Food is okay, service is okay, and menu is amazing. This is one of those places that I really wanted to like but walked away underwhelmed. Everything about it seemed right up my alley. For starters we stopped on the way back from North Carolina, cute, eclectic town, quirky sandwich place with an extensive menu in an awesome historic building; it really seemed like the perfect storm.
For starters, the menu is overwhelming. It is huge and has just about any type of sandwich combination you could imagine. The sandwich names are quirky and don't really indicate the type of sandwich you are ordering. You almost have to pick a quirky name and go for it; it seemed too daunting of a task to read the entire menu complete with descriptions.
We ordered chips and dips or something to that effect as an appetizer. It consisted of house made potato chips, two soft pretzels, and tortilla chips. The dips were 'house made' onion dip, salsa, and ranch. The best part was the potato chips. The onion dipped which seemed somewhat hyped up on the menu was a dead ringer for the Liptons packet mix. The soft pretzels tasted exactly like the freezer super pretzels and were just as chewy. The tortillas were nothing special, at all. For meals we one of the steak subs, really couldn't tell you the name of it and a BBQ Bill Burger. The steak sandwich wasn't bad but wasn't all that great, I have had better at Jerry's and Jersey Mikes and MUCH better at Southstreet. I subbed out the side of fries with the burger for cheese and chili fries and I was okay with whatever the difference in price/extra charge would be. I was told when I ordered that I would have to get the appetizer size if I wanted chili cheese fries. So I scratched that, but the waitress then stated she would see if the kitchen was able to accommodate that as they 'are swamped'. Back track, it was a Sunday afternoon, there was no wait, tables open, and the kitchen is mainly pumping out sandwiches, burgers and fries...
In the end the chili cheese fry order came to fruition, but arrived cold. Too full from the fries and appetizer and bites of steak sub the burger remained untouched until lunch the next day. Sadly too say the best part of the meal was a cold left over burger...
The waitress was sweet and really seemed like she was hustling, she had tables both upstairs and downstairs but certain aspects were off. There was only one small plate for the appetizers and no napkins. Since we didn't receive a visit from our waitress we had to manage with the lack of napkins and one plate. I am guessing this is the type of place that has the potential to be great if you have your thing that you always get, for us being first timers it wasn't memorable for the right reasons. All in all we will still be searching for 'that' place to go if or when the next Boone, NC road trip happens... read more