This review is for the restaurant side, which is open limited hours on Friday and Saturday by reservation only. Kate and Ally's is always our family's go-to spot in the area. We've tried just about everything on the menu at this point, and every single dish has been outstanding. Everything is prepared beautifully, and the service truly outshines any other restaurant nearby. It has that warm, homey vibe where the waitresses even know us by name. Their specials change often--my top pick is the short rib gnocchi, which is absolutely incredible. And definitely don't forget to BYOB! If you haven't tried this gem yet, you're missing out. read more

Starting with the warm bread and amazing butter we were amazed. Lindsey and entire team were beyond attentive(sorry I failed to remember other names) never had to ask for more water etc-they noticed! My husband couldn't believe all the lobster in his lobster bisque soup, I loved the tuna sushi appetizer which was a full meal in of itself. Husband's filet mignon was cooked to perfection and scrumptious as well. My lobster/shrimp carbonara rigatoni amazing. Needless to say we cannot wait to return. read more

They have the best chef in town. The food is always incredibly delicious! The staff is very friendly and informative! Cash only.... No problem! read more

Amazing food, attentive service & a cozy spot for dinner! We have tried Kate & Ally's a few times when it was catered but this was our first time dining in. You need to call for a reservation to make sure they're open since they are super busy with catering but they generally have some availability each week! The crab tacos were incredible. I wish I got 100 orders of them. They were the best crab tacos I've ever had! For dinner we had the two of the specials: Short Rib Gnocchi and Seafood Lasagna. They both had so much flavor and were delicious. They also have an extensive dessert menu - we took home a slice of cake which was also off the charts. Can't wait to be back! read more

Kate & Ally's - Crab Tacos, Steamed Clams - New American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

See all

Great restaurant with delicious food. Watch their schedule and make a reservation whenever you can.

Had a party in their private room which was very nice, food was absolutely delicious, servers were wonderful, would highly recommend having a party or dinner at Kate &Allys! read more

I have been trying to get into Kate and Ally's for over a year. I called and was able to get a reservation last minute. I have never been so happy that I got this reservation. The food was off the charts. The Service, was also amazing. Very cute little restaurant as well. Everything on the menu sounded incredible and I was going to order the filet mignon with au poivre sauce until they told me they had a halibut special for dinner. Halibut is my favorite fish and needless to say it was prepared in the most delicious sauce. It was in a lemon white wine, butter, caper sauce with fresh tomatoes, and also came with three large jumbo shrimp. It was served with a side of asparagus and roasted potatoes. My boyfriend had the filet mignon in a Gorgonzola crab sauce. He is an incredible griller and he said he couldn't have made that piece of meat any better. It was cooked to perfection. The only thing better was the special we had for an appetizer. It was gnocchi with short ribs. It probably was one of the best things I've ever ate in my life and I'm still dreaming about it. Also, the portions were large that we took so much home, and what I also loved is that the food came out piping hot. I am a big advocate for desserts as I love my sweets, but we were so full... definitely next time. This was one of the best meals I have ever had, and I look forward to hopefully being able to get a reservation again soon. If you can get a reservation, grab it. I highly recommend Kate & Ally's. Also... It is BYOB. read more

Kate & Ally's - My halibut and his filet mignon with Gorgonzola crab sauce. - New American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

See all

I was really looking forward to dinner Kate Nelly's as they had catered a number of parties where I used to live in the food was absolutely delicious. So when we arrived (party of six) we were greeted by the hostess - very pleasant. The restaurant is warm and inviting our waitress was very good, friendly and very knowledgeable of the menu. She was also very enthusiastic about the food which was a good sign. We started out with ordering several appetizers, which were very good. I decided to order one of the specials- the pork chop Milanese. It was a large piece of breaded boneless pork with arugula, tomatoes, and possibly cheese laying on top basically it was a salad plopped on top of the pork so salad actually made the pork mushy and it was like putting cold on hot- not at all appetizing. In fact, I took two bites and was done- terrible! when the waitress came around to collect the plates, I told her to take it away. She never asked me what was wrong with it so I paid $44? For a meal I didn't eat. Dessert was very good however, the cappuccino was delivered to the wrong person, and it was supposed to be decaf the other cappuccino with regular coffee. Thus one of the cappuccinos went untouched as my friend did not feel comfortable that it was in fact decaf. Portion sizes good, nice service, somewhat overpriced - food mediocre at best. One and done! read more

Ambiance was quiet with lights on each table. Service was excellent and the food was unique and delicious, with many choices to consider.

So good! Great atmosphere. Amazing service. And the food ....... My wife and I split the she crab soup. That and the hot fresh made bread could have been a tremendous meal all by itself. Then salad. By the time our entrees came we were already full! But we soldiered on. I got the short rib gnocchi. My wife got the filet with some kind of crab sauce on top. Both were excellent. The meats were insanely tender. And very generous portions. Piping hot, and melts in your mouth. Absolutely delicious. As full as we were, we decided to get the chocolate dome cake and vanilla ice cream. Really, really good. The place is expensive, but worth every penny. We highly recommend it. Btw: bring cash. They don't accept credit cards read more

Food is always delicious but pricey! I was not allowed to order two appetizers for dinner, which was kind of annoying since I knew I would have to take the dinner home because I wouldn't be able to eat all the food, which I did. Their she crab soup is to die for! At these prices though I won't be able to frequent very much read more

Food and service is amazing here. My husband was born and raised in Point Pleasant so he has always had the best and freshest seafood one could ask for. Kate & Allys has the best lobster bisque that we have ever had anywhere(that's saying a lot)!!! This is my favorite place to eat. EVERYTHING they serve is just amazing. read more

Kate & Ally's - Yes he poured the wine in the water glass but I still love him. - New American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

See all

Tostados and the gnocchi were fabulous wait staff excellent! It's byob so super affordable!

Service - Great! Atmosphere - Excellent NY Strip - Very good Hunter's Chicken (Their signature dish) - not as good as it used to be - I was disappointed a bit. Pricing is a bit high, but worth a try - make your own decision...... read more

Consistently great food. Filet is always cooked to order and delicious. Atmosphere is very appealing.

Wow! This was the best meal I've had in a very long time. The service was great. Our waitress was super attentive but also not overbearing. We ordered the carpaccio and burrata for our appetizers and both were knockouts. For our mains we shared the steak and the chicken dishes. I can't remember their exact names but I attached pictures below. Everything was so fresh. We also got the lava cake which was just dreamy. The picture doesn't do it justice. We're already looking forward to returning here. read more

See all

We had our wedding in August 2023 at Kate & Ally's. They did a magnificent job making sure our wedding was exactly what we wanted. Lauren was our planner and she ensured we had everything we wanted and kept everything moving without a hitch! Our guests LOVED the food! and a few have been back for dinner since. We can't say enough good things about the facility, food, and attention to details! We're so glad we had our special day at Kate & Ally's! HIGHLY RECOMMEND. In addition, we've been there for dinner several times and have never walked out disappointed! It is a hidden gem in Lacey. Linda and Ralph Walker read more

Delicious food. Probably one of the best crab soups that I've ever had. delicious gnocchi . Super friendly , efficient staff. on the pricier side , but if this place was in Asbury, Point, Red Bank etc, you wouldn't think twice about the prices. Don't let the outside fool you ((strip mall.) read more

5 Plus Stars!! I met a Beautiful Lady there for a dinner and the staff could not have been more welcoming and hospitable! The food, service and atmosphere were incredible!! I would highly recommend them for dinner anytime!! you won't be disappointed! The back patio sitting by the water just topped it off!! Dino read more

We went to K&A for catering and was very pleased and impressed. The people who helped us were incredibly helpful and patient. (Our half in the bag nephew went to help pick it up and they even made him look good.). read more

Not sure I understand if this is for private parties only or open to the public. My husband and I stopped one night and there were guests in the doorway. We walked up to one guest saying to the hostess, "Who are they? They're not part of our party". The hostess just said she didn't know. We just left read more

Impeccable food and excellent catering menu. Kate & Ally's sent Lindsey to set up an hour prior to our event and provided everything we needed including paper products, utensils, serving trays and ladles, even coffee and tea station. The only thing that disappointed was I felt that they should've provided a couple of extra pieces of chicken just to be on the safe side. In the future I would order 2 trays of chicken instead of 1 chicken and 1 roast beef. Our guests raved about the food and several people asked me for the caterer contact information. read more

The food is always amazing, especially the she crab soup! Service is also right on top of things to round out your evening.

This is only based on how lovely they have their outside dining set up. During these crazy Covid times and how the Gov'ner hasn't opened up inside dining yet, we are seeing more restaurants striving to open by having outside dining. Some are doing it right - and this place is. Seriously, I comment to everyone about how cute they have it set up with the lights, plants, trellis landscape happening right there on busy Rt 9 and sitting there you probably don't even give it a second look cause they expertly place high hedges along the perimeter. High praise to them considering their customers ambiance while they dine. Every where else is just pitching tents. read more

Kate and Ally's is amazing. We went for my birthday in December so it was decorated beautifully for the holidays. The staff is fantastic and the food is to die for. Have also been to many events that have been catered by Kate and Ally's and food is always delicious. read more

Warm cozy atmosphere, staff very friendly and welcoming and most importantly the food was delicious. I've been to parties they have catered as well and the food is amazing. I would give them 5 out of 5 stars, the quality of the food is exceptional and the presentation is amazing. Why cook yourself when you can get Kate and Ally's! read more

This place never disappoints food is always fresh and delicious specials are amazing it's hard to choose a main dish especially after you order many of the delicious appetizers staff is wonderful it's Lacy's hidden gem FYI Reservation is a must BYOB and cash only read more

Easily the biggest kept secret in ocean county! Probably the best food I have ever had in my life, everything was cooked perfect. You definitely get your moneys worth! 10/10 read more

Omg it's been such a long time since we have had such an incredible dinner anywhere dining out. This is the place! The food was beyond amazing and the staff was so attentive and sweet you couldn't ask for any more. We both had the She crab soup which hands down was the best I've ever had in decades it was perfection - warm bread and herb butter to accompany the soup and then a side salad with home made croutons that were so flavorful (it's the little things) next up was shrimp with crabmeat which was so fresh and tasty delicious crabmeat on top of beautiful fresh shrimp - keyword delicious and fresh fresh fresh- home made mashed potatoes were delicious too- my husband had the most fantastic tender delicious strip steak of his life and was thrilled. Apple crisp and home made ice cream for dessert - it was the best for sure and we are already going back and simply cannot wait. Inside decor was also warm and inviting! Highly recommend this place the food is just beyond and they all seem to really care! read more

See all

I used them to cater for a small Christmas party at my home. The owner was not very interested in my business and took two days to call me back. I asked to meet with them to go over the menu, which they agreed to but it was obvious that they considered it beneath them to bother. They never contacted me before the party to confirm, and did not seem to take it seriously when I told them I had a guest with a nut allergy. They showed up early on the day of the party, but the young man was good setting up. The cheese platter consisted of a bunch of cheese cubes, all of which tasted the same. The food was ok, not great. I wouldn't use them again. read more

Food is always excellent, service was excellent as well. We always enjoy an evening at Kate and Ally's.

Anniversary party of nine. The food was very good, as expected. It's BYOB, which is nice, but we weren't offered beer glasses or ice. The filet was awesome, but not cooked medium....very rare. For an added $5.00, I had about a tablespoon of crab sprinkled on. Was told I could not bring a cake for the celebration. Ok. Looked for a dessert menu or coffee...nope. Had to go in search of waitress to pay the bill. Everyone did enjoy their food and appetizers. Nice setting by their fireplace. Only mention the above petty peeves so the owners might address them for future clientele. All in all, a nice family dinner. $$$$ read more

The food and service is always amazing. Hidden gem of Forked River! Their catering is great also.

This place never disappoints! Food is always delicious and it is truly a hidden gem! read more

Kate & Ally's - New American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

Excellent food, excellent service! You will not be disappointed in menu selection. Personally enjoy their chicken dishes!

Just the best in the area. Great food and great service. We have eaten in and had takeout and they never fail. The best lamb chops ever.

We were a party of 10 for a friend's birthday and my biggest regret is that we live 60 miles away. Otherwise I could see my self coming back here again and again. Service is great! The food was up there too. I had the short rib over spinach and it was delicious. My wife absolutely loved her seafood stew cioppino. For our meals this place would be a 5 but it was noted that the person ordering the steak said it was kind of dry and that the short rib over fettuccini was drenched in a way too thick and creamy alfedo sauce as was the seafood lasagna. My friend who ordered the pasta carbonara raved about it. Everybody seemed to love their appetizers and soups and we did have a wide variety of these items. Still having blissful thoughts about my meal there. read more

Food is good, menu changes but some favorites stay like the hunters chicken. It's only open - typically Thursday to Sunday to eat in but the catering is awesome as well. BYOB is nice read more

I attended a wedding on 5/12/18 at LBI Foundation of the Arts in Loveladies,NJ and I must say that the food was absolutely delicious!! I was very impressed and wanted to give you a thumbs up and thank you! I don't write reviews very often but you are well deserving of an excellent review! Thank you! Chris S. read more

This is our third visit to this restaurant and each time we had excellent food and service. We made reservations for the eary dining. The ceaser salad was crisp and seasoned just right. Crab soup was creamy with enough crab to signature it as authentic. The beef short ribs with gnocci were fork tender and enough for two meals. Dessert was a choice of chocolate cake or homemade bread pudding. i chose the bread pudding and was pleasantly rewarded with a unique apple and delicate syrup laced pudding that blended perfectly. We had a nice selection of coffee or tea to end a perfect meal. I always pay attention to the type and quality of bread served with the meal, and this bread was hot and crusty served with a flavorabe herb butter, an accompanying delight. Its this attention to details that puts this restaurant into a higher category. The waitstaff service was attentive but not intrusive. The one negative was our table next to the window with the setting sun reflecting through the blinds. Next time we will request a table by the inside wall. BYOB read more

Kate & Ally's - A great dinner at Kate & Ally's - New American Near Me - Forked River, New Jersey

See all