My wife and I found Mama Silvia's by accident. We didn't have a reservation so we sat at the bar, and we are glad we did. Mike was the bartender and he made excellent cocktails and was a joy to talk to. We both enjoyed our meals and ended up having enough left over to take home. Great portions. The atmosphere was charming and as a young couple sitting close at the bar was a great chance for us to be relaxed in a more classy environment. We will be back. read more

Quaint and romantic. I had the best salad ever there! Traditional Northern Italian, comes with potatoes, but ask for pasta if you prefer.

We were in the mood for some pasta and someone had recommended Mama Silvia's. Initially, the restaurant looks small, but as you enter you realize they have an upstairs area. My sister and I decided to share the carbonara, but each order the table-side Caesar salad. Both were great! Our server Savannah was amazing! We were a group of six, and we had some picky eaters but she was so patient. The table-side Caesar was delicious. The flavor was so good and something I'll be ordering anytime I come here! read more

See all

After riding the Durango Silverton Railway which is a 9 hour train ride. We decided to have dinner before heading back to the hotel room. We found this little Italian restaurant by mistake on our way somewhere else. This turned out to be great decision on our part as everything about our experience was superb. We were greeted with friendly faces and seated rather quickly as they worked us in without a reservation. We both ordered the pistachio crusted chilean sea bass with fried polenta. Let just say the food melted in your mouth. Our waiter Dan was gracious, knowledgeable about everything on the menu and extremely pleasant. I loved the set up of restaurant as well. We sat by the kitchen which was open so you could see the chef's cook and pastry chef prepared the meals. For me that was totally AWESOME. Plus they had a tv that played a show of how each dish was made. Which was even more exciting. I told Mark I just need Gordon Ramsey to pop up and I would die happy. read more

See all

Incredible home style Italian food! Cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, generous portions. They DO have a kids menu and the portions are quite big. 10/10 will be back. Make a reservation and don't miss this gem just off Main Street. read more

Great service. I ordered Cesar salad . Has to be for two. For $30 was way skimpy. Also had spaghetti and meatballs. Meatballs were tasty. Spaghetti sauce was lacking. There was hardly any . Probably will not return. Their sushi restaurant next door is way better. read more

WONERFUL!!! We walked in on a Saturday night without reservation. The staff was very helpful. We sat at the bar as we waited. Our bartender Mike was knowledgeable and helpful with our drink selection. He makes an amazing Old Fashion. We were sat at an intimate table in the corner. Our sever, Kate was also helpful and very nice. I started with the pasta fagioli. It was good but not memorable. I would pass next time. My wife ordered the special, Bronzino ala Picatta and it was AMAZING. Cooked perfectly, tender, flavorful without a pronounced fish flavor. I had the Agnolotti which was also very good. It didn't have a traditional Agnolotti shape but more like a ravioli. That said, the past was homemade and wonderful. The cheese/ Spinach filling was perfect with an amazing sauce. We will definitely be back. Good location, nice atmosphere, friendly staff, good price and amazing food. Thank you everyone for a very nice date night with my bride of 10 years. read more

The Italian food we ordered was mediocre. Had peas in everything. Didn't taste authentic or anything great. Won't be back. I love Italian food so my expectations are high for it and this wasn't it. Sorry to say. read more

Food was cold. Service was horrible. Bill was high. No one cared at all about waiting an hour for our meal that we couldn't eat. Shame on this place. Never again. read more

Best Italian food I've had in a long time!! Do not miss this place. Sooooo good. Incredible salad.

the food wasn't good. i expected pasta with my chicken and all i got was a huge piece of boiled chicken. on top of that it was crazy expensive for only getting a piece of chicken. the service was good but the food wasn't great. read more

The chicken marsala is pretty good. The soup is awful. Was a bowl of grease. The free bread is just ok.

My wife had the eggplant Parmesan, but I think it was called something else on their menu. However, it had the absolute best marinara sauce she has ever had! I had the fettuccine Alfredo with scallops, and again it was absolutely delicious! The food seems very authentic. Prices were reasonable service was quick. We are definitely keeping this one on our list for when we come back. read more

My husband is currently on assignment as a wildland firefighter in CO. It's worth mentioning because as anyone knows the hours in the summer for firefighters can be long and a chance for a meal during the day are pretty slim when you are away from home. He went to Mama Silvia's the other evening tired and hungry hoping to grab a bite to go after a long shift. Initially he was told sure they could accommodate a to-go meal. However, shortly thereafter someone came from the back and spoke with the woman who had ok'd the to go order. She then proceeded to tell my husband that they were too busy and would not be able to serve him. Whaaaat!? I don't know what the policy is here and frankly I don't care. That's not how you treat people. My husband doesn't have the time to write these reviews while he's on assignment and honestly I would have wrote this off to just a bad experience but he had a very similar experience at another restaurant last night. So I decided to hop on here and just say how disappointed I am with these businesses and the level of service or complete lack of service that he has received in Durango. Shameful read more

Needs work. The food is upscale mass Italian. Spaghetti and meatballs. Linguini with random seafood. Eggplant parm. That's all fine with me and I give it two stars. It was OK. I think the main problem is with staffing and management. It's not really OK to sit for fifteen minutes without water, much less a drink order. It's not ok to take an order from one member of a party and then disappear and take the other order ten minutes later. It's not acceptable to serve cold food at $50 a plate. This is bush-leaguer and not worth the money. Do better. Go elsewhere. read more

If I started this review as frustrating as my dining experience at Mama Silvia's you'd stop reading so I'll start with the good news, the food is good-5 stars good but the ordering process is a mess. If you're dining in you likely won't have any issues so enjoy! If you're trying to order Togo please keep reading. To start, there are two reviews for the same place here on Yelp, Mama Silvia's and Mamm Silvia's, ironically, the one spelt incorrectly has the site information http://www.mammasilvias.com which does have an updated menu but you can not order online from the site or yelp. Ok, inconvenient but not a big deal, I call to order only for the recording to refer me to the online ordering site-seriously. On my second attempt to call I request transfer to Mamma Silvia's and got the automated message that the "voice mailbox has not been set up" proceeded by disconnection. At this point, I'd normally give up but I have a 3 year old that wanted spaghetti and I wanted him to eat so off we go for a face-to-face order. The inside is small with just a few tables (visible from the front) and a bar. There was a single table occupied and I asked the front staff member if I could place an order to go. After some thought, the employee said she had to check with the newly hired kitchen staff so they wouldn't be overwhelmed- it's 5pm on a Wednesday with only one patron but ok, I wait patiently. I mentioned the online ordering wasn't working and learned that was intentional as the staff gets overwhelmed with orders so they turned the online feature off. I then mentioned there was not an answer on the telephone and was told they don't answer the phone until a specified time. I'm a bit annoyed but already there so the kitchen agrees to make my order, I pay, then get directed to walk next door to the sushi place to pick up, yes, the sushi place. Sure, I again oblige. Back to the good news, the food is delicious. We had: Pappardelle alla Bolognese with spicy sausage, Penne alla Rustica (was spicy and so rich in flavors), the Spaghetti con Polpette (Speghetti and meatballs) and Insalata Capricciosa for about $80. We ate everything! My 3yo ate the adult size Speghetti too so all in all this is worth the good eats. 5 stars for the food. Minus a star for not updating the website or phone recording to help patrons looking for Togo orders. read more

Mama Silvia’s Italian Kitchen - Spaghetti con Polpette - Italian Near Me - Durango, Colorado

We decided to give it a go after reading some mixed reviews. Glad we did! We were seated quickly and waitstaff was courteous and timely. I had a salad with citrus and arugula that had a nice lighter taste with an interesting herb topping that complimented it well. The entree was chicken piccata and I was pleasantly surprised. The chicken was perfectly tender with mushrooms and capers. There was enough for two meals. My husband had the Chicken Marsala and thought it was good. He did think it could have been a bit more tender, but he ate ALL of it. I tried it and thought it was fine. Go figure For dessert we split a nice tiramisu. read more

Mama Silvia’s Italian Kitchen - Chicken Picata - Italian Near Me - Durango, Colorado

See all

Food was phenomenal! The best Chicken Parmigiana that I have ever had. My husband had the lobster pasta special and it was spectacular. Our server, Dan, was great too. Extremely friendly and very helpful with menu recommendations. read more

Overprice, low quality food preparation, poor service, low staffing. The only saving grace is that they have a nice atmosphere. But unfortunately that doesn't make up for poor service. Skip this place! I keep trying to let his place be good but they refuse to offer anything of quality. Three times I have been here in the past year and I am still met with the same issue, there is NO HOST. I have had to wait to be acknowledged by anyone who works here for an average of 10-15 minutes. That doesn't even include the wait time for the table. The staff just runs around, tending to tables, and ignores anybody standing at the door. It's absurd. Do they want business? It does not seem like it. The food is mediocre at best. It has really declined since they opened. A true disappointment. It's sad the only good Italian food we can get in Durango is pizza. It really is a shame. My theory on why this place has not gone under is because it's owned by East by Southwest next door. There's no incentive for them to make quality food, provide good service, or make money because most of their clientele is foot traffic from that damn train. The sushi place next-door subsidizes the Italian restaurant and prevents them from going out of business. read more

We enjoyed our meal so much... we are going back for another amazing meal while in Durango! The pumpkin stuffed ravioli with scallops was the special, and I am so happy I ordered this dish. The service was terrific!! Make sure you make a reservation... and you won't be sorry! read more

Service was really slow and never improved was the worst thing of the night. We got drinks and then it was 25-30 more to order food. Food was just meh. Not bad and good portions for all the chicken dishes . The bread was just bread you could get from kind Soopers. Salad was also uninspired. read more

I had the Pistachio Crusted Sea Bass w Garden Vegetables and Roasted Potatoes. The kids had spaghetti w meatballs. My mom had the pasta w sausage. It was all delicious! The Sea Bass was so good!!! The staff was great and very friendly. Great dining location for our girls trip! read more

Food, dinner and dessert (Tiramisu) was fabulous. The ambiance was perfect. Small locale but elegant menu without being overpriced. read more

Mama Silvia’s Italian Kitchen - Perfecto - Italian Near Me - Durango, Colorado

So I was disappointed in the meal tonight. I got the spaghetti and meat balls and for dessert the creme brulee. Pasta was so over cooked it was mush, couldn't even wrap around the fork without splitting. Sauce was fine, meatballs were good. Unfortunately the mouth feel was completely mushy due to the pasta it ruined the meal. For 20 dollars a plate I expect properly cooked pasta. I've honestly eaten day old pasta from my fridge that was better. The sad creme brulee did not set properly. It was completely runny throughout the bottom half. I'm not shocked that a kitchen that doesn't know how long to boil pasta messed up a creme brulee, as it considerably harder to get right. So why did I order it? Hope, last time I was here, I remembered the experience being great especially the dessert. Unfortunately thier kitchen isn't putting out the quality it used too. My mom was also disappointed, her pasta was the same mushy mess and her eggplant parmesan was tough because the slices were super thick. I think this restaurant has done better and should get back to a higher quality cooking, the devil is in the details. Or drop your prices 7-10 dollars, then I wouldn't expect as much. Cheep food = low quality expensive food should = high quality. read more

We don't eat Italian food very often but decided to splurge and I am so glad we did! This place has excellent food and ambience, great service too. The menu is very diverse and not just noodles. My husband is diabetic so we eat low carb, I'm always delighted when we can get fresh veggies instead of carb heavy noodles. I had the sea bass and it was amazing! The fish was so fresh and high quality (they own the sushi place next door). Chicken Parmesan was outstanding. We will definitely be back. read more

Mama Silvia’s Italian Kitchen - Chicken parm with veggies - Italian Near Me - Durango, Colorado

See all

Fantastic food and great wait staff! Highly recommend the chicken Marsala and pesto pasta.

I got two entrees for take away although I was initially told they weren't doing take away. Considering the limited seating, I was surprised I was told this on the phone but in person, they said they were doing take away. I ordered the veal marsala that was fair but I kid you not, the veal was four bites and no more than two to four ounces. $36 for an appetizer sized portion and I was glad that I ordered two entrees for myself. The bolognese was some of the best I've ever had and although I cannot speak to the chicken dishes, I would NOT order the veal unless you want to stop for a value meal on your way home. I suspect that they remain in business because of the tiny portions and high cost of the food. Don't hesitate to get the bolognese but I'm guessing that regardless of what you order that you'll walk away hungry. I'm a local and like to support the local eateries and pay cash so they can avoid processing fees. I'll stick to making my Italian at home. read more

Restaurant recommendation from the waitress at the hotel bar. Newer Italian place in downtown. Homemade pasta gets my attention quickly, and this place is authentic. No reservations on a Thursday evening, but we were able to get seated right away. Jordan was our server, and she was friendly, enthusiastic and efficient. Ordered lasagna, rich and creamy, savory sausage and a delicious, light and flavorful marinara sauce. My wife got the spaghetti and meatballs, again homemade pasta with plenty of delicious homemade fresh meatballs. Our friend got the chicken marsala and said it was delicious.We ordered an angel hair pasta, and it was also delicious. Homemade bread and roasted garlic served with the meal. No salad with the meal, but everything was so good, we didn't miss it! 3 mixed drinks also. $108 before tip. If you are looking for a great Italian meal, you have to give this place a try. read more

See all

The food was what you would expect for authentic Italian cuisine with some very interesting flares of flavor. It was absolutely amazing and the best Italian food I have had in a very long time! The server, Tony, was incredible. You could tell that he had a breadth of experience in the industry and provided a level of service that you would expect in a 5 star resort. The prices are very reasonable for the high end quality of food and service. We will 100% go back and will be telling everyone we know about this gem of a restaurant in Durango, CO. read more

Kate was a great server and I really enjoyed my meal. I had the Linguine Arrabiata. Plenty of delicious mussels and just the right amount of spiciness. Very fairly priced, fresh bread served as well. My daughter had the meatballs which she liked - but I liked them a little more than her. Highly recommended, full of flavor, best meal I've had in a long time. read more

Had an absolutely amazing lasagna dinner! My husband had fettuccini pesto that he also enjoyed. Our waiter (Trevor?) was delightful and very knowledgeable about not only the menu but also local tips on things to see and do while in Durango. There are many items on the menu that I look forward to trying on my next visit. If it was possible I would give a six star rating! Treat yourself to fine Italian dining @ Mama Silvia''s. You will not be disappointed. read more

Tonight I had the special: pumpkin ravioli with pine nuts and a brown butter sauce. It wasn't good...it was sublime. This was one of those meals where you don't want to be bothered while you're eating it. You just want to be left alone with your pumpkin ravioli and house Chianti. Everyone loved the calamari even if the dish it was served in wasn't ideal for sharing. My daughter liked the spaghetti but surprisingly, my son thought the chicken Alfredo lacked taste. I tried it and agreed but the staff was quick to help with some parmigiana and I was impressed at how responsive all the wait staff was. Be sure to make a reservation before you come, but make a recommendation. read more

Mama Silvia’s Italian Kitchen - There were no songs for the forgotten tonight. - Italian Near Me - Durango, Colorado

See all

The Chicken Marsala plate was the most tender & flavorful I've ever had! Veggies and potatoes come with. Good service and we saw the chefs preparing the food from our table. Excellent wines by the glass. Reasonably priced for a high-end meal!! read more

Very good Italian place. You may get confused by the "Thai iced tea" or "Mochi" on the menu, apparently owned by the same owners of "South by Southwest" next door. Our appetizer was fantastic- can't remember the name but the fresh mozzarella ball with tomatoes and basil was delish! I had the farfalle bologonese- I was disappointed they didn't have meatballs- but their sausage was good as an add-on. My friend had the pesto spaghetti dish- we both polished them off. Home made pasta definitely. I had the first item on the dessert menu- again "Italian" makes- it was delicious. The place is a little small and cramped- but great service and food. read more

Mama Silvia’s Italian Kitchen - Italian Near Me - Durango, Colorado

See all

I love this place and try to get here when ever I have some extra money AND feel like Italian food... Durango does have an issue with a lack of great Italian places. Don't get me wrong the city has some choices but 'great' is the keyword. Mamma Silvia's doesn't disappoint on too many fronts, but there are a few I will break those down though. I love the lasagna here, the issue I have is that sometimes it has been sold out when we have been here. That is a good thing I suppose. I know the pasta is made fresh which I absolutely love and I tell everyone about. If you like pasta and fresh pasta this is the place. The issues I have are that the place shares space with East by Southwest which is a sushi joint. There is usually a smell of seafood and fish, not my jam but hey if you like sushi and seafood probably not going to bother you at all. I'm not a fan of it but I will put up with it if I get some amazing pasta. The bathrooms are shared between the restaurants so it can be humorous to watch people making wrong turns from the restrooms and getting confused about where they are at. And the place can be a little noisy at times. I happen to have sensitive hearing and love quiet places but this is a personal preference so it isn't really something I ever feel the need to mention or include in my scores. read more

We experienced fine dining tonight at Mama Silvia's. We were greeted by Haley who was an excellent server. The Ravioli dell' Aragosta was simply gourmet. We also enjoyed an excellent salad with orange slices and greens. We will definitely return read more

Driving through Durango and wanted Italian food. This place is new, had decent reviews and figured I would give it a try. They were initially a bit confused on what to do with a party of one, then I was offered up a seat at the bar. Ok, not my ideal but I can make it work. The bar tender seemed to not notice me at first but eventually he acknowledged my presence and I eventually got a glass of wine. Since he was fine to look at I wasn't in a big hurry The menu is decent, it won't wow you, but decent options. I had the tortellini which was good and thankfully not over cooked. They seem to have an extensive wine list as well. All in all, not a bad experience. If I'm in Durango again I'd go back to this place. For this part of Colorado that is usually cowboys and cattle drives, this is a nice change from the usual piss poor run of the mill steak house. read more

Mama Silvia’s Italian Kitchen - Tortellini - Italian Near Me - Durango, Colorado

Ate here on a very busy Sunday night. Their systems were glitchy causing the weight staff some stress, but they handled it with grace and were very attentive in their service. We were sat near the kitchen. I was impressed by the smoothness and calmness in the kitchen considering how busy they were. It seemed very organized, and the team throughout the restaurant seemed to work very well together. Everyone was helpful and kind. The food was soooo delicious. Made from scratch and thoughtfully executed. Overall, we had a lovely dinner and left feeling full and happy! read more

Mama Silvia’s Italian Kitchen - Italian Donuts and cappuccino to end the meal. - Italian Near Me - Durango, Colorado

We were visiting Durango and decided to try this place. It turned out a bit "different" for our taste. The appetizer salad was way, way too sour and the chicken picatta too rubbery. The carbonara ok but not great. Our waiter was condescending. read more

Fabulous seafood pasta. The only things that I would change is make to sauce thicker & use angel hair pasta.