I ordered half pound of 3 items. There's no way that's what I got. 3 Scallops equal half pound? 4 shrimp and a few mussels. RIP OFF big time. Over 70 dollars for an Appetizer. read more

I'm only giving this place one star because it won't let me give zero. the management of this place is extremely terrible. me and my girlfriend walked in and got sat, waited over 30 minutes to even get service while i sat there visibly looking at four people sitting there doing nothing. there were tables that were dirty right near us. our waiter who was extremely nice and amazing told us she had to do everything around here. she's a hard worker who had to work 5 tables by herself. The only good thing I have to say about this place is the food which I give a 8/10. read more

Juicy Seafood - dirty table, been here since the moment we sat down - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

Spent $108 on crabs overcooked and stuck to the shell. Shells so soft they won't crack. Trashed the 2nd bag. waste of my money. Seasoning good but not worth what I paid for horrible quality. won't be back and hope This saves the next person the bleep disappointment. read more

Great food Fast service Welcoming to all races Would recommend Would eat there again read more

First of all, I just want to say that you guys got excellent service and the seafood are amazing, but your sauce are too salty and it's kill off the sweetness of the taste of seafood, so I would recommend you to lower your sodium levels and add some extra lemon juice in order he seafood boil to enhance the flavor to taste better, thank you and as for now I don't think I would come back for a second time. read more

One of the better Seafood Restaurant in the Rochester area. Ordered Cajun crab legs, clams, shrimp and some lobster tails. Also ordered a few varieties with just steam and butter. Cajun sauce was fantastic, seafood was fresh and portions were very generous. Potatoes and corn is included with the combo orders. Restaurant was clean and service was good as well. Thank you read more

See all

Rochester 5, but 3.5-4 compared to places in California. Did a takeout of the Christmas Special (2 pounds snow crab, 1 lb lobster, 2 lb headless shrimp, 1 lb mussels, 1 lb clams, corn and potatoes). We got the juicy special with medium spice. It was a FANTASTIC deal. So much hot, delicious seafood. I would say that the actual sauce was just okay (I feel like I always could use more garlic) and it was a little salty for me. The snow crab legs were huge and tasty and the clams were great. Corn and potatoes were large and they didn't skimp on that. This is a good place for seafood in terms of very great prices and specials. Would come back. read more

Juicy Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Lets start by saying this was my first experience with this restaurant I spent a pretty penny witch is not the problem I get home to eat my food as soon as I grab the crab leg there is hair wrapped around the leg I instantly checked my lovers bag and it's as spicy as can be she eats a potato and hair in her mouth how embarrassing how disgusting why no hair nets so I called to inform the manager he tells me I'm sorry b it I can't do anything unless you bring the food back and show me I have pictures sir the food is from last night I throws it In the dumps it's seafood who keeps that in there house. I told him I have pictures in the hair with time stamps he tells me that won't work he doesn't fix the issue that is disturbing I'll never eat from here again read more

Ever since Joe's Crab Shack and the Original Crab Shack closed, Rochester hasn't had a seafood restaurant like that. The restaurant reminds me of Boiling Crab in California. The interior is nautical theme with wood and rope everywhere. You can sign the walls and benches if you can find a permanent marker. After a 10 minute wait we were seated. The host lined a piece of white paper on our table. She then brought over a bucket lined with trash bag that included bibs and gloves. There is a sink on the back wall. I ordered Combo Special A: black mussels, shrimp and snow crab with the juicy special seasoning. It came with corn and 2 potatoes. This was $25 and very filling. It was good minus the fact I didn't get anything to break the crab legs. I also ordered french fries, it comes lightly breaded with cajun seasoning. I really enjoyed the fries. Both times I that I dined here were on a Saturday. The line was long and out the door. It was very disorganized in the waiting area. The floors had garbage from the previous patrons. No one had bothered to clean it up. The first time we dined here our waitress was all over the place. She would tell us one thing and do another. For example, she was ready to take our orders and as soon as we said our order, she said she would be back. She was scatter brain and just a hot mess. DO NOT order the raw oysters. They are from Mexico, most oysters in this area are from the Northeast. The oysters were too meaty and chewy. I would return here when I am in the mood for a variety of seafood smothered in sauce. read more

See all

Juicy Seafood has become a staple in the Rochester area. Located in the Henrietta area, This spot has been a favorite amongst my friends and now it has grown on me! I usually order the Create Your Own: 1/2lb clams, crab legs, and shrimp (no head). The first time here, I chose the juicy special seasoning and turned the temperature of spice to hot. Well-seasoned, not over cooked, and the bag included corn and potatoes! I purchased a side of sticky rice (a must) to soak up the seasoned juice that was leftover in the bag. So good! The second time coming here, I picked the combo option of mussels, legs, and shrimp. I turned the temperature down to mild. I will say, the spice level WAS underwhelming (My mistake). The seasoning did taste different. This time around, the thyme overpowered the rest of the seasoning. Wasn't all that bad after squeezing some lemon in the bag, but definitely a different taste. I'll be returning soon! read more

Juicy Seafood - Combo #1: 1/2lb black mussels, crab legs, and shrimp (no head) - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

Definitely not a bad idea to come here to get a seafood boil, most of the spots here that offered them don't have good seasonings or either the corn and potatoes are over cooked or old but this spot is very delicious. The wait wasn't bad for the amount of guest that was in the restaurant, but it was freezing, even the waiters had coats on lol. But once you start eating then you get hot and feel better. Bring a friend and crack some crabs open, good portions for the prices, me and my family always spilt a bag read more

See all

Great service, great food! We ordered the combo and it fully filled 3 bellies. The atmosphere was nice and chill.

Yah know when you have food regret.... this is it. I'm also just not a fan of an establishment that has patrons signing the walls, which, just saying our wait staff forgot to give us a marker. There's the word bi$#& and cross outs and it's just that if I wanted that I'd go to a dive and expect to pay 6.99 a plate. I certainly wouldn't bring my family to a place with swear words on the walls. So there was some repetition due to communication challenges. Although very kind and truly trying their best. I don't want to jeopardize any jobs so I will spare details. We did have to ask for the wet naps and silverware and refills of water but maybe the person was off their game due to the food requests. I had the make your own with green mussel, black mussel, clam, shrimp no head hot juicy mix of seasoning which was good. I'm always suspicious of already opened seafood, the green mussels were halved, some had broken shells, some of the black mussels didn't open and also had broken shells mmmmm no thanks. The shrimp and tiny clams however, were quite good. The tatos were well cooked, the corn chewy and tough. Chicken (impulse purchase) wings well done w sweet chili, I figured why not since 99% of the staff are Asian. They were ok, fried well w standard jarred sweet chili sauce dumped on. My pal was able to order her seafood special with no butter but that also meant no seasoning. I'm not sure why what you would assume is a spice blend couldn't just be shaken on top but we were told that you couldn't cook any of the seafood without butter. So in an attempt to have some other flavor cocktail sauce was requested, and caused confusion. Eventually we were asked "is cocktail sauce the red one", yup it is and we were brought marinara. Also if you didn't want potato and only corn they wouldn't substitute without an up charge, only a dollar but really? (also silly cause the corn was not delicious) The surrounding tables also ordered the special and their servings looked much more substantial. read more

See all

I checked in and coupon came up for 10% off; great well no. The coupon was for Halloween October. Why would they leave it attached and NOT honor the coupon? Good business practice would be to honor their advertisement. The food was served with a quick turn around after ordering. I had to call for assist about three times which is indicative that the server could check in on the party more often after the meal was served. The food was good and the experience has room for improvement. read more

See all

Finding myself with some free time and having heard about this place. I roped my fellow Yelper, Jenny, into a lunch date. Wasn't quite sure of what to expect but I'm always down for seafood which isn't easy to find in Roc! I was surprised it was table service. I'd put it in a fast casual category. The menu was interesting with some errors - spelling errors, butter listed as a seasoning but it's not a seasoning, and so forth. I have to say the prices are definitely reasonable. They have fried options and bakes! I opted for the special bake of the day which cake with shrimp, crab legs, crawfish and corn and potatoes (I did not taste the corn or potato). For $20, I was impressed with the portions! Our server, Oliver, was entertaining and had no problens rolling with us. Asking questions,returning Jenny's cold fries, etc. I will say I asked for the Medium level spice and barely felt a kick so if you like heat,kick it up a notch higher than you think you need. The only disappointing thing was that I asked for a side of butter and I'm 99% sure that the "butter" provided was fake movie theater popcorn butter. Next time, I go, don't be surprised if I bring actual butter with me. I'm just sayin.... read more

See all

Drove two hours from Buffalo to come try the seafood and it was amazing! Perfect amount of spice, minimal wait time and juicy seafood! The corn could've been cooked a little longer, but still not too shabby. My partner got crab and she loved it! Said it was cooked to perfection. We got the juicy seafood blend of spice and enjoyed it. Spicy, but not so dramatic it makes your lips burn or anything! We will return even for the drive. read more

Horrible service. Waiter was very unprofessional - said they'd be right with us but took 20 minutes to come back. No apology on the wait after obviously avoiding us, no waters, said the bar was open but was not, didn't tell us what they were out of until we ordered it and never received a side of sauce even after 20 mins. The place was dirty and menus were so greasy it left marks on the paper table cover. It was so cold inside, still wore our winter coats. The bathroom light was out. Food was mediocre - seafood quality seemed alright but not a flavorful seasoning at all (medium Cajun garlic seasoning) Hushpuppies were great! Prices were great but considering this experience it was not worth it. I do appreciate the bib, gloves, shell trash can and cracker...would have preferred to have 2 crackers or a metal fork (only had plastic). read more

I was craving seafood sooooo much one night and finally decided to check out Juicy Seafood! We had to get take out since this was during the quarantine. Ordering over the phone was easy enough, though be aware that some of their menus online such as from grubhub or door dash is not super updated so prices may vary. I wish I had known about the family pack because that would have saved me some money, but it's ok, I didn't mind spending a little extra to help businesses at this time. We ordered the combo A (mussels, shrimp and crab), combo D (shrimp and crab) and an extra lb of shrimp. We both got the juicy seasoning and you get a choice of mild, medium or hot, which we both went with medium. The sauce was just right for a medium hotness. Everything was ready in 20 minutes and came in well packaged to-go boil bags! The mussels were a little lack luster, I honestly would skip this one. They don't absorb any flavor and they're kind of tiny so it just adds to the weight of your boil. The shrimps however were our favorite! They were tender, de-veined very well and juicy! We like to smother it in the sauce again after we peel the skin off. The crabs were also delicious. I was skeptical about their size when ordering since most restaurants tend to skimp on the portion but my bf got 1/4 of a crab for his half lb and i got half a crab I believe for my 1lb of crab combo. There were a lot of legs and quite a bit of meat. The crab meat was sweet and salty and just so yummies! One warning though with the crab, obviously they can't give you the metal crab cracker thing and we had a bit of trouble with the thicker crab claws. We managed though, maybe get a hammer ready or something if you don't have a crab cracker at home. Also, we definitely did not need that extra lb of shrimp between the two of us (we do eat a lot) but it was soooo good the next day too. The boil bags come with potatoes and corn which were so soft and delicious. Pair your boil with rice to maximize fullness and really make use of all the sauce. Check out this place and be ready to get messy! read more

Juicy Seafood - 1lb shrimp (top) and combo D (bottom) - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Decided to come here with my gf and her nieces because we all wanted some seafood but didn't feel like cooking it. The place wasn't crowded at all when we got there so we were sat as soon as we came in. Looked over the menu and decided to get a few bags, one for myself, my gf and one for her nieces to share. I got a bag with Dungeness crab, claims, boiled eggs and then all bags come with corn and potatoes but I also got a side of broccoli. My gf got the combo special F with king crab, clams and sausage. The girls for a snow crab legs and then they ate some of our stuff as well. We all got the bags with the juicy special sauce which is all the sauces mixed. The girls stated their crab was over cooked. They were hard to crack and the shell was really soft. I'm 33 and have been eating seafood since I was their age so around 7/8 and I have cooked seafood more times than I can count and the crab was over cooked. My gf did not like the king crab leg and the claims were super small and not cleaned that well, and a lot of them didn't have meat in the shell. The corn and potatoes were just that corn and potatoes, can't really mess that up. My Dungeness crab was actually cooked perfectly so I can't complain about that. The sauce was okay to me, not the best and not the worst I've had. I they liked the sausages that came in the combo bag, I didn't try them because I don't eat pork. Overall I wouldn't come here again. I would just buy my own seafood like I usually do and do my own seafood boil. I wasn't impressed but it's not the worst seafood place I've eaten at. read more

I must start this review off by saying, Rochester has some good restaurants! Secondly, I have never eaten somewhere they bring you a bucket o' seafood in a bag full of sauce. That being said, I don't have a frame of reference. Maybe there are better places that serve seafood smothered in sauce. Also, it seems at Juicy Seafood, the day of the week and time you show up impacts your experience. I went on a Thursday at 8 and I had a great dinner. The exterior of the restaurant is warm but looks like a repurposed Ihop. The interior is inviting but not unique. The servers seemed helpful, fun and up to answer any questions. After the brown paper goes over the table....it's game on!! I ordered a combo, there are baskets and other items on the menu but for my buck, combos are the way to go. I got the juicy seasoning at medium spice. It was good and just mildly warm. Next time I will try hot. FYI, juicy sauce is friggin amazing. They should sell bottles of it. It's so good....some would probably drink it. ‍ The seafood was great and the corn and potatoes complemented it well. Meal portions are excellent, you get a lot for your buck. Next time I will probably order a extra corn. Corn with juicy sauce is tight! I enjoyed my visit. I will likely return and I will recommend this place to friends. You will lika the juice! read more

See all

I didn't know what to expect when I pulled into the the Juicy Seafood (JS) parking lot, adjacent to Wendy's. I was greeted by a beautiful array of lights on trees, which proved to be an amazing spot for post-meal photographs!! However, given Henrietta Rd. is not Henrietta Oceanfront, our expectations were that of a Rochestarian suburban eatery. Upon walking into JS, I was immediately greeted by all the signatures on the wall, a homey touch to our dining experience. As we sat in our seats, we were promptly welcomed by unexpected six-legged friends - . Now, we don't know if this was related to the HUMIDITY or JS's juicy cuisine (which may also appeal to ants), but it was certainly a surprise. After a slightly complicated ordering process, we got to listen to today's best hits on the John Tesch radio show, such as "Dancing With a Stranger." When the food arrived, I was faced with three baskets of fries, one of which I didn't order. Any seafood comes in a broil bag, turned upside down, which helped keep the heat and flavor (and JUICE!) contained until we enjoyed our seafood, sausage, and chicken tenders. The fries did need a little extra salt, and we were delighted to be provided with sea salt, which me reminded me of the ocean ;). We did have to remind them about our calamari order, which apparently explained the extra fries! Cajun and calamari are pretty similar ;) Overall, the food was decent and the atmosphere was enjoyable. Service was appropriate for the restaurant. Conveniently located sink outside of bathroom for hand washing needs. Would I come again? Not intentionally. But, JS may be in my future if I ever find myself aimlessly wandering the streets of Henrietta. read more

See all

I had to see what the hype was all about so I took the short drive over to Rochester.. We had to wait about 15/20 mins for a seat, which wasn't bad. There were 6 people in my party and the place was packed. I wasn't a fan of the customer service at the hostess station or our waitress but as the night went on and the crowd cleared out the service e got a little better.. I ordered the Combo Special steam bag with Lobster Tail, crab legs and shrimp. You also get 2 potatoes and a half ear of corn in the bag and you can also choose if you want any spice and butter flavor. I'm boring so I got no spice with garlic butter and it was AMAZING !! The entire bag was full of seafood deliciousness and I'm happy that I had the chance to try it out. My best friend isn't a fan of many things that are seafood so she ordered chicken tenders and shrimp and she enjoyed all of it. Another friend ordered some coated fried wings and she wasn't a fan, she said they needed to be cooked longer.. read more

See all

Pretty good spot I think it's good , maybe a lil pricey but at the end of the day I'll be back in the future for a 3rd run, I would like to try the boiling crab in California one of theses days! FACTS read more

See all

I was craving seafood and we found this place one night. It's the Rochester equivalent of The Boiling Crab in California, although this is considerably more expensive. Service was good as we were seated promptly. However, they don't have the cracker for the crab legs, which made the dining experience unnecessarily difficult. In terms of the food, it was good. I believe we got the juice special, which included cajun, garlic butter, and lemon pepper. Pretty flavorful. I'm not a big fan of crawfish, but you know how Asian girls are, they love that stuff. read more

See all

Yummy seafood boil! I always get the combo D that comes with 1 lb snow crab legs and 1/2 lb shrimp with corn and potatoes and I add the 2 boiled eggs which are super yummy. It all comes mixed in the sauce that you choose and the spicy level that you choose, I always choose the juicy special sauce and medium spicy level which is pretty spicy. Last time I got a side of noodles as well which I dipped in the sauce and it was sooo yummy! They also have cheap drinks and the place is cool with sharpie writing all over the walls (you can sign your name on the walls). The only reason I give 4 stars instead of 5 is because sometimes the service is good and other times it's not the greatest. read more

Juicy Seafood - Combo D with boiled eggs - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Good food some times too much salt but its delicious I enjoy the food so just tell them sauce on the side or no spicy

Really enjoy my time at Juicy Seafood whenever I go! When I first moved to ROC, I figured I'd never get crawfish unless I went to the south or visited my parents when they got crawfish shipped. Enter Juicy Seafood. This place is great! It's extremely busy and even take out can be long, so if you don't intend to sit down, order ahead and pick up when it's ready. If you're planning to eat in, just expect a long wait during typical busy dinner hours. Sitting down does have some perks though. I always love just getting the white paper mats dirty and having the bucket to toss shells into. The service has always been good, though apparently they've had issues in the past with people skipping out on bills, which wears on the staff. We always get the crawfish and shrimp with heads on, with the full season mix with hot spices. We love it spicy, and Juicy Seafood makes their spicy level acceptable. It's not very spicy but will give you a small kick in the back of your throat. The hush puppies are just ok, and sweet potato fries are bomb. My partner and I love coming here and will be coming back often! read more

Juicy Seafood - Fried Shrimp basket and hush puppies - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Excellent! I ordered the Thursday Special: Crab Legs and Shrimp (no heads) basket and a coke. Medium spice and Juicy Style. Amazing! $33.20 read more

Juicy Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

I was excited to come here all the way from Syracuse because, I missed Joes Crab Shack. Plus we had some customers tell us that it was good, but some times were better than others. We got there at opening time, so that way our meal could be the freshest. I ordered the 1/2lb. snow crabs and 1/2lb clams, and my date had ordered the special snow crabs and shrimp. We received our order maybe 10 - 15 min after (it was very quick.) and it came in a balloon like bag. I opened it and I found some crab legs and tiny clams. I was disappointed, the sauce tasted like franks hot sauce mixed with a liquid butter and then had some Cajun seasoning that was over salted. The quality of seafood was a 5 out of 10, the 1/2 lb of crab legs was not even close, the clams were so tiny and had sand I was still hungry after eating it (I'm only 110lbs, so it doesn't take much to fill me.) My dates food was pretty much the same, but he got a stomach ache. If you like cheap seafood then hey give it a go, but if your looking for quality then keep driving. read more

Juicy Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

This was a last minute decision while in rochester but we were not disappointed. The service lacked any connection. The food made up for it . We had the hush puppies for a starter . They were flavorful and perfect for a table of 3 the food came out pretty prompt . 1lb crab legs shrimp no head sausage and green mussels potatoes corn all in mild juicy sauce Wow this was a hit bins and gloves and dig in . I understand while there was a wait because this sauce was delicious!! I will take the lack luster service for this burst of goodness called juicy sauce . read more

Juicy Seafood - Potatoes shrimp corn juicy sauce - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

When you walk in, the older gentlemen doesn't really take names. He tries to seat you by remembering your face. He did sit people who came in after us before us, but that's because he wasn't organized. That's an easy fix though. However, what was problematic about him was when he sat us down he said that the prices were too cheap and they will be going outta business because we should be paying a lot more. Why would you tell us that and why would you forecast that on your business?! He needs to learn better hostess and business etiquette or just don't do the job. Other than him, the food was really delicious! We tried Cajun seasoning. It had extra flavors reminiscent of Asian spices more than Cajun but still really good. We had the weekend special too. Definitely recommend that! The waiters were an excellent team! One picked up if another one got busy. They were super friendly, made sure drinks were topped off, and made sure we were good throughout our meal. read more

Juicy Seafood - Boil comes in a bag - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Roll up your sleeves to dig in. They have a nice menu and big plate portions. We tried fried shrimp and boiled shrimp for lunch. The food was enjoyed by all. Give it a try v read more

See all

The flavors are really good. It was hard to eat it without the proper tools. They only provided the crackers. I would definitely try again. Beware: they won't honor yelp deals I don't recommend getting the blue crabs since they don't give you the necessary tools to pull the meat out. The oysters were also not shucked away from the shell. You pay $18 for a dozen, you'd think they at least do that part for you... They also do not serve alcohol yet. read more

Juicy Seafood - Wish they had the shallot vinaigrette sauce. They also don't shuck the oyster off the shell. You have to do it yourself with only a fork - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

We accompanied my mother-in-law and some of her co-workers to Juicy to celebrate her birthday. It was a Friday so it was very crowded and the wait was long, however the food was worth the wait. I created my own special with crab legs, shrimp and clams. Get the seasoning mild if you're not a huge fan of spice - it's delicious, but strong. The corn was VERY over cooked (I'm thinking they leave them in water or steaming because they are super prune-y) which is my reason for 4 stars instead of 5. The ambiance is also a little strange - the writing all over the walls doesn't really make sense to me, but hey - whatever works. Either way, I'll be back and maybe I'll even tag a wall. read more

Juicy Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

First time here at Juicy Seafood and the food was great. I ordered the shrimp basket and my husband ordered the steamed lobster, steamed crabs, steamed shrimp with potatoes and corn. The food was seasoned well and very delicious. We also ordered 6 lemon pepper wings that we took home. We will definitely be back. read more

See all

My wife and I went . To Try it out. We ordered just appetizers. We were not hungry, but we wanted to eat something.. we ordered chicken fingers. I ordered a side of macaroni and cheese. It was OK. I have had better but it wasn't bad. It was basically average not really anything above average. I would give it three stars. There was absolutely nothing outstanding about it. The fried shrimp was good. I think they deserve a second try perhaps with my wife and I are hungry. Also, they're sitting. They are booths are not very wide careful.. subway dropped their dinner on the floor. It was not cleaned up. It was over by the front door. My wife almost broke her neck. She missed it. read more

My service was TERRIBLE. My waiter rushed me to order and wouldn't look at me or my guest while speaking to us. After taking our orders he brought our food and NEVER came back to check on us. We had to ask multiple workers for multiple things after being told "I'm not your waiter". He had a horrible attitude and did not receive a tip for it. ONTO THE FOOD: it was subpar. nothing that can't be done at home, honestly. the corn was mushy and over cooked despite being 'on-the-cob', crab legs sat in the juice so long that it didn't crack when we tried to open them, they just bent, and all the spices were clumped up in the bag. the only thing that would keep me coming back would be the experience of being at a seafood boil and nothing else. nothing made it stand out. we enjoyed the experience but for 70 dollars it could've been way better. would've given them one star but they can have another, just because it was fun. read more

The food was good but the bathroom and booths were nasty. There was art and names all over .

When I arrived it was packed so we waited like 15 min to be seated, as soon as we ordered it seem like the food come out fast. On top of that the lemon pepper seasoning with the medium spicy sauce was great. I'm going to have to make this one of my favorite spots read more

Juicy Seafood - Combo E - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

This was my first time here and it did not disappoint! Service was fast and the food was some of the best seafood I have had. We were a party of 7 and I like that the hostess told us about the 18% gratuity added for parties of 6 or more. I don't like surprises. It's a family friendly place and even my 4 year old niece and 10 year old grandson loved it! We will definitely be back! read more

Juicy Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Rochester, New York