Everything is homemade even the bread/buns for all the sandwiches and burgers. The bakery was divine. The no bakes are creamy texture not the grainy type. Cinnamon bread had just enough sweet and cinnamon that was overpowering. Decent prices. Good amount of food for the money spent. read more

Main Street Cakery Cafe - Updated menu 06/2026 - Burgers Near Me - Fairview, Pennsylvania

See all

The quality and quanity of the food has gone down. I ordered a spicy black bean burger from the menu, but was told they don't have it. I asked if they had a grilled cheese, as it was not on the menu as in the past. She told me yes. It arrived over cooked and greasy and when I asked for pickles, was told they don't do pickles anymore. The fries arrived in a small black dish, which appeared to be re heated. The ice tea was old and cloudy. We finished our subpar meal and the waitress never picked up our plates or asked if I wanted a refill of ice tea. I had to hunt her down to finally get the check. I then noticed that there was a charge for a child's drink. Apparently a child drink does not come with a child's meal. Not a big deal, but one more negative issue.Needless to say, I will NOT be going back to this Main Street Cakery. read more

We went there for a breakfast to-go and came back for a sit-down lunch, it was that great. Homade cooking like it came from mom's kitchen. Nice personable people. Clean establishment. Ample parking right off a main street. Seating in the dining room has nice big windows. We had the breakfast sandwiches. They were ready fast and had a nice amount of bacon. I can't remember if we had lattes or cappuccinos, but they were smooth and hot. Lunch time rolled around and we both ordered the Ruben. The homemade rye and chips were excellent. We also splurged and got the coconut pie. Count us fat and happy customers!!! read more

See all

I've been going to this establishment pretty regularly for the last 3 years. It's always been good and the portion sizes were very good. I just went there today and the food was not good at all, not fresh, and the portion sizes were very small. The portion sizes definitely don't match the prices! They've also made changes to the menu. Half the stuff that I used to order was unavailable. I don't know what's happened but I sure won't be back. read more

Amazing food and service. Stopped here after a morning of fishing and everyone loved their meals.

Great food! Everything is fresh, tasty, and reasonable. The herb & cheese bread is fantastic. Wait staff is friendly & efficient.

Stopped by to get breakfast (they serve it all day until 8pm) and it was very good! Our server was super nice and helpful. The store also has a cute bakery in the front with delicious options! read more

My family loves this place! The food is fantastic (I especially love the tuna salad on croissant), the service is excellent and there is plenty of comfortable seating. I honestly would eat here every single day if I was able to. read more

A delightful alternative to fast food. Wonderful varied healthy menu items. For lunch I had the Cakery Club sandwich on homemade white bread...it was delicious. Others in my party had "breakfast" items at lunch and they looked very tasty. I stopped back the next morning for an Eggs Benedict breakfast with home fries....also excellent. Service was speedy and wait staff was friendly. read more

Cute place just 5 minutes off interstate. Service was very quick and friendly. Nice selection of homemade stuff. We had the turkey sandwich and pulled pork sandwich. Was amazed how fresh they were. They make there bread fresh. Make sure to grab some great sweets at a good price. Do go and enjoy. read more

See all

Small, family, local, stellar in all ways. Great business ans most highly recommended even if it's out of your way. read more

Main Street Cakery Cafe - The neat turkey club on planet earth. - Burgers Near Me - Fairview, Pennsylvania

Nice place. Modern, nice menu, breakfast all day. Great service and food. If you're looking for an everyday place to enjoy a good meal and service. This is the place. read more

This place is INCREDIBLE! The sandwich bread was light, fluffy, tasty, just everything you'd ever want. The sweet potato fries may be the best I've ever had in my actual life. THAT SAUCE IS AWESOME! I would carry it around with me at all times if I could. I can't get over how fast the food came out and how good the service was. I'm sad I don't live here I would be here all the time read more

Good sized menu, including breakfast all day. Food was really good and came out very quickly. Staff was also friendly and welcoming.

My daughter and I stopped in at this restaurant on our way thru Erie to Wisconsin. We were suppose to meet family for breakfast but those plans fell thru. We decided to eat here anyway, and was pleasantly surprised. The staff was friendly and the food was well prepared. I did order the potato pancakes as side because they didn't have hash browns, but I'm glad I did. The potato pancakes were the best I've had. So order them! I wouldn't hesitate to go back, and if you haven't tried it, it's worth stopping in. While paying the bill, I did eye up their baked goods which looked phenomenal, and I couldn't pass up not getting a blackberry muffin. I will be enjoying that on the long trip home. read more

Who wouldn't want to visit a Cakery?!? So we were traveling and looked at yelp for a place to stop for brunch. The cake photo on the site page won my heart and stomach! We jumped off the highway and within a few minutes we were here. What a great little gem! As you walk in you will be greated with a baked goods counter. Good thing I was eating first or I would have bought several things, I was hungry and it all looked like sugary goodness. Directly past the bakery counter was a coffee bar with a couple of stools and some great choices. Then was the Café. We sat down and received immediate attention and welcoming with cheerful service throughout the visit. Since this is a bakery, they make a lot of their own breads. I ordered the avocado toast with a side of hash browns and then we tried the biscuit with sausage gravy. The toast was from scratch Italian and had awesome dense flavor and chew. The two thick slices with the avocado mash, fresh sliced tomato, basted egg on each and balsamic drizzle was hearty and satisfying. The fresh diced potatoes were good but could have used a bit more cook time. The biscuit was excellent as was the gravy with a rich sausage flavor to it. The mini potato pancakes made a nice hash brown alternative of crispy potato goodness. I wish I still would have had room for cake after that, but my belly was satisfied. The prices were VERY reasonable. Our check was $16+change before tip. Awesome place! read more

See all

The food here is always made with love, you can tell. The staff members are friendly and make you feel comfortable in both the dining room and drive-thru. I love that you feel like they actually appreciate your business. Plus, the service is always quick AND precise. I have never had a bad experience here, and I don't think I ever will. Stop here if you can, you won't regret it either! read more

We've eaten breakfast, lunch and dinner more than a dozen times. And baked goods, too. But I can only rate them a 1 to 2. Why? THE FOOD IS SIMPLY NOT FRESH. Worse, they think it is...when it is not. We once asked if the biscuits were fresh, before ordering. They were old. The owner stopped by to explain they were fresh when we complained. She carefully explained that her daughter had baked them the night before, and they were "fresh." Huh? Baked goods are the same... day old. And the burgers, well the meat is precooked. They simply heat up the patty. Hey, Cakery, this is not fresh. And it tastes that way...Old. read more

Wow! Good food! I travel for work and was near their Fairview location. Checked their website and saw they used the toast app. Ordered food. Got a lot of breakfast foods over the course of a week. Everything was hot, delicious, and ready for pickup on time. Refreshing to find homemade food married with reliable tech during the lunch rush! Those pancakes! OMG! read more

Was not impressed with Main Street Cakery. The waitress was rude and failed to refill our drinks. We asked once and she felt her priority was to chat with other staff. Waited 10minutes and still never came by. Finally got up and got our own. Kitchen staff wore no gloves when handling raw chicken and wiped hands on apron. Was really gross. Could see the kitchen from seats and staff was certainly not trained in food safety. Won't be back. read more

Such a great asset to the Fairview community. Great service, great food, and a great atmosphere.

Decided to stop here for lunch. It was so cute inside. All of the pastries and cookies looked delicious inside the glass cases. We ordered the Avocado toast and it was a perfect combination of sweet (Brie cheese ) with a hint of tartness (balsamic). My niece ordered the chicken salad sandwich, we both thought it had a bit too much celery, but it was good. We also had an iced Carmel Macchiato - which was perfect!! You need to stop in here for breakfast, lunch or dinner. read more

Main Street Cakery Cafe - Avocado toast with Sweet potato fries !!! Delicious - Burgers Near Me - Fairview, Pennsylvania

See all

Everything is homemade there and it's always fantastic. Our family gets take out here frequently and it doesn't disappoint. I highly recommend the country fried chicken meal. read more

All American food , all breads, rolls, cakes and pastries are home made on sight. Great service and not rushed to get out when you are done. read more

What a delicious Stop! My friend wanted to have some soup end it certainly smells good to me and taste great to him. However, my desire was for a dessert. I finally chose a peanut butter flavored fluffy frosting filled a chocolate cupcake. Definitely Delicious. I wanted to eat several of them. read more

See all

What can I say? Excellent food and service!! Dang!! Love it when I get what I expect!!

I was dreaming and I thought my mother in heaven was cooking for me. I woke up and I was at the Cakery. Seriously this is fresh, homemade food. Great comfort food that will leave you smiling from the friendly attentive staff to the yummy food!! Don't forget to leave with some awesome desserts. We got amazing fresh peanut butter pie, chocolate chip cookies. Stop there your heart and tummy will be glad you did!! read more

You just sold me a dozen chocolate chip cookies that were half baked, raw in the center and gooey. Not edible. I don't understand how you could hand a person this kind of crap with a conscience. If you can't bake, then get out of the business. This isn't the first time with the cookies. While I'm at it, some time ago, you served me a fish sandwich that was raw - I walked out. read more

Clean friendly and good food that is reasonably priced. Their bakery has some excellent choices that are always delicious. Thanks Ben Meatloaf read more

Whoa. Waited too long to try this place. Had the meatloaf that was on special. I'm hesitant about meatloaf because the kind I make is hard to beat and theirs met my expectations. Real mashed potatoes! And the best chocolate cake I've ever had. When you think of chocolate cake and everything you hope it would be, this is it. It's the chocolate cake they serve in heaven. Seriously check this place out. The service was great also and our server super friendly with the kids. read more

See all

I'm hoping someday I can up my rating, but for now it's a three. The service is usually okay and is certainly never rude or anything but the servers are usually pretty young and inexperienced. I don't know if I've ever had the same waitress. Always friendly though, but not always attentive. The place has always been "seat yourself" every time I've been there. It's got a pretty limited seating space so I don't recommend large groups especially if you are going during a busy time or wouldn't mind waiting. They have a booth type of thing along the back wall that could seat a larger party (usually it's broken up into parts so that multiple parties can be seated there) and there's a table toward the front that seats about 6-8 I think. During the summer they have outdoor seating but it's basically in the parking lot. I usually have the pulled pork sandwich because I always have hopes of it being good, but it never really is. The pork never really tastes that fresh (kind of like it's been reheated) and is always on the dry side. And they don't have pickles! I asked for dill pickles and I was told they didn't have any :( I don't know if they NEVER have pickles or if they were just out. The bbq sauce is sticky and dried out. The rolls are pretty good...they are really fresh and homemade but sometimes fall apart...not that I'm a master baker or anything, but I'd recommend a flour with a little higher of a gluten content for the sandwich rolls. The most recent time I was there they held up better than I remember before. The fries are SO GOOD. They are fresh cut and always done perfectly...not soggy!!! But I have gotten them when they are not seasoned at all (which I don't mind at all, I like salting myself) but I've also gotten them where they season them with salt AND pepper so if you're not into pepper just ask. They have lots of homemade desserts!!! After all, they started out as a Cakery. They also serve Marcie's homemade ice cream. read more

Always great service - Kelly is our favorite! It's nice to have healthier options in Fairview like soup and salad for lunch.

Some of the staff are really rude and I was just avoid this place. Erie has too many other (better) alternatives with much better customer service oriented staff. read more

New to the area and this has been our FAVORITE discovery! We LOVE this place! Great service, really great food and very well priced! read more

Reuben bites, fried balls of sauerkraut and meat, is brilliant. Burger was delicious. Salad was fresh Bakery and dessert was outstanding read more

Ughhh the Mac and cheese with pulled pork makes me one happy lady! It's my guilty pleasure! Not to mention the muffins and cookies waiting for you by the door when you leave! How could anyone drive past this place without stopping. And oh yeah talk about speedy service! Fantastic little cafe! read more

Main Street Cakery Cafe - Burgers Near Me - Fairview, Pennsylvania

Love this place and love the Reuben bites!!! Friendly service and great menu. Wish it was bigger inside! read more

Lunch is good, better than breakfast! But that's just me. We are always looking for new places to enjoy. It's local and that's a positive!

Better than ordinary food with an occasional wonderful special. The Cakery deserts are fantastic.

The first time we got sick for some coincidence hours after eating at the Erie location. A couple of years later we decided to try the location in the next town & as we were placing the order they said prices had an extra $5 on top of the already $18 simple salad. Unfortunately, In addition the their portions are smaller than most places. I ended up purchasing the same item from The Public House down the street & it was much less expensive than this place. read more