It's Reigning Whiskers & Paws is an amazing pet boutique. It truly is a one of a kind shop focusing…read moreon the care and needs of dogs & cats and their owners and friends. Visiting the store is quite an experience. There is a vast variety of hard to find quality health conscious food supplies in stock. If you can't find it, they can be ordered. The owner and staff are thoroughly knowledgeable. They are pet owners and have been for years. Once a month guest speakers are on the premises to talk shop about pets! The variety of esoteric and eclectic pet supplies is amazing. It is well worth the trip to stop by and check out this amazing store.

EDITED on 4/19. A Customer Service Manager contacted me to issue a refund for the difference in…read moreprice & apologized for the confusing message about price match. Since I did have both receipts, I would be eligible for the refund. I think a new employee misunderstood their policy. They also gave me bonus points and a coupon which I felt was very nice and very good customer service!

Friendliest and most knowledgeable people in the garden and farming buisness!! I love going there!!read more

We recently bought a bunny from here. I knew very little about bunny's. . Sean stepped in and…read moreanswered all of my questions and helped me pick out everything we needed to get started. Pickles is thriving. Very healthy, no issues. Will be going back soon to stock back up on supplies.

Ava is a excellent employee. Always so kind and honest. She's very helpful in dog department!read more

Pet sense is a very good pet supply store. They have pretty much everything you would find in other…read morepet stores, however the prices here are very good. Today I bought my dog an all leather collar. I had priced it at two other pet stores at $20 and $30. I bought it here for $16. Awesome!!! It is worth stopping in if you are in the area shopping.

i was considering getting a dog and was doing some research - how much do dog diapers cost? well -…read morethey had a few to pick from and i am glad i checked this place out before getting a dog that needs diapers. other pet supplies here were reasonably priced and the staff was friendly. for a pet store it did not smell like wet dogs, which is a plus.

They have Open Farm, which is one of the best, humanely sourced dog foods that you can buy in a pet…read morestore along with Stella and Chewy brand. I always have trouble finding Small Breed in the 4 Lbs size bags in most pet stores. They have plenty! Very happy I found this place. I didn't even know they existed until today.

I used to love this place. The staff is fine, the products are good (if you can get them). My main…read moreproblem with Choice Pet now is stocking issues. I've been a customer for about 10 years, currently I am buying 4 different items from this store... treats, canned pumpkin, chicken (bone) broth, and meal toppers for my dog. I stop in anywhere from two to four times every month to replenish my stock of each item...lately, over the course of the last 2 months, at least one of these items is out of stock for weeks at a time. When I ask about stocking issues (because I never used to experience this), they claim that the system automatically re-orders items as they are sold from the store, this is simply untrue based on frequent out of stock issues for days or weeks at a time.

I have been visiting One Stop Pet Shop regularly this summer as we have been living in Montauk. I…read morewas already familiar with the business from my parents buying dog food there when I was younger, so once we knew we'd be spending the whole summer in Montauk this year and would need to provide for our two young guinea pigs, I knew I'd want to do so through a local business and I contacted One Stop in advance of our arrival to order some supplies. They were helpful and efficient over the phone and made a special order from their supplier for what I would need so that it would be ready when I arrived, not requiring me to pay in advance. Throughout the summer I have visited several more times to stock up on hay for my piggies as well as some fun new toys and treats for them. Not all pet stores cater to small pets and I have been pleased with their reliable stock of what I need most (lots of quality hay, at the same price as the big chain stores) along with some fun extras. My young kids have been with me on most visits and have been treated kindly in the store, and the staff has always been helpful, organized and efficient. I will definitely continue to return to stock up for our piggies whenever we are on the east end!

Very handy to have cat and bird supplies locally. Always…read morefriendly and knowledgable.

Friendly and informed advice. Private parking lot is a plus since the shop is on a very busy…read morestreet where parking is a premium.

We were visiting Mystic and came upon this gem! We had an…read moreincredible experience with the owner and learned a few tricks for our puppy at the same time . See for yourself you won't be disappointed!

Jackie in grooming is the best! She handles my super squirmy little lady like a champ!read more

I am a frequent flyer at this location and although there is many times you wait at the register…read morethe guys Zak , Nick etc as well as girls Jill my favorite ! They are all helpful kind always ask about pets and thank for the donations absolutely every time. Greatly appreciated

This is the epitome of great local small business. In the hobby it's referred to as a LFS, they…read morecater to both fresh and saltwater (always looking for newly captive bred fish). They offer friendly advice and recommendations for you and your tank. They also sell live rock, RODI and Saltwater itself. They have a good selection of saltwater fish and will order anything you need. Good family owned store...a step back in time!

It's good pet shop u can find good deals u most ask the stuff first , place needs to be more…read moreorganize but I like ill come back again