Review update: After a wonderful experience, matured by an unusual sub par experience, I had yet another stellar experience with server Annie, manager Bill Holder & the excellent food I am accustomed to here. Kudos to both the above mentioned people for providing superlative service/dining experience! read more

I enjoyed our dinner at Loxleys. The appetizers were good and the entrees were also good I ordered the meatloaf and my partner ordered the steak which he said was tender and flavorful. My son devoured his burger after stuffing his face with chicken wings, lol. The outdoor dining was lovely on a summer evening. I will definitely go back. read more

Matt the bartender was the best. Good beer recommendations and a super nice guy 10/10.

Stopped in for lunch today and could not be more pleased! The service, the food! Danielle was our server, and quite possibly the best service I've had in years. She was amazing....food so good so fresh. The table near us had a few questions for the chef, and he was happy enough to come out, answer all the questions, and of course, take a few suggestions from them, which he did with a smile. I thought it was very nice and professional. Will definitely be back if we are in the area again. I will add that basically the whole menu or most (75%) of it can accommodate gluten-free. read more

What a mess..... Saturday evening 6:30pm reservations - Party of 6 in the treehouse. The place wasn't that busy for a Saturday night - which was weird. The main server took our drink & appetizer order. 2 Iced teas came out after a while and the beers didn't come out until 15 minutes after that (we had to ask for them). A separate server delivered our appetizers. We were missing one of our appetizers (mozzarella sticks). The server was obviously mis-informed about the menu because he thought we weren't allowed to order them. Mozzarella sticks came out a couple minutes after that. The main server was very nice and obviously, some things were out of her control. Nothing against her at all. Main server took our dinner orders. Tried to order ribs...they were out of ribs. Tried to order meatloaf and they were out of that also. While fumbling around with the menu to decide on something else - Let me check.... Oh wait.... We have meatloaf. Food starts to come out..... One cheesesteak came out first. Another cheesesteak came out 10 minutes later. 2 meatloafs came out 10 minutes after that. The Chicken Penne pasta I ordered, they accidentally put shrimp in it and had to make it over again. More waiting.... My brother-n-law's Rueben wasn't ready either. By the time everyone had their food, 3 of our guests were almost done eating. The Food was decent....to just OK. The restaurant is very neat but its obvious they have issues. Unfortunately....we are local to the area and this is probably not a place we'll visit again anytime soon. read more

Most of the food is average. I've been there a few times in the bar area to watch Penn State games. Last visit they charged me for Mayo when I ordered a sandwich. Not sure when restaurants started to charge for condiments for sandwiches but times are tough I guess. The Delmonico steak I got on another occasion was very good. Never had bad service from any wait or bar staff. read more

I was throughly disappointed all around. 1st hosting - many servers and people around host table chatting about how many tables they had etc. Then 3 people asked if we had been helped... 2nd - our server was very disappointing. It took about 10 min to get a server and he seemed like he didn't want to be there. He was not very attentive and only refilled our drinks once. 3rd - the food was not great. It seemed like it was all just canned food or things heated out of a jar. All around truly disappointing. I would not recommend this place at all! read more

The chicken sandwich tasted like boiled chicken, there was no flavor. Also for you beer lovers, they say $3 domestic beers, but they're actually $5. This has happened a few times. We live so close and want to come more often but it's been disappointing. read more

Tried the fish tacos, 3 huge stuffed with fish, delicious. Service was a bit slow but wonderful waitress. Others had Caesar salads with Anchovies and I heard they were yummy! Ambiance very nice, great date night location. read more

First time back here since the pandemic, and the menu has been updated. Excellent options, everything we ordered was delicious, and the menu accommodates vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free and low fiber diets, all. Very welcoming, very nice out door dining, highly recommend! The blackened salmon burger is an absolute must! read more

Loxley's was new late in the summer of 09. I've been here 4 times at the time of this review, so allow me to give a fair assessment. I give this place four stars primarily for the unique decor, social atmosphere, and overall experience. Atmosphere: Loxley's decorative motif is inspired by the whole "Robin Hood" theme. It's basically a big treehouse on the outside and a secret den on the inside. I've really never seen anything like it. My favorite part about the place is the social atmosphere. There is always an eclectic adult crowd - fun and upbeat minus the obnoxious college kids. It was very crowded on the weekends and nice evenings, but not a sardine can like the Brickyard. Food & Drinks: I went for lunch and had the wrap of the day which was a crab salad wrap with a side of fries. I give it a B+. I ate twice at the bar\lounge area and had the burger topped with crab and the southwest burger. Both were fantastic. The sweet potato fries are great. The last time I was inside with a large group and had almost every appetizer and a sirloin medium rare. Both appetizers and entree were well prepared and satisfying. Not exactly Ruth's Chris, but good enough for the price. They have an average selection of beer and wine, but a fun array of signature cocktails. I haven't had dessert, so I can't comment on that. Overall the food and drink is average to above average. You wouldn't go there just for the food alone (maybe a beer and burger). You would go there for a fun time with friends and a satisfying bite to eat. Service: All the servers I've had have been great. If you eat in the bar area on the weekend, you have to work a little harder to get noticed. Which is fine, seeing that there's a few servers for about 50-70 people. The service has been just fine for me. Summary: Don't go here if you're a foodie that can't stoop to the fare of the commonfolk. Don't go here for a fine wine list or amazing beer selection (go to Olde Greenfield for the wine, Quip's Pub for the beer). Not the best choice for a private, quiet, and romantic anniversary dinner (though there is nice seating inside). Don't go here to get plastered and carted home. Do go here for a good Lager (and by "Lager" I do mean Yuengling) and a great burger. Do go here with lots of friends. Do go here if you're a local - chances are you'll see someone you know. Do go here early in the evening with kids - they'll love the treehouse. Do go here if you're one of those crazy Ren Faire people - you could probably stay in character... actually no, don't do that. Do go here for a fun time and overall good experience. Hope this helps! read more

The service was fine, the ambiance was nice. Unfortunately, the food was some of the worst we have ever had in a restaurant. The cottage pie was greasy, no real flavor - pretty much inedible. My husband ordered the ribs and they were tasteless and fatty. All the food, including the fries were tepid. The waitress said if we had told her, she could have 'corrected' it. Like what could she have done? Not sure why people like to eat there. read more

We stopped in here because we heard about the treehouse dining, but it was closed due to weather on the night we came. We thought the food and service was great. The portion sizes matched the price well. There's plenty of seasonal drinks available. We'll be back to try the treehouse! read more

See all

My review is just for the outside bar area. Loxleys is a bar / tree house that's connected to the Heritage Hotel. As you walk towards the building from the parking lot this place looks like a big kids tree house and I felt like Robin Hood might be lurking nearby. On the lower level they have a dance floor and a large bar surrounded with high top tables. There are stairs on either end of the first floor that lead up to the "tree house / deck" area. If you like to people watch you will enjoy the upper level of Loxleys because you can look right down on the dance floor. There are plenty of tables on the upper level where you can have dinner or just hang out. There are several bathrooms but you need to go inside the hotel section and find them. They are spread out but not too hard to find. There is another bar inside the hotel that you can grab a drink at if its too busy outside. I wasn't expecting to find such a fun place in Lancaster. Its close to my girlfriends parents house so I'm sure we will be back here again. read more

Picked Loxley's for a 90th birthday party. This turned out to be the best decision we could have ever made. The room was set up beautifully and the food was amazing. Everything was taken care of and we got to enjoy the party along with our 35+ guests. Consider this for your next event. They made it easy to book and did a wonderful job of making sure everything was going well. A huge thank you to Bill and Erin for a wonderful event. read more

Loxley’s - Beautiful food table. - American Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

This is a nice place with a different look on the outside. The food is on par with nice restaurants and the prices aren't bad. We had the Ahi tuna sandwich with chips and side salad and the chips are really good. The beef tip stroganoff is on but the noodles did not seem fresh. The mashed potatoes are good and thick. The meatloaf was delicious. I would recommend this place to others. The desserts of the day are really good as we have the mudslide cheesecake and lemon creme brûlée. They have many of the day desserts. read more

See all

Very long wait between being seated and getting out food... like and hour and a half.... We almost left it hit a McDonald's drive through just because we were hungry. The drinks were very very watery... I had a margarita, another in our group had a daiquiri and another iced tea... very diluted and watery with no flavor. The building is nice and maybe they were just short staffed but we were just disappointed we were so hungry and waiting and waiting. read more

Great outdoor space, including covered space in case it rains. Friendly helpful staff, especially during these difficult-to-staff times. All those people complaining about service during COVID? You should be ashamed of yourselves. Restaurants can't get staff. No one can get staff. Suck it up and quit whining. Everyone's doing the best they can. Food's okay, basic pub grub. read more

We were staying at the Heritage hotel and decided to try the restaurant. Overall, very nice. A lot of room between tables and groups. A nice and varied menu. Prices are very reasonable. Wait staff was great. Service was relatively fast considering how busy they were, The beet and chèvre salad was superb. Fish and chips were very good. The crab and corn bisque was horrible. However, when we complained it was removed from the bill. read more

Sucks ass. This restaurant is terrible because the service is absolutely atrocious and the food is gross anyway. They are especially rude in the bar on the first floor. Don't plan on getting a smile, or even service! If you're hungry go to a restaurant that is good, because this one is not. read more

Loxleys was initially a failure of an establishment. After an onslaught of emails to management and a good month of ironing out the kinks, it has turned into a great spot for moderately overpriced food and drinks and an overall great time. There's a bartender named Scott (not me) that works there who is a grand champion bartender. He will treat you like a valued patron, which is awesome. Loxley's offer a Gorgeous atmosphere you can't find anywhere else and delicious food. I recommend dropping by. By the by, Doug the bartender is borderline insane, but he means well. read more

Loxley’s - American Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Oh man this place was kind of a disaster. Was here for a rehearsal dinner and the wait for our food and drinks were extremely long. Food was not that great and the staff literally didn't even know what table to drop off the food off at. They just kept coming around to each table auctioning off plates of food in hope that it was someone's. Would never host an event of my own here. read more

First view of this restaurant is just breath-taking. Inside decor does not disappoint either. We sat upstairs and watched the beautiful sunset. Food was some of the best I have had in Lancaster county. Everything was made just right and tasty. Dessert brownie with ice cream was delicious. Wish they had more dessert choices though. The service by the young gentleman was one of the best. Compliments to him. As for the bar service, it was a bit lacking. Need more servers in the bar area. They try hard but its just too much for 1 or 2 service people to handle. read more

We were given a gift card for Christmas. We went during the week after they opened up post Covid-19. They have a beautiful outdoor dining space with an oak tree growing through the middle. I had salmon and switched risotto for sweet potato fries. The food was piping hot and delicious. read more

Had a nice family meal here on Saturday night, 7 adults, 1 baby... A couple of food snafus but waitress Kelly compensated very well, without being asked to do so. Nice atmosphere inside and generally good quality products and service. I've been to the outside arena and really like that vibe - in good weather of course. We'll be back. Thanks again Kelly, you deserve to be recognized favorably by management! read more

Loxley's is a Robin Hood-themed restaurant (as the name somewhat implies). As a restaurant, it serves food. As a Robin Hood-themed restaurant, they give some of your money to a charity. Nifty idea, right? The food was pretty good, the service was excellent and the atmosphere was... Well, strange to say the least. It seemed like I was on the set of a Robin Hood film (I'd have to say "Prince of Thieves" since nobody had an English accent). read more

It's a great meeting place for friends. Love the patios and the atmosphere. Food is decent. Enough to choose from something for everyone. Check out the fish on the way in. read more

we came at 4 and were seated quickly. however, it took 3 hours to get our food, the food was not good- very bland. and after 3 hours we still haven't gotten our check. read more

This restaurant has a really cool atmosphere going! Definitely something unusual and very enjoyable. We really enjoyed our time there. Food was great and service was exceptional. I definitely recommend this place, especially on a fair summer or fall evening. read more

Highly recommend this place. We sat outside and the atmosphere and view is so pretty. Food and service was excellent! Got the beef stroganoff and ahi tuna sandwich, both were amazing!! And they let us feed the koi fish! read more

Loxley’s - Pond - American Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

I wish I could remember our waitress name. She took an order of an ENTIRE party of 34 people and got nothing WRONG. Nothing. We came in after the NIT field hockey tournament. She was attentive and on point. Food was just as good as the service. Fantastic. If this business reads this we were there on Saturday the 25th at 6pm. Top notch server! read more

The food was ok. I had an angus burger that was too well done to really enjoy it, The house made potato chips were great. The facility was pretty good and the covered patio areas are pretty n ice. read more

Loxley’s - Angus burger w/house made chips - American Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

What a lovely restaurant! We sat outside, we had to wait for about 5 minutes but that was no issue. The service was quick ! Their outdoor aesthetic was gorgeous ! Our server Ariana was so sweet and knew the menu very well ! The hostess seemed annoyed, we felt as if we were a burden. But other than that we will certainly be back. Great job Loxleys! read more

Loxley’s - Honey goat cheese burger - American Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Brisket Sandwich was flavorful. The service was not good. Food was not hot and excused as a busy day. We were served a dessert to compensate for less than good service. read more

It was good it's borderline could and grab my problem was I ordered a gin martini and I got it in a non-stemmed class I know this is anal but it bothers me the truth Martin you should be served in the stand class. We started downstairs on the ground level we asked to move upstairs without hesitation accommodated us and more dust upstairs food was good just slightly better than average pretty cool little place hotel is better than it seems I would definitely visit and stay there read more

Loxley’s - American Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

The room we were in was cold and we were in between two large parties so the environment was undesirable, but thats not why it gets 2 stars. The food was mediocre. Wild mushroom ravioli was no good. Very bland and the vegetables didnt pair well with jt. The pesto sauce didn't taste like there was any pesto in it. My husband got the seafood risotto and it was actually decent. MIL got the salmon with sweet potatoes and "mixed greens" which were green and waxed beans.. not my take on mixed greens. The maple sauce with it tasted like log cabin, I much prefer the real deal. Maybe the other items on the menu aren't half bad but I won't be going back to find out. read more

Ate here on Saturday October 10 for a post birthday dinner. Food was really good. My wife love her salmon and the seafood pasta I has was pretty good. The only problem we had, we were sitting outside, were the yellow jackets that were hanging around our table. Definitely would eat here again read more

As others have stated, don't dine here unless you have lots of time. Food is very slow out of the kitchen. Once you get it, it's good not great. A bit overpriced for the quality of food. read more

Went to dinner for the first time last weekend and was disappointed. Waited 10 minutes for our table (with a reservation). Upon being seated, we waited 20 minutes for a server to arrive for him to tell us how busy he is. Took our drink order and we received 4 beverages (3 fountain sodas and one whiskey) 15 minutes later. We decided to place our order while we had him there. Received our meals all with something wrong. Waited another five minutes for utensils and napkins. Asked 4 times and a half hour for the check. Once received, waited another ten minutes for him to return which never happened. Tracked him down to pay. First and last visit! By the way, I get "busy", it's your business to serve customers and should welcome being busy. read more

We had a wonderful dinner! Our waiter Matty D was great. Thanks matt! We had a complicated order and he was more than wonderful about accommodating us. read more