Staff was friendly. Food was good. We had pizza, pasta & Stromboli. All were delicious. 5/5

We ordered lemon pepper wings and received hot wings. The pizza pretty much tasted like a frozen pizza and was cold by the time it was delivered. In fact DiGornios tastes better than what we paid $60.00 for. We used their delivery service just due to being tired, waited about 40 minutes. We are frequent visitors to Tybee and we will not be eating here again. read more

Awesome! I can't believe all the 1 star reviews. Most seem to be written by folks that are wound just a little too tight, or mama didn't teach 'em any manners. We ordered and picked up, and quickly devoured a nicely done pizza, served with a smile. read more

Really good pizza. Feels like a pizza place in a beach movie. Fresh ingredients and doesn't have that plastic tasting cheese a lot of chain pizza places have now. read more

Just ordered some pizza Large pizza half meatlovers/ cheese, 6 wing and some bread sticks. The pizza had the longest piece of hair that stretches across the Nile River, the bread sticks were very hard and the wings had no flavor. I don't recommend this restaurant. Picture below of the hair. read more

Lighthouse Pizza - This is the piece of hair that came from the large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tybee Island, Georgia

Don't bother. we ordered for delivery at 5:45 pm , and was told 45 min to 1 hr. we explained the urgency of that delivery time. at 8:23 they called to ask if we Still wanted the pizza. My band was onstage playing a show by then. Apparently they don't need the business. The sad part is that we liked the food in the past, but , as they wouldn't answer repeated calls to find out about our delivery, we will not give them any more business. read more

Good enough afternoon snack. Online order deal is large with 1 toppings, bread and pop for $25.

had pictures of seating, but when we got there, takeout only. so we couldn't try the food

Good pizza ....... Nothing spectacular.....great customer service....... Easy to order online...... would order again

While running errands on June 3, 2023, my wife ordered a pizza from Lighthouse Pizza. I must say it was one of the better pizzas I have eaten. It was even good cold. My 12-year-old did not care for the breadsticks. She said they were too buttery. When I looked for them later, they were all gone. Someone liked them. I cannot speak to the cleanliness of the restaurant as our pizza was delivered. But I would definitely order again. I must add that friends of ours ordered pizza on the same night and did not report the same favorable experience. read more

Quick service and good pizza. Pizza was thin crust and perfectly cooked. Thin layer of sauce and cheese with toppings scattered on top. Would have liked more toppings. Very nice staff. read more

Food was awesome and I highly recommend the half baked cookies , they were absolutely delicious.

Lighthouse pizza was just OK. We had the deluxe extra large and honestly not very flavorful. It was not "bad" just lacking. We also had a calzone which again was just OK. Pepperoni, sausage and mushroom. The service was very good and timely. It is difficult to find really good pizza on Tybee. read more

Our family really enjoyed the pizza! The Buffalo chicken and meat lovers seemed to go the quickest but honestly, all the pizzas were very tasty! We also enjoyed the Greek salad and breadsticks. The delivery driver was also super nice. We would order from here again! read more

Lighthouse Pizza - a group of people eating pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tybee Island, Georgia

So incredibly rude and still no pizza after HOURS. Do not order from here. We called to ask if they delivered and the person who answered said go to our website over and over again to every question and then he hung up. Desperate for pizza delivery, we ordered online. Big mistake. Never arrived. Still trying to rectify. Just pick another place read more

Don't let the bad reviews influence you. The bad reviews gave us pause, but we were looking for an easy, quick pizza option. The pizza was good, the price was reasonable, and the service was quick. read more

I hesitated going to Lighthouse pizza because of the bad reviews. I ended up ordering from them and REGRET IT! They are running a SCAM by adding TWO service charges to the bill. Then when you pay the bill they try and double dip by suggesting a 16% tip. Our two pizzas and 24 wings came to almost $100 with tip (actually two tips). There are lots of pizza places on Tybee Island. There is no need to get it from Lighthouse Pizza. The food was mediocre at best. One other thing... Their x-large pizza is just a Large pizza... Don't be fooled by the name. read more

Lighthouse Pizza - What the heck is Service Charge A and Service Charge B? What a SCAM. - Pizza Near Me - Tybee Island, Georgia

I wish I could give this place 0 stars. It was horrible. The food was so bad and the management was even worse. This place needs to be shut down. Even talked to the owner and he was so rude. We ordered an extra large pizza that said it was 16 inches and it came out as a personal pizza. Half of the pizza didn't even have cheese we said something and then they just threw on cold cheese on top of it wouldn't give us a refund or help us in anyway. It was ridiculous definitely do not recommend unless you wanted be disappointed. read more

Very tasty pizza! I appreciated that they offer pizza by the slice, which not all Tybee pizza places do. This allowed me to try a little before committing to a whole pizza... and it was delicious! Bear in mind that I like NYC style pizza, which this appeared to be. Good balance of sauce and cheese and a nice thin crust. The dining area was clean and the counter service was friendly and fast. What else could you want? We will be back for more. read more

The service here is absolutely awful. Incredibly rude staff. I won't be ordering from here again.

I would recommend you go anywhere else! Absolutely horrible. Waited one hour with no compensation not even a care for the customer's experience. After waiting for an hour, we just asked for a refund instead and we were told "we don't do refunds." Absolutely ridiculous!!! Please do not waste your time and give this establishment any of your money. read more

Pizza had no flavor and was extremely dry ,was also very overpriced. The dough seemed like cardboard and there was very little sauce. Our first day and first meal on Island , not a good start. Would not recommend Lighthouse pizza ! read more

We ordered a L, XL, and cheese sticks. With tip, it was $70. The pizza was ok, and it fed our family of three with two slices remaining. I expected that we would have substantial leftovers to pick at for lunch the next day, but with a paper thin crust and sparse toppings it didn't go far. FWIW, the XL pizza was about the size of a Papa John's large. If you love overpriced, ok tasting NY style pizza, you should try it. read more

Waited 1 hour & 45 minutes for delivery, only to find items were missing from our order and items in our order were incorrect. Tried to contact the restaurant to rectify the errors, waited on hold for 15 minutes to speak to a manager who then told us we had to drive to the restaurant if we wanted the rest of our food. Upon arrival, manager made no offer to correct our order since we did not bring it back even though we had pictures of proof. Extremely unprofessional throughout all interactions. Pizza itself was bonafide cardboard. read more

Ordered pizza three hours ago! Called to ask where it was and they said it was on its way. Then called and they said it was picked up! Then they hung up! read more

I was craving pizza and I was pleasantly satisfied after ordering a large pepperoni pizza! Im not sure why the ratings are so low, it was good! Definitely recommend. read more

Absolutely horrible customer service. The manager was incredibly rude to both myself and his own staff. He had wildly inaccurate pricing clearly posted on the wall and refused to acknowledge it and severely overcharged us for what we got. Would not recommend anyone else experience this disgusting lack of service read more

The pizza was goodish....the delivery service was 50+ minutes late making the pizza cold. the driver was so high he could of reached the top of the lighthouse. On the Dave Portnoy scale, I rate this a 0.7. read more

Over priced but the only delivery pizza on Tybee island that we could find. It was okay but the Greek salad was lettuce and not much else w the oil and vinegar. read more

Located steps away from the beach, this pizza is perfect for an evening by the water. We had a large crew at the beach and ordered up four pizzas (one cheese, one pepperoni, one sausage and one ham and pineapple). The crust is doughy and thick so if that's not your style, you might not like Lighthouse. I, for one, loved the chewy texture and the sauce was delicious. Some at our party on the beach thought the toppings were a little sparse. The staff was very friendly and accommodating with our order. Great beach food! read more

We ordered 2 pizzas and a salad for our family- everything was quick, fresh and delicious!

Wildly overpriced and mediocre delivery pizza. Cannot speak to an in store experience.

One unearned star. Calzone should be called quesadilla...empty and so thin it only had one side. Dry chicken wings were probably pre-cooked and nuked. Good thing the box tasted good or I would have gone hungry. The root beer was good, but they had nothing to do with that. When the phone rang, it was extremely loud and had some irritating sound I've never heard before. One of the staff told me that they couldn't change it on the owner's orders. She said that he liked it because the staff responded to it more quickly...really? They need a visit from Gordon Ramsay. Go to Huc-a-poo's. read more

Lighthouse Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tybee Island, Georgia

Upon getting sat, I noticed how gross the restaurant looked. My friend went to the bathroom while I waited to be greeted. He came back and I still hadn't been greeted. I'm a patient person so I decided to look over the menu. Everything was overpriced and they charged for anything they probably considered inconvenient (well done, party cuts, thin crust). My friend and I decided to just leave and go somewhere else. To whoever runs the place, you clearly don't care about your customers. Don't think that just because you're by the beach that people will flock right in. Upcharging on party cuts and well done pizzas? Pathetic and lazy. This place has no chance. read more

Staying at Desoto Beach Hotel and ordered delivery. Delicious pepperoni pizza and Greek salad, enough for 4. Easy on line order, delivered before the time stated. From upstate NY and equals any pizza up there. read more

The pepperoni pizza was fine- not amazing not terrible. It was slightly too greasy but good enough to eat. The salad was also okay. I don't know if I would order from here again. read more

After watching the fireworks on Tybee Island I realized I was absolutely starving. So instead of getting ice cream we started looking around for a place with real food. Unfortunately, most places that were open that late required ID. I think this is a common practice though I have no idea what is normally open at these late hours. Anyway, we walked around for a bit until we realized the pizza place was open. The three of us decided to sit and eat though it took us forever to decide what we wanted to eat. We finally decided to split a specialty pizza. The two that were the most unique were the Cheeseburger and the Taco Pizza. We decided to go with the taco pizza though I was nervous how it would taste because I'm not a fan of ground beef. But it ended up tasting awesome thanks to the taco seasonings. My husband liked the crunchy doritos. I liked this place though I might consider going to the other location as this location wasn't the cleanest (from personal observations, not just the recent review by an employee). read more

Haven't eaten at Lighthouse Pizza in a number of years, but ordered carry out because they had gluten free pizza and our out of town family eat gluten free. Pizza ok, but incredibly small and expensive. If it was just the pricing on gluten free that was high, ok, but all prices high. At Hucapoo's a HUGE pizza for the same price as a virtual "personal pizza" size here. Secondly, the "Greek salad" had maybe a teaspoon of feta cheese on the whole salad and was served with a small container of oil and another small container of balsamic vinegar????? Add to that, the shrimp that were added additionally, are tiny miniature, and are either canned or frozen at best, on Tybee Island????? Really sad with all of the shrimp boats here on the island..... read more

Lighthouse Pizza - Greek salad with shrimp???? Certainly not fresh, looked canned or frozen at best...... - Pizza Near Me - Tybee Island, Georgia

Take out only which was the only negative. Pizza was great and was ready quickly. Very friendly staff.

Did you just take a mini tour of the Tybee beach bars including Tybee Time and wet willies? Are you starving and concerned whether they'll let you in some of the nicer establishments? Are you still carrying one of your froze daiquiris and seeking a place that will look the other way and allow you to bring it in? Have a seat, you found what you were looking for. The wife and I had a pizza and breadsticks, and I had a craft beer. All were delicious. They don't have medium sized pies, so we went with a large. Mistake. The small and breadsticks is plenty enough to feed two people (who have been drinking). The large is huge and covered in the delicious toppings. Although it isn't a romantic environment, for most of our meal it was only the two of us in the restaurant, so it was enjoyable. Side note about their claims if "unique Tybee dough": the only thing making it unique is that they hand make the dough daily. It's not actually related to Tybee in any way. read more

See all