The Randall House in Pine, Arizona is a staple of history for this quaint town. Having been frequent visitors when it was a breakfast spot, I was sad to see it go, but wanted to give the new updated Mexican restaurant a good try. The decor is as it always was, simple and elegant. Have been a few times since they opened and have sat indoors and outdoors. I know it mentioned reservations required, but that is no longer the case. They also now have their liquor license, so you can enjoy a beverage with your meal. I usually am fond of tamales, but this last time I opted for the chicken sopes. They are divine! The best way to describe them is tostadas, but on a fried green corn base. Anytime I can have green corn, that is what I choose. I told them I will wait for their green corn tamale because I know it will burst with flavor. The desserts are a huge favorite from the grape pie, buttermilk pie, and flan. They ran out of the chocolate flan, so I am already looking forward to trying that on our next visit. Everyone was friendly, they would come by and talk. Spent a good deal of time with our waitress getting to know her. They are extremely family oriented which is important to us. It is really worth anyone's time around the area or even take a fun jaunt to get away from the valley to escape to this delicious retreat. We are really enjoying this new little restaurant ourselves, just writing this makes me crave another sope! read more

La Casa Randall - Chicken Sope - Mexican Near Me - Pine, Arizona

See all

What a fun experience! The interior of this spot feels slightly museum like. It's a home made into a restaurant so it really feels like you're eating at grandmas house. The food itself was very yummy, I loved their rice! I really appreciated that they allowed you to try multiple sauce flavors on one plate because like myself I am very indecisive sometimes! Our server was very funny and friendly, made us feel right at home. read more

See all

Reservations required. No walk-ins. No to go orders. They have indoor and outdoor seating. Open Tue-Sat 4pm 8pm This used to be the Randall House known for breakfast. That is closed and they have reopened as La Casa Randall. They specialize in finer Mexican cuisine. Just opened and menu may change. Call for reservations. read more

See all

As a first time visitor to Pine Arizona, we noticed this old but quaint house hidden behind a white fence with some green foliage. I was excited to see "La Casa Randall" stating a Mexican cuisine restaurant We anxiously awaited for the evening to try out this restaurant, to which we were extremely delighted with not only the quality of food, but the kindness and the love of cooking from the wonderful owner and staff! Upon arriving we were kindly and professionally greeted. We were then asked if we had reservations in this case we did not. There were no issues and the staff was very eager to seat us at one of their rustic style tables. Although the menu might look simple, I can assure you, the quality and taste of the various dishes are exceptional! Our server, Vicky was engaging and offered her suggestions. I'm very pleased with the entire dinner and the deserts were truly wonderful I look forward to the next time I'm in town to visit this amazing restaurant Highly recommend read more

See all

I came here once during a staycation up in Strawberry/Pine area. I had passed this place numerous times and decided to finally try it for breakfast one morning. While it is a really cute spot and has nice indoor/outdoor seating available plus a small bakery counter, unfortunately the food/flavor didn't quite deliver, but I would still recommend checking it out just for the atmosphere, service, and supporting local. When I went, I sat on the front porch and ordered a hot chocolate and a really simple traditional breakfast of fried eggs and sausage patties plus a side of pancakes. Hot chocolate is basically impossible to mess up, it was tasty and warmed me up! The eggs and sausage were pretty standard, not bad but nothing spectacular, and the pancakes were a bit dry, but nothing that a little butter and syrup couldn't fix/mask. My waitress was friendly and prompt and I still enjoyed my overall experience here; I may try some new places before returning, but if you are looking for a cute, quick, reasonably priced bite to start your day, this spot will get the job done. read more

La Casa Randall - eggs, sausage, pancakes and hot chocolate - Mexican Near Me - Pine, Arizona

La Casa Randall breathes life into a 100+ year old tradition and historic home built in the 1880s. The service is friendly and welcoming. The owner loves her food and her thriving new opportunity to serve authentic central Mexican cuisine with a grateful smile. Try the mole with the enchiladas, along with the poblano and chipotle sauces. The unique rice and the charro beans meld well with the enchiladas. The chips and homemade salsa are resoundingly delicious and the queso fundido with chorizo and corn tortillas delivered the taste bonanza! Make reservations if possible. The building and dining areas are a delight. read more

See all

Simply delicious food! Unique flavors and a very comfortable setting. MUST HAVE specialty drink, "The Vampire." A unique and yummy margarita. The friendly and accommodating staff will make you feel at home. read more

La Casa Randall - Enchiladas with a mole sauce. - Mexican Near Me - Pine, Arizona

The service was excellent. I wish I could a gallon of the poblano sauce, it is absolutely mouth watering. My hubby got the chicken flautas and I got the chicken enchiladas. Both were delicious. The beans are better than any I've had before. The owner is the sweetest! read more

La Casa Randall - Chicken Flautas - Mexican Near Me - Pine, Arizona

This was my first visit after visiting Pine many times. I am sad to learn that it will be closing in January of 2023. Came w a friend and we both enjoyed a delightful brunch. Their specials were located on a board as you enter. The person I was with had the omelette special. I had the breakfast sammie with a croissant, ham, eggs and swiss. The croissant was warm and the fillings were cooked to perfection. The charm of the historic house was a nice way to spend a weekend brunch. I hope to return before they close and may purchase a few of the trinkets that are found around the restaurant. read more

See all

amazing!! the food- the service- the atmosphere!! everything was perfect. flautas with the green poblano sauce was superb! The shrimp quesadilla was delicious!. highly recommend. read more

Food was mediocre. Chips served ice cold. Salsa was tasteless. We had wanted to go here for a long time and we were very disappointed. read more

It's a small, local business that has been turning out amazing food for decades. The croissant sandwiches are so good, the quiche is delicious, pancakes are lovely and I've never had a better pie. The mixed nut pie will truly bring your pie dreams to life! And yes...I did take slices to go The LOW STAR reviews are clearly from visitors who expect chain restaurant service. Go to Dennys in Payson if you want that. We've had a summer place up here for years and Barb and her food are fantastic. Don't be a poorly mannered traveler with metropolitan city service expectations. That's entitlement and impatience showing. It embarrasses the rest of us ;) read more

La Casa Randall - Veggie Sammie...soooo good!! - Mexican Near Me - Pine, Arizona

See all

I had a nice breakfast here at the Randall House when I was staying in Pine one night. They have a few rooms inside the house that they seat you in or you can dine outdoors. The room I was in reminded me of a classroom. It had games, arts, crafts, and some toys that I haven't seen since I was a kid. It was fun and nostalgic and brought back some old memories. For food I ordered the Yoga Scramble and enjoyed it. They also have pastries and pies in the front where you pay. The Randall House serves both breakfast and lunch. read more

See all

Memories of my Nonna's house... This place does remind me of my Grandma's house as a kid. They have 4 or 5 smallish rooms with 3 or 4 tables in each of them. Healthy food options (yay), plus artwork available from area artists. For her a Yoga Scramble and hot tea. They have many options of tea, believe she went for a ginger peach. Her dish was scrambled eggs, spinach, onions, red peppers, feta cheese with rye toast and added jam. I chose the Mountain breakfast sundae. This had mixed fruit, yogurt and homemade granola. So good on both ends of the table, yet again. Parking can be a little tight during the week. Use the dirt lot right behind this place. read more

La Casa Randall - Mountain Breakfast Sundae - Mexican Near Me - Pine, Arizona

See all

Can you drink the green chili poblano sauce? I can it's outstanding. From the excellent margarita to the chicken mole this place is a hidden gem. The owners are so sweet and friendly. Let's support the locals read more

We love this place, the staff is always so nice and friendly! I went in looking for homemade strawberry soda- which the previous restaurant offered- and was informed they do not sell that but the gentleman did offer me strawberry Fanta in lieu. I kindly declined but took him up on his offer of a slice of their "Grape Pie". Never have I heard of this type of pie and I've been a pastry chef for 9 years! The pie was absolutely scrumptious, a flakey and butter crust, with some style of cream atop the crust, layered with fresh green grape halves topped with, I believe, a chantilly cream and coconut flakes. It was simply divine and I will be returning regularly for that pie! read more

We had a terrific dinner at La Casa Randall in Pine on 8/1/24. The food was AMAZING & the drink that we had ("The Vampire") was absolutely terrific. Most of all, the homey atmosphere & the fantastic, very friendly & attentive service from our Server, "Josephine", as well as the attention from Manager "Adrianna" & her husband (who was working as the Bartender and who stopped by to not only visit our table but to give us written instructions on how to make the drink, "The Vampire") made for a fantastic evening. We've have rarely experienced such positive attention from a group of staff at a restaurant! So friendly & helpful! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! read more

Excellent Mexican food in a very quaint old house. Service was very good and the chicken enchiladas and pork were as good as we've had. Ignore reviews from before this was a Mexican restaurant. read more

La Casa Randall is a local Mexican resturant offering familiar yet different Mexican cuisine... Service was attentive, friendly, carried out by happy servers... all the staff seem like family and treat their guests like part of that family... If you wish a cocktail, wine, or just a cold cervesa - it's all available... Chips and fresh salsa are on every table... The dishes offered are unique and delishious ...fresh ingredients and unique flavors attractively presented... And the dessert selection a must ... Pick several and share... Definitly will go back for more!!!! PS.... This is a casual, fun, festive atmosphere !!! read more

Absolutely amazing food! We enjoyed both entrees, the chicken enchiladas were flavorful with tender and juicy chicken meat wrapped in delicate corn tortillas but the poblano sauce took them above any expectations! The Chile en Nogada was poetry on a plate, the savory beef with the sweet dried fruit was delicious and the play of the crunchy nuts and the silky creamy sauce was heavenly! The rice and beans deserve a mention as both were perfectly executed and freshly homemade and a perfect complement to both dishes. Highly recommend Casa Randall and look forward to many future visits! read more

Great food, great service. We will return again. Champiqueso appetizer was awesome as well as the shredded beef flautas. We also had the flan and the buttermilk pie. Give it a try. read more

Good authentic Mexican food in Pine, AZ Try out the rellenos! They are too die for! The location is the old Randall house, it's adorable and very homey. read more

Wow! The lady at the front was super rude to us. The previous reviews were correct regarding the karen. My family and are we're so excited to eat here . There was only 1 couple Sitting outside. We were the only ones waiting to be seated. We waited patiently and she kept repeating that she will seat us and to wait. Which is what we were already doing, she gave us an irritated look. When I spoke to my mother in law who was cole and suggested she how outside to stand In the sun, the lady again said I'll be right with you to sit you! I said I was talking to my mother in law.... she micromanaged everything we did! We immediately left !!! read more

A cute little cafe, tucked inside an old house. Totally reminds me of my Grandma's house. Good food, and excellent service. The hot chocolate was awesome with a giant sized marshmallow! Definitely would eat here again when we're visiting again! read more

See all

Food was delicious and the Spicy Margaritas were five stars!! It's such a great place to spice up your night!!

The fare switched from a sandwich shop to a Mexican Restaurant with limited hours. The staff is helpful, the food is not bad but the portions are small. Chips were old and cold, salsa while home made is not ready for prime time. The options in Pine are not extensive. As of this writing they're still in transition from the old sandwich shop. read more

When you want to feel the breeze and listen to the trees talk and expect grandma to come out on the patio and bring u a fresh hot meal than this is the place to be! My mom came to visit us and she said this was the best homemade meal she has had well she was right. The lunch menu rocks! read more

See all

We discovered Randall House while visiting Payson and Pine for the weekend. First, the ambiance is amazing. It's in a quaint older home with lots of light and original hardwood floors. Many tables are surrounded by windows and there is also room for outside seating. As you walk in, there is a homey seating area, and a case with a variety of house made bakery items and pies available that look great. We were pleasantly greeted and sat by a window in a back room. The staff was very attentive and checked on us regularly for coffee refills. I ordered one of the daily specials, Apple Chicken Sausage Hash. It was amazing with two poached eggs, potatoes, sausage, pieces of apple and cheese, with toast. It was a unique combination with the apple, and it worked amazingly well. You could also tell that the cook really pays attention to the details with garnish and a slice of twisted orange. The food was delicious, and more wholesome and healthy than other options in the area. Some of the other reviews here did not reflect our experience at all. The food was great and reasonably priced. The owner even stopped by to say hello. Couldn't be more pleased and we'll definitely be back again. read more

La Casa Randall - Randall House daily specials - Mexican Near Me - Pine, Arizona

My husband and I stopped here hoping to have breakfast. They had a long wait, and by the time we got to sit at a table they were no longer serving breakfast. They gave us the breakfast menu at the table, but when the waitress took our order she said it was too late for breakfast. It was just disappointing, but we ordered lunch. There wasn't any shade at the table, they really should get a few umbrellas for the outside seating. read more

See all

Mother's Day 2021. We were sat immediately. Beautiful grounds, nice live music, sitting in the shade. After waiting for 1 hour, I asked "what is taking so long?" The manager and our server were anchored in justification and made zero attempt in empathy. They were full of rude attitude for asking obvious question. Yes, it is "Mother's Day", not one server or employee prepared us to wait 1 hour + for our crepes and avocado toast. No one else seemed to be waiting 1+ hour for simple dishes? Food was good. There are a lot of great places to eat in this area. I recommend choosing somewhere else. read more

Amazing little find in Pine Arizona. The food was great. The staff are friendly and the service is great also. This is the second time I have eaten there. Will stop in again next time I am there. read more

We continue to love Casa Randall, and now, we love it even more since they are one of the ONLY restaurants in Pine, where you can call ahead, and they will text you when your food is ready to pick-up! Couldn't agree more with others that the poblano sauce is fantastic. And so are their specials-chiles en nogada is a fav. We will continue to support them!! read more

This place has a relaxing vibe with fresh baked food and desserts. Next time I am in town I will be checking out their breakfast menu. read more

See all

This location is permanently closed! I drove around looking for it, and finally asked a local, who said it is closed. Wish they had updated that on their website for social media but I thought I would put that on here for anyone else visiting. read more

This place is great! Excellent Mexican food and margaritas. I had the tostadas, one chicken and one beef and both were perfect. The owners are very warm and friendly. read more

The food was tasty and very flavorful. Great courtyard and friendly staff. Thoroughly enjoyable. We had the mole and the chicken toastados

Incredible that Pine would have such an outstanding, authentic, original recipe, made from scratch Mexican food restaurant. When tasting their wonderful array of delicacies, you'd swear you're sitting in a cantina in Durango or Oaxaca Mexico. This is a must go to the next time you are ever in the Pine/Strawberry area! read more

This experience was not great at all and the only reason I'm giving them three stars is because the last time I was here I really enjoyed it. Either they were short staffed or it's always like this when they are busy, but it took us almost an hour to get our food. There were quite a few tables that were full, but that is just ridiculous. It took almost 10 minutes for the waiter to come over to even take our drink order. At that point we ordered our food as well and then settled in to wait. We had no idea how long it would be! The entire time we waited no one once came by to see how we were doing or if we needed refills. We did have to ask twice how much longer it would take for the food to come and the server looked annoyed. The food was good once it arrived, and thankfully it was piping hot! I think they must have just really gotten behind. I may give them one more try, but steer clear on a busy day! read more

See all

I love the Randall House. The food is cooked fresh to order and has an amazing flavor. It always hits the spot. I typically go for breakfast to enjoy the sunrise views in the amazing town of Pine. Sitting outdoors and having great food in a very pretty environment is the best. The staff here are always smiling and friendly. I definitely recommend if you are local or a tourist enjoying the fresh mountain air, to grab a bite to eat here. You certainly won't leave disappointed. Keep up the great work and giving exceptional quality and service to your customers. I Look forward to seeing you all again soon. Oh and definitely walk around and enjoy the grounds around. They have done an amazing job at providing a nice variety of trees and flowers, and one of my favorite is the ponds with all sorts of fun items to look at. read more

La Casa Randall - Outside seating. Lots of shade. - Mexican Near Me - Pine, Arizona

What a great place to eat. The atmosphere is perfect. The corn hole score keeper from Old County Inn was filling our hearts with some awesome tunes. The food was amazing. Perfect weather, great staff. The croissant breakfast hit the spot. Definitely will eat here next time we are in town visiting the crew read more