based on reviews we chose Legends Steakhouse for my birthday dinner before the Joe Nichols concert. Great choice! I had the Filet with mushrooms and a side house salad. Even the salad was better than most but the filet was melt in your mouth and truly wonderful and the mushrooms had such a great flavor I had to ask the owner how they were prepared. Truly an exceptional meal and I enjoyed every bite. My husband chose the ribeye with loaded mashed potatoes and salad and was very happy with his meal too. The atmosphere was casual and nice. The owner mentioned they fed the band that day too. I hope they enjoyed their meals as much as we enjoyed the meal and show too. A very nice birthday date. We will be back before future shows in Newberry. I would attach a photo but it would be of Joe Nichols instead of my steak read more

Stopped by traveling from Columbia and had an amazing lunch. The blacked chicken house salad was incredible. My mom really enjoyed the key lime cheesecake. We will be back! read more

What made me choose Legends? 4.9 stars on Google with over 1500 reviews. When I pulled into the parking lot I did laugh that it was not glamorous- it looked like a location for a sports bar! Instead, you found a family friendly, casual atmosphere with phenomenal food. The cut their own beef, they pick the best ingredients. The owner was working tonight and just running a tight ship. You can always tell when a business is a team, when the employees are happy. And that natural trickle down feeds the consumer. So, I was dining solo and sat at the bar. I had a lovely chat with a man next to me. Jen was my server/bartender and on top of everything! Lovely young woman for sure. And Jeff took the time to talk to us about how they are different. I really appreciated that his restaurant is approachable. I'm not even sure if that's the right word- it is fine dining food, without the financial or social glam required at other establishments. I mean- family friendly is literal. He has built a business to cater to everyone, anyone. Food- I was so impressed by everything. I ordered the filet and my sides were mac-n-cheese and mushrooms. OH MYYYYYY- Steak cooked medium rare and perfect juicy, flavorful. The mushrooms simply stunned me- I had to ask why there was a sweet taste... teriyaki sauce! I knew I tasted something sweet- it made them so extra and I already love mushrooms. The mac- it looked dry on top, it was just the baked cheese layer, under was the perfect gooey, creamy cheese your soul craves. OH- and btw, the sides were huge! I felt like I could have shared with several people. Wow wow. So much food. Reasonable prices. I had a Filet dinner, 2 amazing sides and a cocktail- $50. For that caliber of food, that is very reasonable. Tomorrow is prime rib night and I sooooooooo want to go back again! Thank you for a fabulous night- I was celebrating and your business made my day even better! read more

See all

Excellent food. We have eaten here several times and never disappointed. Nice place to get a meal other than fast food. read more

Our 2nd visit here (6-11-26): Very efficient and friendly server ("Jen") made this another great experience here. Very personable owner Jeff welcomes guests and remembered us from last time. Caesar salad was fresh and crisp, filet was prepared perfectly, the sautéed mushrooms and loaded mashed are incredible! We will be going back again. VERY MUCH WORTH THE VISIT! read more

See all

This is a great steakhouse! We were dropping my sister off at Newberry College and found this spot for dinner! The staff were so friendly and welcoming! The restaurant itself was very spacious between tables and such a nice dine in vibe. The food was great! From the Bread and Garlic Butter Basket, the crab cakes, and my ribeye meal, everything was delicious! Definitely a must stop when in Newberry! read more

See all

This is a popular local steakhouse and I can tell why. Service and food was great. We had Valentines dinner here and went with their special which was one appetizer, two ribeyes with two sides and dessert to share. Overall great deal and we ended up taking home leftovers. Started with the fried green tomatoes they were fried perfectly and seasoned well the sauce and pimento cheese complimented it well. For entree we both got the loaded potatoes and roasted corn for sides. The ribeye was one of the juiciest ribeye I've ever had cooked to requested temp. You can tell they have quality cuts of meat here. The potatoes and corn were both delicious as well. For dessert we shared a strawberry and cream cake. It was moist and not overly sweet. Overall great meal. I'd definitely recommend checking this place out. read more

See all

if this is what's best in Newberry, I feel bad for yall. Service was horrible. The food came out three separate times so half us were done before the rest came out. Potato skins had been microwaved and barely had anything in them. Burger was fixed wrong for one and the wrong side with the other burger. Overpriced and absolutely not worth a penny. Will not be back. read more

The steaks are amazing!!! I've had other dishes that were equally as wonderful. The owner is always checking to make sure everything is to your satisfaction. When we decided to treat ourselves, we head to Legends! read more

Absolutely amazing! My husband and I had the tomahawk steak, and it was honestly the best steak I've ever had! The lobster dip is a family favorite, and the fried green tomatoes were delicious. My daughter had the blackened salmon with asparagus, and everything was cooked and seasoned perfectly. We all shared bites, and there wasn't a single thing we tried that we didn't love. And that peach cobbler cheesecake... WOW! Absolutely to die for! The food was incredible, the atmosphere was great, and you can tell there's a lot of heart behind this place. And honestly, the owner is the real Legend! We think his picture deserves a spot on the wall with all the other legends! read more

Food ok. Not cooked as ordered (med rare, but came med well); Burger bland. Service very slow. Adult beverages weak. Ordered water instead of seconds. Prices charged higher than what's listed on the menSat outside bc our dog with us. read more

Legends Steakhouse - Dog - Steakhouses Near Me - Newberry, South Carolina

Nice atmosphere, nice people, good food, great location, good prices. Wonderful and peaceful ambiance with all of my heroes plasted on the walls! Especially Clint Eastwood read more

I celebrated my 70th birthday here with 6 friends and can't wait to go back! The place was casual, welcoming and the server was friendly and attentive. With seven people there was lots of food and lots of reviews. Crab cakes? They were extremely tasty. Fried green tomatoes? They were great! Asparagus? These were delicious! I mean delicious! All our steaks were perfect and my girlfriend said her hamburger was deliciously messy! The Cajun coleslaw, loaded potatoes and the French fries were all good. I really enjoyed the Mac & cheese. We are really looking forward to going back very soon. Did I mention the reasonable prices? read more

Juiciest ribeye I've ever had. Everything was absolutely delicious. I know where I'll be going when I want a good steak! read more

See all

The food was amazing, and I could tell by how busy they were! We almost left, but the owner, Jeff, called us back inside and even took care of my family's meal! Our server, Brooke, took good care of us also! I'll definitely be back the next time I visit. read more

See all

The most amazing mozzarella sticks of my life! They were so thick and cheesy. Very friendly vibe- the staff knew almost everyone's names. I will be dreaming of these mozzarella sticks for years read more

Legends Steakhouse - Mozzarella stick - Steakhouses Near Me - Newberry, South Carolina

This was our 2nd time at Legends and it was just as great as the first time! Server was prompt and attentive, the steaks were excellent and the owner, Jeff, talked to every table while we were there! The restaurant sits at the end of a shopping center so you'll need to look for it! read more

We were in town for the spartan races, and this place was JAMMING. It's sometimes hard to find good food in our small town explorations but this place was delicious. Despite them being super super busy, service was great and friendly, and the food all came out hot. The steak was cooked perfectly, crab cakes were delicious, and the fried mozzarella was the biggest cheese sticks I've ever eaten. We'd come here again for sure! read more

See all

My family and I ate there last night and it was WONDERFUL! The food tasted fantastic and reasonably priced and the service was great! The menu has many dishes that I'm looking forward to try in the near future! read more

Went on a Tuesday evening. First time going there. No wait. Asked for a vodka-grapefruit and waiter said he'd have to check to see if they had grapefruit. Owner/manager said give me a minute and ran next door to grocery for more grapefruit juice. Big plus in my book. Had steaks. They were very good and cooked great. Rice pilaf and asparagus sides were very good and wing appetizer was also. Highly recommend. We'll definitely be going back. read more

Burgers and service are fantastic. The owner is a great person to talk to the place. Feels like you are with your family. Great ambience great location. read more

Legends Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Newberry, South Carolina

Long travel day... stopped in because we didn't want fast food for dinner. Honestly had no great expectations.., but... our dinner was fabulous. Seriously.. my blackened salmon was delicious. Memorable even. Hubby had steak kabobs and they were also fantastic. Sides of macaroni and cheese and steak fries... we shared these and both were delicious. Owner came by to speak to us... a super nice guy. We've traveled the world and had amazing food all over... we will definitely come back to support this great little local restaurant. read more

Legends Steakhouse - Blackened salmon/steak fries - Steakhouses Near Me - Newberry, South Carolina

See all

The burgers were good and prepared as ordered. The steak kebabs were also prepared well. The fries were good but the Mac and cheese was terrible! Service was good. Everyone was friendly. read more

This has become my go to place for lunch and dinner while traveling to Newberry for work. The food is delicious no matter what you get, and the staff and service are amazing. They welcome you like family. I'll keep coming back when in town. read more

There were 4 of us and we each got a different entree. All of them were very good from the Hawaiian chicken to the filet. Only disappointing item was the shrimp cocktail which was $13 for smaller shrimp that had some type of Cajun seasoning but was served with cocktail sauce. Just plain bad and overpriced but tried to not let that ruin the evening. Bare bones interior but great service and an appreciative owner. read more

I genuinely had one of the best meals of my life last night. One of those meals that sticks with you. I met up with an old police department partner of mine and we needed to meet half way. He picks LEGENDS STEAKHOUSE of NEWBERRY, SC. We started with the Pimento cheese dip with bread. FANTASTIC. So good, we had to order a second. Then I ordered the 8 ounce filet, medium well. It literally melted in my mouth. And let's not forget the service.... Kelly not only took the time to introduce herself, she was SINCERELY interested in who we were, and why we were there. I've eaten at the big-named steak houses. This place is right up there with Ruth What's-his-name. Stop here. You'll probably run into me while I'm in South Carolina. read more

I've been here twice. Food is good with generous portions. Our steak was cooked perfectly. We will be back next time we come up here for a concert at the opera house. read more

What a great find. Terrific food and exceptional service in a relaxing, unpretentious setting. The fried green tomatoes were delicious, the Nashville pretzel bites had some real bite, the steak was cooked perfectly, and the sides were far from perfunctory. Not only was the mac and cheese sensational, the rice pilaf was unexpectedly one of the best I've ever eaten. Make sure you say hi to owner Jeff, a restaurateur of the first order who ensures that all his customers have a first-rate dining experience. read more

I was driving north on 26 and needed something to eat. I stopped into one place, but it wasn't what I was looking for so I looked online and was lucky enough to find Legends Steakhouse. It was a great experience from the time I walked in the door until I was back on my way on the highway. The owner was more than welcoming when I walked in, and he was the one who brought me my menu and told me the specials. I overheard him complimenting the server, and he was telling her that he was proud of her effort the other day. I thought that it spoke very highly of an establishment that he was taking the time to compliment his employees in such a manner. Both of them were extremely attentive to me and the other party that was dining. I overheard him take a reservation, and he treated her like she was family. It seemed, and felt, like an awesome place and it was all due to the owner and his staff. My steak was fantastic and it rivaled the Metropolitan Grill in Seattle. The char on my asparagus was perfect and the rice brought it all together. I could go on about how great this place was all day long, but I will wrap it up with this: the name of the place is legends and the wall art is absolutely worth checking out. They were all great, but the one that stuck out to me the most was Mr. Muhammed Ali standing triumphantly over Sonny Liston in the first round. The art made the ambiance perfect. The service was impeccable. The food was delicious. If you ever are in the area, you will have a wonderful experience dining there. Unless you are a vegan, and then you have enough problems on your own. read more

Jeff is doing an incredible job attending to guests at Legends Steakhouse and the food it of excellent quality.

i would highly recommend coming here, and to definitely get the salmon and fried green tomatoe!! my aunt and I came here and this was my first ever time visiting them and the customer service was amazing, very kind, very friendly. My aunt loved her steak bites, we did not have to wait long for our food was brought out in a timely manner, if you are in Newberry and want to stop and eat some delicious food I definitely would recommend Legends. read more

Yummy lunch at Legends Steakhouse in Newberry! Great steaks and the fried green tomatoes were delicious! Owner Jeff and waitress Nikki were friendly and outgoing. We will definitely be back! read more

Excellent food and service! The owner was very friendly and the staff was very helpful! The fried green tomatoes were delicious as was my steak and loaded mashed potatoes! Highly recommended read more

Food was very good! The service was top notch. Stayed on top of drink refills without being asked. Very friendly and upbeat .

My family, about 22 of us, showed up today for lunch, and I thought the owner and staff would be irritated by the number of people we had, but instead they were so kind and accommodating. They happily put tables together and took our order. Our food came out shortly after. The food was great, and the service was exceptional! We will be back! read more

Sorry I didn't get any good pictures of our food but it was all very good. Super clean restaurant as well as the bathrooms. The waitress was very friendly and very good. The mozzarella sticks are absolutely amazing. The burger, filet, steak fries, loaded mashed potatoes and side salad was all very good. The owner is very personable! Highly recommend! Very casual atmosphere! read more

Legends Steakhouse - A quarter of a mozzarella stick! They are huge and amazing. You get 4 - Steakhouses Near Me - Newberry, South Carolina

I requested a vegetarian pasta dish which they were happy to create. The pasta and the asparagus were terrific. My husband ordered the filet which he loved read more

Great atmosphere and customer service. Wonderful service. Food is always good. Owner Jeff is extremely wonderful.

Absolutely great food and great service The owner is extremely friendly and knowledgeable. If you're looking for great food and good prices this is the place for you. read more

After a family funeral we were looking for a great steak and a relaxed atmosphere. Boy did we find it at Legends Steak House in Newberry, SC. Not to be confused with a chain of a similar name in TN. My wife and I scoped it out earlier in the day to check the dress code and make a reservation. Relaxed and comfortable. Perfect. We met the owner Jeff Kagan and he couldn't have been more open and friendly. He answered our questions and welcomed us later when we arrived with family in tow. The food was delicious. From Cheesesteaks to Filet Mignon, fried green tomatoes and beautiful salads. Go hungry, leave happy! Chris T. January 5, 2025 read more