Been to Lefty's twice. Once for lunch and once for dinner. Place is always busy. Have not been able to secure a seat at the bar, but we always get a hi top adjacent to the bar. Cocktails are on the mark. Service is very attentive. Portions are large, food is typical tavern menu. Ive enjoyed the calamari, the burgers and especially the pork chops. Atmosphere is typical neighborhood vibe. Great place to watch a game. Decent beer and wine selection. Bar room is lively. If you want a more quiet experience, I would recommend the dining room. If going with a party of four or more I would definitely suggest a reservation. read more

Visited Lefty's Tavern and had a pretty good experience overall. The standout appetizer was definitely the fried calamari. It was perfectly crunchy, well seasoned, and had just the right amount of salt. Great appetizer! For my entree, I ordered the Salmon BLT, which was a Lefty's recommendation. Unfortunately, it fell a bit flat for me. Maybe the lefty recommendation symbol gave it too much hype and because of that I thought it would've impressed me more. Also my mother noticed that the salmon wasn't fully cooked in the center. I also tried the Thanksgiving dinner. The turkey was white meat, my dad really wanted dark meat and he said this could've been better but it was still good and enjoyable. What really elevated the experience was the service. The lady that attended to us was so attentive throughout the meal, checked in regularly, and made sure everything was taken care of. That made a big difference! read more

Good food, service is inconsistent. Sometimes they have love music check out the site for events. My favorite is the penned with chicken, add cheese and pepper. Calamari is good. Grouper too. Drinks are ok. There's a full bar. Two sides of the restaurant for seating. They have a big menu with lots of options. read more

Came here to celebrate my father in law's birthday. We had reservations and were promptly seated in the bar area. Our waiter was very attentive and friendly. The bread they serve is amazing. My mil and I split the stuffed avocado. I was skeptical about combining avocado, crab, mozzarella, and balsamic reduction but it was very fresh and tasty. I had the chicken cutlet sandwich with sweet potato fries. The cutlet was a little dark but it wasn't burnt. My husband had grouper francese over penne which was good also. For dessert we surprised my FIL with molten lava cake which was served with vanilla ice cream. We all had a bite which was very good. I'd come back for sure! read more

See all

Attended a friend's baby shower here, and they had such a lovely private party room. We have a set menu to choose from with a salad, a few entree choices, and dessert. My huge portion of pasta primavera was delicious. Our server seemed a bit overextended balancing the party room and her other tables, so service wasn't as attentive as it could've been - but she was doing her best! Plenty of parking on a Saturday afternoon! read more

Zoey our server was amazing, kind and courteous. Her demeanor was so joyful and made our dinning experience delightful. The food was amazing and the taste exceptional. I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone wanting a great dinning experience. Definitely worth the time. read more

Lefty's Tavern - Ribeye steak with Grits and Spinach - Bars Near Me - Barnegat, New Jersey

See all

Lefty's really never disappoints ribeye cooked med rare yum! delicious and lobster mac and cheese app on point ! read more

Made a reservation because it was Valentine's Day and we wanted to make sure we could eat there because we had a show to go see. The place is so nice. The staff is attentive. The food was delicious. Definitely recommend. read more

See all

Lefty's was so nice. The decor is clean and modern. The waiter was really nice and accomodating. My companion had a chocolate martini that she loves to get whenever she goes to Leftys. We shared the pretzel app which came with a tasty honey mustard and queso. Both good. I had shnitzel, which was sort of a fun thing you dont see on menus. It was buttery. Very nice. Sauv blanc had a nice pour which I appreciate. Def would recommend! read more

Very good food and presentation. Was presently suprised by the variety of menu items.

Without a doubt, they serve the best, most flavorful Manhattan style clam chowder in all of southern NJ. Prove me wrong... Lefty's has a full menu and specialty seafood items that will tickle and sate even the most discerning palate. There is a full bar where drinks are strong, and the customers are smiling and chatting away. The wait staff is very friendly and their service is on point. Even on a busy Saturday night, this crew is like a well oiled machine that anticipates your needs and keeps things moving along. I will continue to give them my business in the future. Get in here read more

Lefty's Tavern - Legendary Manhattan clam chowder - Bars Near Me - Barnegat, New Jersey

Have eaten there many times , service is always great, they need a new menu, or early bird specials, always have to ask for pickles with hamburgers, and sandwiches. have been there so many times i know the menus .. read more

Early mother's Day dinner at Lefty's. Been here a few times now and have never been able to complain. We had a group of eight, restaurant was packed, but service was still outstanding and like we were the only one's in the place. All of the food was hot, fresh, and delicious. Their chicken cutlets are so good, don't know how they get them so crispy and delicious. The stuffed avocado, sweet and sour calamari, and clams casino were great. French onion soup was delicious. The schnitzel and spaetzel was delicious. Peaches and pork chops, and other dinners and specials - no complaints. And just so you know, righties are welcome to. read more

See all

Convenient location with fair pricing for just okay food. Descent frequent dining discount plan, good restaurant for varied menu options if looking for better than diner food and not gourmet. Watch out for parking lot potholes! read more

I was treated to a special occasion for my birthday. We were in a party room. The food was excellent and so was the service. We weren't rushed and a good time was had by all. read more

Love Kevin and the wait staff Great food- Affordable Could use a little more local seafood for a shore restaurant Very good over all- staff is great- owners always here Overall best spot in Barnegat read more

went with my son today and was shocked at how horrible that cheesesteak was. I don't think it's really that difficult to make a good cheesecake but do you figure it out a way not to do that !cheese steak soon as I received it I knew it was going to be awful! read more

Lefty's Tavern - cheese steak - Bars Near Me - Barnegat, New Jersey

Lefty's is one of our LaSt of its KInD aROuNd Barnegat AnD if yoU havNet beeN gOoOO! The owners are younger and know how to differentiate between the older and younger crowd in Ocean County, there is daily Specials and music on the weekends! The prices and portions of food are MORE than generous and have YOU tried the lobster bisque soup?!? It's any Seafood dish for me from here but especially the garlic clams which again is an incredible PORTION for about $14 ! The coconut shrimp as well are lively and affordable for their size! The service is impeccable and cleanliness is above all the rest I have to say ! The servers are never on their phones or with bad attitudes and always laughing and making great conversation - the way it should be in any friendly local establishment ! I would HiGHLY recommend LeFtYs for AnY HoLiDaY ReSeRVaTiOnS , group dinners , couple outings or just a bite for ! ThE aTmOsPhERe iS LoVeLy and iNvItInG aNd tRuLy A hIddeN GeM iN BaRnEGaT aMoNgSt aVeRaGe eaTiNg eStAbLisHmEnTs read more

See all

Great place for dinner. They have something for everyone including a great chicken sandwich, savory cheesesteaks, delicious soups and a small but lovely wine list. All in all a nice place and a friendly and very competent service staff. Highly recommended! read more

See all

I've been several times to this restaurant and it's nice to see rotating specials that always seem to hit the mark, both food and adult beverages. Their chowder (award winning!) was also so tasty the first time I tried it that I ordered several more to take home with me. The staff is always pleasant and were super accommodating the last time we went and were surprised with three extra people than we originally told them (a communication error on our party's part), even though it was a busy night. read more

Amazing!!!! The service the ambience on the food all exceptional thank you Zoe for a wonderful New Year's Day meal! We will be back! What? read more

See all

Food - we got 3 soups and share everything. The lobster bisque was meh. Id rather canned. The french onion soup and manhattan clam chowder were yum. My Dad seemed to like his cioppino, and Mom her prime rib...besides green string beans, 1 yellow wax bean, and one cailiflour floret. Not bad, just odd. My stuffed chicken was delicious, and the proportions were huge, but the penne surrounding it was straight out of the strainer/colander. No sauce. Im reheating it now and had to fancy it up with my own EVOO, basil and tomato and salt. Service - the bus boys didnt bus. I thought our waitress was lovely and saw she had 2 big tables, including us 3. We ordered a $7 coffee we did not get,so I went up and had the host remove it. No big deal. Ambiance - freezing It felt like the boss wasnt in the house so everything fell apart. read more

Very Disappointing Meal Tonite! We ate here for the first time right after Christmas and had a terrific meal. Everything was delicious and well made. We brought guests tonite expecting much of the same and were sorely disappointed. I spilt a Caesar Salad with my husband. It had so much thick dressing on it, neither of us could finish it. I had the Spicy Seafood Scampi Special. There was no taste of lemon, it contained tomatoes and there was no spice. The meals were delayed as the waitress told us they were backed up. We didn't mind. However, my dish must have been sitting under a heat lamp as the shrimp and lobster were tough and dried out, and the noodles were overcooked. My husband had the shrimp and scallop dish, which I'd had previously and thought it delicious. He wasn't please with it and said it was just OK. The only positive comments my gracious friends made were that the sweet potato fries were good. We have no plans to go back anytime soon. read more

I've never had a bad meal here. The prices are right, and you can't beat the happy hour. Bartenders are experienced and attentive. Quesadillas , salmon BLT, turkey dinner, excellent. Like I days never had a bad meal here. read more

Great food and prices. The pork chops and chicken wings are awesome. They are the most reasonably priced restaurant in Ocean County. we all love Lefties. read more

very friendly atmosphere from the moment you walk into Lefty's, lunch and dinner menus are reasonably priced, most importantly the food is always consistently delicious. read more

Way to go Lefty's! So my Dad and big sister celebrate the same birthday.My oldest sister not the one in the picture and I treated our Mom and Dad and our other sister showed up for a glass of vino and birthday creme brulee!!We started with the drunken clams amazing and clams oregano.All of us ordered the same dish my sister and I upped ours for a side salad that was a nice size but very simple spring mix with some croutons and a few onions I love a salad! The meal of choice was the shrimp and scallop medley we ordered with extra spinach and no sundried tomatoe's very good and generous amount of seafood and artichoke's.My mom enjoyed her rice pudding and everyone left with very full belly's and to go box's. Our waitress was extremely friendly! read more

See all

We come here often, both to dine in and for takeout. One of the featured items tonight was "build your own" cheeseburger. Not my usual order, but it sounded really good. I ordered a medium-well burger and was looking forward to my first bite only to taste a completely burned piece of meat. It was like biting into a piece of charcoal. They thought they could disguise the burned meat with melted cheese, but it was obvious and inedible. Whoever cooked this burger knew it was ruined and overdone, yet instead of cooking another one, they boxed it up for us to take home. It was early in the dinner hour on a Saturday and not nearly as busy as a typical week night at happy hour time. Congrats on ruining a regular customer's dinner and being too lazy to cook another burger. read more

Friendly staff and amazing food. The garlic parm wings are my favorite. Also they have some of the best Manhattan clam chowder you will ever find. read more

Food is always yummy and great quality ! You are always greeted with a smile and leaving full and happy. Nachos are amazing! Highly recommend the chicken parm sub vodka sauce.... yum! read more

Saturday night walked in welcomed and accommodated super fast to a great high top in the bar area. Sweet Natalie was our amazing server for the night she was quick, smart very cute and made for an all around great night along with her side kick Riley who helped for any requests that we needed. He is so adorable and very tall ! Met Lori as well who might have been the manager she was very nice had a nice chat. Food off the charts. Delish! Fun night with everyone can't wait to go back. Jenn the owner is very lucky to have such hard-working and pleasing staff, give them all a big raise! Only thing I would suggest is dim the lights a little in the bar. See ya soon! read more

Great food, great service , friendly clientele. Best onion rings anywhere, but all the food, from bar food to full meals are excellent

Oh boy lefty's did not disappoint. The food was sooooo delicious. I ordered the grouper franchise. The sause, the grouper and the pasta was like heaven! The service was amazing it was quite literally perfect. Everything about this restaurant is amazing. read more

Lefty's Tavern - The Grouper Francaise - Bars Near Me - Barnegat, New Jersey

The food was great! I was able to make the veggie panini vegan by removing the cheese! It was delicious!! Service was great! The waitress helped us with everything we needed! The restaurant itself was clean, spacious and very modern! Definitely will come back! read more

Lefty's Tavern - Veggie Panini Sandwich - Bars Near Me - Barnegat, New Jersey

Food is very good here and the ambience is great also. Been a few times and will continue to return!

Just boring and bland. No atmosphere or ambiance. Large portions of mediocre food. Fried lovers heaven. Not our thing.

Tonight I went to Lefty's Tavern. I realized it was crowded. The hostess & manager asked if we wouldn't mind sitting at a high top. That wasn't an issue. The issue was that we waited at least 15 minutes for the server to come to our table and acknowledge that we were there. But the server went to another table that came in after us and took their order. That's when we decided to leave. I told the manager that I was not happy with the service. Instead of apologizing he was very rude and said that they were busy and trying their best. All I asked for was a sincere apology and I didn't get it. Very disappointed. read more

Fantastic! What a find! Great food. Nice dining room and an adjacent bar. The owner greeted us and was charming and welcoming. Home made dessert... fabulous. Can't wait to go back. read more

Love this place! The people are great when it comes to service and very friendly. The food is very well made! we didn't have a long wait at all either. The ambiance isn't anything that amazing. Just simple but still nice. I feel everything helps that the decor isn't such a huge deal. read more

Don't know where to begin. Awesome staff, great ambiance, excellent food. Have eaten here several times now & every experience was perfect. Always order something different & have never been disappointed. Food is well seasoned & cooked to perfection. read more