I heard about M.Henry just browsing Yelp looking for a new breakfast place. Oftentimes I've found that a restaurant might get a lot of hype that it doesn't necessarily deserve so I looked with a bit of skepticism even though the reviews were almost over-the-top positive. As I continued to browse I was surprised to see that when people's breakfast experiences didn't quite live up to expectation, many were mentioning M.Henry while reviewing other restaurants! I figured it must be worth a visit and that was absolutely the right decision.
First of all, the interior of this unassuming Andersonville cafe is very charming and welcoming. The feeling is somewhat like a combination of simple southern hospitality meets provincial France. M.Henry is both a cafe and bakery, and I think they did a fantastic job with the layout, keeping the two aspects of their business separate. Since access to the cafe requires a short walk through the bakery, however, my wife and I were met with wonderful aromas which were instantly reassuring.
Upon being seated in the very cute and simply-decorated cafe, a feeling of being relaxed and comfortable came instantly. The wait staff were so nice, kind and respectful and were easily able to detect when we were ready to order, needed a beverage refill or were ready for the check.
Coffee was the start of the adventure, of course, and it was delicious-- flavourful and rich without being too strong or pretentious. I saw other folks ordering orange juice which appeared to be fresh squeezed (maybe next time!). My wife ordered the dulce banana rumba french toast which was so tasty and deliciously-sweet. I thought the combination of flavours used was just right so that it wasn't overwhelming or confusing. It was easy to know exactly what's in it and that's one of the things that makes a nice breakfast I think. It was also very appealing, visually, and just begged to be devoured (OK- no problem!).
I ordered something from the specials menu-- peach & sour cherry bliss cakes. I don't know if I can say enough about this! "Bliss" is a perfect word for this because I really was blown away and I almost never say that about breakfast, even though it might be my favourite meal of the day. When the dish first came out, it looked so beautiful because of the skilled presentation. I thought, however, that it was going to be too sweet for me and I started to get a bit worried.... until I tasted it. The hotcakes were super-light and airy without lacking substance. A smooth, light and tasty marscapone cream trickled out from in between them. A touch of sweetness was added by homemade brown sugar granola and fresh currants. Then the combination of gently-cooked fresh peaches and sour cherries was so delicious that it was shocking and also added just the right amount of moisture. Because of all this, the hotcakes absolutely DID NOT need any syrup or butter. In fact, I think that would have ruined them (something else I normally would *never* say)! M.Henry did something else with this dish that I really appreciated-- on my plate was a garnish of sliced fresh pear. Late summer peaches and sour cherries together on the same plate with fresh pear? That's not only beautiful, but was a very nice, subtle celebration of the changing seasons. Well done! Side dishes of tender, juicy apple-maple chicken sausage and mildly spicy and snappy veggie sausage made our meal complete and well-rounded.
Honestly I was amazed by M.Henry and I can now understand why fellow Chicagoans are raving about this place, especially considering you get all this and it comes with very reasonable, right-on-target bill at the end. I believe it's a bit difficult to show innovation and creativity when it comes to breakfast (unless you want to pay a fortune) simply because so much has been done already. These guys are very good at what they do, however, and they are all about freshness and great taste and texture. I was very impressed and will *definitely* be going back again. In my opinion this place has some of the finest breakfast offerings in the city. I don't see how anyone could be disappointed so please go! I want to go back now and check out the lunch menu! M.Henry gets my highest possible rating because of how it compares to the rest of the western-style breakfasts I've eaten all over the city. One thing that I wonder about, though-- today is Friday and it was pretty damn busy considering most people are supposed to be working. I'll bet the crowds on the weekends can be pretty intense. read more