Cancel

Open app

Search

Marsella's Pizza

4.3 (44 reviews)
Open • 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Updated 3 weeks ago

Marsella's Pizza Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Marsella's Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Eggplant sub

The pizza is so good but the pizzas are so expensive and I don't understand why. The small is literally a pan pizza . Also please don't order the eggplant sub it was so bad . I don't know what I was thinking ordering that ‍.

Large pepperoni sausage mushroom ALWAYS pretty, always tasty, always BEST PIZZA AROUND...
Jenny T.

Just gotta say they make consistently beautiful pizza that is really the best around... very tasty!

Large sausage and mushroom pizza
Hungry L.

We heard a lot of positive reviews on Facebook and local fb food pages about this pizza joint, so we figured why not make the 40 minute drive and try it. Upon arriving, there were plenty of patrons in the parking lot hanging out, waiting for their order to be done and more waiting inside, ready to pick up also. Parma sure loves this pizza joint! It was b-u-s-y!! We ordered a large sausage and mushroom pizza. It was plenty for 2 of us. The crust was nice, not too thick. The sausage was generous and what we call old school with caraway seeds and it is "pinched" into pieces. The mushrooms were also very generously spread over the pizza. (I believe they were canned mushrooms). The sauce was a hint of sweet with just the right amount spread all over the pizza. It was a great pizza!! We will definitely order from here again, but maybe when it's not snowing. Ha ha

Large pepperoni and mushroom pizza

See all

11 years ago

Love their pizza ... Always consistent ... As in consistently good!! They never skimp on the sauce or cheese !!

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of B M.
0
12
2

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

used to be great , now is crap, chicken bad, pizza bad, everthing expensive, no more ,,,,,

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Lala P.
170
16
0

16 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Marsella's Pizza

Review Highlights - Marsella's Pizza

“Glad they have the new owner who was and is a longtime employee of this pizza joint.”

Mentioned in 4 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 12,966 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Joe De’s Brick Oven Pizza - Margarita pizza

Joe De’s Brick Oven Pizza

4.7(69 reviews)
5.4 mi•Puritas-Longmead

I just relocated to Ohio from Connecticut, so finding a real New Haven pie here was non-negotiable…read more Joe De's is legit. First visit, I got the New Haven pie with sausage -- which they source directly from a local butcher, and you can taste the difference. We also got to talk with one of the owners for a while. Super personable, and the customer service matches. You can tell it's a long-running family business. I wanted to go back once more before writing this, just to be sure the first time wasn't a fluke. It wasn't. Second visit was the margherita as-is plus a New Haven pie with beef pepperoni. Both exceptional. The sauce is what really sets it off. Growing up in the South, I had no idea what good pizza was until I moved to CT. Leaving that behind was the thing I expected to miss most about Connecticut. Glad I don't have to -- they've got a regular now.

We have been wanting to try this place out for awhile after hearing so many good reviews and they…read morewere right, this place has some pretty good pizza. We ordered online and picked up in the store. Our order was ready on time and the staff was very nice. The pizza was light and full of flavor. I was pleasantly surprised and would definitely order from here again. It is more expensive than your average pizza, but worth it if you like brick oven pizza and they also have other items like salads, appetizers, and sandwiches.

Photos
Joe De’s Brick Oven Pizza - Beautiful and cozy

Beautiful and cozy

Joe De’s Brick Oven Pizza - X-Large New Haven Pizza (12 Slices)

X-Large New Haven Pizza (12 Slices)

Joe De’s Brick Oven Pizza - Great artwork and such a clean place

See all

Great artwork and such a clean place

A Slice Above

A Slice Above

4.2(171 reviews)
3.7 mi
•$$

We traveled up the highway traveling toward Niagara Falls, had to charge our Rivian and stumbled…read moreacross the place. After we charged we stopped off to grab a pizza to-go. We are so HAPPY we did! Greeted immediately upon entering this unassuming place, looks like it may have been an old Dominos take-out. We had the pleasure of meeting the owner, he was very cool. No place to sit, everything is made fresh to order. We ordered the 'Where's the Beef' medium, which turns out to be a total Meat Lovers Big slices of bacon strips included. Perfect crust texture in my opinion. Absolutely amazing. Burned my mouth because I couldn't wait to taste it and didn't even care that I burned it. This pizza is worth driving out of the way to order and take home. Delicious!!! This place is 15 out of 5 for sure.

I have always driven by this small pizza shop and told myself I would try it one day…read more The Superman logo catches my attention every time. Finally decided to call in and give it a chance. I ordered the buffalo chicken pizza. Holy smokes guys. This is seriously one of the best buffalo chicken pizzas ive ever been blessed with eating. Pizza itself had a crust that was flaky, crunchy, and flavorful like crispy cheese. Had a wonderful buffalo flavor without overpowering the zesty ranch sauce. These guys did it right (leave blue-cheese off buffalo chicken pies!!!!). I will be back and I recommend the visit.

Photos
A Slice Above - Outside view

Outside view

A Slice Above - Medium NY style pizza with Italian sausage

Medium NY style pizza with Italian sausage

A Slice Above - Pepperoni monster.

See all

Pepperoni monster.

Marsella's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...