Very decent Italian restaurant. Will go back. The food was good and prepared in a timely manner. The service was excellent and the entrees were reasonably priced. read more

Ordered to-go when we walked in and sat for 30 minutes- card in hand and ready to pay, while being ignored by our server. We got tired of waiting and walked to the counter where our food (which was quite bland) had been ready and waiting for quite some time. The cashier said "sorry I just got here" instead of fixing the problem or comping our meal. $30 and All we ordered was the large pepperoni roll and a to-go drink that they didn't even give us in a to-go cup. Horrible communication from the servers. Not everyone is local and knows to pay and pick up food at the counter. read more

Mama Roma - To-go pepperoni roll - Pizza Near Me - Buckhannon, West Virginia

we were in town for the Strawberry Festival and during the parade on Saturday we stopped in here. it was recommended by some friends. We were greeted promptly and sat down by the window and watched the parade. The food was GREAT. Best chicken alfredo EVER. My wife had the chicken Parmesan and we both took over half of our meals, iced down, back to Ohio for dinner the next night, This cute restaurant has the best food, great prices and huge portions. I can't wait to come back. Come to Mama Roma and you will not be disappointed. read more

Great pizza hand tossed dough real good cheese Spaghetti and meatballs was awesome. Clean place read more

Fantastic meal at Mama Roma on quaint Main St. of Buckhannon. From the first smell as you enter, you know it will be delicious as garlic wafts through the air. Quickly seated in the cute dining room with original brick walls. Friendly service. Food was delicious! The pizza looked amazing yet we did not have. The salads were nice but the garlic rolls take the prize! Yum! Entrees were also excellent - one enjoyed Fettuccine Alfredo with chicken and another the Stacked Eggplant which far exceeded expectations. Great presentation!Would hands down return!!! Oh, we also had the Peanut Butter Pie to go and certainly found it tasty also. read more

Mama Roma - Stacked Eggplant was fantastic and beautifully presented. - Pizza Near Me - Buckhannon, West Virginia

See all

Pizza had far too much grease to where toppings slid off from crust and overall flavor was very bland. Typo on menu saying they offer Coca Cola products, but instead only offer Pepsi products. Service was excellent. read more

Chef Marcio made an amazing meal. We started with bruschetta for our appetizer and it was probably the best I've ever eaten. Then had salad with a wonderful house made balsamic vinaigrette. The kids had pepperoni pizza with a crust that was to die for and the marinara so light and flavorful. My daughter in law had the eggplant parmigiana and I the eggplant rollatini, both were superb! I highly recommend you come and try it. We finished with the tiramisu and lemon cello. Delicious! read more

See all

Most of the the best dishes we ate were good: * The best garlic bread is different from others in that they are large rolls instead of Italian bread. A soft pillow roll loaded with garlic, which is absolutely delicious * Margarita Sicilian (Pan Pizza) with added pepperoni. What makes these pizzas so unique is the balsamic vinaigrette that is drizzled over the entire pizza * Another unusual but equally as good dish is the Hot Antipasto, with Spicy Shrimp, Clams, Mussels, Meatball and Sausage in Garlic, Olive Oil, Extra Fresh Oregano, Piccata Sauce, w/ Calamari and Anchovies * Topping the meal off is an overly stuffed Cannoli with chocolate syrup poured over the top The only dish that was off at all was the spaghetti and meatballs. The meatball where huge and the sauce was pretty good, but the pasta itself did not appear to be drained of water, which took away from the dish read more

See all

I had a gift certificate so I tried out Mama Roma for the first time. The garlic rolls were soft and had plenty of garlic. The salad was good and came with more than enough house dressing. The last thing I tried was the Greek pizza, I would definitely order it again. It was some of the best pizza I've had in the area. The service was very polite and attentive. I will definitely be returning here in the future. read more

See all

The food was amazing The service was perfect Only complaint was limited parking Highly recommend this Italian restaurant read more

Food was so good I forgot to photograph it before we ate. We started with the eggplant stackers which is a take on caprese salad with a few rounds of lightly breaded and fries eggplant, with a drizzle of balsamic glaze. We got a large pizza, extra toasty, Mama's house special which was kind of like a supreme pizza with pepperoni and meatball slices, so good! Our waitress was also very friendly and helpful. She was attentive while the place was filling up. It seemed the after church favorite so really fills up around 1pm. We were visiting our son at WVWC and we're pleasantly surprised at this seeming family owned and operated Italian spot read more

See all

Newest restaurant on Main Street. Large, clean and well lighted. Two window side tables. Approximately 12 to 18 additional tables. Our server was friendly and attentive. Our meals were large and satisfying. Quite unexpectedly the fried calamari may have been the best we have ever sampled. My Italian salad was huge and full of Italian meats. My wife was pleased with her house salad topped with grilled shrimp. The house dressing was outstanding. The beverages include tea and Coke products. We will certainly return. read more

Food was really great as well as service. The bruschetta was some of the best we've ever had. Cannoli was huge. They cut it in half for me and my husband so we could share equally. The picture shown is half a cannoli. It was stuffed full. Wings were delicious as well. Pizza was good. read more

See all

excellent food. Delicious pizza, strombolis and pastas. Garlic rolls are awesome. Very clean.

Excellent Italian good and the lunch menu prices and very large portions of food. I had the chicken parm, which came with two pieces of chicken with red sauce and mozzarella on top, a large helping of spaghetti with it. You have a choice of a house salad and soup to start. I had the tortellini soup which was great. They also serve cinnabon style garlic bread which again was phenomenal. Can't beat $10.95 for all that. Check the pic read more

Mama Roma - Chicken Parm with Spaghetti and garlic bread. (Lunch Portion!) - Pizza Near Me - Buckhannon, West Virginia

My significant other, and I were staying in Buckhannon on Friday 10/06/23 before to going to the Forest Festival in Elkins the next day. We have had some good meals in Buckhannon over the years. But we decided to try someplace different. Big mistake. We went to Mama Roma about 630pm. It was clean and visually appealing. The server was cheerful and seated us quickly. There were only 2 or 3 other couples there and 2 servers. My GF had spaghetti and meat sauce with a tossed salad. She said it was good, nothing special. I had the "Italian Feast" with a creamy chicken tortellini soup. The soup was very good. My entree, on the other hand... No so good. It was supposed to be a combination of baked lasagna, baked rigatoni, meatball & Italian sausage. I regret I didn't take a picture. I regret even more that I ordered it. The sauce was a very small amount and a bit sweet and thin for my taste. There was about 2-3 small bites of lasagna, 3 very thin slices of a tasty meatball and 4, 1/4" discs of sausage. But, what this dish consisted of was almost entirely rigatoni. It was topped with a little cheese and placed under a broiler. That melted the cheese but also nearly burned the edges of the massive serving of rigatoni with crunchy, overcooked edges. A nice looking restaurant. But I doubt that I'd recommend it or return for a meal. read more

I was visiting family and drove down from Atlanta. Service is great. Folks were friendly. Got 2 Pizza for the house to go and 3 of my kids finished in record time and enjoyed it very much. We ordered the Cheese and Margarita large. read more

See all

My second visit to Mama Roma shows standards have remained just as high in quality of food and service. We were greeted seconds after entering. Restaurant was packed but they accommodated us quickly. Veal parmigiana with a side of spaghetti, salad and garlic knots was delivered in a very reasonable time frame. Two tender pieces of veal the size of my hand for $18.00. This establishment is busy for a reason. It's good. Will return soon. read more

Mama Roma - Veal parmigiana with side of spaghetti and garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Buckhannon, West Virginia

This is hands down the most authentic Italian you can get in West Virginia. Everything is made from fresh ingredients and the staff is always friendly, I can't wait to try everything on their menu!!! read more

Mama Roma - Rigatoni ala vodka with chicken and a large Stromboli. Bothe delicious and made fresh to order. - Pizza Near Me - Buckhannon, West Virginia

See all

Food was great staff was very friendly one of the best Italian restaurant I've eaten at

pasto assolutamente assolutamente perfetto che renderebbe orgoglioso un italiano. Translation absolutely positively perfect meal that would make an Italian proud. I had the Rigatoni À La Vodka with meat sauce and sausage with creamy spinach tortellini soup and let's just say that when they say made with love they mean it and you can tell that it also extends to their service because they took to time to try and figure out a meal that would make a COMPLETE STRANGER feel at home even though I didn't eat there it made me feel as if I was eating back at Il Proverbio in Palermo. As I sit here writing this the only thing that I can say about this restaurant is this "Perfetto in ogni modo." read more

Vrry good food for take out. Waiter recommendations were very tasty. Excellent presentation and good quality. One comment: when eating Italian it's a sin to eat without a good wine pairing. That was lacking. read more

I must say I was totally impressed with this place !! My husband and I have been wanting to stop in since it opened but we never really had the chance to but tonight we had the chance to and I'm so glad we did. Service was excellent , the food was superb .. The lasagna is amazing. If I could give 10 stars I would :) We will definitely go there again read more

I cannot say enough about this place! First of all, I'm a vegetarian so menu options are generally limited. There was plenty for me to choose from, and I had a hard time deciding. I settled on the Rigatoni ala Mama. As I was waiting, I second guessed my decision because I'm always disappointed with the eggplant. To my surprise, the eggplant was prepared correctly! It was delicious!!! PLUS it comes with 2 garlic rolls - imagine a cinnamon roll, but with garlic! I ordered lemonade as my drink. Yet another very pleasant surprise! It's REAL lemonade!! Not the drink mix over-sugared garbage found everywhere else! The atmosphere is almost perfect! It's a very clean and cozy restaurant. It's set up so you can actually see your food being prepared! I love it!! I love the trellis over the doorway and the flowers hanging from the ceiling! The food was a little pricey, BUT the portion is huge! I ate my dinner and had two more meals the next day. My one and only disappointment is I live over 2 hours away. However, I will be making excuses to go to the Buckhannon area just so I can eat here again! read more