I swear to God that I just ate the best pizza I have ever had in my whole entire 53 years of being on this planet! The crust? Superb! The toppings? Excellent! The beer? Stupendous. The service? Absolutely impeccable. My only issue is that this place is 2.5 hours from my house! I will definitely be back when I am in this area. Hands-down it is truly the greatest ever. read more

Keith's Pizza-South - The best pizza in the universe! - Pizza Near Me - Bemidji, Minnesota

Came in after work had to wait a bit for the pizza no biggie was really looking forward to wings and pepperoni pizza but when I got it they were boneless wings super disappointed I wanted bone in wings not soggy nuggets. People were nice guys first day no biggie but prices almost made me walk out and get little Ceasar's down the street for bone in wings and one 12" cost me $45 that's insane I could've gotten little Ceasar's for $20 less. Tiped %18 added like $7 more to the bill for one pizza. Probably won't come back here. Food was good just overpriced in my opinion. Wish they had actual food wings and a menu on a board I had to just walk up to the cashier and awkwardly say umm I want a pepperoni pizza and wings no prices no sizes it's a fine in restaurant but should have a price up I wouldn't have ordered anything if I saw the pizza and wings were $20 each! read more

Keith's Pizza-South - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Bemidji, Minnesota

See all

Good place to eat it has solid food but the dishwasher gives teeth for 20 dollers so 5 stars w (tyler fadness)

It was an explore MN weekend getaway for me and my fam and we went to Bemidji to see the Paul Bunyan and Babe statutes. Wanting something familiar but local we tried Keith's Pizza. It was a very nice and well kept restaurant, awesome staff and some good food! Great variety on the menu! I had broasted chicken, my wife had pizza, and our son got his fave dish of fettuccine alfredo!!! I was at their South store and took those photos!!! read more

See all

Thank you to Keith's Pizza for the awesome pizzas at the end of the Loop the Lake bicycle event in Bemidji! I loved the cheese pizza AND your pepperoni pizza slices! read more

Keith's Pizza-South - Thank you! - Pizza Near Me - Bemidji, Minnesota

We chose this place because of the plant based cheese option. We have 2 vegans in our family so it was a no brainer when we saw they offer soy cheese. A smaller establishment so keep that in mind. Nothing fancy. Pizza was good. I wouldn't say amazing but good enough. The sauce lacked flavor but they were generous with toppings. My parents liked the wild rice soup. They have "pizza kits" for kids. Such a fun idea! They bring pre portioned ingredients and crust and kids get to put their pizza together. The kids really enjoyed it! The 2 in our group that ordered sandwiches were not impressed. Just said they weren't very good and would stick to pizza next time. Didn't offer specifics. Overall a decent option for pizza if you are in the area. read more

Keith's Pizza-South - Kids pizza kit before - Pizza Near Me - Bemidji, Minnesota

See all

We have tried Keith's twice now. I cannot for the life of me understand the hype for this place. The pizza has no redeeming qualities whatsoever. The crust, the sauce, the toppings. It's just lacking flavor. We will be going elsewhere. read more

I have ordered form here before, the crust was under done this time and was really flavorless for the "Italian" pizza. I expected better because of past experience. It arrived in a timely fashion and it was hot, delivery person was friendly and helpful but overall I won't order this pizza again. read more

The place had very good service. I decided to take out my pizza but I did look around the place. I would certainly eat in if there was a next time. I ordered the special which was a large sausage with bread sticks. Bread sticks were very good but the sauce was very plain. The pizza was average favor but better than a frozen pizza. Sausage was few and far between. Very small probably frozen. With a few minor improvements this place could have a great product. Price was average but I have had much better for the price. Easy to find and plenty of parking. Sign said lunch buffet is M-F read more

Keith's Pizza-South - Pizza Near Me - Bemidji, Minnesota

See all

I have never ordered from them before. And ordered a fantastic pizza and combo platter. It was amazing worth every penny. The staff was very, very respectful and fun when I walked in.. Can't wait to come back and try it again. read more

My stomach hurts because of the food, I pooped my guts out. The food took forever and i was the only person there. i pooped my pants because of it read more

It really pains me to write this. I love a good pizza and enjoy trying new places when traveling. Based on popular opinion when I polled several locals about a good pizza place my hopes were high. Ordered a couple things to try. Wanted to build a simple 3-topping pizza but the total for three toppings cost more than a 5-topping pizza from the same menu. Aside from the mild aneurysm in my math brain, it also created an inconvenience in ordering. (TIP: order an existing pizza from the menu and make substitutions is key if you want to keep up with the math/value). They also charge $2.50 for delivery regardless if the address is only 900 ft. away at the nearest hotel. Asked if the toasted cheese bread had any garlic on it. Was told yes. False statement. Both the pizza and (non-garlic) cheese bread showed up lukewarm (900 ft delivery). The crust on the pizza was undercooked and soggy- due to the excess moisture from the sauerkraut (which was a disappointment in itself because "The River" was supposed to be the owner's 'specialty'. Woulda thought they had this issue figured out by now). I always give second chances so we will see if things improve tomorrow night but, so far, I'm not impressed. Oh well. read more

Keith's Pizza-South - Pizza Near Me - Bemidji, Minnesota

See all

Bunch of stoners that don't know how to cut a pizza. Pizza is sooo good. All the toppings cheese yummy everything good good. I would just stick to pizza tho. I ordered spaghetti and I'm pretty sure I was eating pizza sauce. I had to throw it out ordered a house salad I had a Mealy slimy green pepper. I don't know who is approving that these meals go out even if it's not a manager and they should have some sense to know OK if I wont eat this why would somebody else eat it. I'm 45 years old and I grew up on Keith's south. read more

Five of us dined at Keith's Pizza for the first and only time. The pizza was just ok and greasy. The service was absolutely horrible! We were the only diners in the entire restaurant and had to walk to the counter to ask for a refill on sodas, even though we had a server. Our refills didn't arrive until after our pizzas arrived. We only saw our server when we were seated and she took our order. The server never checked on us again until she brought our pizzas to us. I then had to wait in line at the counter, behind customers picking up their to-go orders, just to pay for our sit-down meal. The restaurant itself was nice, with a warm ambiance, but for mediocre pizza and horrible service, we will not be back. read more

Call to order for delivery just to repeat my self over and over with my phone number or with my order just so I can still receive the wrong order not sure if it's a telephone problem on their end or whatever it may be the food is still great just stopped ordering because of the Pete and repeat read more

Went here for lunch. Had the thin crust pizza, as well as an appetizer. Have driven by a hundred times and we'll be back. Good pizza, good value. read more

What can I say...it is almost Dave's Pizza. Nice atmosphere and outstanding pizza. Never had a bad experience. Handy location if you live in anymore area. read more

The food is amazing. I love the pastas and specialty pizza's, and They have great happy hour prices read more

Located in plain site of the BREC should make it easy to find. I have eaten here maybe 15 times now with small to large groups. Never disappointed with the quality or the service from Keith's. I also eat at their north location. Check this out - half cheese the other half Italian sausage http://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=0dkLYQyhfJzAKnTSJElhRQ&userid=j2L-iiLnXyolau57SZj_Bw AND..bottom is The River with sour kraut, Bavarian sausage and a bunch more stuff...the top half is Italian combo style pizza http://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=ok1q6Yuc8CkutHOQXBbJHQ&userid=j2L-iiLnXyolau57SZj_Bw read more

See all

Always grab pizza here when in town or going through. Take and Bakes taste just as good as baked in store. The River with sauerkraut is always a must but usually through in a Tuscan and something new we haven't tried before. Always fast friendly service with a smile. Never get pizza anywhere else in Bemidji!! read more

Keith's Pizza-South - Take n Bake Pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Bemidji, Minnesota

Ordered pizzas to go and came to pick them up before they were done so I ordered a beer while I wait. "That's 43.95." Me, "put it on my card." She rings it up and gives me my card back then asks for the card so she can ring up the beer seperately...derp! $43.95 for two -2 topping 14" pizzas that were not good at all. Kieth's use to be good. Yuck. read more

Great local place that catered our team pasta feed on short notice and even delivered it to the rink! Good pasta, healthy servings, great customer service! read more

They have awesome Pizza. the IX is the best. I took my Grand-daughter last week for lunch. Cheese slices for her pepperoni & sausage for me. They took great care of 3 1/2 year old, and the co-diners were great too. It's more expensive the Domino's or the Hut, but the Piazza is much better. read more

the pizza was very good. The pasta was good and very large portion. The service was slow and they forgot to make one of the orders.

Pizza is good quality. Thin crust is my favorite here. The all meat pizza is fantastic, I love the texture of the sausage. The veggie pizza was a little heavy on green olives. I guess they need to get rid of them? The lack of stars are for value and customer service. Two 12" "large" pizzas cost $40 even with using a coupon. They refuse to acknowledge your coupon over the phone and force you to bring it in. If you are referencing a coupon from their website - get this - you have to print it out and bring it to them. Y'all got printers hooked up to your smartphones, right? Yeah, me neither. Bottom line - good pizza, kind of a ripoff. P.S. Large pizzas should be at least 14", many times they are 16" and xl is 18" read more

This is a great local pizzeria here in Bemidji. The pizza is out of this world!!!! I came here for lunch having the buffet. I wasn't disappointed with any of the pizzas I tried. The cheeseburger pizza with pickles was especially good! And the chicken is excellent too!!! I ordered a local beer. Terrific! Finally the staff was courteous. If I'm ever in the area again, you better believe I'll stop in! read more

See all

My wife and I ordered a House pizza and the deep fried mushrooms from Keith's and they were great! The pizza sauce had a good balance between being acidic, sweet, and fruity flavors. We got the thin crust and it was excellent! In the middle of the pizza, the crust was crispy and thin. The crust on the outside was airy and crisp. The prices for pizza are reasonable for the quality of the product. The deep fried mushrooms are fantastic!!!!! read more

Love the Bavarian sausage and brick oven sandwiches! Buffet is always popular. Bill Anderson and staff are warm and welcoming. Recommend to anyone looking for a pizza place to call their own. read more

Great pizza! White sauce and almonds add incredible flavor to all their choices. Good sized salads and the wild rice soup is the best in town! Fried chicken and pizza on the lunch buffet is value priced and hot! read more

Great quality ingredients, cook on the crust is on point, and staff is always polite and courteous. And they're dependable.

We were recommended to this restaurant by the staff at the hotel we're staying at. We were in the mood for pizza and were told this was the place to go. Even better was that we heard it was a buffet on weekdays for lunch. We got there just after the buffet started and we were glad we did. The place had filled up pretty good. Of course it is a bit smaller than we thought it would be. The food was amazing although not a whole lot to pick from. Just three pizzas, fried chicken, breadsticks, and soup. The soup was creamy chicken wild rice and honestly it was the best that I had ever had. I must have had four bowls if it. The staff was friendly and pretty on top of things considering how busy they were. Overall it was a good experience for the price and we'd definitely go back whenever we're in the area. read more

I have eaten here often over the years and have always had the same opinion, their crust is terrible. It's by far the worst crust options in Bemidji. Their pizza sauce is also too spiced. Their prices keep going up, every time you go in it seems like all the prices have gone up by about $1 on almost everything. Way too expensive for truck food with some fresh sausage being the only local product. read more

Great service, Met the original Kieths son and was a pleasure to talk with gave us complimentary bread sticks because the location we were at did not do chicken strips. Pizza was excellent 1/2 cheese for daughters loaded for wife and I. Really well made!!!' Thanks Kieths Pizza... Worth the drive. Kevin read more

Don't waste you money! 17 dollars for bad pizza. The topping slip off the crust. Not worth the money! read more

The girl that took care of us was very sweet. She was quick and checked how our food was tasting at a perfect time. The menu is big, perfect for a college student and their parent. It's north woodsy feel is cute for everyone. It was a little diamond in the rough. The cheese in my calzone wasn't fully melted but other than that the calzones were super tasty. read more

Never changes! Bren eating pizza here since i was a little kid am 40 bow! Delicious so hot!! Sometimes you get a rouge employee that only cuts 3 or 4 slices of pizza in odd shape beware cAn be food quality issues. read more

Unfortunately this place isn't all that special. The options for pizza choices seem good but the prices are outrageous. After spending over $20, the pizza we ordered was just very plain, somewhat overbaked and quite unimpressive. Purchasing frozen pizza for under $10 in walmart would have been a better deal and would have tasted the same. Of course this is my opinion and I hope someone else has a better experience at Keith's south side. read more

Great pizza but the real reason I've gone was the all you can eat wings every Thursday. Maxing out there was the best

Some of the best pizza I've had from a restaurant! Highly recommend Keith's South, a little better than the north location.

Good pizza good price so tired of "fast" pizza! Always excellent service whether it's done in or delivery, I'm on south end of town. For nymore location.... love it cozy and convenient for mom and son dates. read more