Good place! Service was a little slow but the staff was very friendly and gave us a little off the bill since service was slow. Very nice touch! As for the food, it was quite good. It was empty at first and ended up packed. Small spot but very intimate. I'm definitely coming back read more

Margarita's Cafe - Pollo Aguacate Pollo Margaritas - Mexican Near Me - Merrick, New York

I've been to the Margarita's in East Meadow many times, this was my first time at the Merrick branch. The food is similar but the Merrick outpost is much smaller than E.M., with funky decor and (IMHO) better food. I didn't have a rez, got the only empty table as a walk-in. Service was friendly but slow as only one person was serving the whole place plus there was a glitch with our order, but the excellent food and drink quality made up for those issues. We were too early for the Tuesday $3.50 margarita happy hour (starts at 4:00), so shared a half pitcher of house margaritas instead - they were tasty and strong. (Please don't judge me for early alcohol intake, had a hellish morning so needed a nice numbing agent:) My Mole Poblano Enchiladas were fantastic, 3 of them loaded with chunks of chicken and covered with a sublime mole sauce. Partner's Burrito Mojado was made with skirt steak, he said it was delicious as well. The dishes came with yummy rice and beans, and each plate was embellished with a lovely purple orchid. read more

See all

My husband and I used to come here before and it was the best of the all the margaritas branches. This was the first time we've come since they updated the menu and apparently changed the owner (as per the staff). The tap water tasted like pipes. The meat quality was significantly reduced, the chicken tasted like it was boiled in chicken juice, the ground beef was like Ortega sloppy Joe. And it seemed they put the same chicken in all the chicken meals and same sloppy Joe meat in all the beef meals. The plate came out hotter than the food. I'm very disappointed at this DRASTIC change in quality. It tasted significantly different than it used to. However the staff was really nice. read more

Place is a little small but it is so intimate. I had such a great time with my girl's. It's a perfect date night spot the music wasn't too loud. Food was delicious. Severs was very courteous. I would definitely go back again. read more

See all

First time at this location and the food is great but we gave $100 in cash and tried to put the rest on a card. The waiter charged the card for the full amount and tried to act like he didn't see the $100 bill. Super slimy move. Very glad we noticed before leaving. read more

Wow, this place shakes you down and nickel and dimes you for everything. $11 extra for sour cream, rice, and a tortilla??? And what is the random $2 fee by the tax?? Their happy hour prices are teaser prices read more

Margarita's Cafe - Receipt - Mexican Near Me - Merrick, New York

After ordering takeout from here about 3 months ago (see my previous review), my wife and I finally had a chance to dine here. MUCH better experience this time! It's a small restaurant so keep that in mind when planning to come around a peak time (6:30pm on a Saturday we had no issue, but by 7pm it was packed). The margaritas tasted fresh and packed the right amount of punch, and the guacamole we ordered was actually made table-side, fresh and delicious. Definitely better than the last batch of guac we had when we ordered takeout... The entree I ordered this time (mole poblano) was very tasty. The sauce had a nice flavor to it, just wish there was a little bit more chicken in the dish... but the rice and refried beans that came with it were also very good (again, beans were a huge improvement compared to what I had the last time). And yes, the plantains still rock! read more

Awesome delicious food! Atmosphere is fun and welcoming. I love the chips and salsa. Fajitas were yummy and service was good. I would go back again read more

Took a gamble on this place and it paid off royally:-). Nice interior vibe ( but I really miss Meson Ole!) and sat in the back which I recommend. A/C was a but too warm for my taste. The guacamole which they made fresh at the table was excellent. Drinks were good but wish they were bigger as other places often are. All the food was really excellent and heartily recommend! I am looking forward to my next meal at this establishment!!!!! read more

Margarita's Cafe - Enchiladas Suiza- beef, chicken & cheese. Excellent!!! - Mexican Near Me - Merrick, New York

See all

We went on a Sunday night. There was no wait and the service was fast. I ordered the empanadas which were crisp to perfection and not greasy at all. Also, the drinks were made strong and served in a decent glass. read more

3 1/2 - 4 stars. This may have been the first gathering where one of us did not pre-plan a place to eat. Feeling lost I once again turn to yelp for guidance... Well Margarita's itself is not a first but this location was! In the mood for guacamole and I was trying to keep things healthy. The guacamole was good- the salsa and chips also! Then I ordered I believe #41 it was chicken with rice and beans. My friend ordered steak fajitas and she loved them! The service was top notch! When I asked for red onions on the side and jalapeños on the side the server had no problem. He then even asked me if I want more peppers and when my friend and I said how much I love spice- he asked if I wanted to try the special red pepper from Mexico!! So I did!! Amazing :) read more

See all

MERRICK location finally back to full service, for margarita's that is, quit the assortment , they will make it anyway you want also. excellent pricing for happy hours 4-7 and all day tuesday, service was very prompt and pleasant, food freshly prepared, main course could have had just a little more meat, but otherwise fine. quality wise i see no difference between this place, freeport and wantagh. tip: don't use a credit card in wantagh location. merrick is smaller then the rest, but if you are a local it's much more convenient, plus tons of parking vs. freeport and wantagh which is limited. good place to come even for just drinks and appetizers. read more

Amazing ambiance on a Saturday night . Best drink from all Margaritas on Long Island . Couldnt ask for better service! 5 stars isn't enough ! read more

Margarita's Cafe - Tequila sour - Mexican Near Me - Merrick, New York

There is no way this location is related to the E. Meadow location. we were the only people in the place and yet it took like 30 minutes for our food to come out. I could literally hear the kitchen people not working for a solid 15 minutes after our order went in. Then finally they decided to get around to cooking. While we waited. My pina colada had big chunks of ice and separated instantly. The waitress did not understand English very well and got my order wrong and all of the food was totally subpar. Yes we were there early in the evening but only one or two other tables came in while we were eating. It was a miserable dinner. The location on Merrick Ave is nice but this place is totally on autopilot. No-one is minding the store. Nobody is running the room. Don't throw your money away here. Go to E. Meadow. read more

Happy Hour?!? Not so much!! Nothing was happy about our experience at this restaurant! We are always in the lookout for a great Happy Hour. Driving to another restaurant we saw a display in front of the Cafe advertising a great happy hour , we chose to stop in. The first off putting thing is the happy hour is available at the bar only. The restaurant is VERY SMALL and seats 3 -4 people at their tiny bar. So only 3-4 people may experience happy hour The second red flag was after ordering our drinks the bartender pulled a jug that looked like an old vinegar bottle from under the counter. She proceeded to smell it. She then had her co-worker smell it and pour our margaritas from the same bottle. GROSS!! The third and final straw... they advertise $5 tacos. They list 3 types available. I chose 2 and pointed to them in their happy hour menu. We asked for sour cream with the tacos and 1 extra tortilla. Each Taco had a $2 extra charge for meat. Yes meat. So they were $7 tacos not $5.I pointed this out to the manager and he did adjust the menu price but then charged us for using a credit card , saying the bartender forgot to. He then also charged 1.95 for the sour cream and $4.95 for the extra 2 tortillas!!! this made the bill EXACTLY THE SAME PRICE as with the adjustment. When questioned the manager said" you should be lucky she gave you the wrong tacos". They should have been $2 more each. So he was not honoring the happy hour bc his staff made an error!!! Btw... the tacos were ok.. not great!! We will never go here ever again!! I will be posting on the local mom sites and warning people! We recommend you avoid this establishment as well!! read more

Went early on a recent Sunday. Music is festive but too loud. Food was decent, and the Margarita good. When a large party started to arrive it was difficult to get service attention and the check. Needed more help, only saw the manager/owner and one waitress...I can't imagine the party got good or quick service. I'll be sticking with South of the Border down the block. read more

Order delivery from here tonight, I got enchiladas chicken mole which tasted good but didn't arrive with beans and rice, was pointless calling as food would be cold, My wife got chicken fajitas which only had 6 small pieces of chicken and for $19 that's a lot of money I know place is known for its small portions but when it's delivered with other charges it was a lot money for what you get. read more

How is the restaurant called margarita's cafe and you're not serving margaritas? That was just a start. Queso looks like it was poured straight from a can. Guacamole is not good and the salsa is watery like it is store bought as well. Lobster was stinky like it's old and my friend's lobster was undercooked. And on top of all of this the owner is rude. read more

Margarita's Cafe - Mexican Near Me - Merrick, New York

See all

Very disappointed with the take out. First, they forgot to pack the salad dressings and I had to drive back to the place to get it. When I opened the salad, the avocado was all black, missing the cabbage and mostly just iceberg lettuce. Then the vegetarian platter, the cheese tostadas were hidden under the lettuce with no cheese and soggy beans. Very small portions. I'm very surprised because last time we went it was great service, bad night? read more

See all

Service was ok, but it took a long time for the food to come out. Our server didn't really speak or understand english so it was difficult to order, to make it easy we just pointed at the menu item we wanted. We asked for extra queso cheese on the side of the chimichangas and inside we received shredded cheese on the side and instead of it being melted on top. Total miscommunication/interpretation. Food was decent but I've have better from their other locations. I ordered the Margarita chicken dish, the chicken pieces were very small barely any meat on the bone. read more

Margarita's Cafe - Mexican Near Me - Merrick, New York

Horrible service and very salty dinners. Margaritas were awful. Waitress did not understand English so our orders were wrong including a simple margarita. When asking for a manager, the server brought a menu. It's like this location is owned by someone else vs the East Meadow location. Skip this location and go straight to the East Meadow location. It's much better in food quality and service. Never going back to Merrick location. read more

First let me say I have been to three of their locations and their each a little different. The merrick one is a little smaller and also doesn't have a liqour license so there is no alcohol. However this location is never crowded so ive never had to wait which is nice. Staff is very friendly, probably their most friendly location. This time i got the chicken quesadilla appetizer which was a little greasy and didnt have much flavor. However it was a big portion for an appetizer and once you added the homemade quac it came with it was tasty. Main course wise I decided to go real authentic mexican and got the Mariquites which was a mix of seasoned shrimp, chicken, and beef with plantains on the bottom. Plantains were over cooked and had no flavor. However the shrimp, chicken, and beef were seasoned perfectly. Got sides of homemade quac which was great as well as their homemade salsa. read more

Really good food and great service. Small place that can get crowded on the weekends at times.

Food and drinks are excellent. Attractive decor and friendly service . Great selection of Margaritas. The ones we picked were awesome

Came here with my boyfriend for dinner on a Saturday night. The staff was super friendly and attentive and the food was delicious. I ordered the chicken fajita and the chicken was so juicy. The side of guacamole was yummy as well. I would have loved to have gotten a sangria with dinner but they still do not have their liquor license. My boyfriend was also craving a Mexican beer, but alas, no alcohol. It's a shame because the food is so good! I'd love to have a margarita at margaritas some day. The liquor license will be a great addition to the fantastic food! read more

Margarita's Cafe - Side for fajitas - Mexican Near Me - Merrick, New York

See all

It's great have a Margarita's Cafe in town. When it comes to Mexican food Margarita's gets close with an American touch. This location is small but has a nice atmosphere. Service is always good with a friendly wait staff. Menu is big and I typically order the fajitas which you can't go wrong with. Portions are big and the meat included is as juicy as it gets. They is still a delay with acquiring their liquor license which is a bummer so if you're in the mood for drinks make sure you call first to see if they are service liquor as of yet. Overall I really enjoy dining here and have been here half a dozen times and will still continue to dine here regardless of their lack of liquor. read more

Best place to get Mexican food , Brian the bartender was the best good food and great drinks must come if your near by.

ever since Brian the manager took over the place has been amazing service has been great

Been here a few times and food was good. Last Friday, not so much. Ordered jalapeño poppers w cheddar cheese. Got a few cheddar and the rest cream cheese and frozen in the middle. Second batch was all cram cheese which we don't like. Waitress couldn't have cared less. No apology, nothing. Food was ok, took awhile to come out and place not crowded. Won't be back. read more

The service was very good as soon as we got the there. Food was delicious. I had a party of 6 people and everyone loved the food. It was my first time to this margaritas but it's definitely not gonna be my last. My favorite one so far read more

came here last night for the first time. We love the margaritas in east meadow so decided to try something closer. They don't yet have their liquor license but that was fine for us. We split guacamole and It was great! Fresh made. The steak quesadilla app I ordered to start was a bit greasy. The chicken tacos were amazing tho! Loved the flavor on the chicken. Great rice and beans on the side too. My bf got steak and said it was cooked perfect. Well def go back again! read more

Margarita's cafe is a authentic Mexican restaurant located on the restaurant dense Merrick Ave. It's a bit different from the Tex-Mex you'd find at Chipotle or Taco Joe's. Margarita's occupies the space where Burger 9 point 5 and Cafe Nee were. I had the Mole Poblano. The sauce was flavorful, and the flavor certainly built throughout the dish. The flavors were far reaching exemplifying smokiness, a little sweetness, a little spicy and chili, and hints of earthy and nuttiness. It came with rice and beans which were tasteful but not as complex in flavor as the mole poblano was. I found the quality of the food to be good and a great value for the price. The cost of the meal which included chicken, salad, rice, and beans was under $10. The service was friendly, quick, and attentive. You can be in and out within 30 minutes. read more

Nothing negative at all. We had a huge party and they were able to seat and tend to us. There live mariachi band takes request and walks around playing music. It's a family party type atmosphere. We had young kids and adults, all equally entertained. The food was great. The appetizer sampler has fried cheese, salami, chicken and all. Drinks have a nice kick and you taste the tequila. I had the steak fajita. It comes with everything a fajita needs, in addition to a side plate of rice, avocado and salad. Highly recommend. We'll be back. read more

I called ahead of time and made reservation for my daughter and the manager was sweet and very helpful. My daughter celebrated her "17 " birthday at Margaritas Cafe with her friends a party of 5. She was so happy with the service and the they all said the food was delicious. This is her first time with her friends at the restaurant and out since COVID-19 and she said only good things about her night out with her friends. My husband and I love the location and the food is always delicious and fresh. The atmosphere is wonderful for some Mexican food and the non - alcohol drinks taste delicious. We do like to drink Margaritas, but since they do not have a liquor license those non-alcohol drinks are the best. My daughter and her friends loved them it adds to the occasion when you are out for some fun and you want to create good memories and take pictures of your night out at Margaritas Cafe.Thank you for making her evening special and allowing us to drop off her birthday cake since it was gluten free and it's her favorite dessert. We will definitely go back to visit for a meal. We wish you a great holiday and we will see you soon. Stay safe and thank you. read more

Margarita's Cafe - Glutenfree Delicious! - Mexican Near Me - Merrick, New York

See all

This is not your average Tex Mex or American style place. There are regional items you don't usually see around here, like the vegetarian stuffed poblano peppers. Humongous portion sizes, great for sharing or eating the next day. The rice is well spiced, and the vegetables taste real (not frozen and reheated...). They understand what vegetarian means, so you don't have to worry about discovering bits of pork in your salsa (for example). Nice people, great service, small and cozy. Plenty of parking out the back. Even the police come here for meals to go! No actual margaritas yet, but word is they expect a liquor license soon. read more

Went with my boyfriend, great service and food, highly recommend the pina colada took me back to punta cana

Got takeout during covid pandemic to help support local businesses but regretted it. If we were in the restaurant every dish would have been sent back and that takes a lot for us to do. Steak was basically uncook, pounds of oil in the quesadilla tray reflecting how cooked, even just as simple as the guac was just huge chunks of avocado and tomato- not diced, not mashed up, no seasonings. They clearly put no effort in to our meal. Never will go back read more

Love margaritas but this place has no liquor license. We get take out here on occasion. Tonight we ordered an "entree" steak quesadilla. I open the container and the quesadilla is lumped in with the refried beans (which I hate) then I put it in a plate and realize how small it is!! Don't order the entree quesadilla it's tiny and smothered in refried beans and soggy af by the time you eat it. read more

Margarita's Cafe - Mexican Near Me - Merrick, New York

See all

The two stars are only because our order was correct and it was done on time. We ordered takeout and The food was horrible. The tamales were hard and resembled microwave tamales. My fish tacos were floppy and tasted of soap. The guac had no flavor and half of our rice was undercooked and hard. Safe to say we're not going to be back here ever again. I would definitely take a hard pass on this place and just go outside of merrick for decent Mexican. read more

Ordered dinner tonight. Food was cold, lettuce provided with dinner was brown & meal was missing rice & refried beans. Best part of the meal was the tortilla chips. Not ordering from Merrick location again read more