I was genuinely excited when this bagel shop opened and it quickly became my go-to spot. The food and service were great at first. Unfortunately, I've stopped going because the store now allows non-service dogs inside -- and this is a very small space. I've personally seen large pet dogs rubbing against shelves and rugs and barking while customers are ordering food. In such close quarters, that's especially uncomfortable and unhygienic. I completely understand and respect legitimate service animals -- that's not the issue. The concern is allowing pets in a place where food is prepared and served. Because of that change, I can't continue to support the business. I hope management reconsiders this policy. read more

Ordered via TooGood2Go on the Wednesday before Thanksgiving. For $5.99, they gave us a baker's dozen, and there were not two bagels that were the same! I'm wondering if it was because it was a holiday week, and people were out of town, so maybe they had more bagels left over? But typically when I've ordered TooGood2Go from other bagel spots, they give me multiples of the ones people no one wants, like blueberry or egg. But at Knead A Bagel, there were so many different varieties - a bialy, everything, strawberry, rainbow, sesame, cinnamon raisin, pumpernickel, just to name a few. The bagels still tasted fresh too. Would visit again, even if it's not through TooGood2Go. I think they also have breakfast sammies, so I wouldn't mind getting one of those next time. Tip - there's a small lot in front, or street parking. It's far enough away from the main area of Rutherford that you should be able to find street parking if the lot is full. read more

Knead A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

They have strawberry bagels! But they taste just like a plain bagel. I was so disappointed. Bagel was decent though. Service was good, efficient. The place has a counter with some high chairs to sit. It was neither bad nor good experience hence the three star rating. read more

See all

Knead a Bagel is easily one of the best bagel spots around, and it absolutely deserves all five stars. From the moment you walk in, you can feel the care that goes into everything they do. The bagels are consistently fresh, warm, and perfectly chewy--exactly what a great bagel should be. Whether you're grabbing a classic plain with cream cheese or going for one of their specialty sandwiches, you really can't go wrong. The ingredients taste high-quality, and the flavors are thoughtfully put together. The service is another standout. The staff is friendly, efficient, and always patient even when the line is out the door--because yes, it does get busy, and for good reason. They keep things moving without making you feel rushed, which is rare these days. You can tell the team takes pride in the product and the experience. The shop itself has a clean, modern feel, making it a comfortable place to sit for a quick breakfast or coffee. Even if you're taking your order to go, the attention to detail is clear. read more

Great bagels! Crispy exterior chewy bite. If using too good to go, go on a Monday. There were 2 available but they ended up giving us both for the price of 1. They are holding up incredibly in the freezer. read more

Bagels were very big,but slightly squished which makes it hard to appreciate the inside texture. Good flavor for the salt and plain bagels that had a nice crust. The strawberry and cinnamon raisin lacked in flavor. Also available to purchase are muffins, and typical breakfast sandwiches. read more

Knead A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

The variety of bagel and cream cheeses are outstanding. The owner is really nice as well as the staff. I highly recommend this bagel shop.There are seats available if you would like to eat in. It is comfortable and peaceful environment. read more

New bagel shop in Rutherford--already rolling out the dough like pros! Great for a quick stop, with a solid selection of bagels, cream cheeses, and breakfast options. I recently ordered catering, and not only was it beautifully presented, but they ran it with the precision of a well-oiled toaster. Fresh bagels, spot-on service, and zero stress. Definitely worth a visit! read more

Excellent New Jersey bagels. Big sandwiches. Chewy bagels with a crunch. Close to the stadium and worth a try.

Love this place!!! Boyd gets the pastrami egg and cheee bagel everytime and I always switch it up went for. a classic bagel with scallion cream cheese today. read more

Beautiful, clean new establishment and friendly service. The bagels were ok, I felt they lacked taste and they weren't as densed as I would like. They did however have flat bagels and mini bagels which is nice addition to the regular bagels. read more

Making it 3 stars only because the business did try to remedy the issues. This Knead A Bagel is located on Park Ave, central to another very popular and well established bagel spot in town, so I was eager to check it out. Came here around 10:30 & it had a decent number or people. During our time there, it got incredibly tight. Think it's been open around a week. The location is quaint, with a small bar area with about 5 bar stools, so def a more grab & go spot. It was superrrrrrr busy so it was difficult to get by in the tight space and no one could figure out where the line started, ended or who was in line to order or who was waiting. We were not acknowledged when we entered at all and had to wait around 10 minutes to order. The woman who was taking orders was also toasting bagels & doing other things. Finally, our order was taken & the woman seemed confused. She wasn't sure if they had certain ingredients and didn't seem sure about what the orders came with etc. After we ordered, we asked if we should pay - but we wanted coffee, too. She told us the coffee was free (very nice!) Not sure if it will be an all the time thing. We waited 40 minutes!!! We began to notice that all the people waiting were people that weren't there prior. We asked about our order. The woman we spoke to went to the back & said they were working on it then. we waited maybe 5 more mins. For the long wait, they were gracious enough to give us 2 more bagels and also charged us less, which they did not have to do. We appreciated that but I do have some suggestions: 1st & foremost they need to establish some organization. The lady who took our order, in my opinion, was doing too many other things. The line was super long but they can make the line start & end & waiting area more intentional with signage, maybe. Also, having a number or taking the last name would be helpful instead of calling the whole order out every time something was ready. When we got home - we noticed my bagel wasn't even wrapped well with enough foil. Prob because they were rushing to get it out. Overall, not the best experience but I will give them the benefit of the doubt as they just opened and I will be trying & updating my review soon. read more

Knead A Bagel - How they wrapped our bagel ? - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

This bagel place is new to Rutherford! It is in a great location on Park Ave, and even has a small parking lot. The inside is small with a few seats at a bar top. They do however have some outdoor seating which will be nice to sit at during the summer months. My wife and I ordered 2 bagels with cream cheese and both were good. The price was also cheaper compared to others nearby. The best part about the shop was the service. Everyone was extremely friendly. We had our dog with us, and they brought our food outside and even gave us some turkey bacon for our dog! We will definitely be coming back again to try more of the bagels and other menu items. read more

Newer bagel place that replaced an old gas station. Great spot to stop for a quick bagel. They have a nice selection of bagels and cream cheeses. Also lots of breakfast choices. Good quality bagels and service was spot on. Would recommend! read more

Five stars isn't enough ! I'm from NY I know BEC /Bagels . This place has some of the best i ever had . I just have to show you the bacon they put on this sandwich !! Place is amazing . read more

Knead A Bagel - Look at that bacon - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Love this place! The ambiance is nice. You can sit at the window counter and watch Park Ave. The owner and the staff are very nice And helpful. I was asking how the buffalo chicken sandwich was and the owner said she would make one special for me. It was delicious!! Little FYI...I ate it there with a plate, but if you are going to eat it in the car, get a wrap because the sandwich because the sauce will drip. Highly recommend!! read more

Amazon homemade bagels and cream cheese! We tried 4 different types of bagels and all were amazing. The owner was also very nice

The food here was very good and came out fast. The staff was friendly and helpful. We ordered a pumpernickel bagel with regular cream cheese, and an everything bagel with lox and chive cream cheese -- both were really delicious. A solid spot for a great bagel! read more

Woman owners! Right there starts the beginning of a great business..they care about all the little things and have wonderful relationships with everyone. Women love to Please! Everything I've gotten there is delicious!! The French Toast Bagels with walnut raisin creme cheese is the best breakfast food I've had in years..over the top. You gotta try it!!! Oh, their homemade soups are Fantastic too!!! read more

Love the bagels here they are amazing . I think if they just pay attention to the outside seating once customers leave . It usually covered in trash which is disappointing that adults leave such a mess after they eat. Also there are flies by the trash can once you walk in . If they move the location it might help. read more

Absolutely the best bagels I've tried in this area. While I was missing a bagel from my order - I'm still giving five stars as the bagels were delicious. Light and not doughy with a lovely slightly crisp exterior. The cream cheese was fresh and tasty. Looking forward to trying again. read more

New bagel location , opened two weeks ago . Service was good. Clean location. Outdoor seating and limited . Had a toasted onion bagel with lox spread. Filled with lox. Enjoyed my bagel! read more

See all

Took my son out for breakfast. We loved the bagel breakfast sandwiches. Bacon, egg and cheese on egg bagel and a BLT on egg bagel. Bagels are fresh, huge and made to perfection. Nothing like this in central PA. Thank you knead a Bagel. Great experience for us both read more

Thursday morning flagel with scallion cream cheese and bacon. Horrible and took forever. Flagel was nearly burnt, barely a scraping of cream cheese. Had a great first experience here on opening week, but this was awful. read more

Knead A Bagel - Toasted (burnt on the outside) flagel "with" scallion cream cheese and a slice of bacon...horrible - Bagels Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

I can't believe I'm making this review. Don't get me wrong the bagels are super good, I have been to the store many times before. But after biting into their plain bagel with cream cheese I was completely in shock after hair was amongst the food I bit into. I didn't believe at first! Knead a bagel was my go to ever since it opened! First time I've experienced this in ANY restaurant. A shame that Knead a bagel had to be the first. read more

Place won't last long. Too expensive. You can't rip people off. Place is not even set up right read more

CHECK YOUR RECEIPT ! The cashier helped herself in adding a gratuity on my card without my authorization. When I brought it up to the manager, she did in fact reimburse me. However, how many other customers did this happen to that didn't realize it? I don't care if it was 2$ or 200$ !! It's the principle & it's out right thief!!. Do better ! read more

Great bagels, especially the French Toast and now the Strawberry. Also the Cream Cheese flavors are great. Easy to Park.. Try them you'll love them. read more

I've noticed they raised their prices on a few items but did not change the prices on the menu. I told a few of the workers who said they were working on it. It's been 2 weeks. I get the egg raise, bit coffee, and a bagel with butter? My next step will be to file a complaint with the department of consumer affairs . read more

Been here twice already. The staff is wonderful. The sandwiches are out of this world! It's great to finally get meat like back in the day in your breakfast sandwich. read more

I love this place! The bagels are the best I've had and the other menu items are delicious. The staff is always super friendly and the owner is very nice read more

I mistakenly ordered a catering order from the Rutherford location when I meant to order from the Ho-Ho-Kus location and didn't realize until it was too late. The owner was so understanding about the mix-up. We love their bagels (we have only had the HHK location but they are the same owners) and really appreciate how nice the staff is! read more

I found This place off a google search and it is amazing !! 100% worth the drive. The staff is friendly. The bagels are always fresh and always so good. They have a good variety on their menu which I have yet to try anything else but it's definitely on my list to do. They even have a great option of drinks to choose from. 100/10 recommend !! read more

Go here to be ignored. I stood at the cashier's stand while she rang up 2 customers then walked away while I was waiting to pay for a bottled drink. Then another worker rang up another customer without even acknowledging that I was waiting. I put the drink back and walked out. If you're not ordering a sandwich, you'll be ignored. Supreme bagels 2 blocks away has far better service! read more

First time at this newly opened bagel shop. Bagels were so good ! I had a salt bagel and it was really tasty. The wife had a bagel with Nutella cream cheese and she has been talking about it all day. The service was quick and the place was super clean. Juliana, one of the owners, was super nice. I would suggest this to anyone looking for a quality bagel read more

I'm visiting my Dad from Florida and been waiting for this place to open! What an amazing place ...spotless inside, fresh ingredients and the bakery items are to die for! greeted immediately when you walk in and smiling staff! let's not forget the name ..GENUIS! ....and yes after trying this place I KNEAD a bagel and or sandwich from here. read more

Amazing bagels. Had an egg bagel with chive cream cheese. It was really tasty. Staff was extremely friendly. Can't wait to go back!

The bagels were great! We didn't have to wait at all. I would recommend this for good fresh bagels!

First off , this store is brand new. Everyone should have patience and give them time to settle before judging them. It gonna take a couple months to work out the kinks and get a proper system going. I came here 5 times already and each time the bagels were amazing and service was great. The owner is in the front everyday. She a hard working lady , and working in the front every day. The reason why it is insanely packed is because , of there bagels . I honestly think it better than anyone in the city In two months time , this store will be firing at all cylinders read more

One of the best bagels I have had in the town.. their vegetable and scallion cream cheese are really good..