I prioritized checking off the original Katzinger's at the German village but they are not open until a later hour and we had to make adjustments to our day's schedule. We stopped by Katzinger's in Dublin, a very family-friendly suburb, on a Sunday morning at 9 am and picked up the Katzinger's Reuben in deli size. It is stacked with corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing. We brought the sandwich as lunch for our visit to the COSI: Center of Science and Industry because they are brown-bag friendly. The sandwich sat in our insulated cooler bag for about three hours before we go to it and it held up really well. The meat was tender but the bread lacked a caraway tang. The diner has a complimentary, all-you-can-eat, self-serve pickle barrel. Realistically, you only need one or none at because it was overly salty. read more

See all

You can add parking and move to the suburbs, but Katzingers is still Katzingers. I had to laugh during my most recent visit after the storms when there was a bucket and rags inside the door in perfect trip hazard position just like on third street - leaky roofs are apparently an essential Katzingers tradition. The menu is also the same - we're all living in the same economy, so just like most places the sandwiches have shrunk and the prices have grown, but the quality is still there. And the pickles are still free, so we're not in the end times quite yet. read more

Prior to last week, I had only been to the German village location. I really like that this location is open until 8 pm and seemed less cramped. I felt like the tables were a little bit more spaced out and the staff were friendlier. I love their matzah ball soup and pickles. The pickles were so fresh in the barrel here!! I also loved their special which was a hot roast beef sandwich with garlic, caramelized onions and Italian granolas. Absolutely delicious and I hope it makes it to their daily menu because this honestly is the best sandwich I've had from Katzingers. Definitely give this location a try and check out their special!! read more

See all

Truly disappointing, nothing like a slymans Cleveland or NY Katz , sandwich was cold and portion size was legit horrible , other places give you double if not triple amount of meat read more

Katzinger's Dublin - Cold and small portions, nothing like a NY Katz sandwich or even a Cleveland slymans size sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

I went in a week ago and asked the woman behind the counter: "I need a pound of Rugelach and a Round Challah ahead of the holiday." She said: "When do you need it?" I told her: "11 am on Saturday, Sept 12." She took my name and number. I even asked her if I should buy it and freeze it or pay ahead of time. She said: "No. Just pick it up on the 12th Today I went in and the other young woman said: We don't have any round challah we sold it all Thurs and Friday..." And I had to buy square challah reluctantly. And it wasn't cheap! Thanks a lot. It would be nice if people honored their promises, ESPECIALLY when I relied on it ahead of Rosh Hashana... Will not count on them again. And I ordered a breakfast sandwich while I was waiting on an onion bagel, she put it on a roll...And the bread I bought was stale... Disappointing all around. read more

I grew up eating and loving Katzinger's Deli in German Village, so I dropped in the Dublin location craving corn beef.....when I got it home to make sandwiches, I opened the package to a majority of fatty meat. I had asked for extra lean, but the person working behind the counter had no idea what I was talking about, so I assumed they no longer sold extra lean......but this meat is nothing but FAT! read more

Katzinger's Dublin - Corn Beef.....supposedly - Sandwiches Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

I've had Katzinger's plenty of times for office events from their other location, though years ago). I remembered always enjoying it. Decided to swing into the Dublin location. Love the interior, space, layout. The staff were awesome. FOH took great care of me and it was fun seeing the BOH banter with each other having a good time. Unfortunately, I was underwhelmed by the hot corn beef on rye. The mustard was the best part but the meat was just above cold and frankly lacked any flavor. The rye was good but a tad too dry for my preference. At almost $20 for a sammch and fountain drink I'd really like to have more than meh. I'm a sucker for a deli so I won't give up; so helpfully next time knocks it out. read more

I really wanted to love this place. With Katzinger's name and reputation behind it, I walked in expecting a home run--but unfortunately, this lunch date ended up more like a slow single to right field. The Sandwich Situation - $39 for two sandwiches and two sides of potato salad? For that price, I expected something crave-worthy. Instead, I got an order mix-up right out of the gate: pumpernickel bread instead of the bagel I clearly asked for. The salmon was overly fishy, and the sandwich as a whole just didn't hit the mark. Average at best. Potato Salad - It looked promising, with a hefty portion and nice presentation, but the flavor was just... missing. No real seasoning, no zing, no wow factor. Very bland, and it definitely didn't do anything to boost the experience. Value - For nearly $40, I expected a deli experience that stood out. Instead, it felt more like a quick grab-and-go meal that missed the premium mark entirely. Service & Atmosphere - This is where Katzinger's redeemed itself a bit. The service was excellent--prompt, polite, and professional. The interior was clean, well-organized, and inviting, with that classic deli charm. Final Thoughts: Katzinger's has the polish, the brand, and the potential--but for the price point, the food needs to deliver. I'm all for paying more for quality, but this just didn't justify the splurge. I might give them another shot... but I'll double-check my bag first. read more

See all

My hubby had been excited to take me there since he had their egg salad sandwich for a work lunch. So when we were in the area (and very hungry), we stopped by here and got some sandwiches to go. I got the Jimmy's Photo Finish, with pastrami, Swiss cheese, red onion, hot mustard, grilled on rye. It sounded like a sandwich I loved as a kid, so I had to try it. At almost $18, I was expecting an enormous sandwich, but it was a pretty average sized sandwich. The flavors were really good. Just the right amount of hot mustard, so it wasn't overpowering. My hubby got the egg salad sandwich again, and was very happy with it. I couldn't resist adding a slice of their cherry cheesecake, as well. It was really creamy, and light on the sugar. The cherry topping was so good with the cheesecake, I just wish there was more topping! Checked out the decor while waiting for our food, and saw they sell fresh bread and bagels. You can even ask for a half loaf and have them slice it for you! (If they had a location near my house, I'd definitely be stopping by regularly for their bread!). Overall, loved the place. read more

See all

We had such a great time! We went around 5pm on a Tuesday. There was few people so it was nice. Plenty of seating and has similar same charm as the German village location! Our food was so great, we had a Katzingers Ruben, Judy and Jerry's Sunday Supper, and red skin potato side. Then had a garlic pickle (or 2)! Yum!! We love coming here and can't wait to come back soon! read more

See all

Kept seeing reviews about how good this place was. It definitely was not!!! First time here and for the price I expected so much more. I got the number 69 and the chicken had a very off putting flavor. The bread was very oily from where they grilled it! My husband got the number 31, nothing "hot " about the sandwich, Cole slaw tasted like straight mayo, and the Russian dressing had zero flavor. I absolutely love pickles, was excited for them and those are not pickles!! Biting into a cucumber with zero flavor other than salt! Definitely not worth the cost! read more

I had the Rueben, it's good but prices are high. The pickles are a nice touch , but

Everything went well. This was our second time in. I ordered the number 41. Chicken salad sandwich on rye. It was very good. We didn't have to wait long for our sandwiches, but they were definitely made fresh. We love this place. read more

Just picked up our sandwiches as we were in the area and love the katzingers in German village but we are so disappointed in our 2 sandwiches. My husband got #76 and can barely bite through it the bread is so hard it's almost impossible. My sandwich was lacking in meat. For the price of the sandwich I expect a thick sandwich but what I got was lacking. My bread was also on the older side. The restaurant was also empty. All in all probably won't come back due to the price and quality. I'll just go to the original location. read more

Never was the same after covid. The Dublin store is even worse then downtown. I miss A good NY Jewish Deli. read more

I went to Katzingers today for a sandwich at lunch. The food was good but it took a long time to get it. I saw three people standing around talking while a tall man wearing hearing aids was working. I wanted to say something but I wasn't sure if he could hear me. By the time I got my sandwich it was cold. Unfortunately this is not the first time I've seen this here: people standing around talking while only one person is working. If you've not been here, you order food at a counter and then wait at your table to be served. They also have a small market. At this point not sure I would recommend this place. read more

Is it possible that I have found the best Reuben sandwich I have ever had! A resouding YES! Perfectly toasted rye bread with hot corned beef, Swiss cheese, house made Russian dressing and of course, sauerkraut! The crispiness of the toasted rye bread continued throughout every bite and was accompanied with layers of flavor! The corned beef was very flavorful and had the perfect amount of kraut. The house made dressing was full of flavor as well. My wife had the tuna and I tried one bite of it -- equally as delicious of a sandwich. It would be great even as a hot tuna melt (which is also available) Be sure and check out the pickle barrels where you can chose from whole dill or garlic dill pickles. You simply cannot go wrong with any sandwich that you order here. Wide selection of sandwich offerings. The desserts looked great as well, but we just did not have room to be able to share one. Ask about their charcuterie board options! read more

Katzinger's Dublin - Be's Bustling Birdwich (Deli Size) $15.95 Oven-roasted turkey, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, Russian dressing grilled on rye. - Sandwiches Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

$18?!? First time and I was looking forward all day to a great Rueben. Both my guest and myself got the deli sized Rueben. Very disappointed. We both had the same thoughts. Besides the grumpy cashier where she is waiting just to be angry with you about something, the sandwiches were so bland and lacked any sort of flavor. i am not sure how! not one bit of saltiness or flavor in the corned beef. Minimal 1000 island and I'm not sure if I saw any cheese in there. My second half had broken up bread and barley filled with anything. AND THESE ARE $18 SANDWICHES! read more

This was hands down the BEST corned beef sandwich I have ever had! I ordered the #21 Genes Free Lunch. It has corned beef, roast beef, coleslaw and Swiss cheese. I got it on gluten free bread and had it grilled. The bread held up well and it was piled with meat. A very filling sandwich for sure! I topped off my meal with a bag of chips and a can of Dr, Browns rootbeer and got outta there for roughly $18. Yes, I know that is somewhat pricy for lunch but totally worth it!! The service was good. The manager was pleasant. The restaurant was clean and parking was plenty read more

Katzinger's Dublin - #21Gene's Free Lunch Sandwich on gluten free - Sandwiches Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

I've lived in Columbus for the majority of my life and this was my first trip to katzingers. And honestly I was disappointed. I got the #9 cause I'm a pastrami girl and I got the smaller size which basically equated to me making a sandwich at home? I thought the pastrami would be at least the chunky thick cut & flavorful kind. Nope was still pretty thin like any kind you'd get from the grocery store. And the rye bread was nothing to write home about. Neither was the mac salad. It wasn't dry which was nice but it didn't have really any flavor. Giving 3 stars just because my food was ready when I picked it up & it wasn't bad just not worth $17 - I definitely could have made this all at home and had the same experience. Overall I am definitely not pressed to return. read more

Sorry. I really do not enjoy leaving a negative review. First time visit today to celebrate our 51st Anniversary. My wife and I have always enjoyed great deli food at places like Katz's, Carnegie, Corky & Lenny's, etc. We were excited to try Katzinger's. It was a soul-crushing disappointment. Based on their popularity and longevity, I guess we caught them on an off-day. Our sandwiches were tasteless, the latkes were awful. The staff couldn't have been nicer and the place itself is very attractive. For us, it wasn't worth the hour drive there and back. Sorry. read more

I was hankering for a sandwich and got recommended this place. On first impression, you walk into an area that looks like a regular deli counter. Then you look up at the menu and there are so many options, it's almost overwhelming. They are all organized by which meat is running the show on the sandwich, which I liked. Along with sandwiches, you can order sliced meat as well as traditional Jewish food. One thing I couldn't find on the menu was the difference between their sizes. I asked and one is a quarter pound and the other half pound of meat. The sandwiches are pretty expensive at $18 per sandwich with no sides. Once you order, you head back to the dining area and the area where they make the real sandwiches. In front are two barrels will self-serve pickles. I have mixed feelings about it because I like unlimited pickles but also it is an open container sitting out all day, which is a little unsanitary. The area was clean but at least half of the tables were out of napkins and I had to jump from table to table looking for some. The employees were nice but some were standing around and could've replenished the napkins. I ordered the upper Ruben that was featured on Food Network and it was pretty fantastic. I really enjoy their sandwiches but the prices keep me from frequenting here more. read more

See all

Pros: Good location with easy parking All you can eat pickles Large seating area Cons: Quality has declined significantly since they opened sandwiches half the size for more money limited staff so service slow Matzo ball soup was tasteless and watered down Pro tip: Visit the OG downtown location instead read more

We are always on the lookout for a good deli and will drive out of the way for it. Having grown up with Lou & Hy's in Akron and Slyman's in Cleveland, and many trips to NY & Chicago, we have experience to compare. We ordered 2 deli size sandwiches hoping to take leftovers home for later. Unfortunately it was all very thick, very dry bread and hardly any meat. I can't imagine what the regular looked like if these were supposed to be the larger ones. I love a good deli potato salad and my first bite into it was crunchy uncooked potatoes. Couldn't even eat it. The flavor was great and I'm sure it would have been awesome if the potatoes were cooked. We did get some "Ruggies" for the road to go with our Starbucks and those were pretty good. Maybe the German Village location is better, I'm not sure, but unfortunately I can safely say we will not be back. read more

See all

I somehow had no idea this was here. It's been a while since I've been to the one in German Village, and I needed a quick lunch, so I stopped in. Not huge, but it's big enough, and very cozy and warm inside. You order at the counter, and they bring your food out. Loads of different sandwiches. I got the belly buster, which is pastrami, coleslaw, etc. I got a large, and while it was pretty big and fairly good, it seems a little overpriced. But then that's my complaint about Katzinger's in general: It's good, not great, but priced as if it were great. Still, a good sandwich, and it's a Columbus institution that has been around for years, so I don't want to bash them too much. And of course there was the knish. Perfect. Thin pastry around a mix of hot mashed potatoes and soft onions. Heaven. I also got a bagel to go for later. Everything bagel, a bit hard from being old or overcooked, with good scallion cream cheese. Don't forget to get some pickles from the barrels. Loved the garlic, the dill was mushy. The total bill actually wasn't too bad: $25 for a lot of food. The service was minimal but excellent. The whole experience was good. There are loads of other things on the menu I'd like to try. I'm not on board with the super fandom in town, but I'll stop in once in a while read more

There were so many St. Patty Day special and I just went and try a Ruben Sandwich from Katzinger's. As you enter, you will see a fully stocked deli counter. Their option for deli sandwich is quite extensive. Highly recommend to study the menu before going. After ordering from the counter, just walk over to the dinning room and the staff will bring your food to the table. As you are waiting, there is also two huge bucket of pickle that you can self serve. I got a bowl of homemade chicken broth with noodles and the Ruben Steve's Cross Currents. I do like their light and subtle chicken broth, plus near 1-1 ratio on the noodles. As for the Ruben Steve's Cross Currents, I love the mix of the ingredients. The chopped chicken liver add an extra layer of creaminess and the super refreshing and crunchy coleslaw. For personal tasting, I think it can use a bit more seasoning to bring out the flavor from each parts. read more

See all

Really? This is a $15 "real deli" Reuben....they should be ashamed of themselves. There was barely any meat in every bite, and thankfully I had thousand island at home! read more

Katzinger's Dublin - Really? This is $15 "real deli" Reuben? They should be embarrassed - Sandwiches Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

The food here is incredible! I'm so happy it's close to My work for takeout or dine in on lunch. Remember, Quality ingredients means steeper prices. Chips, sandwich and drinks as $16. It's great for once in awhile, but because of the prices I can't go as often as I'd like. read more

I love the food at Katzinger's and go there frequently. However, the service has never been great. I went to pick up lunch today and it was not busy AT ALL. There was a man behind the order counter as I was waiting to place my order, but he said nothing to me and was just slicing cheese. I waited probably 5 minutes until someone came to the order counter to help me and she was frantic. She was interrupting me while I was placing my order too (which is probably why my order ended up getting messed up in the end). I am pregnant and getting over an illness. All I needed was a quart of matzo ball soup. Once I got home with my order, I saw they gave me soup with noodles and NO MATZO BALLS AT ALL. This is not the first time they have messed up my order. If they could practice some patience while I am placing my order maybe this would stop happening. read more

What a wonderful store and restaurant! Much more room inside compared to the original German Village store. And of course free pickles, plus very friendly personal... read more

See all

I took my father-in-law today for lunch because he loves Rubins. I got a Rubin as well which the meat was almost ice cold. I ate half the sandwich, but I mentioned to the nice young lady working the register. She apologized and gave me a refund on that sandwich. It will be a while before I return. BTW, my sandwich barely tasted like a Rubin. I'm not sure why. read more

Today was my first time ordering from Katzinger's and I was pleased. I ordered the chopped liver, Latke and carrot cake. The chopped liver was delicious and filling. More than enough for a couple of people. I only gave 4 stars in my review as I ordered sour cream with my Latke which wasn't provided. The carrot cake was moist and very tasty. Regardless, I'll be back. read more

Katzinger's Dublin - Sandwiches Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

I have been to the Katzinger's downtown and got excited when I also saw they have a location in Dublin. I ordered food to go. You walk up to the counter and order. Once your order it placed you can then find a seat if you are dining in. They had a lot of yummy looking desserts. My sandwich was good and filling. It was a quick in and out but most likely will end up here for lunches every now and then. read more

This was our first visit to Katzinger's Dublin location. Hand sanitizer is available for customer use throughout the business. Tables are nicely spread out. I ordered the Bill, Gary, & Beufort Upper Yeogh Reuben with coleslaw (choice of slaw or sauerkraut) on pumpernickel. It's warm/toasted, creamy, smoky and super delicious. I would highly recommend it!!! My husband ordered the Ka & Shoggy deli size. It was stacked full of Turkey, corned beef, & slaw. Served cold. A massive sandwich! (Names of sandwiches may be misspelled/slightly off.) I also ordered a side of Greek salad, which was decent. Nothing to write home about. Could use a little more vinegar or some. We also had a dill pickle and garlic pickle. The dill is great. The garlic pickle tastes very fresh- maybe could use a little more time in the spice mix. Overall I would definitely recommend this place! read more

See all

The place is pretty cute on the inside. Parking is convenient as it's right out front so no need to deal with street parking or a garage or anything like that. The service was good, quick & attentive. The food was also good, although they kinda skimped when I asked for extra lettuce and tomato... wasn't really ... EXTRA like I asked. $17 for a sandwich is also pretty crazy to me, but... I wasn't the one paying for it so ... I didn't even look at prices when I ordered. ONLY due to the prices I won't be able to afford to be back here. read more

We've been to their downtown location many times and have been very happy. So having all those high quality experiences I had some high expectations. I was not disappointed. The Dublin location has the same great vibe and atmosphere. This location was larger, spacious and there was plenty of room inside with additional patio seating. I love the eclectic decor multiple pictures and knick knacks, cook books etc. There was music playing which added to the relaxed old school atmosphere. We were sad that they weren't able to fill the pickle barrels. I had the classic Reuben and a dill pickle so rest assured I got my pickle fix. The service was friendly, we had to wait but it wasn't too bad. The employees wore gloves and masks. We took our sandwiches to go and went to a park and had a picnic date. read more

Katzinger's Dublin - Sandwiches Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

I ordered deliver and I'm so stoked they're in Dublin now! I ordered a corned beef sandwich, garlic pickle, koogle and challah bread. I absolutely love their food from the north market location and it's just as tasty at their Dublin location. I inhaled the food in about 8 minutes ha! You can choose what type of break you want your sandwich on and of course I chose challah! The sandwich is stuffed with corned beef, and is juicy, tasty, gooey, and falls apart in your mouth; exactly how it should be. The garlic pickle is very juicy and tasty. It's a pickle, not much to say. The koogle is just absolutely delicious! I got the apricot filling, but they're all wonderful! The Pastry itself is perfect and filling is nice. Now let's get to the challah! I thought I ordered 2 pieces of challah for $4, when it arrived, it was an entire loaf!!!! And entire loaf for $4?!?! I'm shocked, stunned and thankful! They have the best challah around and I'll be enjoying this all week. I wanted two pieces to celebrate my deceased grandmothers birthday tomorrow morning, but this is just wonderful. Very thankful for this bread. read more

See all

Repeat visit. We ordered the #1 (Reuben) and #60 (Salmon) with sides of macaroni salad, redskin potato salad, and potato latke. Sandwiches are excellent. Sides were a bit bland but good with some adds to our liking (Dijon, pepper). The latkes are very good. read more

See all

Made a visit here with some coworkers for lunch and frankly was disappointed. This could have been due to the incredible hype around Katzinger's, however after my experience I'm not going to be recommending this place to individuals visiting the area. For context, I've been to numerous Jewish delis outside Columbus and this probably ranks at the bottom of all of them. Unlike the other Katzinger's location, this deli only offers table service if you want to sit down to eat. We were greeted by a member of the staff and then were seated at a spacious table. There were many individual tables in the restaurant and then a few communal tables that could be shared by several small parties or one really large group. The space was well decorated but nothing super memorable. In terms of the food, I ordered a regular Katzinger's Ruben which was $12.95 (not including tax). The sandwiches come in two sizes- a regular size and a deli size ($15.95). The regular size is a quarter pound and the deli size is a half pound. I was quite disappointed in the size of the sandwiches in comparison to the cost. Another member of our party ordered a deli sized version of his sandwich and it didn't look that much larger than the regular versions. My Ruben was served on a decent piece of rye, however when they toasted the rye, they used so much oil that it pretty much ruined the bread from a textual aspect. The sandwich overall wasn't anything mentionable. For $12.95 you have a lot of better lunch options in the Dublin area. They also have a self service pickle bar where they have regular and garlic pickles for you to choose from. The regular pickles were pretty good but I would stay away from the garlic ones. The garlic pickles tasted like someone threw garlic powder in a barrel of pickles and just gave it a stir. Overall, don't think I'll be returning. read more

Katzinger's Dublin - Katzinger's Ruben - Sandwiches Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

I guess we could call ourselves regulars at this point. We come for the Reuben which is excellent. Their soups are also quite good but they only make them in the colder months. I have seen some reviews where the staff is called out for being inattentive. Those folks may be happier at McDonalds. Go on in, be chill, and enjoy a relaxed pace. read more