My wife and I came across Mangiafoco after straying just a little bit off the main streets of Florence, looking for a place to recharge after spending our day either in a train or walking in the punishing heat of an Italian heatwave.
It's a fairly small place but has a very cool, modern design which I found refreshing after eating at a lot of places that were older and/or didn't pay as much attention to the interior design. With one look inside you can tell that it's a wine bar, as there's bottles stacked all over the place, but with care and not just stacks of wine boxes due to a lack of storage. There's a cooler with meats and cheeses and a small food prep area in the back of the dining room, and a bar in a slightly raised area to the left of the main room.
The menu is fairly compact, with several appetizers (a few being Tuscan charcuterie, of course), pasta dishes, and a few main course type options. I wasn't feeling particularly hungry, so my wife and I split an order of their prosciutto bruschetta to start and I got a little bit adventurous and got their steak tartare for my "main", Asking for a suggestion on the wine, we went with the waiter and got a 2012 Montalcino. Their wine list is large, but not an unmanageable behemoth, so there was plenty of selection but not overwhelmingly so. Most of the list was in the 25-35 euro range, so quite affordable as well.
The bruschetta came topped with a generous slathering of black truffle, cheese and prosciutto, on thick, thoroughly toasted bread. Given the truffle spread, it was very rich and had a lot of big flavours. It was actually the tipping point for me deciding that after three weeks of having more truffles than I'd ever had before, I wasn't a truffle guy, at least in large quantities like this.
When my tartare came, it was an intimidating sight. I had done my mental math a little wrong, and thought that the very precise description of 150g of meat wasn't that much. Well let's put this in context: a quarter pound of meat is 110 grams, and a burger loses about 20% of its mass when its cooked, so my steak tartare was 70% heavier than a cooked quarter pound patty. I've had steak tartare before, and liked it obviously, but this was a lot of raw meat to put back as you just naturally have that voice in the back of your head telling you that its a risky proposition. So needless to say, I took it a bit slow with my mound o' meat, mixing in bites of the tasty fennel and carrot salad, and putting our bread basket to good use. The meat was good though; seasoned nicely, with a slight bit of acidity and herbiness, although I was a bit disappointed that there wasn't an egg yolk on top.
Our Montalcino was a big bodied red, with just a bit of a sour bite that all paired well with the equally big flavours of the truffle and beef.
Service was very attentive for an Italian place, and very helpful.
I'd definitely suggest Mangiafocco if you're in Florence, as the combination of old world food in a modern atmosphere is a great combination.