The cheese on the pizza is top-shelf and the sauce is delicious. The Italian beef we had was quite…read moregood, too. The mozzarella sticks were okay, but I would have preferred wonton style. We will definitely be back for the pizza. Francisco is an awesome waiter!

We were craving some pizza after a day on Pewaukee Lake and decided to do a quick Yelp search. We…read morecame across Sal's or Salvo's pizza. We're an Italian family from Chicago so it's safe to say that we know our pizza. They are located on Oakton Ave. but they offer parking in their lot outback. Easy in and easy out. The venue is not huge or fancy but they had about 6 good size tables if you decide to stay and eat. We ordered a thin crust sausage pizza with olives, peppers and onions. We were NOT disappointed. This was some really good pizza. They don't skimp out on the cheese. The ingredients to pizza dough ratio was spot on. The services was good for this family owned pizza joint. We will definitely stop in when we are in town again. We vouch for them.

The sauce has changed. It is so spicy and hot our throats we're on fire . None of us could finish…read moreour food. We use to really love your food. The meatballs were hard as a rock and burnt. Could not even cut them. Garlic bread was the only edible thing. 40 bucks wasted as we had to dump our meals.

Awesome thin crust pizza. I will be back. Fast friendly folks in a warm home feeling restaurant.read more

My wife and I drove up from Chicago to have lunch with our Grandson and his family…read more We both agree that this restaurant is deserving of a 5 Star Review for the following reasons: 1. Friendly proprietor 2. Cozy environment 3. Good appetizers 4. Great Pizza We will definitely be back when in Sussex.

Excellent service! Excellent pizza and garlic bread!…read moreBeer was cold! We arrived around 6 PM. We will be back! Great place for the family too.

The flavor is fresh and delicious. Great customer service and I had delivery, but it was warm…read moredelish and fresh tasting

MOD Pizza - Pewaukee, WI…read more Let me just say--this pizza hit every note. My fiancé and I stopped at this location recently, and as someone who's plant-based and dairy-free, I was honestly blown away. The dairy-free cheese was melty and flavorful, the crust was perfect, and the amount of veggie toppings they offer? A dream. I felt like I could build a pizza that actually fit my body and my tastebuds--and that's rare. No stress. No settling. Just pure deliciousness and a welcoming vibe. Thank you, MOD Pizza Pewaukee, for making people like me feel seen and satisfied. We'll definitely be back.

Great food and fast service. The setting is unique and appreciate the history. The pizza was…read moregenerous even for a small and the toppings were fresh. I'll be back.

Had a Company President Large with Garlic Bread . Highly recommended. Great sauce . Terrific…read moreservice. Lisa Z . Was great . Around enough but not too much . I will definitely be back next time visiting.

Some of the best pizza in the area. Fresh dough hand pressed, toppings more than just generous and…read morebaked in big ovens. I like mine a bit charred and pies are crispy and well made. Seating is tight with only 4 or 5 booths so reservations are recommended. You can eat at bar if seats are open or outside at lakefront tables.

I love a good thin crust pizza and they did not disappoint! I was warned, "the toppings are A LOT"…read moreand even warned, I was shocked by how loaded these pizzas were. I personally felt the crust was overbaked, but perhaps it's necessary to hold up the toppings without wilting under the weight? Also would have liked a bit more sauce, but, that's just me. (I'm "saucy" lol). We ordered carry-out and our pizzas were ready right on time. Solid pizza, solid service!

Our first experience with Sals was fantastic. We ordered take out and were not disappointed. The…read morepizza was hot and ready at our order time. The food was very very good. We had a Chicago style deep dish. The cheese was delicious and the sauce was the perfect amount of tangy with just a touch of sweet. We also had a standard crust pizza which was loaded with cheese and delicious toppings. The pizzas are very filling and I think the two 14" pizzas will be three dinners for our family. Will be back often!!!

What sets Sal's pizza apart is the cheese. It's amazing, and they don't skimp on it. We are so…read morehappy that Sal's has come to Sussex. As for the service, our pizza was ready exactly when they told us it would be, and they have two card readers which cuts the wait time to pay in half. Great experience for our first of what will become many trips to Sal's.

Very good pizza. Great specials . Friendly service. I definitely recommend it. Location is kinda…read moresmall, but there are plenty of tables still available . They deliver too.

Got the Italian beef with the hot peppers on the double dough crust. Let me tell you, that was the…read moresloppiest pizza I've ever had. First slice I pulled from the pie ripped all the cheese and toppings off. Maybe this was because they put the cheese on top of the toppings? I'm not sure. Usually pizza the next day is desirable, however, I don't think these leftovers will be edible with the amount of grease that was on those tasteless little square slices. Next time I'll toss in a red Barron ‍