Saturday afternoon: 2:30PM. Seated in less than a minute. Drinks to table in 2M17S. Bread to table in 1M22S. Food to table around 11M08S. I ordered based on a recommendation from the server: the Stuffed Shells. Sauce was meaty, a little sweet, the cheese was VERY stringy (massive cheese pull), and the shells were full of light, delicious ricotta. My wife had a small stuffed with pepperoni and sausage. Crust was crisp on the outside, and soft on the inside. Toppings were plenty and there was no space left missing a piece of sausage or pepperoni. All in all, a very good experience for a first time. Will have to come back again. read more

Luigis Pasta & Pizza - Small stuffed with Pepperoni and Sausage - Pizza Near Me - Shawano, Wisconsin

See all

We went here probably over 10 years ago and remembered it was good but couldn't remember what. Haha we went back again and it alll came back to us. My husband got the 12" pepperoni and sausage pizza stuffed and was only able to finish 2 pieces it was so filling. Excellent pizza he said. Cheese stretched as long as he could reach! I got the linguini and meatball and the sauce was amazing! It doesn't come with cheese on top like the spaghetti does but honestly the sauce was enough to make it a winning dish for me. It came with a salad and cheesy bread which was also good. May try one of their other sides to soak up red sauce next time. We splurged and ordered a turtle cheesecake to go and honestly was the best cheesecake I've ever had. I can't wait to go back again sooner! read more

Luigis Pasta & Pizza - Pepperoni and sausage stuffed style pizza - Pizza Near Me - Shawano, Wisconsin

Great servers, food was hot and timely. Very friendly all the way around. We had a group of 20 with all separate checks. They handled fantastically. I would go back! read more

The food has always been fantastic . Have been to their restaurant for many years. Even before they moved to the new location. That says I've been there for a long time read more

In my opinion this is the best pizza in Shawano. It's always packed on weekends so it's hard to find a parking spot.

Great sandwiches Friendly staff looks clean. Great prices. Good drinks a That's all folks read more

Ordered Sausage and onion pizza . Very skimpy on the toppings . One tiny piece of sausage on each piece . Are onions that expensive that there were little to no onions on the pizza ? Would not be back for pizza for sure ! read more

Service was fantastic, I didn't get our server's name, but it was a man. The food was good, superior even. With the exception of the chicken Parmesan; it was a huge miss! The chicken was not breaded! read more

Best Luigi's I've been to. Will go out of the way to visit this place places always busy.

Best pizza around, and very reasonably priced! We've had other things on the menu, as well. All good! Great service when a large group of us were there. We sat on the patio. Very comfortable. read more

Always great food and friendly service! Love the pizza, Philly cheese steak sandwiches, especially! After eating there on a regular basis, they are always consistent! I've never been disappointed! They have great lunch specials during the week with great prices! Check it out! read more

Good food but they assess a surcharge for using a credit card. It's not a cheap eats place, but just include your operating expenses in your prices and don't bother me by telling me you're hitting me with an additional 3.5% for using plastic. It's 2022 for Christ sakes and credit is the way things work. read more

I like their pizza and usually my wife and I share a large one. Consistently good pies with more than adequate cheese. Service is quite adequate and prices are reasonable. I heartily recommend the place, especially for anything Italian. Excellent atmosphere. read more

We stopped in for lunch on a trip up to door county after finding this place on Yelp. Food: pizza was hot and good with a great tangy sausage on our pizza. The Cesar salad was plenty for the three of us to share and was really good. Chicken Parmesan sandwich was just ok. Service: restaurant wasn't too busy and we were seated on the large outdoor patio. Service was a bit on the slow side-fairly long wait before we saw our waiter, slow on pop refills and slow with the check. Bottom line: decent food but service could be better. read more

See all

This place checks all the boxes: great food, great service, great atmosphere! The cheesesteak sandwich is a must.

Definitely not overrated. My wife has been going to Luigi's for years and telling me how good the pizza and sandwiches are. Now I "always" trust my wife's best judgement so I was not surprised by my dining experience. This being said is Luigi's doing anything crazy unique? Probably not. Are they using some new technique or ingredients I have never heard or? Definitely not. But the food is good. The portions are good. And the price is fair. No complaints and I will be back. read more

Luigis Pasta & Pizza - French Dip with fries...this was delicious and the cheesesteak is just as scrumptious. - Pizza Near Me - Shawano, Wisconsin

See all

Hi everyone I went to this restaurant luigis in shawano wi. This was my first time there and we walked in and got seated. A little note we did not see any sign stating there will be a3.75 % and on to the bill because they changed credit card company and they get charged a fee for credit and debt cards. Anyway we order and get the food and we are ready to pay. Then I see the extra fee and ask what it was. She told me they change company and I said how was Supposed to know about this fee. She said it been there 6 month now and I told her I never been her before so how would I know. She just looked at me like I was a Idiot. So I told her I never come here again and they need to post shit like this. So if you order 100 dollars of food you are paying them 3.75 for your credit card charge. Is that ridiculous read more

Did takeout. Pizza and pasta was very good. Fresh. Employees are pleasant and helpful

Large group of us from out of town went to eat after not being able to find another restaurant open in the vicinity. Although the place was busy the waitress was attentive and the service was pretty fast. Gluten free noodles were surprisingly good, pizza was good, Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo was Excellent! Pasta meals came with salad and bread which was a plus. Just beware of the extra charge for using a credit card. It is posted everywhere but if you aren't paying attention to your surroundings it could be a surprise. read more

Luigi's is a Shawano favorite for pizza and spirited drinks. My family knowing that I am foodie highly recommended Luigi's pizza and several of my family members said it is their favorite place in Shawano to dine. My father ordered up a couple of their gigantic football pizzas and they did not disappoint! Nice crust cooked consistently from center to crust, nice gooey real cheese and the jalapeños they use have a good kick. We ordered this on a Friday night and we finally polished off these two more than generous sized pizzas Sunday morning. If you are craving pizza while in the Shawano area then this is your spot! read more

See all

I've had both good and not so good experiences here. Their food is very good and their staff is friendly and attentive. The restaurant is clean and the ambience is fantastic. Their cheesecake is fantastic. :) I've never been unimpressed by their food. Delivery orders can be problematic. I've had them take much longer than was told and was actually given the wrong order once. read more

We were passing through Shawano, WI on a rental car road trip from Minneapolis, MN to Oconto, WI last Fall. We stopped here for dinner. We were tempted to get a pizza there, as they looked so good, but decided on a meatball parm sandwich sub and a Philly cheese steak sandwich instead. Both came with a side of fries and service was prompt. The food was excellent and the servers as well as patrons were all super friendly (Midwestern hospitality!) We will definately be back next time we pass through. read more

Any food on the menu is great! Drinks are great and the workers are friendly and make your visit fun

Took my fiance here for the valentine's night special. Very clean amazing atmosphere the staff was amazing and kind. The waitress was amazing always asked if we needed anything. The food was more then excellent it was amazing. I have ate at some pretty high end places and I will have to say I am amazed at the quality and quantity you get from this place simply above the rest if your in shawano Wisconsin and want good food and be treated like your family definitely stop by here you won't be disappointed. read more

Great food! Unfortunately our waitress was very condescending when we were asking questions about the menu. She also only came to our table 3 times our entire time there. We had to go to the bar to get more drinks during our dinner. Her attitude towards us resulted in her getting a $0 tip since we don't reward bad behavior :) read more

We made a loop with the Inlaws a few weekends ago from Green Bay, Appleton, and up to Shawano and stopped in for a Late Lunch on a Hot and Humid Sunday afternoon. Inside was full so we decided to sit out on the patio, covered, out of the sun and very clean. Our waitress was excellent, and our pasta was perfect. We've been to the other Luigis restaurants in the area (except Appleton) and this one is the best so far, we will be back... most definitely. read more

Love this place i drive 18 miles to get great tasting pizza and Excellent meatballs & sauce

It was okay. Three of us went last weekend. My wife had penne pasta with pesto sauce. She really liked it. she thought the garlic bread that came with it was dry and old tasting. She said the lettuce salad was okay if you like iceberg lettuce. Our friend had baked mostaccioli with marinara sauce. She said it was okay. Not great by any means but okay. Slightly flavorless. She concurred with my wife on the salad and the garlic bread. I had the sausage, peppers, onions, and mushroom sandwich. For the most part it was fine. Not the spicy Italian sausage I'm used to but it wasn't awful. The breadsticks I ordered with it were good. The people at the table next to us got a pizza which may have tasted fine but it looked like it had been frozen first. I'm glad we didn't order pizza. Quite a few people there for 2 o'clock on a Sunday afternoon. read more

My wife and I finally had a chance to go out together, both very much looking forward to Chicken Alfredo. We where seated and then waited 10-15 minutes with no waiter, while tables that arrived after us had there orders taken. I finally asked at the front desk if we had a waiter, she said she would check but after another 5 minutes waiting we walked out. Not Cool read more

This place offers a good choice for American Italian food. The Pizza is the best in town, and they offer fresh Sundrop from down the street at all times, definitely a good place to eat in town. read more

Amazing pan style pizza! Just the smells alone in this place are worth the trip! I haven't tried the rest of the food on the menu because I can't pass up the pizza! read more

Great pizza! Extra creamy cheese and nice tangy sauce. Restaurant is homey, with a nice staff. They are always friendly and the food arrives quickly. It's definitely the best pizza in Shawano. A real plus at this place are the amazing desserts! Save room because there are many amazing ones to try. read more

We drove 10 miles to pick up our food.. But they gave us everything except the pizza. Called them back and they didn't even offer a gift certificate. Bad service read more

My first time to this location. The pizza was good, the pasta was good. Nothing exceptional. The service was great. Very friendly and courteous staff. Was really put off by a surcharge to use a credit card to pay for our bill (4%) on top of tipping 20% seems like an added dig. This is a cost of doing business. I was initially curious about the ATM in the lobby but after getting the bill, it began to make sense. Pay to use a credit card or pay to get cash out of a machine. Unfortunate. read more

Pizza is excellent but their pasta is hit and miss. Desserts are indulgent and worth every calorie. read more

No customer loyalty will never beat here again .I went there and had the seafood alfredo not knowing that the clams still had shells on them and shrimp still had the hard tails I took a bite and swallowed and something got stuck in my throat I tried to eat bread and drink water I immediately called the doctor the next day because I couldn't talk and she told me to go to the ER I went to a ear nose and throat doctor they put a scope down my throat and said that I scratched my throat and possibly my vocal cords I called immediately and talked to April and she said that the insurance company would cover that bill.. well of course they denied it and it will not cover it I'm very upset so now I get to pay $650 out of my pocket so I will never eat there again until everyone I know not to read more

Our delivery order is always wrong. We won't be ordering delivery anymore. Called and they didn't even care.

I was a little disappointed they wouldn't deliver 15 miles away, but was glad we got our lazy butts out of the hotel and came in here to eat! The hostess was quick to seat us and our waiter brought our drinks and food just as quickly! The fried ravioli was delicious, next time we'll get two orders! We got the stuffed pepperoni pizza which was probably one of the cheesiest pizzas I've ever seen!! I was stuffed after only one piece, we had plenty for a late night snack later! If I'm ever in Shawano again, we'll definitely come back! read more

See all

Food was good if the order was made right! Ordered pizza with no green peppers had green peppers, missing oil for bread that it was suppose to come with, ordered cheese on salads didn't get that, missing 2 sides. Frustrated. I called and they really didn't care. This has happened multiple times. I have given them more than enough chances. If the cook can't get it right maybe the person packing up the order could check it? read more

Two of us were seated on the patio. It is large but covered so it doesn't feel as open air, but I bet it is nice and shady during a hot summer day. There is a small fountain and the decor is all kitschy like my Grandma's house would be. For our drink order, I jumped on the Lambrusco by the glass. It is SO hard to find places that offer that. All the reviews here are talking about the pizza. My guest and I were all about the pasta. First of all, it is hard to decide. Crab and Spinach Manicotti? Spaghetti and Meatballs? Seafood Fettucini? We asked the waitress about the seafood, because this is Wisconsin, rural Wisconsin at that! She assured us that the owners are from Sicily and the food is authentic. It is not clams from a can, etc. I was hungry for tomatoey sauce, so I opted for Penne with Vodka Sauce and Mushrooms and I begged for a sample of meatballs. My guest ordered Bruschetta. It is a plate drizzled in Balsamic with 4 (5?) crispy flats heaped with fresh tomato and herbs. We both got the regular salad. You have a choice of bread sticks or garlic toast. She advised we order the bread sticks. The food arrived quickly. I got 2 giant meatballs swimming a rich tomato sauce and a huge bowl of penne. The mushrooms added a delightful punctuation to the Vodka sauce. The noodles were perfectly al dente and not blah like some places, so salt must have hit that boiling water. The waitress plopped down a plate of 4 large fluffy Parmesan and herb crusted bread sticks, but she put them by my companion. I was planning to ask her to move them where I could reach, when a plate was set on my side of the table! That bread alone could be a meal. Hot and flavorful. Yum! The meatballs were not totally hot all the way through, but I could already tell they were mostly going in a to-go box to be reheated for lunch the next day, so I didn't say anything. That sauce is smooth, rich and delicious. The meatball is tasty and tender, and did I mention, huge? I ate about half my penne when my friend mentioned she was getting a dessert. She had noticed a display case walking through to the patio that I had totally missed. Our choices were Peanut Butter Chocolate cake, Red Velvet something, raspberry cheesecake, peanut butter cheesecake and chocolate cake. I actually think there were more, but I only remember the ones I was debating. We both opted for peanut butter chocolate cake, because I figured I had had the others before. But that cake was a surprise! Ok, the piece was huge - a large tall wedge frosted with peanut butter icing and a chocolate ganache melted over the top, garnished with chopped peanuts. BUT, it was obviously homemade and way more special than I anticipated. I wish I had looked at that raspberry cheesecake. I assumed it was the frozen stuff everyone has, that I do like, but I can get it anywhere. I may have missed out! We waddled out with to-go containers so impressed and miserably full for hours. I strongly suggest sharing with friends. BTW, our waitress was so friendly and efficient. She made our meal even more delightful. read more