Late night mac and cheese, to go! Waited a very long time, but I was able to indulge in some *interesting* people watching between the wee hours of 0130-0200 in the morning, so that's always a win. The food itself really wasn't that great- had the buffalo chicken mac (super blah and didn't have that spice or heat) and the Brady street mac which wasn't much better. However, it is open late, and we appreciate that. read more

Mac Shack - :D - American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This place was "okay". Lacked flavor. The pictures that I posted- don't be fooled, there is really no flavor..just a nice presentation. Not in a rush to be back. Staff was nice. I ordered boneless wings and all I can say is, they were very hard not crunchy just hard. read more

Mac Shack - Buffalo Chicken Mac - American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

This seemed like it would be a better place for take-out, rather than dine-in, but we were there and sat down. I like the menu options. I decided on Tuscan Chicken Mac and enjoyed it very much. Both of the other people I was having dinner with got the Meatball Mac which they too enjoyed, but one was served in a to-go bag. In fact all of the plates are served in the same foil platter but if you dine-in it comes sitting in a hot pan. They don't have silverware, everyone gets the plasticware whether you stay or go. Seeing how there were a few delivery drivers waiting, others would agree it is a got to-go spot. Watching them cook from the table, I can say that everyones food is made to order and not prepackaged so, it is fresh. read more

Mac Shack - 1701 Brady - American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

I had the OG mac and cheese. I'll admit. I'm basic and grew up on Kraft Mac N Cheese. I didn't want a bunch of extra stuff in it. It was. . .decent. You can taste the wood fire in it but it was, despite all the cheese, a little bland. It was weirdly oily and kind of dry at the same time. I hit it with sriracha and that definitely elevated it. Other types my table tried were the Greek Freak and the Tuscan. Everyone raved about that one so maybe those extra ingredients are what's needed in order to get the whole fancy macaroni and cheese experience. The staff were super nice and accommodating. The restaurant itself was clean but the restroom was a little on the not-so-fresh side. It's a gender neutral restroom which is always a super cool thing to see. I plan on going back. I want to try the jalapeno cornbread and some of the flat breads. Not gonna lie, though, it adds up quick and with a group of three or so it can easily turn into an $80 experience and I still have a little trouble reconciling that with the fact that it's mac and cheese. read more

If you love mac-and-cheese, this will satisfy your craving with a twist. Their prices are a little higher than expected, so we purchased the "mac flight" option-- 3 for $19.99. If you consider this option, select to dine-in, as the portion will be better than the to-go ones. Prep and cook times did take a while and we were the only ones there. If you love chili cheese fries, theirs are delicious-- not your usual chili! read more

Mac Shack - Meatballs, Elote & Tuscan Chicken - American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

It has been a running joke between my husband and I that this restaurant would never open. We lived in the building for 3 years and in that time they were always under construction so we really didn't know if it was going to work out. We moved out recently and it seemed like right when we left, they finally opened! Of course, now we HAD to go check it out. We came in today during their grand opening and I have to say I was really impressed. The atmosphere was really nice, the artwork/decor on the walls were inviting, and I liked that we have a view into the kitchen. I ordered the Tuscan Chicken Mac and my husband got the Buffalo Chicken Mac. We also shared an order of the Mac-Ting which was essentially their take on poutine. My first impression of the mac was that the portions were huge! Definitely would have been able to share one order with someone else. Their prices do reflect their portion sizes, so while I felt like it was a little pricey I do feel like you are getting plenty of food for it. I really enjoyed the mac though. Both mine and my husbands were delicious! The wood oven leaves the tops bubbling and crispy while the mac underneath is super creamy and decadent. The Mac-ting was pretty good too! Next time, I definitely want to try the meatball mac or just the normal mac. I also think it's really great that they have vegan options and have their own house made vegan cheese sauce. Definitely something that I will want to try in the future. I was pleasantly surprised by my experience at mac shack today! The staff was super friendly and the food was delicious. I recommend coming when you're good and hungry because you will have plenty to eat! I hope mac shack gets plenty of business now that it's open because I think it's a really great addition to the Brady street food scene. read more

See all

Finally open! I have been waiting for quite some time and I was not disappointed. I consider myself a Mac head, like a crack head but for Mac. I ordered a 3 LIL COWS to try more flavors, I did get it to go but it didn't seem to impart the dishes. The three pastas I tried were, Tuscan Mac, Meatball Mac, and the Greek Freak. Tuscan was my favorite, the meatball was very creamy and the Greek was a little rich for my liking. Definitely enough food for 2-3 people. Overall great atmosphere and great food. I look forward to seeing how they grow in the coming years. read more

See all

Delicious man n cheese in so many varieties! Including vegan and gluten-free. I'm here on business and ate here two days in a row. The staff is also super friendly and helpful. read more

Mac Shack - a neon sign that says life is great cheese makes it better - American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Got two chopped salads with NO RANCH DRESSING!!! Thanks. Have a nice night!!! I enjoyed my $12 salad with NO DRESSING. Dumbass

Ordered Mac Shack on Uber eats tonight and we were utterly disappointed. I got the vegan Buffalo Mac and my girlfriend got the Tuscan. The noodles were dry and cold by the time they arrived (and they were early according to the app). The Buffalo cauli in my Mac was soggy and fell apart on the fork. Overall the food had no flavor. It actually made my girlfriend nauseous. Would not reccommend read more

Mac Shack - Vegan Buffalo Mac - American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Amazing food.... With that said, the first 2 reviews on Yelp were from Justin R. and Justin K. How bizarre that their reviews are similar and they post the same posted pics. Anyways, i had the flight and all 3 were delicious. My favorite was the Greek Mac but Buffalo & Meatball Mac was incredible. I am not interested in Vegan food but I am curious what Mac Shack can deliver in the vegan option. read more

Abnormally long wait for food. My friend and I were the only two people in the restaurant and our order took way too long.. food was good tho! Would come back! read more

It's overly slow. Please stop saying Covid is the excuse. I can tell that this place has potential but lacks experience or employees truly trained to meet the demand of Brady St. Give it a try, but just know that if you want some delicious Mac, it won't be the place to get it quickly, and especially late night. There was no line when I arrived. The approx wait time for Mac is about 20-30 minutes. It's unfortunate but that's just how it is currently. Hopefully there's room for improvement in the future. I don't think they will stay open as Brady St is a fast paced environment and the critics are relentless. I won't be back and I recommend trying this once. read more

It's soooo good. I had the Tuscan Mac and I love cheese. It was everything. It's similar to Noodles Rosa but it's just all around better. (My guy got the meatball Mac and they're home made. Just know they use marinara so ask for it without, that combo can be weird.) Love it! read more

This is the type of place where you and your friends go when you can't decide what to eat and settle for something near by. Not to say that their mac and cheese isn't good! I'm not a mac and cheese connoisseur, so as far as my opinion goes I'd say that this place is not bad and I'd go again. read more

The Mac n cheese was alright... just alright. First, the Mac n cheese options are quite expensive, which is fine but your expectations will only grow. Like I said the Mac n cheese was alright. Second, we waited 38 minutes from when we ordered till when we left, which for Mac n cheese is some bs. Like I said the Mac n cheese was alright. At this point your expectations are high because you've ordered and been waiting a long time... this s**t better be the good is what you're thinking... but is it? Well I'm here to tell like I said, it's just alright. read more

Ordered a bowl of chili and Macaroni and cheese with chicken. It was not very busy but we literally waited 30 minutes for our food. My chili was colder than room temperature. I took it back up to the counter and waited 15 more minutes for warm chili. Food was good but don't go here if you are in a hurry. read more

I have ordered from here several times through DoorDash. If you have not tried the elote Mac or the Buffalo chicken Mac, you are missing out. Can't decide? They have a flight option for 3 macs but in smaller portions. My food always arrives hot and fresh. read more

Mac Shack - Elote Mac - American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Do not place an online order through the website. It will not go through. Call instead. They keep saying they have wifi issues.

Everything we tried was amazing! I'd recommend the flight if you're sharing with 1-2 people so you can try multiple things read more

Mac Shack - Mac Flight - American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

If you're a fan of MACs and trying this restaurant in hopes it's of the same quality/comprable, skip it. Spent around $40 for two regular size Mac n cheeses - the BBQ Mac and Elote Mac. While the shredded chicken on the BBQ Mac was moist, everything else was dry. It looked as though they put plain noodles on the bottom and sprinkled shredded cheese on top before baking it - nothing cheesy or gooey about it. The elote Mac was the same in regards to flavor and lack of cheesiness, and it didn't have much corn topping. If you're in the mood for mac n cheese and thinking of trying this place, I recommend skipping and just buying a box of Kraft Mac n cheese from the store instead. read more

Hmmmm.. I have a couple points to make: 1. Lot of worker, lot of customers, no food. Customers were all waiting. (Chaotic) 2. Got Meatball mac. Great sauce, but the meat balls are cold. (Maybe be on me because I got it for take out) 3. The workers were very nice. But for perspective they were suppose to open 2019 pre COVID. Would think these issues would be sorted out before hand. read more

The most basic and greasy mac and cheese you could imagine. How they charge this amount for the service and quality is laughable. I wouldn't recommend and will not return. read more

Gordon Ramsay couldn't save this place. It takes a lot for me to write a negative review, but wow did Mac shack disgust me. We were the only people there at 8pm, and I got to watch some of the employees literally eat from the prep station while they made our dish. Since I didn't want to share forks with that random guy, we had to throw our food out immediately. read more

The staff were very friendly, and the food was fantastic. It's a little bit expensive, but the portions are large and very filling.

very good and nice people. had a long wait but definitely worth the wait. got the bbq mac and was served hot and tasted fresh, crunchy onions and good cheese! read more

Mac Shack - American Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

It took 45 minutes to receive my food and by the time it arrived it had a dead bug in it. Luckily they refunded my order but it was such waste of my time. read more

I expected some really good Mac and Cheese from a place called Mac Shack. It is very below average. The buffalo chicken mac is what I got and the flaming hot Cheetos crumbs were stale, the chicken doesn't even look or taste like chicken and the mac isn't really all that good. Very disappointing. Stay away. read more

I placed an order online and it told me it would be ready in 30 mins. I got there at the specific time and still had to wait another 30 mins. On top of that they didn't tell me my order was ready, I had to go ask what was the additional hold up. Then I didn't even get everything I ordered. I ordered fried chicken in top of my OG Mac and it was no chicken at all. read more

very bland, took 30 mins to get 1 bowl of mac and cheese, extremely overpriced. would not recommend in the slightest.

The greatest place in the history of food. I don't want to eat anywhere else. Great food. Amazing decoration and top notch customer service.

We went tonight for the first time and loved it! The food is delicious and they give nice portion sizes. The staff, and I mean all of them, from the people taking your order to the kitchen staff are super nice and hospitable. The kitchen staff even came out on multiple occasions to check in with us. Its nice to see and interact with the people who actually cook your food! The front staff gave us a free family brownie with ice cream on top and man was it delicious and the front lady was really great with the kid and interacted with him on multiple occasion. We will be back! read more