11/6/2025 @ 1:30p.m. I bought 2 flans for my co-worker's birthday. . . We got severely ill. Co-worker took 2 bites and remarked "this doesn't taste right". I was like hmmm. I ate more than she and as a consequence was sicker. I called the bakery this morning to inform them in the hopes of preventing others from being affected the same way. The young lady was very cavalier and unconcerned. Anyhoo will not ever go there again. read more

Shout out to you all. The cake for our event was great, the look, texture and taste. I wanted to say thank you. Everyone loved the cake. We didn't even have a piece to take home. I will definitely go and recommend you for all my Bakery needs. Thank you read more

La Pinata Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

The mango tres leche cake is to die for. Although prices have increased over the years, they maintained the taste and quality of their tres leches cakes, so worth it. No tables available to eat inside since covid. Staff are cordial and friendly. Best mexican bakery in town! read more

La Pinata Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

Amazing cakes... love there chocolate cheese cake, hot chocolate, Churros, Tres leches etc. There cakes are always fresh. read more

La Pinata Bakery - Cake made fresh for daughter's birthday - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

cakes are amazing but the workers attitude is ridiculous. Do better because your prices are too high to have shitty service.

Terrible! Horrendous service and poor quality food. If I could give this place 0 stars I would. I had called early on and placed an order for a tres leche cake with whip cream, strawberries & peaches, thin layer of dulce de leche with almonds on the side along with it saying happy birthday mom on the cake. The lady had repeated my order exactly as what I said and told me it would cost around $50 or so because of the additions, no problem. I live in Long Island and told the lady taking my order that I would like to pick it up early because I live 2 hours away which she was accommodating and said okay to 9AM. On February 11, when I went to pick up the cake it did not have the writing on top and the nuts were very scarce. I had asked the young lady to please put more nuts since there was barely any. Once I paid I just received back the receipt and said if I can have a bag. She stated they charge $1.50 for the bag and I said okay I will pay but then told me there is a $7 min since I was paying with a card. So, I just carried the box. Finally, when it came to opening the cake for everyone and cutting a slice I realized this was the completely wrong order. I had given my mom the first slice hoping it would still be good just different but she couldn't finish it. Just like that the whole cake was thrown out. I was so upset and embarrassed that I had brought this cake for my Mother's birthday. It was such a terrible feeling of disappointment. The mousse was so thick and the whipped cream was overwhelmingly thick. The next day (Feb 12) I had called early in the morning and told the bakery my situation that I got the wrong order and could even send them photos. I spoke with a lady named Miriam who really made my experience even more unpleasant. What had happen was that the young lady from the day I picked up the cake did not give me a yellow copy of the order I only got the payment receipt. On that order someone had crossed out the strawberry and peaches and wrote caramel mousse. I told Miriam this is incorrect I never stated that. To make it more unpleasant this lady was inconsiderate and rude towards the end. Because I didn't get that order receipt I couldn't fight my case. Stating that they can give me a $5 store credit. But can't reimburse me. I stated I would like to talk to the boss and she said she would leave a message and the boss would get back to me but because the boss doesn't come everyday just here and there that she can't give me a definite period as to when the boss will contact me. So, I waited the whole day on February 13 and got no call. I called again on February 14 and finally spoke to a lady who was much more pleasant and helpful. I told her I was expecting a call and just wanted to see if the boss was available. The lady said she will see if there was any message left and as to my surprise the lady informs me that no message was left. Miriam had told me she left a message for their boss. I do not appreciate being lied to which made me even more upset. However, the lady was much more understanding of my situation and gave me a number to reach out to so I can send photos of what I received. Which, is what I wanted to do early on but Miriam was not at all helpful. I sent the pictures to the number and Miriam calls me back which I really wasn't too happy about. Stating she spoke with the boss and can only give me $22 store credit for their bakery, when I physically go they can service it. Which I had repeatedly said I live in Long Island. Tolls are not cheap. I have never experienced this before and never wrote such a detailed review like this for a bakery. What upsets me is how inconsiderate and unprofessional this bakery has been. I would stick to much better places& with better customer services such as Martha's country bakery. But I wanted to support this bakery because it's wasn't just me but my whole family that has been coming here for 10+ years. However, most definitely we agreed to never go back to this bakery. Horrendous experience!! Please don't waste your time and money. read more

See all

This bakery used to be my favorite but the prices are outrageous for a lot of cream on a small cake. That being said Tres Leche is my favorite! read more

I have been getting all my cakes and sweets from this place for years Everyone there is amazing and professional especially the owner. If anyone needs a cake or special order please visit them. Look at my recent order. read more

La Pinata Bakery - My godsons 16th birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

This was no good at all payed a lot of money for this cake and it was supposed to be a tres leches but it had no milk at all horribly dry and no flavor it tasted liked it's been there for days read more

La Pinata Bakery - a piece of cake with a bite taken out of it - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

I just when this morning they didn't want to take care of me and my mom they were very racist and nasty people that came after us was taking care off they very disorganized and rude I won't ever come into this place they act like they never seen black people read more

I've ordered two cakes now and have been very pleased. The bakers/decorators are extremely talented: they can replicate any design with perfection. Both cakes were strawberry shortcake and delicious as well as beautiful. I'm also impressed with the service: the ladies that take orders are very professional and efficient. read more

La Pinata Bakery - Bridal shower cake - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

a very good spanish theme bakery in yonkers that has a abundant amount of cookies , pastries , pies , cakes , etc , with theme cakes as the anchor. came by with a friend to pick up a birthday cake and while she was doing her biz , i notice a decent selection of italian pastries including cannolis and napoleons and i will never say no to a custard filled eclairs . they do a very good job of displaying all the sweets in plain view and i better not look to much as i feel my waist line getting bigger. after finishing both the chocolate shell cannolli and most of the eclair ,i can honestly say that this bakery in yonkers will see me again to get more goodies . 4.5 stars on my yelp meter and my work staff really enjoyed the assorted 2 pounds of mini cookies so much that they didnt leave one crumb left in the box read more

They did amazing with decorating my daughters first birthday cake, flavors were delicious and moist, but failed to listen to the main ingredient where each type of cake was suppose to go. I had more leftover than expected because of it. Expensive ($320) for 50 people, if my family wasn't paying for it I would have totally purchased elsewhere. read more

La Pinata Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

The cakes here were good a couple of months ago and the prices were fair but all of the sudden quality decreased and the prices went up. The other day went to pick up a custom order we made over the phone and we asked for the cake to be for 8-10 people. When we went to pick it up the cake was smaller than what we asked for AND we had to buy another cake(the cake show in the pictures below). This cake mas more filling than actual cake and it seemed like the filling was old because after an hour or so the cake became inedible and we had to throw it out. We are extremely disappointed. You just lost a customer. If I could I would give you zero stars but since it's not possible you only get one star. read more

La Pinata Bakery - The cake - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

used to come here for years Always gotten my cakes from them. Big cakes as well called for an order for a small order and they tried to take advantage of the prices. Lost me as a customer. read more

Such a bad experience at this place! The manager Roberto was very nice and tried to fix the issue by charging me 1/2 price, but the girl at the counter was completely useless and had a bad attitude as if I was wrong for expecting my cake to look like the picture. Definitely not going back to this place. If you want a cake with a basic design, then this is the place for you. If you're looking for a cake made by a professional, avoid this place at all costs. Look at the pictures and let me know what YOU think. OH...AND THEY MISSPELLED "DETECTIVE" THE FIRST TIME AROUND. THE MANAGER HAD TO FIX IT. Smh. read more

La Pinata Bakery - What I received. - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

This bakery USED to have good quality years ago when they were a small but ever since their renovations. It seems that quantity has overtaken QUALITY. They do want to charge the big bucks for a cake but it's always a disappointment at pick up because quality is not delivered. Resenlly I order a cheese cake for a birthday of my nice. My surprise was cake was not cheese it only had a thin layer of cheese . They are super sloppy with their work & don't care about the customer one bit. You don't get what you pay for. I will never use this bakery again. Don't make the same mistake I did. Horrible customer service. Definitely recommend driving the extra mile to another local bakery where you will get quality, there's plenty in Yonkers. read more

La Pinata Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

I ordered a custom tres leches cake for a 10-person bridal shower and every single one of my friends and family enjoyed it. Prior to the event, I discussed cake details through text with Kathy and Miriam, who were very accommodating and helpful. I sent a picture of what I wanted and the cake was made just like I envisioned and even better. The berry mousse filling was a big hit and the cake wasn't overwhelmingly sweet. The price was reasonable as well. It was perfect! read more

La Pinata Bakery - Custom tres leches cake with berry mousse filling. - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Way overpriced and the quality of their products has declined. They have inflated the price of their cakes and don't even ask about the cookies. So not worth it. Plenty of other bakeries with better quality Ingredients and better pricing. read more

This is an amazing bakery! Get there early and you see the bakers bringing out the fresh warm pan de dulce. I saw the manager dealing with a situation, which was handled very professionally. All the girls that work there are always so pleasant and efficient . They keep the lines moving for such a busy place. Everything looks and tastes even better! I have been coming to this bakery for 6 years and will continue to keep recommending. read more

La Pinata Bakery - Red Velvet "Coco" themed cake. It was beautifully made and tasted as amazing as it looks! Best red velvet Fondant cake I've had! - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

My place to order very personalized cookies and cakes. They have been in Yonkers for many years.

This red velvet cake is delicious! I ordered over the phone for my fiancé's birthday and he loved it! Great friendly service and delicious cakes! read more

Very beautiful cakes , professional staff and the cake is NOT sweet which is a plus to me I will definitely continue on coming here !!

I would just like to thank the staff at LaPinata Bakery in Yonkers, NY for the excellent service that they provided to me. They did a huge favor for me in delivering a birthday cake. This is not something that they normally do as they deliver tier cakes. I explained my circumstances with the geography of the situation, and was met with empathy. They agreed to deliver the cake for me. I can't thank them enough for the joy that they brought to the birthday person and me! I highly recommend them! I was told by the birthday person that the cake was as she said FANTASTIC!!!! Thank you again!!!!! read more

I had the best experience at this bakery. A couple of my coworkers had recommended it to me so I decided to get a cake for my boyfriends birthday. I had asked for the cake to be ready the day of which was Memorial Day. After I had picked up the cake I was walking into my building and I tripped. I obviously knew instantly I ruined the cake. I was devastated. I called La Piñata, explained what happened and they told me to come right back. I rushed back over and they fixed the cake completely within 15 minutes. I was so grateful and they weren't even upset about it. As I waited for the cake I had some of their rainbow cookies....SO GOOD! I thank you guys for providing great service and delicious sweets!!!! read more

La Pinata Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

This is the only bakery I go to, I always leave happy and satisfied with my purchase ! I love their cookies and sweet bread ! read more

La Pinata Bakery - Short and sweet !!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

I have been going to this bakery for years for their Strawberry cheesecake. The glazed strawberries on top make this cheesecake my absolute favorite. A must try! I also love their Mexican bread/cakes.They are so colorful and delicious - it's worth a trip just for that. Recently, I ordered a custom cake for my fiance's 30th birthday. I found a picture of what I wanted online and sent it to them to see if they could replicate it. Not only did they replicate the cake design perfectly, but they did it in the less than one week's time. The cake was so fresh and delicious, it was the talk of the party! I really can't compliment this place enough. It's a hidden gem in Yonkers. read more

Love the tres leches cake with strawberries and peach! Light and delicious. Totally recommend for birthdays or any occasion.

Sorry.im be Costomer for long time that good on time now not so good because the price is to high also some workers is inappropriate bad don't know get relationship whit costumer is a huge change since I'm remembering that time sorry ican said that we'll is 100% a reality..I hope the owner get some consideration about..god bless us..bye ..also need to consideration n nice & old costumers tha apporting businesses in that bakery .. read more

Cakes taste fresh, the 3 leche cake with Dulce de leche filling is amazing ! However very pricey .

The mexican sweets are so yummy and fresh. Just ordered a birthday cake and can't wait to see it. read more

La Pinata Bakery - World traveler theme cake, they did an amazing job!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

The caramel Tres leches cake does not taste the same anymore, it seems like they chose quantity over quality. Sorry la Pinata I could taste the cheap ingredients. I see why My family doesn't even order here anymore. read more

Ordered a cake for my partner and his mothers birthday. The cakes were okay but not what was expected with the money I paid. The cakes in total came out to about $250 and mind you they only were for 10 people each. I expected much more out of the cakes. They used only butter cream instead of fondant - with the exception of the decorations. The decorations were cracking and the fondant designs fell off of my partners moms cake. While the staff was very helpful because I was originally had alot of questions, I was not satisfied with the final product. An extra star for detail on his crown but that's about it. read more

See all

I ordered the tres leches mango round cake with extra fruit around the top it was delicious everyone at the party loved the cake but just a little bit pricy for 30.00 ppl 85.00 read more

Their cannoli and cappuccino is so good! Regret not getting their strawberry shortcake and tres leches cake. Will definitely be back the next time I'm in Yonkers. read more

I read the reviews and still gave it a shot . I have to say the reviews are not what I experienced . I was told I had 2 days to place the order I wanted as it was a custom cake for my daughters first birthday . Let's just say I showed up late and gave them a day to get it done . They took the order and was very helpful with the whole process . With going over email pics of what they recommend to the time of the cake being ready they delivered 100% . I have dealt with bakery's ie cassones , neri , And cerbones and this place is on a top tier that sets the standards of how a bakery should produce products . The cake was exactly like the picture and the flavor was one of the best I have had . The strawberries are fresh the cake was light and fluffy and a party of 40 had everyone wanting more . The cons are parking , the area and price can be a little better but I have no regrets and will be buying all my pastries and cakes here from now on . read more

La Pinata Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

One of the best bakery I've ever ate cake from. Highly recommended and love the dulce de Leche cake. Best cake ever.

Very nice place to go in and drink a nice hot coffee with family & friends Their cake are good and prices wise. I like how friendly the staff is when it comes to help each customer. Their coffee and panini are the best. Most important about the place is that is clean read more

The service is not the friendliest, the process of getting your pastries is very disorganized, the actual food is ok.

I wanted to surprise my significant other with her two favorite cakes for her birthday. So I got one cake from the Cheesecake Factory and the second was going to be from La Piñata. I had a very busy schedule and a short window to make the surprise happen. So I called ahead and asked specifically, If am purchasing a cake from you, would you be able to write on a cake I received from another location, I explained where I got it from and that they couldn't write on it (it's prepackaged and frozen). The young lady said sure come in I can do that for you. I arrived and ordered the cake and made the request again. And the young lady serving me seemed confused, so I told her someone confirmed they could do it and and she left to ask a manager. There was no manager available so another young lady decided to decline writing on the cake because of liability reasons. Made no sense but I was short on time and out of options because I had no time to figure out a plan B. She didn't seem to care and wasn't bothered that she was going to lose a sale in the moment and a customer for life simply because she wouldn't honor what their staff said. I drove out of my way to them and they refused. I offered to put it in writing that I wouldn't pursue them, if they could please help out. For something as simple as writing on a prepackaged cake. I offered to pay for the service and they still declined. The lack of flexibility just shows they didn't value my business. I wasn't irate or disrespectful but I felt disrespected that I wasted my time after they confirmed a service. I called the local Shoprite and asked the bakery if they could help and the gentleman without hesitation said yes, you don't even have to buy anything. ShopRite is a larger corporation that this bakery and didn't fear "risk". I am not one to signal a personal bias based on appearance or race because I would hope that wouldn't play a part in them assisting me, but I couldn't make sense of why they would give me such a hard time when I was spending money to just write on a cake. They actually write on these cardboard things that they place on top of the cake. They could have written it on one and handed it to me to apply myself without coming in contact with the cake I brought. I will not return and I will be sure to share my experiences. read more