Sugargirl Bakery made my daughter's 18th birthday cake, and it was absolutely perfect from start to finish. The custom design was stunning and exactly what we asked for, and the cake was fresh, moist, and delicious -- our guests couldn't stop raving about it. Everything there is always fresh and truly scrumptious, and the owner is a gem: kind, patient, and clearly passionate about her craft. I highly recommend Sugargirl for any occasion and hope anyone reading this will support this awesome small business. P.S. The cookies with the sprinkles are not to be missed! ( A note from my kids) read more

EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED! Was able to walk in and receive a tres leches small $45. Can't complain, they're good for last minute pick ups, thank you for that. The cake was so dry and crumbly. For being a "tres leches" they should be embarrassed. This is not the first time getting a very dry cake from them. It's literally a hit or miss there and this last time may keep me away. Or perhaps until I need a last minute grab. Unfortunate. read more

Sugargirl Bakery - Tres Crema De Leche with 3leches Cup - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

Excellent neighborhood bakery that's family owned. We love the chocolate dipped raspberry sandwich cookies, the cream horns, mouse slices & flan, among others. Very reliable - everything is always super fresh. We go to Sugargirl b/c they're excellent and we want to support family businesses in the neighborhood. read more

If you want to get delicious baked goods from people who care about their customers and give them a wonderful and welcoming experience from the minute you walk in then you should definitely come check them out. You will be so happy you did! They have something for everyone from loaves to cookies to cakes to strawberry tiramisu! read more

See all

One of my favorite flans in the city. Not at all eggy and incredibly smooth. Their personal desserts are super generous and easily serve 1-2 people. They recently introduced fresh juices and I love their cantalope one Service is absolutely wonderful and everyone is super sweet. read more

I love a place that keeps the same family energy and feel. Staff is extremely knowledgeable and helpful. They work with their customers and ensure that their vision and needs are met. The cakes are beautiful and taste delicious ! RECOMMEND 100% I went by for my daughters birthday last min with no vision and left extremely happy and felt like my daughters birthday was complete ! read more

Sugargirl Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

Absolutely delicious! Currently obsessed with this place! Their cupcakes, cakes and tres leches are absolutely delicious!!!!! Their rugelach are to die for! Very fresh cakes, not too sweet.. just perfect!! Absolutely best customer service, sooo sweet! Gladys and her team are amazing! Loving this place read more

Sugargirl Bakery - Koop demon hunters delicious cake - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

Bought a passion fruit mousse. Did not expect that at all . Definitely coming back for that.

As I mentioned before, my to go place for all of our occasions. I'm nearly there every week. Can't thank them enough. Great service. read more

Sugargirl Bakery - Dominican Cake w vanilla filling - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

My family and I have been going to the same bakery for over 17 years, our go to place for every occasion. Lovely people, great customer service, the atmosphere is welcoming, always looks very clean. We keep going back for the cakes and always walk out with a few other things. read more

Neighborhood gem that makes the most amazing desserts, pastries & cakes. Any & everything from flan, tres leche, custom cakes, tarts, cannolis, fresh bread & even amazing Spanish coffee. Family run business with top notch customer service, they definitely go above and beyond. Also have GREAT prices. I definitely recommend the guava & cheese mini pastries, you won't regret it :-) read more

See all

I ordered takeout for my birthday and I was happy I did! The personal red velvet cake was so delicious, it had real cream cheese frosting like I haven't had in a long time and the cake itself was good (although a smidgen dry). The macarons were good too, although almost three dollars for a tiny one is a little steep. But nuts are so expensive now, so maybe that's why. I would definitely order again from here. read more

Was in the area and got a sweet tooth so stopped here for a treat. I ended up getting the dulcet de Leche cheesecake and the strawberry cheesecake. Bkthe was delicious. read more

See all

Had to purchase a last minute cake this past weekend and Sugarboy did not disappoint. It was a beautiful pink and white marble cake with butterflies and a little crown decoration. Sugarboy also offers cake toppers and sparkler candles! The cake was nice and moist and dulce de leche flavored and it wasn't too sweet! It was perfect! I am a sweet lover and I am very critical on how I like my sweets. I also purchased the flan with tress leches cup and it was a dream! Will definitely be returning to Sugarboy to try more or their sweets! read more

Sugargirl Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

Excellent treats! Great staff - great service! The food tastes amazing - I will always go back!

Love this bakery everything is always fresh and delicious.. But you must be VERY specific with what you want.... The other day I ordered a cake for my sisters baby shower I walked in and saw a cake that was already on display...... It was marble and simple but beautiful I'm going to attach a picture below.... When I went to pick up the cake I was a bit late maybe a hour, I walked In and literally end up standing there for a hour... Seemed as if they had a new girl and she didn't know what she was doing, I bought 20 chocolate covered strawberries right there and then cost me 57$ on top of the 97$ I paid for a cake that my sister absolutely hated because it wasn't the one that we clearly ordered...... I'm sorry, It really messed a lot of things up..... I was charged almost 100$ for something we did not ask for and the cake literally was falling apart, the garland was diamonds when clearly in the first picture it's gold... all I asked was for the happy birthday sign to be removed because it's for a babyshower....... Really just disappointed and felt like it was a waste of money.......... read more

See all

This bakery is a Gem! My daughter is a student at Manhattan College and lives in the neighborhood. She was walking the ave and stumbled into this bakery. She was so impressed by the customer service, she walked in for a cheese danish and she purchased a few items. Everything was delicious. I had to try it for myself. Needless to say I was very impressed. Every time I'm in the neighborhood I must make a stop at my favorite bakery! I bring back danish, cookies, pastries to Staten Island. I can't wait to order a cake for my next party. read more

This is sugarboy bakerys second location, and it is lovely. Its much better than the other location maybe because its new. I do like the original location for the cakes, cupcakes, and other pasteries, and the people there are always nice, and it smells lovely because the kitchen is right behind the counter so you can see them bakeing when you walk in. As for this location, its close off. Its much bigger and the display of cakes are much more on notice. We have order cakes and gotten lil cupcakes for my kids from here. My favorite is there almond bread, that is just delicious, and best beleive the prices are reasonable. It took me along time to find a bakery that makes good cakes and with this new location Im happy to be close to both. They also have much more besides cake there as well. Cookies, Parfaits, etc. I did leave some pics, so check it out if your in the area. read more

See all

Sugarboy is an amazing bakery. The staff is so attentive and friendly. The baked goods are beautiful and delicious. Stephanie, especially did an amazing personalizing my cake ! read more

Excellent customer service, delicious pastry. My favorite is the chocoflan. They have amazing cakes and cheesecakes. I love how the flan and the cake are mix and the texture that's why chocoflan is my favorite. read more

My sister paid $75 for a small cake with strawberry filing for my dads 85th birthday. I COULD BARELY TASTE OR SEE ANY STRAWBERRIES. The cake was too dense for my liking.My dad liked it but it was overpriced and lacking strawberry. I WOULDN'T BUY IT AGAIN. read more

Sugargirl Bakery - Dominican cake with strawberry filing. CAN YOU FIND THE STRAWBERRIES? NOT IMPRESSED - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

Horrible service. When asked for a price estimate on a cake, I was told they only give prices in person. I figured they would make an exception being that we're in a pandemic, but was rudely told to find business else where. Is Sugarboy Bakery basing their prices on what the person buying looks like? read more

Had my Christmas gender reveal cake done here and it was amazing! Tres Leche!!! Ps. It's a Boy!!!!! read more

Sugargirl Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

Save your money! It's all hype. I purchased a custom ordered birthday cake and it had a weird smell and was dry like toast. It literally crumbled. I called the shop and they came up with every excuse in the book. First, they forgot to write Happy Birthday on the cake. Then the filling was literally jelly (instead of fresh strawberries). The buttercream smelled like stale cheese and they said buttercream is supposed to smell like that. WRONG. Then the cake crumbles when sliced to which they replied their cake is supposed to crumble unless I specifically ordered a Tres Leche. WRONG. Then they asked if I kept the cake outside the refrigerator. NO. When all of the excuses were rebutted, I was told the owner would call me. Which never happened. Folks...get a cake from Wegmans...it will taste much better. read more

I went into this bakery and bought tres leche and it was disgusting . I never tasted a bad tres leche until this day. Never again.

Beware: While they make decent cakes and pastries, they are irresponsible. We ordered a beautiful birthday cake and left a hand made cake-topper with them so they can place on once the cake was done. On the day of pickup they informed us that they "misplaced" our cake topper. They apologized and gave us a measly $20 back. In business that's predominantly successful due to special occasions, you would think they would have a bit more care. We'll be taking our business elsewhere. read more

Love them...a wonderful bakery in the Bronx and their cakes are gorgeous and delicious!

I recently bought a tres Leche cake for my little sisters birthday. It was delicious. Even my mother who Is a chef and tough critic said it was good. I called them prior to going in and asked many questions about pricing, store hours, and flavors, etc. The girl was nice over the phone. The only thing was she called me so many pet names (sweetie, baby,honey) it's one of my biggest pet peeves and personally I think it's unprofessional. It was distracting. When I went in it was the same story really nice & good customer service just persistent with the pet names. I will definitely go back for occasional baked necessities. Good cakes! read more

I ordered a cake for my daughter's birthday and took a picture of a cake I found online. I told them I did not want a replica of that cake and show them what I wanted. I also took a Custom candle and several figurines of Trolls. They did a neat job, the taste of the cake was super good. but they did made a replica of the cake I showed them and did not add my candle nor my figurines. Noone called me back on the issue, I had to make several calls and go to their store and pick up the items they failed to add. I paid $375 for the cake plus $75 for the delivery. I still recommend them their business just be careful with custom orders. read more

Very nice local bakery in the Bronx. I was looking for cupcakes for a coworker and was pleasantly surprised by how friendly the service was. I got two cupcakes with a smile and the lady behind the counter even wrapped the cupcakes in a bow with a floral center :) read more

I drive by this bakery often, and always see cars double parked in front. I wondered what the hype was about and decided to order a cake for my daughters 6th birthday. Now I know why the popularity. I purchased a 1 pound Carmel filling cake. It was absolutely delicious. It was $125, which is expensive but oh so worth it. All of my guest loved it. They have great customer service!!! read more

Sugargirl Bakery - $125 - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

I brought a Black Forest cake from Sugarboy for my daughter birthday. The cake was fabulous. She was shocked and happy. This cake was great. read more

Sugargirl Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

I ordered a cake for one of my best friend's birthdays. I was excited for the design but not all the details were taken care of upon pick up. I also requested to pick up promptly and ended up waiting for them to put it together. The cake was decent, a carrot cake with cream cheese icing and buttercream on the outside, a 10 inch. But this cake did not blow mind, I've had much better. And it was completely over priced for what I got. I would not order here again. read more

Sugargirl Bakery - Sugarboy Bakery - custom birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

Sugarboy Bakery made our wedding cake and we loved it! We worked with Gladys, she was very professional and listened to our needs. They were able to work within our budget. The cake was delicious and beautiful (flower topper shown was made by our florist). Our cake, was Dominican style cake with buttercream frosting, we had three different filling flavors. It was delivered on time all the way to Rye, NY. I definitely recommend Sugarboy Bakery for all special occasions. read more

Sugargirl Bakery - Wedding Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

I love this bakery. They make the most wonderful cake. Design and taste on point. I will order from here. My family enjoy the cake and cupcake . And their customer services is on point too. They are so nice and sweet funny. You feel welcome as soon as you walk in. read more

Sugargirl Bakery - They nail it. - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

My first visit to NY City required me to google all the recommended cheesecake bakers and I chose 3. First was eh...second was good, SugarBoys was Fantasticalious! The cheesecake is creamy, not overly sweet and disappears at home faster than a cup of espresso in the morning. Everybody loves it and dieters stop dieting because they know how good a cheesecake is from SBs. I'm calling in an order now because I've been in City 3 days and been dreaming of that creamy cheesecake day and night since I got on the plane in FL. I'm going to the original location in the hopes that sweet heart young lady is still there that always smiles and brightens up my day. She also lets your approve of the purchase before you pay which is nice, but not needed because I've never had a bad anything from SugarBoys Bakery. Have I tried anything else? Oh yeah I have....anything that looked yummy and it all does. My wife likes the tiramisu (it's to die for) so when my bride buys it, I end up eating most of it before she gets it outside...LOL. They have different flavors of cheesecake slices...and I love em all but the best for me is a large regular cheesecake with cherry topping....OMGB&R (oh my god batman and robin). Five Stars is too low. I give SUGARBOYS BAKERY AND CAFE: 10 STARS AND FIVE FULL CHEAP SUNGLASSES OUT OF 10 AND FIVE RESPECTIVELY. OH...my cheesecake is ready...I'm gone. read more

The worse Dominican. The equality of the cake is really bad, prices out range, but have you're own experience. I know I won't go back. Not the place if you're looking for a good tasty cake. read more

Overpriced cakes- nothing special about them. Even decorations are tacky. Bought a cake for Easter that was just a simple yellow cake and non eatable decorative bunnies on top... a great bakery would not sell that cake for $85. Purely robbery. Shame read more

So, I've been buying my sons cakes from here for a few years, the cakes have been delicious, also family members of mine and friends do too. Sad to say for his 5th Birthday the cake wasn't good at all. The cake is usually moist And soft, this time it was stale and not soft at all, it tasted like it's was made a few days prior to pick up. I am a cake lover, and so are many of my family members. No one ate the cake after their first bite. Sad to say i wasted my money because we tossed the remaining ( almost entire cake) out in the trash. I called the next day on a Sunday, and I wanted to just let them know about the cake, the girl who picked up had the nerve to say maybe it was something I did to the cake. How is that even possible?? I picked up the cake at the time requested and it went straight to the venue. Then she did can I bring the remaining cake in so she can see for herself. And I told her you guys really need to learn how to except criticism, especially if a person is calling about their experience. And I called, so I can avoid making a review, however since she kept insisting it was someone they I must of done, here is my review. And I will no longer be buying cakes from here nor will the people that I recommended. People with in the food business can't blame the customer for what they made. read more

Sugargirl Bakery - My sons Sesame Street red velvet cake, with vanilla and chocolate cup cakes,frosting made from whipped cream. - Bakeries Near Me - Bronx, New York

Stopped by today just on a whim because I saw it from across the. Brought the Pineapple with Dominican cake & OMG I love it & mad I only brought one. I also brought the Coconut Macaroons & a Tiramisu which I haven't eaten yet but I am sure they are excellent as well. The shop & everything in it is absolutely beautiful & the Owner & her workers well so delightfully pleasant. I definitely will be going back again to try some other things. I am a cake & pastry lover, but I am also glad I do not live closer because I would be there everyday. I went to their new location around the corner on Broadway & 231st Street. read more