Shoutout to our local community heroes!!! I don't know how many times that I have passed by this…read moreplaza and not ventured in. But today was the day to be honored by the wonderfulness of Hillary's!!! Diana was our ambassador today. She was radiant, personable, attentive, and definitely a major influence on the charm of this venue. Sure, we bonded a little extra because we are both from Missouri, but it made it especially memorable during this winter storm outside! Cold outside today, but nice and cozy inside here due to the yummy food cooked with Love and the happy hearts of the patrons. People were meeting friends, having birthday dinners, date nights, and even chillin' at the bar. The food is masterfully made. It's a nice menu. Order the pizza first even before the appetizers and drinks... the Chicago deep dish pies take @1 hour!!! Well worth it, trust me! Now after Diana wisely helped guide me through the ordering sequence, she helped me craft my pie. I wanted my fave: double pepperoni, extra cheese. Well, she assured me that there was plenty of cheese already and that she could even offer me to have a layer of pepperoni on top to get crispy. YES, I happily cheered with my hands in clasped in prayer... because I knew God meets not only my needs, but meets my desires. I LOVE a crispy pepperoni!!!!! Ok, let's talk about the beverage selection... can sodas ( my favorite form), amazing wines, and craft beers with many on tap!!! The beer section is top notch!!! I never imagined a small venue like this having an amazing beer selection! Diana let me pick a few to taste. I love an amber, red, or dark, bready, malty, thick mouthfeel, Pilsner, lager, or stout. After those I tasted, I ended up with the Shiner Bock. Great pairing with my pretzel appetizer with house made Boursin cheese!!!!! What!!! Yes, that's right! Don't sleep on this cheese!!! You can spread this unctuous concoction on about anything and kick it up to sky level with its herbs and creamy garlicky goodness! My hubby ordered his favorite hot Italian beef sandwich!!! It was gorgeous and literally so savory, perfectly tender, and mixed with spicy pickle peppers & veggies! I think that sandwich was gone before I finished my first piece of pie!! He kept giving me samples ! "You gotta try this, and this, and this!". He smiled and said this reminds him of his trips to Chicago. High handed compliment from him. And with his last bite of sandwich, he said that he is coming here from now on and ordering this every time!!! Now to my beautiful masterpiece!!! The height of this thin crispy golden crust was like a Royal crown filled with jewels!!! Crispy pepperoni atop of tangy chunky tomato sauce atop of the layers of cheese and more pepperoni!!! I was so excited that I almost didn't even want to stop to take pictures for all of us... but behold!!! I'm so happy!!! Al the textures, decadence, and detail was perfect!!! Gooey cheese pull test exceeded!!! Savory pepperoni was on point! And yes, I shared some with hubby and saved some to take home to do the leftover cold pizza test.... Order a deep dish large enough to have leftovers!!! It was crazy stupid good!!!! Hubby said this was proper food and I whole heartedly support this message!!! I want to try the beers that we out today and whatever the new ones are next time. We don't need to travel but 10 minutes from our home to get spoiled like this!! God bless !!! Don't forget about the heart pie deep dish pies! Valentine's Day or any day is a special way to celebrate these pies cooked with LOVE (*´`*)

Just got DoorDash from here worst pizza I've ever had, inedible. The crust was so hard and…read moretasteless and the pizza was left wet to the point I couldn't bite it with my hands needed a fork and knife. The veggies were borderline raw. And I ordered an artichoke dip, the crackers that come with it were so unbelievably salty also inedible. The dip itself was pretty good but man all that for a meal like this...disgraceful.

We love coming here. The pizza is awesome and so is the service. Welcoming staff always making sure…read morethat we are fully served. I hope you will open a location in Green Cove Springs too

This is our second time dining in this year. We were greeted and seated quickly on a Saturday…read moreafternoon around 2pm. Place was less busy than we expected so it was a perfect time to grab lunch. Our friendly server was a cute girl with neon pink hair. We ordered: a berry mule, Starry, Mtn Dew, fried ravioli, garlic knots, veggie calzone, and a deep dish pizza. Facilities were clean and restrooms were stocked. Parking around the afternoon was less packed than we expected and we landed a spot near the side exit. The drinks were brought over quickly. The mule was strong and cold (just how I like it) and the mint was fresh. Garlic knots arrived first and were even better than the previous take out orders we've had with Bronxhouse. The garlic olive oil that they use is delightful. The fried ravioli arrived next and my husband and I demolished it together. Pizza and calzone arrived at the same time and as we expected, pizza was delicious (crunchy crust, gooey cheese). The calzone was tasty and served in a huge amount so I could only eat one bites before feeling super full (from all the appetizers!). Our total with generous tip was about $100 and it was worth every cent. Thanks to our server and the chefs for a friendly, delicious dining experience. We will definitely be back again

oh my. this is THE best place to get a new york thin crust slice of pepperonI! perfectly seasoned…read more excellent undercarriage, fabulous sauce and cheese!! I have gone to other local spots but came in here when my regular stop wasn't answering their phone. so glad I tried this place. perfect!!!!!!

We do pizza on Friday night, and that doesn't change while on vacation. Pizza was good here, and…read morestaff/service were nice and kind. Only issues- temp inside was so hot when the door opened the breeze was nice, and the soda machine - no refills? It's a decent sized cup, but when the pizza comes out piping hot, a cold drink would be refreshing. In the end, it's a solid recommendation of a pizza place!

One of the few places in St Augustine open late for food other than Denny's or an Americana…read morerestaurant. I ordered the chicken bites and garlic knots. The knots were drowned in a flavourless oil with some garlic. I threw them out. They did however have good ranch and hot sauce for the chicken. I would give them a second chance w the pizza if I was in a pinch for a late night meal.

Shoutout to our local community heroes!!! We are so grateful for this venues fast delivery of…read morequality products!!! We needed this today! A busy weekend after weeks of holiday travel... thank you for this amazing save Five Star Pizza! We had a flyer in the mail for a free large pizza and the reviews have been fantastic. We opted for the family special once I created a pizza profile. A large 2-topping, garlic bread, and a 2-Liter soda!!! My husband made it home just in time to get the pizza hot and fresh!!! He made me look forward to my first bite as he enthusiastically said, "We can order from this place anytime! This is some of the best pizza that I've had in a while!". I definitely do agree!!! The cheese pull was perfect!! I loved the spice level in the pepperoni!!! And it was thin slices so they crisped up magnificently!!! The crust was the quality!!! Cooked well and the texture was wonderful!!! Not burnt or gooey... I am very picky. I was impressed! Their garlic bread (made daily) was generously swimming in their secret recipe garlic butter! Yummm! Then, the hot wings that we added to our dinner were cooked well-done as we ordered. Yay!!! This all washed down perfectly with our cold bottle of Pepsi!!! Yay!! And they added a sheet of coupons on our pizza box that lead us to a QR code that gave us yet ANOTHER coupon!!! Talk about a win win!!! As a veteran pizza maker (@2 years at Pizza Hut)... I am proud to support the masterpieces coming from this venue! And shoutout to exceptional speedy delivery time and the professionalism of the delivery person!!! He was very presentable and personable! God bless! 5 stars indeed!!!

Pizza has been one of my foodie addictions in life but who doesn't like pizza? Over the years I've…read moreeaten at hundreds of establishments from Ny city, Boston/ Connecticut, Miami and everywhere in between! From hole in the walls to nicer novelty places. I've lived in Fl for nearly 25 years now, 1/3rd in South Fl and the rest in Saint Johns county. I have worked my way through the pizza scene here. Bronx, particularly this location, has become my favorite here! My go to for a quick slice, a whole pie, or a casual sit down. Their pizza has the perfect crust! Their dinners are equally delicious! The locations are clean, staff are always friendly and welcoming! It's no secret why they are on their 11 or 12th? Location! I won't ever stop trying new places but they will be hard to beat!

Update on this place. Great pizza joint. Good food, great pizza, reasonable prices, comfortable…read moreseating for twos and fours. Nice crust on the pizza - which makes the pizza. Not "bready". Excellent flavors and good service. Plenty of Italian choices - salads, pastas etc. I didn't catch the name of the young lady who served us, but she was hustling - every table in the place was full and ordering and she manned the counter as well as handled every table alone. Good job Miss!

This place is delicious! Worth the wait- my kids got the pepperoni pizza, my husband has the…read moreBrooklyn special while I got the caprese pizza. Nobody asked for more than one slice because it was so fulfilling and tasty. The guy who grabbed our order was very nice and so was the cashier. The prizes are outrageous; I paid $61 in total for four slices and four medium fountain drinks. It definitely reminds me of my childhood in the 90s- the restaurant is outdated and crowded but the pizza was good so I would definitely come back. Also, I read on google that this was a cash only establishment; it's not. I definitely paid with card.

Pizza Time is a happening place, for sure. The line goes out the door and the display of pizza is…read moremouth-watering. Many unusual combinations and unusual styles of pizza, thick and thin, are offered. Portions are very ample and pizza is served hot and fresh over the counter. There is indoor seating. The service is fast and friendly. The employees keep the line moving. It's very satisfying.

We visited this location on our spring break vacation and the waiter attending us. Her name was…read moreMontana. she was great with the service and helped us on the questions we had about the food. The food was delicious, we ordered a large supreme pizza, order of wings, meatballs, and 2 deserts to take out for hotel. Overall, I had a great experience with my family and this restaurant looks to be a family owned business and I will recommend them and will come again. The prices were decent and the atmosphere was good. Once again, thank you Montana for the great service and I hope to come again in the near future

9 am we wanted unsweetened iced tea. They had not made it yet. They refused to give us an ice cup,…read morethough they had not made the product yet. The woman at the counter was a little rude about it and kept mumbling under her breath as she walked away.

I ordered the white pizza and it looked absolutely nothing like the picture and I'm pretty sure it…read moredidn't have half the stuff on it that it said it came with. It was OK nothing to really rape about and definitely not worth $25.

Had dinner there tonight. We had the garlic rolls to start. Just the right amount of garlic and the…read moresauce with them was very good. The pizza we chose was mac and cheese buffalo chicken. It was soooo good. Our server was Joey and he was so much fun. Also met Jenn who makes the pizzas. Adrian knows his sports! The decor is very cute and loved the Christmas tree made of pizza boxes. It's not real big, and that adds to the atmosphere. Felt like eating dinner with family and friends. Can't wait to go back and try some of the pastas.