Great pizza every time! These bad reviews are deceiving I have been going for years and Gabe is great! Order at least once a month from here read more

On my way to a friend's house and I was in the mood for pizza. Drove through town and found Main St Pizza Cafe. An unassuming pizza with dining room seating. I only wanted one slice of pizza, and I noticed that all the pizza was displayed in open air at the front counter. All the various pizza options had seemed to be there for a long time. I always said that I would never order one slice of pizza if it was sitting in a display. But I was hungry, and I wanted a slice of pizza now. Simple, a Pizzeria displays their pizza on their front counter with people faces looking down at the various pizza slice options. Does that sound appetizing? My bad, never again. Just buy an entire pie regardless of how long I must wait. Why? Leaving pizza out in open counters is unhealthy because it can lead to foodborne illnesses. This is not a reflection of the Main Street Pizza Café. The slice of spinach cheese pizza was particularly good. But this has been s to be a customary practice in all pizzerias for as long as I can remember. read more

Main St Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Kings Park, New York

Been getting weekly for longer than I can remember, consistently legit pizza. Owners are great and service is amazing, quick and convenient but delicate and delicious. Bad reviews don't know what they're talking about. read more

Attitude of the owner Gabe. Very unprofessional and vulgar. charged $28.10 for our pizza that was clearly not freshly made. He would not even admit that it was a reheated pizza that he threw our toppings on when I went back to get my money back and return the pizza he cursed me out and told me to F**k off.! I wish I could give no stars Don't go to Main Street pizza if you want fresh food!! read more

Stopped in after a soccer game with 5 of the ladies and our coach, who had called to let them know prior, that we were coming. The girl who helped us seemed extremely confused. Walked past us several times without saying a word and when we asked for drinks, she just gave a confused smile and walked away so we went to get them from the cooler. Then she brought over some plates and says "plates?" And puts them down in a pile. No napkins, nothing. Very ditsy, and without a clue. The first pie (not pictured) was thin crusted and crispy - delicious! But the second and third pies that came out were inconsistent. The second was super doughy and chewy. The third was somewhere in between. The flavor was great, not too garlicky, but could definitely taste the authenticity of it. If it wasn't for the first pie coming out how it did, I would have rated this place a 1. That first pie though? Yum Oh, and as I left I smiled at (assumed) owner and said thank u have a good night (as I always do) and he didn't acknowledge me whatsoever so that kinda killed it. 2 stars based solely on the taste of the first pie. UNTIL, I was informed (since I left ahead of everyone) that when they went to pay, the (assumed) owner ignored our coach for a while, turns and goes "yeah?" WHAT?? Lol I couldn't hold back a laugh when I heard that. We definitely could have just walked out without paying. One star, for the one good pie we got out of the three. The service here stinks. Definitely won't be back ever again. read more

Main St Pizza Cafe - Regular Cheese Pie - Pizza Near Me - Kings Park, New York

I have no complaints about this place. I order pizza a lot and their Zeppolis. I do order through Slice, but when they were out of gluten free crust they called and offered other options. Super friendly on the phone. Delivery is usually before the predicted time, so that's a plus. I've never actually been there but I do look forward to one of these days. read more

Super friendly staff- amazing pizza and wings! Really reasonable prices. Consider us lifers now!

the pizza here is so good? wow. great place, great service. workers are nice. nice place to be in.

I won't be returning to this pizzeria ever again after years of being a regular customer. The owner has the nerve to blame and HUMILIATE this customer for an order that was partially wrong due to a communication error after I returned it respectfully and politely because I couldn't eat it. Disgusting behavior. Not a dime more from me. You think people are decent and then their true colors come out. read more

We have been a customer for about 5 years, it was our go to take out place. Food was always good and not a long wait time for delivery. Now because of Corona Virus we are all forced to order take out if we do not want to cook.SO WHAT DOES MAIN STREET PIZZA DO, THEY ADDED A CONVENIENCE FEE IN ADDITION TO ASKING IF WE WANTED TO ADD THE TIP TO A CREDIT CARD. Other restaurants in town deliver for free or are not charging during this time and offering discounts. We will no longer order from Main Street. I hope that is convenient for them read more

The deep dish slice was bland. The chicken in the chicken roll was actually great. However the sauce provided with it came across as store bought. Just think they need to revamp their sauce as it provides the main profile for 80% of their dishes. read more

I saw some reviews that the crust is too thin. Move back to Chicago :) Going here for years - I have a food allergy to an herb typically in Italian food, but they use little to none in the plain pie/sauce. (Like it should be actually) Now that my kid is in college they will make up a pie & freeze it to be sent back to school. (heavens to Betsey you say - but I'll tell you that reheated LI pizza is better than any fresh pizza in New England!) Want a little spicy meat lovers pizza - get a pie with Buffalo chicken + Pepperoni. Never had an issue with eat in / take out / delivery in at least 15 years. read more

Had solid take out last week , two pies , meatball parm and a chicken roll. The food was very good and we will be coming back .

These guys have the best pizza in town so much better than the rest of the places don't waste your time come here

I visited Edelweiss Deli across the street to stock up on food for a very long road trip. I then needed to use a bathroom to un-stock-up on other things prior to a very long road trip. Unfortunately, Edelweiss does not have a customer bathroom. When I entered Main Street Pizza, I was immediately overcome by the sass emanating from the two teenagers behind the counter. The gentleman tended thoughtfully to his phone, while the missus played with her shorts, which would be immodest even as pajamas. I was in a large hurry, and so rather than get into a debate about using the restroom, I decided to just get a slice. It wasn't bad at all. It was pretty greasy, but I liked the crust and they heated it up just the right amount. Given the need at the time, the bathroom was fantastic. And I still ate everything from Edelweiss. There's a reason I'm on Yelp, after all. read more

Room for improvement. I'd love to have this local pizzeria be better. For something with Pizza in their name, I'd expect that menu item to at least be worthy of ordering. At first bite, the flavor reminds me of the pizza I had in elementary school. My main issue with the pizza: it lacks flavor, or maybe just salt. Good crust, well executed, but no yummy factor and sauce has no depth. It's ok, but it's not my first preference. Garlic knots are also a dud for me. Baked well, and good texture, but cheap garlic flavor. Ingredients all seem fresh and quality enough, just a big disappointment for my taste buds. The house salad is beautiful and nicely prepared. I hope you're reading this, Main St., because i'd love to become your #1 fan. read more

Main St Pizza Cafe - Garlic salt shown here to illustrate the need for flavor. - Pizza Near Me - Kings Park, New York

Not a fan of Main Street's pizza. My wife ordered a regular pie tonight. It took almost an hour to get here, which is understandable considering it's a Friday night. The problem was with the pizza itself. I like a thin slice just like everyone else but when the pizza is so thin that it immediately falls over when you pick a slice up that's a bit too think in my opinion. To make the pizza worse the bottom of the pie was completely overcooked. It was so close to burnt. My wife and I ditched the pizza and went on to something else. read more

Such a great little local pizza place that doesn't come up short.. very friendly staff, service was timely and the pizza is definitely one of the best in the area if not the best. read more

Had to return a cold hero that I ordered with everything on the side-instead lettuce,tomato & onion were dumped on top of bread. Owner was nasty-slapped menu on counter & said read it that's how it comes. Also said "lady you mustn't get out much!" Never again! read more

Our favorite pizza in Kings Park! Delivery is quick and the specialty slices are great!

We used to come here often for years, however the last few times the food was just average. It Lacked flavor and was a bit oily, Maybe a recent staff change could be an issue. Staff is usually friendly and helpful. I would be willing to try them again. read more

Average pizza place. Employees are slow. Pizza is frequently burned underneath. Odd thin crust on regular pies. Well lit and appears clean. Parking lot is small. Be prepared to wait for your food, regardless of when the staff tells you it will be ready. read more

I love this place. Having moved from Huntington and lost little Vincent's I was pleasantly surprised to have found a thinner style pizza with good sauce here in town. Tried delivery once and it was fast and good. One reccomendation to the owner would be to have his workers look a bit tidier and cleaner. Couple of the guys look like they have been wearing the same clothes for days and it's a bit of a turn off when your being served food. Otherwise glad I gave it a chance. read more

Standard pizza, garlic knots, and Greek salad. Hits the spot when having a craving for pizza. Nothing mind blowing but it's always fresh, good flavor and baked lightly upon my request. read more

excellent pizza! Also, VERY fast delivery service. I do not recommend the mozzarella sticks though. They taste like they were microwaved for 2 minutes. read more

Beware! Misrepresent what they sell. We ordered delivery and catering over a 5 year period. We were happy with only minor issues not worth mentioning... until now. Ordered a Grandma Pie which is advertised on their menu as 12 slices, 16x16 inch pie for $15.95. Was delivered as small 9 slice, 13x13 inch pie not big enough to feed our family. 3 slices were missing! Called and spoke to manager who treated me as if I was crazy to complain & said they only make 9 slice pies despite what menu & online menu states & no one has realized & complained before me. Shocking! Manager also stated owner was not there and I could not speak to him/her even though I asked for a call back. Feel they are being dishonest and manager is very rude to customers. Very unhappy & dissatisfied. Order from Dices, Memas, or Three Bambinos instead! read more

See all

Everyone who works here is always super nice, place & bathroom is always clean. Definitely recommend going here -- they have an awesome Grandma's slice !! read more

I stopped here for a pizza lunch, which was fairly reasonable. Service was a little slow for a lunch hour, but this seems to be more of a takeout place. I had ordered some pizza and garlic knots and ordered for dining in the restaurant (which can also be done). The pizza was a little drier than what I was used to, but it was decent. read more

We placed an order for takout pizza along with a couple other things. The order was ready on time which was a plus. The pizza was OK, not bad but not great. Chicken parm hero was pretty much the same, just OK, with the main problem being the lack of chicken on the hero. Baked Ziti wasnt baked, just ziti with cheese on it. Garlic knots were OK as well. I doubt I would return because there are so many better pizza places around. read more

VERY disappointed with the food here. I ordered a slice of bbq chicken and there must have been a minimum of 5 pieces of chicken with no cheese, sauce, nor bbq sauce. The pizza was very thin as well. Does not compare to local pizzerias. They should teach the high school kids that work there how to cook the food properly. I will not be returning. read more

Been ordering from here for a year, normally not bad. Pizza is average or whats expected. Delivery times are really long. I ordered 2 pies recently took an hour and a half to show up. 1 was fine the second was destroyed, not cheese stuck to lid of box or slide. 4 slices were folded in 1/2 and looked stepped on. I called the young lady put the owner/manager on the phone. I tried(and I stress tried) to explain the situation he immediately cut me off and told me they would send another pie out at sometime , he was too busy to listen. I called them back told them not to bother and called els3where. So wasted 40.00. This is why people call chain restaurant s, the food is standard but they take their customers seriously. This is why small business fails. read more

I order out from here regularly. I find that for the $, it's the best pizza place in the area.