Unfortunately the nice part of this restaurant is the deck by the creek. We ordered appetizers and beer. Food ( boneless wings, onion rings and a quesadilla with grilled chicken) all seemed like food that came out of the freezer and was overcooked. Unfortunately we will not return. read more

The restaurant was great for Super Bowl Sunday. A lot of space and many TVs so you can't miss the game from anywhere you are sitting. The service was great Sophia was so attentive and knowledgeable of the menu because we had many substitution request at the table. The food was the star of the show omg I rarely finish my food at a restaurant and I got a to go box just to end up eating all my food and not needing it!! So yummy read more

Conestoga Restaurant - Crab Dip - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Very large menu that provides something for every taste or desire. Service was slow for this group of 22. Servers tried to help by getting checks handled even before the food came. Interesting experience. read more

ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING! From the moment I walked in to the second | left. Not 1 person greeted me as 4 servers passed me. It wasn't until | asked, "do we seat ourselves?" Then I was acknowledged. The food was so bad we left it barely touched & told the waitress how disgusting it was. Nobody came to ask what was wrong or how they could fix it. $90 for unseasoned steak, sour mash potatoes & unseasoned shrimp and chicken in watered "Amatriciana" with excessive tomatoes, if you can consider it that. I have never been so disgusted with a food establishment as this or how they had full tables! I'll never return nor suggest this place to anyone. We were looking for outdoor dining by the river. This isn't it! It's by a very congested street. Very minimal view of water. read more

See all

This place is the best in the area for sitting outside next to the Conestoga River. The Greek salad and dressing is very very good . I don't care to sit inside this place was just recently completely redone due to a flood of the river. Johann is our favorite server. I will return 100 more times and the Rolls omg I almost forgot are the best of the best read more

We enjoyed our lunch here. The scallop soup was delicious and something I've never had before. Our friend was able to order from the dinner menu and she was very pleased with her chicken. She shared the homemade bread with us and it was great! Homemade meatball sub was spot on. Would definitely go back, especially on prime rib night! read more

Ate there for the very first time yesterday evening. Food was acceptable i wouldn't drive a mile out of my way but I wouldn't pass by it if on my route. The one red flag I had was the south west egg rolls for $12.00 they were about 3 inches long and a total of two! For $12.00 (2) six dollars (1) each per appetizer read more

I got the weekend prime rib special for 32 dollars or 0.0000085 bitcoin in today's price. Steak was 16oz but it was probably bigger. It came with a salad, bread, a side of your choice, and the PRIME RIB!!!! The staff was very kind and seems like there were lots of locals enjoying some liberations and food. My only issue is that the service was a tad slow so the fries came out a little cold. For the appetizer, we got the wings and that was a little on cold and the chicken was somewhat soggy. However, this place will get 5 stars because the prime rib was some of the best in the county! read more

Conestoga Restaurant - Garlic parm and hot wings - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Prime Rib was not as advertised. Far from prime. Very tough and no flavor. Service was decent but atmosphere was very spartan.

So we visited Dutch Wonderland in Lancaster, PA earlier in the day on Sunday. The food inside the theme park was terrible, so we needed some great food to make up for that part of Dutch Wonderland When we got there it was already dark out and was actually colder inside the restaurant than outside so we decided to sit outside which was fine because they have a beautiful outdoor seating area that overlooks the Conestoga River. Our waitress was so nice and took her time explaining some items on the menu and how they could accommodate one of our daughter's allergies. The food began coming out and the cheese sticks came first with the perfect crunchy outside and gooey cheesy inside that made for the perfect cheese pull. I haven't begun filming myself yet so those small details being captures on film for the public to see will have to be saved for a later date. Our 4 year old said her personal pizza was excellent and she ended up eating it all so that speaks volumes. Our 9 year old got a burger patty, steamed broccoli, and orange slices and proclaimed, "This is the best burger I've ever had!" Success! My wife ordered a pizza and didn't realize she had ordered a whole pie, but it was a mix of veggies and pepperoni and she loved it! Said it was very tasty. I got a personal flatbread pizza that was originally supposed to have pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon. I personally am not a big fan of ham or bacon on pizza so I asked for extra sausage and pepperoni and they absolutely delivered! One of the best pizzas I've had! Would definitely recommend to anyone visiting Lancaster, PA. * From what I understand they are under new ownership and things have turned around in a big way! IG & TikTok: @bmh_reviewer read more

See all

Out galavanting and decided to grab some dinner early. We got onion rings for an appetizer. We both got different flavors of wings. Everything was delicious. Our server Amanda was great! read more

See all

Great location and neat building. Nice bar area. Good menu selections - I ordered spinach salad with sautéed shrimp. It was a good portion and tasty. The service was ok, but some salads and drinks had to be asked for multiple times. The restaurant was somewhat busy. Nice outdoor seating for nicer weather. read more

The food is always at the appropriate temperature. Either chilled just right or hot enough that you have to let it sit to cool off enough to eat. The serving portion is more than you usually get from a restaurant. I have never had a problem with the service, even at the busiest time. This is a local gem. read more

Our group of 12 women recently enjoyed lunch at the Conestoga restaurant. We were enjoying ourselves so much, and admiring each dish as it came from the kitchen, that we completely forgot to take pictures. Each dish was beautifully prepared. We definitely will be back again. The waiter was pleasant And gladly provided separate checks for all. read more

Good food. Decent sized portions. Friendly staff. Clean. A little pricey. Might eat outside next time. read more

Conestoga Restaurant - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Great atmosphere! The restaurant was spacious clean and warm. Waitess greeting and seated us. The serice and food was great! read more

See all

Hunny had bacon wrapped meatloaf (3 slices) and I had Jack Daniel pork chops (3 chops), also garlic mashed and salads. Large servings which we took leftovers home. Delicious meal and the service was very good. Weather was lovely so we sat outside. Will definitely return. Highly recommend. read more

Under new ownership. They offer homemade pizza crust and bread. The desserts were delicious. They have a unique menu. I'm looking forward to going back and trying different options. read more

I'm from north jersey and we come to Lancaster once a year. We came here on a limb because we couldn't find something that wasn't a chain that was open for lunch besides pubs. When we walked inside and it was completely empty so we were a little skeptical but decided to try it anyways and we are extremely glad we did. This was such a delicious meal. The food was cooked with so much flavor and was super tasty. They also were out of the large pitas and instead gave me two which were much bigger than expected with no added charge. The waitress was very nice and we sat outside on the patio which is lovely. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Visited this recently re-opened and renovated restaurant for lunch! Nicely done inside, very nice menu and reasonably priced. Service was great and the staff was pleasant and attentive. Would definitely recommend! read more

Location ok, parking almost impossible. Once we made it in, we were seated promptly. The waitress brought the drinks and returned about 5-10 minutes later to take our order, she seemed to have more tables then the other servers. We ordered and waited then waited some more until our food came out, took a minute to track her down to mention that a few things needed corrected. The food wasn't great, more on the average scale. The reviews say that it's better under the new ownership, I can't imagine how bad it was before. read more

I haven't been to the Conestoga in years. The only thing I could remember was that they had decent wings. Unfortunately there were no wings on the menu. I went on a weekday at noon (when they open) and there was line! I guess that's to be expected, during a pandemic, with limited outside seating areas. I was thankful that they had umbrellas because it was a warmer day. The menu that day was very slim (within the last month). The menu I see posted now has much more variety. Or the menu for lunch is different. I was actually struggling a bit trying to find something that looked appetizing. read more

Conestoga Restaurant - Tuna Melt - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

New ownership and newly re-opened in the last 2-3 months... owner is very nice and head cook makes the dough for pizza/flatbreads/soft pretzels from scratch.. the staff is great and they are probably still dealing with new opening.. give it a try and have alittle patience for new opening.. you wont be disappointed!! Give it a try!! food is good, wing nights in thurs!! read more

The food is pretty good, nothing outstanding, but the service is terribly slow. We noticed it at every table. The place wasn't that crowded, but it took forever to get our order. read more

Very nice atmosphere. Delicious food and quality service! Drinks very good! Friendly and clean!

Great home style cooking. Never had a bad meal here yet. Atmosphere is small town country. Staff is always polite and on the ball.

When we arrived at prime dinner hour (6:00 pm) on a Saturday evening and very few people were dining, it should have been my first clue. We were seated and our server took our drink order quickly and served our drinks and then promptly disappeared. We watched as two other servers took care of other tables but we had to ask twice where our server was. We were told that she was in the back having an issue with the system. Yet no other server seemed to be having issues AND on top of it, didn't offer to take our orders in the other woman's place either. We walked out and I will not be recommending this restaurant to anyone traveling to this area. read more

Happy to have snagged a table last night ! Our party of 6 enjoyed the hospitality of our wonderful waitress Savannah & the good food with a Greek twist. When in Lancaster PA, this adorable restaurant with outdoor seating overlooking a river is worth the 15 minute trip out. read more

Conestoga Restaurant - Shrimp Taco - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

This place has really went downhill over the years. Food is terrible and service is slow in a completely empty establishment. The only thing that is fresh is their fries.... We won't be back. read more

Nice little oasis. Servers were friendly and nice. The menu has interesting Greek inspired items. However, you'll find a variety of offerings that will likely please all tastes. read more

This place feels like two different restaurants. Outside, on the deck, by the water, it feels fresh and clean. The food seems to taste better out here (most likely I just get lucky when I sit outside), though the service is sometimes slow. Inside, in the bar area, it feels dark and claustrophobic. Everything feels closer than it needs to be, and the seating at the bar itself is kind of cramped. The surfaces usually feel sticky and it's hard to see what you're eating. The food can swing equally from one extreme to the other -- I've had fantastic meals here in the past, that were cooked to order and looked every bit as appetizing as I imagined. Then I've had really disappointing meals, served on dirty plates, that definitely felt microwaved more than cooked. Last year, I had lunch outside with coworkers -- a sort of farewell lunch. I enjoyed my American hamburger and very generous serving of house-made chips, and my coworkers enjoyed their meals (I can't remember them all, but I know one person really loved the wings and another liked the cheese steak sandwich) . Our waitress was pleasant, though she forgot about our table and we had to go inside to request water refills. On my most recent visit, however, I sat at the bar to enjoy a quick drink and appetizers with coworkers after a particularly rough week. The place smelled... funky. Like someone tried to cover up their dirty gym socks with lemon disinfectant or something. The bar was practically empty since it was still early, but the counter was really sticky. I've enjoyed their french onion soup before, so that's what I ordered. What I go looked like white putty stretched across a bowl of dirty dish water. I only had a few bites and decided I didn't want to spend my weekend in bed with a stomach ache, or worse. Our bartender was very friendly, but was multitasking -- using spray cleaner and a rag to wipe down bar surfaces and trying to serve patrons. I don't like when establishments refill your glass by taking it away from you -- she did this to both me and my other coworker when refilling our waters. She put her cleaning rag down, grabbed our glasses around the rim, refilled them, and returned it to where we were sitting. We didn't touch our refills. Looking through the photos of delicious food here on Yelp, I notice the date stamps and wonder if my recent dissatisfaction is because of a change in ownership. I just don't get a sense that cleanliness or food quality is a high priority here, and that really bothers me. read more

The moment you step at the door someone immediately greets you! As Hispanic, I felt welcomed and attended. We were asked to choose our own table the food was fresh and the crab dip soft and creamy. The chips were freshly made! read more

See all

Food and service was excellent. Their cheesesteak egg roll and crab pita appetizers were super. Their soft shell crab sandwich was best I've ever had. read more

We enjoyed our meal so much that we went again the next night. They updated their menu since the last time I was there to include more Greek options. We had the Greek meatloaf, a cheeseburger, and the Spinach, fig, and feta salad. Very tasty. Service was speedy, food and drinks were good, no complaints. We'll be back again and are looking forward to eating on their riverside deck in warm weather. read more

The drinks were awful do not get the sweat tea it's not sweat. The service was soo slow we were the only ones there and it took 50 minutes to get our food. In the end it took forever to get food and wasted a lot of time. read more

Do not waste your time on this place. Back in the day this used to be a very nice place to sit outside and have drinks and food overlooking the river. It's a dump now. Service was dreadful. Food not the same as indicates on the menu. The best part was listening to the lawn people cut and blow and then spray "ROUNDUP" next to where we were eating. Tasted wonderful with our food. Manager was called over and quite honestly could have cared less. Such a shame! read more

Best gyro in Lancaster! Service is excellent and great desserts! Beautiful view from dining room and the spacious deck.

After 2 bad experiences, we decided to give this place another chance. Our server was OK, not overly attentive, but OK. I ordered their version of bang bang shrimp and Athena sweet potato fries. Both arrived cold to the table, very disappointing. One of us ordered a double rum and coke, pretty sure it was barely a single. I got a tito's tea, which tasted like regular tea. Not a lot of choices on the menu, basically Greek food. I also wonder what restaurant give you a bill without a print out of your purchase. Guess with three strikes, we are out. read more

My mom came here when she was a little girl with her father, and she remembered the bartender slicing up a large pickle for her, with slices so thin they were practically see-through. Well, they no longer have the pickles (we asked), but the food was simply amazing. At one point, we were the only patrons in the restaurant (the bar was much busier). Our waitress was very friendly. We ordered mozzarella sticks (they're the exact same kind that Arby's serves), and I got a caesar salad and club sandwich. It was the best caesar salad I've ever eaten, hands down. The sandwich was also excellent. My mom and I left stuffed and very happy. We will definitely be coming back here on our next trip :) read more

I have been coming to this restaurant over 20 years with family when they come to Lancaster for the arts and craft show at longs park. it is a very large gathering. Have never had a problem. So my son came home from Seattle with fiancé to see home. We took her there. being a big sports fan she wanted test Philly cheesesteak at various restaurants. It Was the special as we entered. Great. We were the first patrons - none available. Ok took substitute never arrived till we were done eating. I do not complain but this time I am! Because party of 7 charged 20% gratuity. Contacted management. The only reaction was sorry. Honestly. read more