We've been loyal customers of this establishment for quite some time & we're not even in town, they always deliver to us. Everything from the pizza to the chicken entrees & much more are always delicious & on point. Tonight we placed our large usual order & the weather was an icy, rainy wintry mix so we expected & didn't mind a delay in arrival. Tonight's incident was a 1st for us with them; they delivered the wrong order completely & the delivery driver had no explanation. We called back to let them know that our order was taken down correctly but the delivery was wrong. The Owner himself apologized over the phone & told us "Please keep whatever was delivered; I'm going to re-make your entire order & due to the inclement weather outside, I will come to deliver your order personally." At this point we were impressed by the Owner's kind gesture but we had been waiting quite a while. Well let my family & I tell you that the wait was worth it!! When the Owner arrived, he apologized profusely & explained he has "new staff in training & it was just one of those bad days where anything & everything could go wrong did." We are very understanding people & when we brought in our Order from the Owner, we immediately noticed something was different,.... We're assuming that to make up for the inconvenience & that fact that we're such loyal customers, he surprised us with an extremely generous amount of extra menu items! We were so surprised by the Owners' kindness, his honesty to his word & promise to come through personally & his incredible generosity that he's won our loyalty for the future,... Anyone can have an "off day," we get it,... But if you give this place a shot, you won't be disappointed!!! I would give them 10/10 stars if I could!! tysm & happy holidays 2022!! read more

Mamma Mia's, you have my heart. I have never in my life been able to heat up pizza in the microwave and it be just as good as the first time I ate it. I order from Mamma Mia's multiple times a week not only because it's by my apartment, but because it's the best pizza shop I have ever tried. I love the owners, I love the staff. They make their food with love and at a great price, too. They have the BEST disco fries in the area. They also have the best marinara sauce, which I learned from ordering their delicious fried ravioli. I have tried so much from this place, but their pizza is really top notch. The amount of pizzas I've shared with my husband on movie night would shock you. There is never a day my husband and I argue about what is for dinner and end up both saying to each other, "Mamma Mia's?" We have no shame. If I want to be healthy, I go for their salads. If I want to bad, I go for their pizza. I've tried so many menu items from the cheese steak, garlic knots, jalapeño poppers, chicken parmigiana sandwich, grandmas pie, salads, bruschetta, and desserts. I have never had a single bad thing from this place and have never had any leftovers go past 1 day. I love this pizza shop. It deserves way higher reviews than it has. They also followed me back on Instagram without knowing how much of a fan I am. I respect that. As well as their menu deals and lunch specials. Fabulous and UNDERRATED. I've never heated up a chicken bacon ranch and have the ranch actually stay on it when I heat it up. This is THE pizza shop in the area and I can crown it as such because I am the pickiest eater when it comes to QUALITY. read more

Mamma Mias Pizza - Chicken Bacon Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Pizza, Penne Vodka Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

They used to be a good place but not ant more. Not good who ever bought it can't make pizza. They can't make sandwiches do them not having the meat. read more

So you are moving out of state and want one last NJ Pizza before you go? Only one choice for me--The Eggplant Rollatini pizza from Mamma Mia's. First it's a work of art from the actual Rollatini at its center to the ample toppings of fried eggplant and creamy ricotta cheese dotted across the pie. The sauce isn't one of those canned sweet sauces, it's a savory, flavorful red gravy. And last but never least, the crust, it's neither too thin nor too thick. It's the perfect doneness and depth to be able to hold your pizza in your hand (or two hands) and not have all the toppings slide off. The owner is super friendly, and they offer specials on their website to save money. But I always order the same Eggplant Rollatini Pizza cause it's sooooo good. And I shall miss you, good pizza! read more

Mamma Mias Pizza - Slice of Eggplant Rollatini Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

So I ordered their food for my daughter's college graduation, the penny and vodka was delicious, the chicken Parm was good but a little dry, the eggplant Parm was good, the calamari was ok. They gave me a lot of food and I had more than enough, the garlic knots were very very good, and they also sent me toasted bread. Overall they did a very good job and I do recommend this place if you are having some thing special. Yes we would order from here again read more

Mamma Mias Pizza - A full tray of penny and vodka, a full tray of chicken Parm, a half a tray of eggplant Parm, a half a tray of Fried Calamari . - Pizza Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

Mamma Mia' must have a new cook. Or it has gone down hill fast. I ordered Chcken Murphy Hot with linguini. What I got was half the size of what they normally give with no sausage or sliced potatoes. Just half the chicken with some mini French fries. The sauce had no hot peppers and tasted like water and flour.i will never be going there again. It was disgusting and that is a compliment read more

We have struggled to find our local pizza place. Tonight we had Mamma Mia's for the first time and man, have we found our local spot! A perfect New York style pizza. Arrived super hot, absolutely delicious. We are so happy we tried it and can't wait to go back! Thanks Mamma Mia crew! read more

We have been ordering and picking up pizza from Mamma Mia's for quite sometime. Always a great experience, this is a nice local spot serving some really delicious pizzas. Staff is super friendly...this is our go to spot and we love supporting this local establishment. read more

This place used to be great. Consistently delicious food at reasonable prices. We ordered from there last night and it was inedible and a ripoff. A chicken tender meal for $9 contained one small petrified piece of chicken and soggy shoe string fries. Their potato and egg sandwich was the same soggy fries thrown into an egg! Don't even get me started on the disco fries. No dancing involved there I assure you. The pizza was also disgusting. Thick awful tasting sauce on a bland hard crust. I called about the chicken tender "meal" and they didn't care. Offered us a discount on a future order. Like I'd want more of this garbage? I wondered if it had changed hands and see from the reviews that it has. Mystery solved. Never again. Just yuck. If you want great pizza and all around great food, you can't go wrong with Ralph's. I should have stuck with my first instinct. read more

Can I give this horrible le place a negative star? -We first tried them when they reopened as Mamma Mia's and it was a disaster. My husband waited there 45 minutes after the time we were told was pickup time along with about 10 other people! They were so disorganized and slow, it was unbelievable. But we gave them the benefit of the doubt since they were new. -Then on Valentines day we called way ahead and asked what kind of time frame they needed for 2 chicken dinners. They took my order 2 hours ahead so that we'd get our food at 5pm. I ordered chicken parm and chicken picata and asked that the pasta for the picata not come with red sauce (that would be a gross combo) and was told that it was no problem, that it WILL come with picata sauce. My husband went to pick it up and waited 35 minutes past pickup time!!! He brought the food home and when we unwrapped everything they put red sauce on my pasta! Not only that it had mushrooms, not capers??? (picata, doesn't have mushrooms, it has capers!) I called and they told me that they would send the correct pasta right over. 3 1/2 hours later they dropped it off. WOW!!! -Then today I decided to give them 1last try using the Too Good To Go app. Pickup time was 8:30-8:45 and we got there at 8:25 and they were locked up but inside cleaning. I knocked and they tried to just ignore me but eventually opened the door to say that they didn't have the food. THIS PLACE CAN NOT STAY IN BUSINESS! They are horrible at customer service and to be honest, in a town FULL of pizzarias why even go back? read more

Excellent ! Sausage - jalapeno Pizza was really good. I wish they offered crumbled sausage too. Sliced sausage does not end up on every slice. The pizza itself though was tasty. Nice sauce. Crust wasn't blah like many places around town. Crust should have flavor. Not just be dough. Garlic powder, onion powder, butter and olive oil. That's what should be in pizza crust besides flour, salt and yeast. read more

We probably eat from here at least twice a week. We are in love with the grandma pie. So much that we will order it, and take to family out in Warren County. I've had sandwiches and other dishes here as well, and all are equally good. Staff is very nice as well. I wish I would've known when they were in Bloomfield. read more

Placed an order with GrubHub only to be told that they don't use GrubHub and that my order is no where to be found. No apology or anything. Thanks for wasting my time. Just a thought, maybe turn off your GrubHub or at least set it to "not accepting orders" like others do. Rude and unprofessional. read more

Do not order from here. Ordered at 6:10 PM was told within the hour. Was called at 7 PM and told they don't have an ingredient for two of the dishes so we substituted with another vegetable. Received another call at 7:30 to say they didn't have another ingredient for another dish. How an Italian place runs out of broccoli rabe and shrimp is beyond me but to wait an hour and a half to finally call and state they are out of something is ridiculous. If they called quicker it would of been no problem but to wait after the food was supposed to be delivered is ridiculous. read more

Terrible pizza and service.Dont waste you money or your time. To many other good pizza places in the area than eating this garbage.

Ok this is it. This is where you order from. Pizza was much better this time around and it also passed the microwave and oven test the following days. They're really using some quality stuff here. I can't wait to eat here again. read more

Food is OUTSTANDING DELICIOUS!! Gravy is like my grandmothers ! Pizza - chicken cutlet sandwich and more first pizzeria I can honestly say is amazing taste like home !! Staff is sweet we would order there every day !! Please if you haven't yet this is a must try !! Bravo cavatelli everything on the menu is a must try read more

$1.50 extra to pay with my debit card for pick-up? No information on that ahead of time, would have just had it delivered. And they had the nerve to ask for a tip on top of that? We will not be back. The food wasn't even good...it used to be under the old owners. And the parking is awful. Done with this place. read more

What happened to this place? The pizza was a mess and very under done for a barstool pie. The cheese pulled off in one piece and left a flimsy wet dough. Too much good pizza around Nutley to bother with this place again. read more

Tried Mamma Mia's a few weeks ago and enjoyed our pizzas. Ordered again this week and was extremely disappointed. Not even close to what our first try was. First time was a Saturday and second was a Friday - two totally different outcomes. Major disappointment read more

Placed an order at 5:27 didn't get my order until 6:50 items were missing from the order and the food was cold and tasteless. The Alfredo was just thickened milk with fettuccine the rice ball was half way decent but the dipping sauce was not Vodka sauce as advertised I got a marinara which also was lacking any seasoning and flavor tasted like a cheap jarred sauce. The chicken on the Cesar salad also bland. The only things that were flavorful were the croutons and I know those are store bought. I'm Sicilian and a former chef so I expect an Italian restaurant's food to taste Italian not whatever the hell I got here. Total waste of money and I'll never make this mistake again. This food is disrespectful to serve you should be ashamed to call this Italian food. read more

Ugh. I had such high hopes for this establishment. The food is so-so at best. The worst part is the way the OWNER treats his staff. I have NEVER heard anyone ever speak to their employees like this. Just disgusting. I could not believe he would curse like that in front of the customers. I would never recommend a place like this to anyone. Subpar food and the owner is a jerk.... No thanks! read more

Me and my boyfriend have been going here for over a month and they are everything you could ever want in a local pizzeria. Some of the kindest folks around and the slices are a SLAM DUNK! The sauce is spot freaking on and I love their pepperoni slice . You also have to try their margarita pie, literally makes me drool! The people here are so genuine and kind, they'll having you coming back not just for the food but also for the company Oh and the penne vodka is the best I've ever had! Ever!! read more

12/10 OMG, I can't praise this place enough. I loved the eggplant parmesan sub. Go on Wednesdays and you can get an amazing deal for a 16 inch sub. This location will definitely be my new favorite go to. Will be ordering again soon! read more

Good food. Lasagne and sauce delicious. Full salads and delicious chicken cheese steaks :)

If you like the pie here and are having a party. Order their 28 inch pie. Delicious. Got it from birthday party and it was a hit

Just opened with new owners. Great food! I'll be eating here all the time. The rice balls are amazing!

We've ordered about 3-4 times and we all love the food especially the Caesar salad with grilled chicken!!!! Great place!!! Currently our favorite place to order from!!! read more

They give you a lot on the meal deals. Pizza is delicious. The pasta vodka and chicken parm has great taste. Staff are very nice.