. read more

Martini Modern Italian - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Tenderloin was just ok...a little too rich for me. Love that you can do half portions for the salad..which was perfect portion size. Martini salad was delicious Butternut squash as an appetizer was fantastic. Desserts stole the show. Their creme brûlée with blood orange sorbet took the prize. We ordered Al the dessert for the table to share so got to try them all. They were all very good but if I had to pick one this is the one I would put at the top of the list. Service was fantastic. Great decor. One weird thing...hair spray and dry shampoo in the men's room...not sure why. Would definitely come back when back in Columbus. read more

Excellent and very tasty! Our waiter was the best and helped us make great choices! The restaurant was very neat and clean! read more

Dinner with my son on Friday night. Seated promptly with a reservation. Lots of activity at the bar -- good vibe. I found the back room to be a bit stuffed-shirt and lacking personality. Server was excellent and well trained ... friendly and professional. Focaccia bread with truffle was underwhelming. Tuna tartare was superb. My son had the lamb paperdelle which looked great, was a nice sized portion, and he said it was very good. I had the chicken parmigiana, which was an overly refined presentation, but tasty. I prefer a traditional parmigiana in a deep dish loaded with sauce and cheese. Affogato for desert was a great presentation and yummy! This is a good restaurant with a varied menu and is, true to its PR, "modern Italian." If you want an Italian meal go elsewhere. If you want steak, with some Italian offerings, this restaurant is a good choice with good service and solid food offerings. read more

See all

REVIEW BY: Avila.Eats on TikTok, Instagram, YouTube Service: waitress was friendly and talkative. Assisting staff was a fellow Hispanic gentleman that was so friendly and talkative. Service after those two was awful. Incredible rude bald gentleman. Asked simple for a second fork and when he looked back he said "I said I'll get it" even though that was the first and only time asking. For that reason I must deduct a star. Ambiance/Atmosphere: inside is a modern (as the name suggests) dining room that is cramped but still spacious in a way. Open kitchen concept adds a nice element to the dining experience and The bar although small is nice with high tables accompaniments. Food: 1. Bread service is soft and fluffy. Slightly sweet. The pesto olive oil mix is really good. 7.25 2. Potatoes side pillowy soft. Good backend flavor and the sauce is glossy and slightly sweet. Potatoes themselves could use more seasoning. 6 3. Alla vodka sweet sauce. Very watery. Would like it more thick. Flavor is decent but I'm not a fan of the sole flavor being sweet. No spice no real pop. 5.75 4. Chicken carbonara is creamy, well flavored. Pasta holds onto the sauce really well and the bacon adds a meaty slightly chewy texture and flavor. 7 5. Lamb parpadelle slight chew to the noodles, the meat is tender and flavorful. Lamb flavor is strong but not over powering. Sauce is sweet and slightly tangy and glossy with a buttery mouth feel. Sauce is really well flavored. 7.5 6. Chicken Parmesan isn't crispy but decent seasoning. Pasta on top has a buttery mouth feel sauce but not all that much flavor as well. Good initial flavor but weak back end. 6 7. Chicken picatta has incredible tender and juicy chicken. The sauce is subtle flavor but a nice punch of lemon. Buttery and runy. Artichokes add a nice crunch and pop of flavor. Chicken skin has a nice seasoning. 7 8. Tenderloin is tuff and chewy but a little better towards the middle. No flavor on the meat itself. The cream sauce on top has a strange flavor but not unpleasant just different. Creamy and thick. The wine sauce is sweet and well done. The pasta paired with the sauce is good. Broccolini is well done. Crunchy but not hard and has a nice flavor pairing with the sweet sauce. Dish relies heavily on the sauce. 5 9. Tiramisu is creamy and sweet. Nice chocolate flavor and great coffee flavor that is noticed throughout the bite. Mostly cream but the lady fingers are noticeable before quickly dissolving. Good flavor. 7.75 10. Chocolate torte silky smooth. Defent chocolate flavor. Ganache is airy and light with a nice flavor. Chocolate isn't as rich and indulgent as I'd like but it's solid. 6.75 11. Pistachio cake is warm with a beautiful pistachio flavor and it soft and buttery. The outter crust is stiff but the inside is so fluffy and soft. The pistachio gelato has a good flavor and paired together gives delicious and delicate pistachio flavor. The cherries add a sweetness and pop of a tart and citrus tang. Really well done pistachio dessert. Cold and warm pairing is excellent. 9 read more

Came here on a Friday night and the place was packed! Although it was packed the service was great and actually pretty fast! We got the beet salad to start and we both got the Lamb Pappardelle Pasta since it was raved about! Personally it wasn't jaw dropping that I would get it again and the noodles themselves lacked salt. I would definitely be open to trying something else next time. Overall cute spot for a date night! read more

Martini Modern Italian - Lamb Pappardelle - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Great food, service and atmosphere. The pricing isn't for faint of heart but the quality and presentation make up for it. read more

Martini Modern Italian - Tiramisu - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Martini is one of the top Italian restaurants downtown, and is in a fantastic location between the Short North and Arena District. All of their ingredients are fresh, you can tell the pasta is made from scratch daily, and every dish is delicious! The service is top notch and this is an excellent option for a date night or dinner with friends & family. If you're in Columbus and craving a nice Italian meal, this is always a great choice! read more

See all

Overall, good experience. Busy restaurant on weekends, loud din. Food is good not great. Price to quality of food value is average to slightly above . I love the bar. Best bar downtown. Restaurant is cramped with a lot of seating for the size of restaurant. Overall, good to above average restaurant. read more

I was standing outside this restaurant looking at the menu and some lady walked out and she told me that I have to try the butternut squash with grilled chicken and that it was the best pasta she had ever had her entire life. So I had to come in and try it today and it was incredible!!! read more

Martini Modern Italian - Butternut squash with grilled chicken - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This place was one of the best circumstantial hangs. Comfortable. Great location. Staff was exceptional. Decor was engaging. I spent a pretty penny and wasn't disappointed (wait for it....). My appetizer was an arancini bowl. Shockingly ample, and more tasty than I could have hoped for. Well done! The lamb pasta was decadent. Pure deliciousness. I would also like to send kudos to Kevin, the bartender. He's amazing. I asked for a wine pairing, but the pairing was a flop. Either your wine catalogue needs better attention, or you should train the staff. The key thing that stopped me from 5 stars was my take-home order. I am a huge fan of creamy pasta. I ordered the carbonara to go. ***before you start*** This carbonara was not a traditional noodle. It didn't feature the noodles, the egg, or otherwise. It featured asparagus and other elements. Texture was off, but not in a good way. I would definitely recommend a re-evaluation of that carbonara. I look forward to coming back with a more sophisticated wine menu/recommendation, and a carbonara that will appeal for its price point. read more

See all

The service was great! Nice ambiance. The appetizers are nice as well. Enjoyed the drinks. Pricey but it's valued quality!

We had a phenomenal 5-star experience. It started with walking in, knowing that they had no tables available due to The Arnolds being in town. We got one stool at the bar (the place was packed) and soon added another stool and settled in for drinks and dinner. We decided to walk through the apps menu and each one was fabulous. The burrata was fresh and creamy, meatballs were just the right spice, arancini were perfectly fried, tuna tartare just okay, carpaccio was AMAZING plus a fresh plate of focaccia and olive oil/balsamic. We loved it. You must go now!! read more

This restaurant exceeded all expectations; from the stunning design to the exceptional food, drinks, and customer service. I highly recommend making a reservation, as the bar area is open seating but fills up fast. We sat at the bar until our table was ready, and were lucky to have Brad as our bartender; he was incredibly friendly and helpful with drink recommendations. The food is a must! Every dish was freshly prepared and absolutely delicious. And the tiramisu? Easily the best I've ever had in my life. It's one of those desserts you savor with your eyes closed just to take in every layer of flavor. read more

See all

Food was tasty. Service was very good and friendly. Ambiance was amazing. Very good vibe. Will definitely recommend it to my friends. read more

See all

Ate here this evening for my birthday! I got an appetizer calamari and shrimp! It was delicious. I highly recommend it. I really wanted to try the lasagna but I was stiffed so I did not. Our waitress/ bartender was great. I def recommend coming out to this place. Great service and fun times and great food! read more

See all

Love the atmosphere and had to return again this year when I was back in Columbus. Brian was a great server. Our dinners were delicious. And when I accidentally left a notebook behind, they called us that evening to let us know they found it (before I even knew I lost it) ... and then they went over the top and quickly mailed it to me!! Thank You!!! That's TOP-NOTCH! read more

This has to be one of my favorite restaurants. The ambiance alone is great for a date night. Hailey was an amazing server and helped direct us to the perfect wine. We ordered the Shrimp pasta and the Mushroom pasta and both were absolutely amazing. The chocolate torte is also worth saving room for! read more

Martini Modern Italian - Bar area and seating/ambiance - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

TJ was amazing! His recs were soooo good and the service was great, thank you martini!!! - yogis girls read more

Wildly overpriced, not nearly worth the costs. Food was just ok, and service fitful. Dinner for 2 with 1 glass of wine was nearly $200. Avoid! read more

One of the best meals I've had in Columbus. Had a reservation, which I would recommend because it's fairly business. Definitely a more elevated and elegant atmosphere. I ordered an espresso martini which was delicious. For food, we started off with the garlic bread, and it was amazing. I ordered a salad and a side of Cacio E Pepe for my meal. The side portion of Cacio E Pepe was a very good deal and portion size for $8. Others at the table ordered chicken Parmesan and were very impressed with that as well. For dessert, we split the Crème Brulle and it was delightful. Our server was amazing and checked on us frequently. We overall had a wonderful experience at Martini, and it's definitely expensive and more of a treat place, but I hope to return for a special occasion! read more

Great atmosphere and amazing service. The lasagna was very good, but lacked a bit of flavor in my opinion. Oh, and I was a little surprised you had to pay for bread service. Still overall an amazing place and definitely recommend. read more

Martini Modern Italian - Lasagna - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This continues to be one of our go to favorites. We had the garlic bread with fondue for the first time and it was excellent. Then we both got our favorites. My wife got the beet salad that she loves and I got the Veal Chop. Thankfully they brought back a version of the veal chop that I love which used to come with an agrodolce sauce and Cipollini onions and now it has a similar sauce with peppers which was very good but I still prefer the original. We got a side of the pasta Cacio a Pepe , which normally I like, but I did not like their version. I would not get that again. The vibe is always good there and our service is usually very good too even though it was only fine this time. read more

See all

I've been here a few times over the years. Always great food... Started with the Caeser salad. Really nice salad with LOTS of Parm! I really love parmesan cheese, but my table mates were not as enthused as I. One thing I would have loved was the option to add some anchovies, but there was no offer. That said, I did taste a little in the dressing, but not as much as I would have liked. All in all, a great salad though. Fresh greens and not overdressed. I did order a martini. It's in their name, so I would guess they know how to make one, right? WRONG! I specifically asked for it to be stirred (all of you know how I like my martinis). They poured the gin into a shaker with some ice, (where it sat at the bar for forever) at which point the waitress (who needed an attituded adjustment herself) brings it to the table and starts shaking the hell out of it. I couldn't believe it! I asked her to stop, and she just kept going. She said, it won't be cold if it's not shaken... I guess the bottom line is, order it however you want, but you'll get it the way they want to serve it. The entree was absolutely AMAZING! Butternut squash tortellini. Jeez, what an incredible dish! So, the pasta and filling are outstanding. The sauce it's served with is exceptional. It's not an alfredo (which I was afraid of), but a cream reduction that was just great. The squash filling wasn't too sweet or too strong with nutmeg. I could eat this at least once a week and never get tired of it! So, after the martini, there was another foible. Our waitress didn't offer bread until after the entrees were brought to the table. Of course, the patrons pay for the bread course, but pasta without bread is sacrilege. We gladly accepted and ordered the focaccia with black truffle and cheese. I thought it was perfect, but my dining companions thought there was too much parm. As though there's such a thing as too much parm???? The dining room is very clean and pretty. The meals are brought from the kitchen in covered pots and served table side. Nice touch. I'll definitely go back the next time I'm in town, but I'll have my martini in my hotel room and order a glass of iced tea at the restaurant. And I hope the waitress found some resolution regarding whatever was bothering her... read more

Everything about this restaurant is amazing !!! The food, the atmosphere, the staff, etc.... I highly recommend this restaurant for a wonderful and memorable dinner. My favorite items are the Arancini appetizer and the Chicken Parmesan !!!! read more

Valet: Yes $15.00 plus tip (Yikes!) Dress code: jeans and shorts acceptable Decor: elegant Bar: full bar and wine list First impressions elegant, low lighting, music in the background. Tables CRAMMED in together at angles. The corner of our table to the corner of our neighbor's table is 14 inches on one side and 16 inches on the other...close, too close. For a couple or single diner, get a table lining the wall for privacy or sit at the bar. I now know waaaay too much about the lives of the surrounding diners). The house margarita is a fine margarita - really good. Not too sweet. The habanero in the salt on the rim is non-existent - sounds nice though. The wine list is lacking. Bread service is perfect. The warm sliced bread is served with a small dish of house made pesto and a dish of olive oil with a touch of balsamic vinegar. The zuppa pomodoro (tomato soup) is thick and full of flavor. The slice of toasted bread is perfect to dip in it or break it up and eat with a spoon. Perfect for chilly days. The short rib is good. It is reminiscent of my grandma's pot roast more than short ribs. I loved my grandma's pot roast. So, if one wants a good pot roast with carrots, this is the dish. Not epic. The pasta was overcooked - mushy. Not fresh. The veal was lacking flavor. The chocolate bread is just ok and yet we were told it is the most popular dessert - let that set one's expectation. The lemon meringue pie has a very nice meringue, a creamy tart center, a little too sweet, and large blackberries tucked inside. The blackberries are absolutely a distraction from the delicacy of the dessert - try blueberries. Our waiter, Brian was excellent. read more

See all

Main dishes very good. Their house salad phenomenal. Antipasto aroncini very good. Atmosphere very good. But here is the rub. TJ was our waiter. We ordered sides with our main dishes. And they never came! We were done with our main dishes And our waiter TJ asked us if we still wanted them,,,, what?? no. My bill was $900. Very unfortunate. You come to expect more from a nice restaurant. This one didn't deliver tonight. Unfortunate. No one goes out saying I'm going to spend $900 and have a bad experience! For $900 we want everything to go well. Not much more to say. Unfortunate. read more

Love this spot in Downtown Columbus on High Street! Atmosphere is very nice, somewhat casual yet classy. They offer a nice menu and wine selection. Tonight dinner was delicious however one of our meals arrived to the table cold. I assume it was ready and waiting before the other dish was ready. We gently let the server know the pasta dish was cold and he offered to make things right with a replacement. We opted to keep the dish. Shortly after the manager stopped by and offered his apologies and comped the cold dish. Handed well. Great customer service. As we were walking out the door the manager came out with a To Go bag with a fresh made dinner to take home! Have you ever heard of such great customer service!! Thank You. read more

See all

As someone who truly appreciates elevated cuisine, I have to say--this meal was exceptional from start to finish. Ordered the "LAMB PAPPARDELLE (GF) Braised Lamb, Wild Mushrooms, Chianti Wine Reduction, Parmigiano Reggiano". From menu I opted to customize my order, substituting the lamb with a perfectly cooked filet, medium, sliced beautifully over the dish. The steak was absolutely melt-in-your-mouth tender--flavorful, juicy, and seasoned to perfection. I only wish I had asked for a light drizzle of truffle oil to finish it off, but honestly, it was outstanding as is. The pasta? Spot-on al dente. Every bite had that ideal balance of texture and taste that only a kitchen with serious skill can deliver. From a service standpoint, the staff was warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming--striking that perfect balance between professional and personable. The atmosphere is sophisticated without being stuffy. You feel like you're dining somewhere special, but you don't need a suit and tie to belong. This place clearly knows how to cater to those who understand and love fine food. I'll absolutely be back--and next time, I'm getting that truffle oil. read more

Martini Modern Italian - LAMB PAPPARDELLE (GF) But instead of the lamb I opted for Filet (medium) - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We had a large group of 14 ladies. We had a reservation, but the numbers kept changing so we had to wait until the large table was available after 30 minutes. We decided to split our group because of the mixup, they gave us the serving of bread. It was wonderful look at the pictures. I decided to order the heritage beet salad with the homemade butternut squash tortellini covered with a beautiful white sauce. One of my Sweet Adeline's singing partners ordered the same thing and she and I agreed this would be the only time we should lick the plate, but in the nick of time we remembered our manners. If you're downtown watching a hockey game, shopping or listening to a Sweet Adelines International competition stop by this place and rest your feet. They also have a really nice bar. I'm taking a break from drinking but another one of my Sweet Adeline's singing buddies ordered my favorite a chocolate martini and the bartender did a great job with her drink. Ciao. read more

See all

I took my friend here for her birthday dinner. Fortunately, the restaurant is also conveniently located close to the hockey arena. We had tickets for the game that night and I was able to snag a last minute reservation for an early dinner at 4:30. Although it was early, the restaurant was already starting to be busy. We were seated immediately. The place had a romantic and a smart casual vibe. They had people who were dressier than others and people in their hockey jerseys and jeans as well. We skipped the appetizers and went straight for the main course after ordering a couple of drinks. I had a glass of cabernet and my friend had a cocktail. I had the scallops which were served with Swiss chard, balsamic glazed mushrooms and brown butter. My friend had the salmon. We both enjoyed our meals. They were delicious and well prepared. For dessert, they brought her something special for her birthday and I ordered the tiramisu which came in a form of a cupcake almost. The desserts were wonderful as well. The wait service was nice. No complaints. Our water glasses were refilled quickly and everyone was nice! read more

Martini Modern Italian - Tiramisu - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Caesar salad, Veal, and drinks were all amazing! Sat at the bar and both the bartenders were lovely! Intimate ambiance with plenty of bar seating if you don't have a reservations read more

Another amazing Camron Mitchell restaurant. Came here before a show in downtown and was super impressed. Our sever John was fantastic and offered lots of good recommendations. Our food was delicious and perfectly cooked as always. Recommend adding shrimp to the penne. The interior design of the restaurant was beautiful too. Very upbeat vibe here even for our earlier dinner. My only complaint and I use that word quite loosely was that bread did not come with the meal a this is an Italian restaurant. There is bread you can buy, but $10 seems a little steep. read more

Martini Modern Italian - Beef Carpaccio* - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Chicken piccata and barramundi were the picks for our table and everything was awesome! It was packed but service was still top notch!

This is a special occasion meal. Amy was our server and she delivered on a professional and yet very fun experience. Love the atmosphere and they was the place is packed but still feels like it's not crowded. We had 3 Things Osso Bucco which was just perfect and just like I remember it from NYC. We had Chicken Parm and this was the reason we come back. It is amazing and my wife's favorite. Then a dessert The Chocolate Bread pudding. All was perfect. read more

See all

I love Cameron Mitchell restaurants. I am so disappointed to write this review and to of had the dinner I did at Martini. I was under the impression you could ask for substitutions or add on to entrees. I had in mind the mushroom pasta w the steak from the tenderloin entree (blue cheese/brie cheese yum!) the server was confused by my order but repeated it back exactly and said he could do it. Unfortunately it came out as two separate entrees then it just went off the rails from there. The girl bringing the food out was sweet as could be, but just took the filet in the back in the kitchen put it on separate plate and brought it back out to me. I could have just done that but I had just wanted it together like we talked about. Go to martinis just order off the menu no adding protein or toppings and you should be fine. Sad lesson learned! read more