Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Maggie's Bakery

    5.0 (7 reviews)
    Closed 9:00 am - 2:00 pm

    Maggie's Bakery Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Maggie's Bakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    1st birthday cake
    Jennifer C.

    Maggie made a cake for my sons 1st birthday while we were here on vacation! It was so cute, tasted amazing and was delivered to the restaurant to refrigerate before cake time without me having to do anything! She was professional, artistic and timely with everything and I appreciated everything so much! Definitely get your cake from Maggie if you are in or around Key Largo !

    Joet C.

    Maggie is absolutely amazing!!!!!!! I reach out to her less than a week before a birthday told her what I wanted... and she made it happen! A local business with such warm and welcoming personality and amazing customer service! And must I say the cake did not disappoint! The filling ouuu.... the cheese cream filling was delicious! Happy to say it's a whole week after and I am still enjoying the cake Thank you Maggie!!

    a birthday cake decorated with peanuts and balloons

    See all

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of J P.
    0
    2
    0

    9 years ago

    Best cake ever! Maggie made me a cake for a Christmas party and not only was it beautiful but tasted Great!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Maggie's Bakery

    Pinecrest Bakery - Key Largo

    Pinecrest Bakery - Key Largo

    3.4(298 reviews)
    0.6 km
    $

    We go to a couple of different Pinecrest Bakeries in Miami, so we were anxious to try the Key Largo…read morebakery to compare. It was very similar to ours. Most of the ladies who work there do not speak English just like in Miami, but there is always one who speaks a little English and if you can speak a little Espanol and point to what you want, you will get what you came there for. Our server was friendly and helped us get our favorite guava pastries. Their prices are very reasonable here. They were fresh baked and smelled so good! They also have Cuban coffee, iced and hot. They make delicious cakes and donuts. And the favorite there is the Cuban Sandwich, which is generously filled with ham, shredded pork, pickle, cheese and crusty bread. They also have pastelitos and croquettas. Parking is right in front of the super cute casa restaurant. There is outdoor dining and a few tables inside also. They have a drive-in also. It is clean and nicely decorated. We will go back next trip.

    First of all they had a drive through!! Already winning!!…read more We decided to split a croqueta sandwich which was absolutely bomb af. And we got some coffees to go. Definitely a good choice to save money. Why sit down for breakfast when you can take it to go!! The line was a little long but the ladies were sweet. And it was on our way to the beach. Can't get any better

    Photos
    Pinecrest Bakery - Key Largo - It is 5:45 am , we have being waiting at least 20 min because they open at 5:30 am. Disrespectful servers we left

    It is 5:45 am , we have being waiting at least 20 min because they open at 5:30 am. Disrespectful servers we left

    Pinecrest Bakery - Key Largo - Cake case

    Cake case

    Pinecrest Bakery - Key Largo

    See all

    Mrs Mac's Kitchen II - Shrimp, fish, and chips

    Mrs Mac's Kitchen II

    4.2(911 reviews)
    0.7 km
    $$

    At the recommendation of friends, our Day 1 Supper was at Mrs. Mac's Kitchen II (also called Mrs…read more Mac's Kitchen (Big) on Google Maps). Having arrived at 4:30pm, we were immediately shown to a table and informed about the happy hour specials. Not normally ones to drink much on vacation, my wife and I instead opted to live in the moment and enjoy the island life, especially since it was 30 degrees when we left Ohio that morning. As such, we each ordered a rum punch (pictured), while my best friend ordered a Bulliet old fashioned and his wife a house margarita. With drink orders out of the way, Deja, our absolutely delightful waitress, took our food orders: sauteed seafood combo (for my wife), backyard BBQ burger with coleslaw (for me), burger and fries (for my BFF and his wife, who -unlike us- were smart enough to save room for dessert). While waiting for our meals, we took in the ambiance of the restaurant, and wow was there a lot to take in! First off, we loved how the old Pizza Hut building had been repurposed and transformed into the embodiment of the tropical island lifestyle. From the display tables showcasing seashells and historic Florida Keys photos, to the license plate light fixtures, to the ceiling-mounted blue sky and clouds panels, to the fish hanging in front of each distinctively Pizza Hut trapezoidal window, we loved it all! When our food arrived, it looked fantastic and tasted even better. My wife described her seafood combo as being excellent, with the Caribbean lobster "almost as good as the ones we get in Maine." Likewise, her fish was fresh and delicious, while the shrimp were succulent. My burger was cooked to a perfect medium-rare and was topped with expertly caramelized onions and bacon with just the right amount of crispness to it. My coleslaw side was also excellent, with the perfect balance of creaminess and zing. Our friends also said their burger and shoestring fries were fantastic. To round out our meal, each of the four of us ordered pieces of Key Lime Pie, which was some of the best I have ever had in my life (and I have eaten a lot of Key Lime Pies!)! Throughout our meal, Deja checked on us often without being overbearing, and kept the drinks flowing. All told, for 5 drinks, 3 entrées with sides, and 4 slices of Key Lime Pie, our bill before tax, tip, and credit card surcharge was $163.93. Considering the excellent food and outstanding service we received, the four of us universally agreed it was well worth the price! Pros: outstanding service, fantastic flavours, great atmosphere, and the 2-for-1 drinks during happy hour were a great deal! Cons: none! Overall we rate Mrs. Mac's Kitchen as being Excellent and cannot wait to go back!

    This place has personality and is cute!…read more The Great: An excellent Espresso Martini The Good: Carrot Cake The Bad: The server was so scatter brained. Friendly, but talked a little too much and didn't write anything down, so kept forgetting things. The Ugly: Unsure about the entire restaurant, but our table was dirty. Like old dirty. Not like, they didn't wipe it down, but more like it had never seen a deep clean and stuff just kept accumulating. I had the shrimp and corn chowder. It was very watery. We enjoyed the desserts. I'm not sure if I would come back though. I'm just wondering if the whole restaurant is dirty like our table.

    Photos
    Mrs Mac's Kitchen II - Front entrance decor

    Front entrance decor

    Mrs Mac's Kitchen II - Caribbean Style Crab Cakes

    Caribbean Style Crab Cakes

    Mrs Mac's Kitchen II - Blackened Blue Cheese Burger

    See all

    Blackened Blue Cheese Burger

    Sal's Ballyhoo's - Fried Oreos

    Sal's Ballyhoo's

    4.2(633 reviews)
    2.5 km
    $$

    Well here I am, back at Ballyhoos for some awesome food. You know I have been coming to Sal's…read moreBallyhoo's for so many years and finally decided to leave a review because quite honestly, this restaurant is awesome. I think it is one of the best seafood restaurants in Key Largo hands down. Not large but just right and a favorite for locals. I remember when they use to have the all you can eat Stone Crab, King Crab or Snow Crab for $75 per person. Those days are long gone but they are still firing on all cylinders. The menu is not enormous but it doesn't have to be as they stick to what they know best, mostly seafood with some burgers and sandwiches mixed in between. Can't go wrong with anything on their menu and they do have a Southern feel as a number of dishes have a little kick to them but do not fear, you can always ask them to leave the spicy seasoning off and you are good to go. On this occasion, I decided to go with their Black Bean Soup and the Grilled Mahi Mahi with Roasted Mushrooms. Both were awesome as expected and I really enjoyed the black bean soup; also, the mushrooms were amazing. Being Cuban you would think hey black beans are black beans but their recipe is bar none awesome. Service here is awesome and very laid back as we are in the Florida Key's . They really make you feel at home and are extremely courteous. Evenings are pretty busy and pretty packed so you may have to wait a bit to be seated but it is well worth the wait. Atmosphere is welcoming and you can hear the Jimmy Buffet tunes playing in the background to round out the Florida Key's feel. Feel like striking up a conversation well no problem, that is the norm and encouraged. Parking should not be a problem either but it can get a little packed in the evenings and on weekends. Overall it was a great experience but honestly I did not expect anything less. So if you are driving by mile marker 98.2 on the Overseas Highway, and are hungry for some good food, well keep your eyes peeled for the sign as you cannot miss it. Wishing you a great time in the keys. Enjoy and Bon Appétit m'es amis!

    Came for my birthday and this place was highly recommended…read more To start they give some complimentary breads. The big brown one was pretzel I can't remember what the other was but it was freshly baked and warm. I tried the mahi Hemingway style. I've never had fish like that before and I was impressed how light it was with it being cooked that way. The Mac and cheese was superb. Bf had the shrimp blackened and they were so succulent. The sweet potato was sweet and rich. More like a dessert. We couldn't have too much of it at once so we took it home. Portion sizes were great for the price. I would love to come again. And hopefully get dessert the next time around.

    Photos
    Sal's Ballyhoo's
    Sal's Ballyhoo's - Incredible burger

    Incredible burger

    Sal's Ballyhoo's - Conch

    See all

    Conch

    Hobo's Cafe - Crab and artichoke dip

    Hobo's Cafe

    4.4(1.6k reviews)
    3.5 km
    $$$

    Absolutely the best meal we have had in quite a while! We…read moresat at the bar, had great friendly service and good cold beer. We started with potato skins, a special, they were huge, hot and delicious. We split the shrimp risotto with mushrooms in a Alfredo sauce, plenty for 2, the shrimp was perfectly cooked and the dish served hot! The only improvement I can suggest would be crisp up the garlic bread that was served on the side. Do not miss this spot in Key Largo

    What a beautiful restaurant. They had high ceilings (unheard of in the Keys) and nice decor. They…read moreeven put sound proof panels on the ceiling to help keep the noise level down (thoughtful!). We ate inside (Floridians like us know better than to expose ourselves to the heat and No See Um's outside at dusk). We thoroughly enjoyed the inside ambiance. Well done. The spacious patio out back did also actually look nice. I wanted to give this 5 stars but my husband was not impressed by the taste (or lack thereof) of his bacon burger so I had to take away a star. I had a delicious Woodrow Chicken sandwich piled high with their signature onions and bbq sauce. When they brought it out, I wondered how I could possibly get the huge thing into my mouth. It was enormous (see photo) and tasty. I cut it in half and ate leftovers the next day. Service was good except our waitress did seem to struggle a bit. She either could not hear us or did not understand us (language issue?). At least she kept asking us until she understood. I do appreciate that. We were skeptical but our order came out right, yippee! We even splurged by getting dessert. Can't pass up chocolate cake when it appears on the menu (rarely). It was a beautiful presentation (see photo)! Next time you are in Key Largo, give these folks a try. You won't be disappointed.

    Photos
    Hobo's Cafe
    Hobo's Cafe - Hobo shrimp

    Hobo shrimp

    Hobo's Cafe - The happy hour calamari.  Huge portion.

    See all

    The happy hour calamari. Huge portion.

    Italian Food Company

    Italian Food Company

    4.5(518 reviews)
    2.2 km
    $$
    Family-owned & operated
    Outdoor seating

    My wife & I had dinner at the Italian Food Co. this evening. The ambiance is casual and slightly…read morequirky - a perfect fit for the Keys. The menu is extensive with any Italian appetizer, pasta, or main dish you could think of. They also have pizza which seems very popular. We both started with a house salad; It was fresh and tasty. For our main course, I had the Spicy Shrimp fra Diavola and my wife had the lasagna. We both commented on the incredible flavor of the pasta itself (mine was served over spaghetti.) I don't ever remember eating at an Italian restaurant where the flavor of the pasta was so memorable. My entree had large gulf shrimp in a spicy marinara sauce. It was noticeably spicy and tasted great. I tasted the lasagna which was also among the best I have had. If you are looking for Italian in the Key Largo area, I highly recommend the Italian Food Co. We stopped back before we left Key Largo. We shared a large house salad and a "meatball panini" (aka, a meatball calzone.). It was great and large; the two of us didn't finish it! To top off the evening we shared an espresso with ice cream. Our second trip not reinforced the first; just go & enjoy!

    Should change their name to Italian Ripoff Company. I know times are tough but seriously. $20 for a…read moremedium and the box weighs more than the pizza. Under 11". Never again will they get a penny from me. Photo for posterity. After eating it edit- Tasted like propane or some chemical. Maybe it was an off night, but I will definitely never be back. Can't wait until Dave Portnoy tries it. LOL

    Photos
    Italian Food Company - Prosciutto y burrata

    Prosciutto y burrata

    Italian Food Company
    Italian Food Company - Authentic Italian Neapolitan Pizza and Market

    See all

    Authentic Italian Neapolitan Pizza and Market

    Pilot House Restaurant & Marina - Crispy Calamari Fries

    Pilot House Restaurant & Marina

    3.9(526 reviews)
    0.5 km
    $$

    This is a wonderful spot with lots of outside seating and parking. We sat at a table that felt like…read moreit was almost on top of the water, watching the pelicans fish and the sky change colors. The menu had a decent assortment of beers on draft and in bottle, both domestic and imported. The menu was spot on with a lot of great seafood options that highlighted local/ish species such as mahi mahi, grouper, and shrimp. Our server, Kathleen, made us feel very welcomed and efficiently took our orders. Service was prompt and the food hit the spot after a day of sailing in the sun. We will definitely go back!

    Wow! Thanksgiving day and we were really looking forward to some open air eating in the warmth…read moreaway from the north-east chill that we were escaping. The hostess was bright and friendly and sat us at a great table with great views of the water straight away. Our server came straight away and got us our drink orders. Always available to clear a plate and bring additional items, it was a symphony of food and service. We took advantage of a special the had on Stone Crab Claws at $7- six of those- check. A dozen oysters with all the fixings- crispy calamari and shrimp. Also some delicious conch fritters, followed up with peel and eat shrimp served hot. Fish fingers for our daughter served with fries. A bar sits central to the whole restaurant and is surrounded by many tables that are nicely spread apart. Boats come up and dock for lunch and the vibe is so chill, you can spend a great while enjoying yourself. Everyone we encountered was friendly from the management to the food servers to the other patrons who also came in on a beautiful Thanksgiving afternoon.

    Photos
    Pilot House Restaurant & Marina
    Pilot House Restaurant & Marina
    Pilot House Restaurant & Marina - Lovely post-sunset sky

    See all

    Lovely post-sunset sky

    Maggie's Bakery - customcakes - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...