I didn't realize I hadn't reviewed this Just Pizza yet! We've lived in the neighborhood for over five years, but it took us at least two years to try this place because the reviews were all so bad...it's a shame it took so long because we've been quite happy with it!! We don't really get whole pizzas here anymore because we're hooked on another place right now, but we still get occasional slices and they're always good, not the best...but good. We love their wings! They're consistently well made, fried hard and we enjoy the hot sauce, and I love their blue cheese. The customer service is decent enough, no real problems. We'll definitely be back regularly! read more

See all

No gloves? At this point a bad review isn't going to make a difference. the thing about their pizza, regardless of topping, is that it doesn't taste like anything. And they all taste the same. Something is missing and always has been. That doesn't stop me from grabbing a slice from time to time, but I noticed some thing today that left a bad taste in my mouth. I noticed that all of the line cooks prepping the pizzas are using their bare hands. Digging into boxes of cheese and toppings, pushing down on the dough. I'm sure everyone is washing their hands blah blah blah, and I'm sure that the heat of the oven kills off any germs, but I still found it gross in this day and age. I was surprised. It may actually keep me from coming back. read more

Whenever I fly into town. They know they gonna see me. I think their pizza is better than their wings but their wings are also kinda fire. I almost always get a large pizza with 50 wings. I get half bbq and half hot and I get them charred. The pizza is a bit sweet. The sauce has some extra sugar or something. But it works out great. Super flavorful and makes me come back for me. The pizza is cut into mini slices rather than triangular. The blue cheese always smacks. The location always get knocked for a bunch of different reasons mostly customer service which they aren't wrong but put all of that aside, I'm always a happy customer. Place is much better suited to go and for you to order combos rather than a slice. There are a few seats to enjoy your meal but not many. It's a smallish place. Next to a 7/11. Either way it's a pricey place but your tummy will thank you. read more

See all

Ordered a Napoletana pizza GF base .....up there as one of the worst pizzas ever. . Floppy base too much tomato which tasted like tomato paste not proper pizza base. The olives were cheap and stale to the point where they were multicoloured and partially dry and far too salty. Nothing good about this cheap and nasty pizza.... Never again. read more

Love their Pizza (you can choose a flavored crust). They do not disappoint from their Cheese Pizza and their Three Cheese Steak with Hot Peppers. read more

I wasn't feeling great and had no energy to cook for myself. I just wanted something that I don't normally eat that would be satisfying. Then it came to me, a turkey sub! ( I'm from New York City- It took a long time for me not to call this a hero!) I ordered the sandwich on line and it was everything I hoped it would be: Fresh sesame roll, cool crunchy lettuce tasty plentiful turkey. All the other requests, perfectly portioned. Came on time, too. It made me happy. It will make you happy, too. read more

Theyre definitely top 3 for slices in my opinion due to the dough not being as soft and as chewy enough that the sauce of the pizza mixes in with it for that perfect texture definitely good taste though. Top 5 for cookies they're definitely soft and chocolaty but it's something about the almost gingery taste a cookie has in the after taste that it was missing. Employee was on top of everything me and my wife needed. Outside of the spatula being on a bare counter the store is def clean which I assumed and hoped the counter was which is why I didn't speak up. Always a good experience when I come here though! read more

Just Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Have been here before, always gotten some sort of regular pizza...meat, cheese, one or two veggies. Always good, but ...just pizza. Last Saturday, however, I had a pizza craving on the way home from yard sales. Parked and asked my daughter to run in and get me two slices. "Meats don't matter," I said, "but veggies, lots of veggies." She came out, in record time I might add, with two slices of onion pizza. No meat. I was surprised they had a vegetarian pizza hot and ready to be sold as slices. It was terrific! Thinly sliced onions and a lot of them. I usually get onion on pizza but never so many or so well done. There were also a few olives, green and black, and fewer mushrooms. That was all good, I will order an onion pizza in future, sans olives. I don't need that extra sodium. The photo does not do these slices justice. Not just because I didn't think to take pic until I'd eaten half of one slice, but because they looked better than in photo, and larger, too. I had one slice for lunch, the other for supper. If you are a pizza lover but should cut fats and sodium (and who shouldn't), I highly recommend an onion pizza from Just Pizza. read more

Just Pizza - Best pizza I've had in a long time, healthiest, too. Vegetarian. Lower sodium, lower fat. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I go to the just Pizza on Elmwood avenue... Their customer service has always been excellent, the pizza and wings combos are greatly priced, they have great salads and a dessert case to pick from also. And a great sit-down area as my family enjoyed for lunch. Kudos to just Pizza read more

I stopped in just to grab a slice of cheese. I've lived in nyc for over 9 years. Their cheese slice was rock hard, cost $5.17 and there was no actual tomato sauce on the slice. In retrospect I wouldn't even pay $1 for that garbage cardboard. In nyc when you pay $5 you actually get a quality slice. I've had better pizza at 7/11 and high school cafeterias. I give this place negative stars. read more

Slow because they were busy but these BBQ wings are ridiculous how good they are. Just allow yourself some extra time with the orders before you. read more

I came here today during lunch to grab two slices. I didn't call ahead of time but they had six different kinds of pizza, if you wanted to come in and randomly ask for a slice: I ordered cheddar and broccoli and a slice of Buffalo chicken. Both were great! I loved how crispy the crust was. The service was good. I was in and out. This was my first time at this location. I'll definitely be back! read more

Just Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Pizza is ok a bit on the greasy side and actually tasted better the next day in the air fryer heated up fwiw! The "atomic" Buffalo wings were actually quite good nice and crispy decent heat level (could be hotter imo) accompanying blue cheese dressing was very good.!I would say definitely not a great place for dining in-not many tables, we were given no plates or utensils and the napkin dispensers was all but empty. All in all kind of a dive.Employees not overly friendly-the security guard (?) who seemed to be on duty was actually more pleasant and helpful than the person who took my order lol She told me it would take 30 minutes for the pizza and she was true to her word, which seems like a long wait for a dine in pizza. read more

My husband went today and got 4 slices of Buffalo chicken and a slice of pepperoni! Each slice over $5 thin as a sheet of paper tasted horrible! What happened I used to love thier pizza ? Do better Elmwood!!!! Smh! read more

Great pizza and staff. Manager was hands on everything helping staff. Wish we lived closer.

I placed an order for a medium Caesar salad and was told it would be ready in 45mins. I arrived for pickup 45 mins later and the cashier got the drinks and cake i also wanted then said that someone else was making the salad. I paid for everything then waited, waited, waited, and waited. I watched MANY people come and go and I was still waiting. I finally asked the cashier when would my salad be ready and I was told that they were filling sub orders which were top priority, seriously! I waited another 10 - 15 mins to finally get my salad! read more

I always laugh and get smiles, food is always amazing and the wings are great, I will be back for more.

They give a wait time of 20 minutes and 40 minutes later food was done. Gave attitude because I the customer was mad. The peppers on pizza weren't even cooked. Place has gone way downhill read more

Food is always consistent. I love their variety of toppings and the wings, while a little small, taste great.

Wanted 1 slice got changed 8.16 didn't realized she gave me 2 okay whatever. then the lady gives me back a ripped dollar I asked for a new one and she replied in the snarkiest way I didn't give u it ripped. Gives me a new one then scolfs at me and walks away. Like lady u already over charged me now u wanna throw a fit bcuz gave me back a dollar that was in 2 pieces and I wanted a new one. What a joke terrible customer service. read more

First of all in the past, most of the time my pizza and wings were good. I don't know what been happening in the past few months, the food has been awful 0n Friday May 2, I ordered triple order of chicken wings. The wings were old, hard and some were burnt lt looks like they had been sitting there along time recooked and served over again! I was very disappointed. I won't be ordering anything again from Just Pizza (Elmwood Ave. Location). It's sad because they use to be very good! read more

Slices are ok sometimes but ordered wings and they were hard as rocks. Won't take the chance anymore.

good crust! great staff, clean facility. great location. kids loved it will be back.

I ordered a medium pizza and 10 wings. I picked it up and when I got home the pizza was burnt snd the wings were fried to hard and had hardly any sauce on them and it tasted like it had been cooked several days earlier. I called back and told them and they said they would take 15% off my next order. I said no. I paid you $35 for this food and now I can't eat it. The lady said bring it back and we will make you another pizza. I said that I was elderly and it was dark and could they have it delivered. She said no. So I had to go back out at night to get the pizza and wings. When I got there, she said she was not going to make another pizza because I had ate 3 slices out if 15, which was a lie. I ate only 1 slice. I told her even if I had eaten 3 slices, they were burnt and the wings were over cooked. She said no we are only going to give you 15% off your next order. I said no because you said you would make me a new pizza if I brung it back. Then another lady in the back said, "Oh just give her a refund and get out". They first of all gave me a burnt up order and wanted to cheat me out of my food and money by just giving me 15% off my next order. Second, I was told to bring it back and she would make me a new pizza, but when I got back there and they seen the pizza and wings were burnt to a crisp, they wouldn't just make me a new order and lied and said I ate 3 slices of burnt pizza. Third, both ladies were nasty and told me to get out the store because I am angry because I had to come all the way back to the store with the idea of getting a new pizza and then they refused to make it and told me to get out. Well I would not leave until she gave me the refund which she said I would have to wait 3 days for. Well I will never ever go back to this store again because it was there fault in the first place because they knew that the pizza and wings were burnt up in the first place and were nasty and disrespectful when I came back for them to set it straight. read more

I was in town from California my family that lives here in Buffalo suggested we try you guys omg the best pizza I had in years the wings were perfect the sauce on the pizza great toppings all fresh lol can't stop thinking about it I'm going to have my family mail me some thank you read more

On Friday the 7th I place order at 4:30 and they said is one to be 1 hour should have received my order at 5:30 but it came at 6:15 and we were fasting terrible customer service. Another thing we ordered bucket of 50 wing and large pizza, the wings weren't crispy as I told them twice on the phone they were saggy the pizza wasn't cooked. It was terrible. How can you run a business and the food even not that great and you pay like $112 for the food it's not about the money but at least the food should have been good. You just loyal I do not appreciate. read more

Pizza is okay. Wings are a 4 out of 10. I was in town tried it bc it was near the hospital. Food fair

I think Just Pizza, had some seriously amazing buffalo wings! They might be known for their Pizza (I think?) but their wings were super meaty, flavorful, and overall delicious. A perfect quick place to stop when going through Niagara. Ordered: - Honey BBQ and Garlic (messy, saucy, yum) - Mac n Cheese bites (whats not to love?) - Large Turkey Sandwich (this sub was really good too!) Since Covid times, there was no seating available inside... that wouldve made things better. Overall, great stop! read more

Just Pizza - a box of chicken wings and a cup of ketchup - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

customer service was terrible I order from here frequently but for some reason my address determine if I could use 100 dollar bill for 40 dollar order crazy world we live in read more

I picked up a double meat ham sub around 5pm. Sat there and waited for it, total was $16 and change. I get home and open the wrapper, the roll is burnt to a crisp, there are 2 slices of ham on the whole sub and onions, I said no onions! I order take out almost every day and this is the worst excuse for a sub I have ever encountered! I called to explain to the worker and she hung up on me! I can't say that I have ever had such a bad example of food in my life and the worker hanging up on me was so wrong. I don't mind paying for good food but I can't comprehend the poor excuse for food. I never call anyone and complain but this has me pretty fired up! I am going to be compensated some how. I could have went local and gotten 2 subs for what they charged me for 1 piece of garbage, which is where my almost 17 dollars went. read more

First things first: it ain't "just" pizza. They got sandwiches and wings too. We dropped in here around midnight after a concert. They weren't taking custom orders anymore because they were about to close. I got a slice that was in their display. It was actually pretty damn good, but I was also more than pretty damn hungry. Hard for me to gauge and put "Just Pizza" into the perfect context based off this experience, but I did enjoy the slice and imagine this is a go-to staple for a late night on Elm Street when most kitchens are already closed for the evening. Parking lot shared with a 7-11 Check out their Insta @justpizza Website: justpizzausa.com read more

Just Pizza - Pep slice with bite taken - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

We recently moved near Just Pizza on Elmwood so we thought we would give it a try. We ordered the Basilico Red Pizza, which has basil, mozzarella, and pecorino on it, as well as an order of wings which were half bbq pit and half blackberry bbq pit. We ordered online to ease the ordering process. The online system said our food would be ready in 30 minutes and it was not. When we arrived at Just Pizza, the staff member said it would be ready it a few more minutes. We ended up waiting an additional 20 minutes. The man waiting next to us stated that he had been waiting for over an hour despite a staff member telling him it would be a 20 minute wait. When tasted fresh, the pizza tasted pretty cheap. There was very little basil and the pecorino was of poor quality. It honestly tasted like "shaker cheese." We had some of the pizza the next day to see if it passed the morning test and it indeed tasted better. Still, I would suggest that better quality ingredients are used if this speciality pizza is continued to be offered in the future. We were pretty excited for the wings, namely the blackberry bbq pit because it sounded very unique. Upon opening the box, the wings were extremely saucy. We are not of the liquidy/saucy camp. We definitely prefer wings with a thickened sauce. Now for taste- I would say the sauce has a great taste but we absolutely could not distinguish the blackberry bbq from the regular bbq. This is a red flag! Perhaps the recipe was off the day we ordered or we were accidentally given two orders of the bbq pit. Overall, we were not impressed by Just Pizza and we do not plan on returning for more food in the future. The wait time was too long and the quality of the food was very low. I definitely do not suggest ordering your pizza from here, but maybe the wings if you like them very read more

Just Pizza - Basilico Red Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

ice cram warm and workers stinky except Parker J Wright and Lucas Makuch, the backround music sucks.

AWFUL SERVICE. We ordered ahead of time and got 20 wings with Cajun fries. She told us nothing was under my name. I showed her proof of my order and she finally decided to check in the back and pulled out my wings. I realized my fries weren't given to me so I asked. She forgot to make them and she just said "5 more minutes". Defeats the whole purpose of ordering beforehand and she didn't even apologize. Yes, you can make mistakes like this but there is a huge difference between apologizing and acting like nothing is wrong. I am never ordering again from this location. read more

Funny thing, my friend meant to order food from a different pizza place and we later figured out he ordered from here - pleasant mistake! We ordered a double wings and fries, but scooped a couple slices of cheese at pick up. They had several options available for on the go slices, most places have one or two, so thought that was awesome. He isn't a big fan of their sauce, but I dig it! You can tell they must've been cranking out slices because the pizza was pretty fresh. The wings were pretty dang good!! For not being from where we planned on going, we were very pleasantly satisfied and would order again. If not the standard mild/medium/hot, expect them to come pitted. Great perk Just Pizza. Many other places around Buffalo charge extra and you kind souls throw that in with price. Very worth it. Fries were just fries, good but nothing to brag about. Not heavy with grease and minimal salt and that's how I prefer mine. Room temperature when we ate them, but it's winter time so I kinda excused that and figured maybe the drive and saving them to eat last is why that happened? Not a huge deal. I would definitely go back. read more

Just Pizza - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Ordered contactless delivery the last 2 play off games. Ordered on line, requested a time, the food arrived right on time on my steps without contact with driver. He called right after dropping of my pizza and wings.A+ for both drivers. The food was great , Lasagna pizza was full of flavor. Thick slices mmm. The Works pizza was great too! Lots of toppings, sliced up and very good. The double wing with honey BBQ on it. Very good sauce. My finger were finger licking good. I will be ordering next Sunday!!! Keep up the good work. Great food and excellent customer service. THANK YOU. read more

See all

Gave this place a few chances, was always sub par, but today sealed it. Guy on the phone was super rude- I called a pickup in and knew exactly what I wanted. He argued with me about the barbecue sauce I was reading off the menu. Just barbecue sauce dude, I literally don't care which type if that's an issue for you. Was told 40 min, I showed up there after 50, still ended up waiting 10. An hour. Then, when I got home, the pizza was missing half of the toppings. Oh, and they only gave me 9 wings. Literally every step of this process- ordering, picking up, and receiving, were just trash. My prior experiences here weren't amazing either. Maybe the other just pizzas are better? I don't want to make any assumptions... definitely skip this one though read more

STUFFED HOT PEPPER PIZZA: Where to start, a beautifully crisp crust layered with a wonderfully delicate blend of natures finest invention, Cheese! To add to the already wonderfully delicious Za, a beautiful mix of sweet Italian sausage and banana pepper rings really takes the seasoning on this top notch pie up to the next level. But what really sets this delicate crust circle apart from other pizzas is the use of the House made pepper dip as a sauce layer, that's truly a chefs kiss ‍. Get this puppy with a honey sesame crust and cut in squares, you won't be disappointed. One of the best Za's the Gang and I have had in a while! read more

Some of the best pizza ive had in a while cooked perfectly and fresh good quantity and overall a great experience

No point in ordering ahead online. The lady said she didn't check the computer, made me wait for extra 20 min, still missed the fries that was on the original order. Throughout the entire visit here the lady never apologized for her mistake. Very rude, very unprofessional. Would give them a zero star if it was an option. read more