Delicious pizza - called and was ready on time and hot and delicious! Definitely recommend the meat…read morelovers!

I'm not sure if you can consider this place a taste of New York here in Fayetteville or not…read more I've had many different pizza from all over the United States and to be honest this does not rank high on the list. Let me start off by saying the service is absolutely perfect. The gentleman behind the counter was very welcoming and friendly. The inside has plenty of seating, a couple of TVs to watch sports or whatever they have on and for the most part, it was clean with the exception I noticed one guy sitting at one of the tables vaping. Now onto the pizza, which to me was not impressive at all, we had purchased six pizzas, three with pepperoni and three cheese and this was for a birthday party and we still have three full pizzas left not too many of the guests were impressed with the pizza it seemed that the dough was old and I'm not sure if that is a term to use or not, but it just seemed when you bit into the slice, it was very hard and not so much on a chewy side and doughy side and very hard to chew. We had a few comments at the party about it, and we could not provide them within adequate answer other than our apologies for ordering from this shop. The pepperoni pizza generally, you spread the pepperoni all over the pizza, but for some strange reason, a lot of the pepperoni were geared more towards the middle of the pizza, which I can't understand why, and it was extremely greasy, which could be understandable based upon the type of pepperoni, which did not seem to be a higher quality than normal, and that would be the same for the cheese. It depends on the cheese as well. In my humble opinion, I think there are a better pizza places in the area other than your national chains which we try to avoid, but I'm not so sure about Brooklyn pizza.

Best NY style pizza in the Pinehurst area. The wait is worth it. There is a reason you have to…read morewait in line and then wait 15 - 20 minutes for your pie to come out. Ask for crispy if that is what you like. His red sauce is also very tasty and combined with his dough, he gets the #1 rating. I just moved here from NYC where I lived for 67 years so I think I am a good judge. His meatball parm hero is also excellent. Tasty meatballs with his spicy sauce combined with fresh mozzarella cheese and good bread combine for a treat. This is our go to place for pizza and meatball parm hero's. So far that is all we have tried so possibly more recommendations to come down the road.

Delicious gluten free! Their gluten free crust is bigger than average with great flavor! I've had…read moreit twice and it's one of my favorite crusts. The put a good amount of toppings on. They are easy to order from in person or over the phone.

BE CAUTIOUS WITH THESE CROOKS!!!!!…read more Tiger's has a huge sign posted in front of their restaurant advertising a Large 1 topping pizza for $8.99. Sounds great, Well, I call and place the order for 1 Large 1 topping pizza and I show up to the store and the gentleman at the register informs me that the price of the food is 12.99 and explained that I never requested the "Special". This is terrible business! If you're going to advertise a price it needs to be honored. I'm all about supporting local businesses but I will not support businesses that conduct business in this manner. Needless to say, I will never return to this place!

Me and my girlfriend get here every time we are craving pizza. One because usually small businesses…read moreare better and the food is great. Everyone time we go the service is great. I will say the ambiance of the place is comfortable, but needs a little updating. But we both love this place!

Whispering Pies was a regular place to visit for the 2 years our daughter played volleyball for…read moreSandhills CC. It was a must when we were back in the area to see our daughter played volleyball against SCC in beach volleyball. It was WONDERFUL! A.J. Is always the sweetest and made another great recommendation. I had a fall special, Blushing Pig, and my husband had the Meat Lovers. There is a picture that describes the pizza I had. It was delicious. They have made some changes since our last visit. Loved the pizza boards the pies were brought out on. If you are in the area, this is a comfortable little place with wonderful staff and delicious food. They have great pies for those needing gluten free and/or vegan. My mother loves them. Meat Lovers is red sauce base, sausage, pepperoni, bacon and ham.

I was looking for another pizza spot in the Southern Pines area and decided to give Whispering Pies…read morea try. I ordered a 10" pepperoni and roasted red pepper pizza -- a good size for one person -- but the topping distribution was hit‑or‑miss. A few of the square slices didn't seem to have any roasted red peppers at all. The overall flavor was solid, just not particularly memorable. The crust had a pita‑like taste and texture: decent chew, but missing the standout character or wow factor I was hoping for. I'll probably stop by the restaurant in person next time and try a slice at the counter to see if it hits better fresh.

UNLIMITED TOPPINGS? Get out of here! Made fast? How is this…read moreeven possible! Cheaper than most pizza places? Now we're talking. I recently checked out MOD Pizza after seeing them all over the country and I was very impressed with what I found. Customizable pizza, with options I never imagined putting on a pie, and all for less than half what Domino's would cost me. Hell yeah I'll be going back. I'm tempted to order a pizza with everything just for the picture. Should I?

This place is usually great but the quality has went way down hill. Wait times are often quite…read morelong, around a good 30-45 minutes till you actually get your food. This itself isn't the main issue however, but what I've seen more of recently is. The flies are just out of control. I watched as dozens of flies just had their way with the ingredients and pizzas that were waiting to go into the oven. The employees didn't even seem phased by their presence either.

We had Mellow Mushroom in Orlando a long time ago and recalled it was pretty good. Tonight it was…read moreamazing! really good pie with great choices for toppings. Out sever was so friendly and helpful. Surprisingly busy for a weeknight which points to good food and service IMO. Pizza after duck bowling for the win!! Fun vibe here.

Excellent service, very nice and helpful staff. Pizza with…read moreregular crust is greasy and floppy, desperately needed salt. They had it on the table so I wonder if they know that.

Pizza night was done right! The food came hot and fresh, and the toppings were plentiful! We have…read morethis thing with mozzarella sticks and these were tasty ones. Husband liked the garlic knots, I didn't try them. The sausage on this special pizza wasn't like the typical kind you get on pizza, it tasted more like...andouille maybe? Never the less, it was well enjoyed, and they did take the ham off as requested.

Nice little local spot. Not really exciting, but friendly…read morepeople and decent food. Great tzadziki. If you're nearby and hungry, it's fine. It could use a woman's touch with some decor.

My family and I love Little Italy and have been customers there for several years. They are one of…read morethe many hidden gems of Fayetteville! Hands down, Little Italy, has the best pizza in town AND it reheats well at home, too! The atmosphere is cozy and inviting and they usually decorate for each season, which always adds a nice touch to overall dining experience. On our most recent visit there, our server was Kari P and she was amazing! Kari kept the flow of the meal at a nice pace and was prompt in keeping beverages filled. Kari was also very knowledgeable of the menu and has the perfect personality in interacting with customers-very courteous, professional and prompt. We love Little Italy!

I've been going here for years now. It's normally really good but this recent visit turned me off…read moreforever. I got the seafood pasta dish like I always do but this time the recipe was incredibly different. I was annoyed because I paid for what I always get but this time the seafood tasted like it had gone off. The noodles are normally thin but they were thick this time. The seafood in the pasta tasted like it had gone bad and there was extra seafood in there this time that just made the dish unappetizing. It normally comes with basically just mussels and shrimp, this time, it came with entire little octopus' and octopus rings that normally aren't there. I took a bite of a few different things but everything tasted awful. I'm writing this at 4am the morning after. I'm sitting in my bathroom vomiting my guts up after eating a few bites of their seafood pasta. It tasted like somebody just scraped together the stuff nearing expiration and threw it into my dish. I have been coming here for years and getting the same dish every time. I don't know why they changed the recipe or why they thought that dish was acceptable to serve.